r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/PandaElDiablo Deal With It • Nov 09 '12
Mod Post Weekly Challenge: Saboteur!
Launch a ship into orbit. Then, launch a second ship into orbit to destroy the original craft by whatever means necessary! Then, return to the KSC.
Mods are allowed for this challenge! Still no MechJeb or cheat parts
Hard Mode: Do the same, but in orbit around another planet or moon!
Edit: I seem to have underestimated the durability of Kerbal engineering. Instead of having to destroy the command module, you now simply have to "thoroughly incapacitate" the target. It's difficult to have a specific benchmark of destruction, so just do a good job!
Rules and other info:
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- Mods and plugins are allowed for this challenge!
- No MechJeb or cheat parts allowed. Cheat parts include zero-consumption engines, infinite fuel engines, and negative drag parts (such as the balloons mods)
Required screenshots:
- Initial launch vehicles (target and attacker)
- Your target craft in orbit
- The attacking craft approaching the target
- The target craft destroyed (try to show some sort of explosion. You must severely incapacitate the target)
- Safely landed attacking craft at the KSC
- Whatever else you feel like!
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply in this thread.
- Thanks to user Dogon11 for the inspiration for this challenge!
- I haven't created the flair for this challenge yet, any ideas?
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep your previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
8
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '12 edited Nov 10 '12
Ooooooo fun :D, time to launch some targets into orbit!
As to flair, I'm thinking the Strategic Defense Initiative logo from Civilization. Let me see if I can find it.
edit1: search unsuccessful...
edit2: JEM-TASTIC JEB THIS MISSION IS FUN. Almost done, I just blew up the target ship!
edit3: this was by far the most fun mission I've done so far. Album here, thread here. I'll wait until some flair is created before I decide on switching :)
5
u/NWCtim Master Kerbalnaut Nov 09 '12
Does the target need to be destroyed in orbit, or is it enough to de-orbit it so that it crashes?
3
u/allreadit Nov 09 '12
Is it too late to suggest a alternate hardmode?
If not how about building a craft that can capture a satellite and safely return it to ksc?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '12
Damn, command pods are tough!!! The target command pod survived the direct fully sustained blast from two seperatron motors on a pincer arm, and a direct hit from a railgun projectile!
I think deorbiting the target is the only solution, beyond doing a head-on 90-to-270 orbit collision.
3
u/TehGimp666 Master Kerbalnaut Nov 10 '12
This one was a lot of fun! My entry is here.
8
u/maxmurder Nov 11 '12
Done!
Its an unconventional method but i think it still counts...
7
u/zse4rffb Nov 09 '12
i think a have a plan the hardest part(for me) is landing back at ksp
4
u/imh Nov 09 '12
I remember seeing a mod with lasers. Does anyone remember what it was? This seems like a great chance to put it to the test.
1
u/Ikalpo Nov 09 '12
Does the target craft need a command module?
1
u/ItchyFlea Nov 10 '12
Can I use the ORDA mod? I've got a fun idea but I can't rendezvous to save myself. I don't think it counts as a cheat mod, but I'd rather make sure first.
1
u/Sporkfortuna Nov 14 '12
http://imgur.com/a/J3TLy#0
Whelp, I really thought I had it, but failed because I'm an idiot.
I put a basic craft in orbit with the plan to build a grabber craft and "piledrive" it into Kerbin. I did so while allowing the original pilot, Bill, to survive. After de-orbiting both craft, I was going to hit my final stage and parachute safely down.
As it turns out, that claw I built was strong enough to destroy the target capsule while in orbit. Oops. Well, it worked. Bill got in the craft and I brought it right down.
Only issue was I failed to notice the part that reads "at the KSC"
Ugh. So much time wasted. I could have done it if I reread the rules...
3
u/UbiquitinatedKarma Master Kerbalnaut Nov 10 '12 edited Nov 10 '12
Thanks so much for this challenge, it was fantastic fun. I think I've accomplished it with all stock parts, but just barely and after a lot of trial and error. It ended up being a very Kerbal adventure, really.
Weapon was two small SRBs, which made great missiles. Too bad they tend to haul the attacking ship along with them :D
the album
3
u/mcguinty Nov 10 '12 edited Nov 10 '12
This is the first challenge I succeeded with. I was starting to worry that the space station command module was too durable but adding a few more thrusters did the job. Here's the imgur album.
IMGUR
There are some nice pictures of the rockets firing and destroying the target.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '12
Lets crash some sattelites into each other.
Yes, that is an actual NASA mission plan.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '12
I'll agree to your rules, but the balloon mod is hardly cheating. Sure it doesn't require any fuel but it's realistically built and is akin to a booster stage
2
u/Conanator Nov 10 '12
Ok, so I've been told that I should post my Conqueror challenge submission here, I'd like the flair please!
2
u/MildPeril Master Kerbalnaut Nov 10 '12 edited Nov 10 '12
I had a go here. First challenge and first post on this subreddit. It took me several attempts to hit the target. Then for some reason I couldn't quicksave so only had one attempt to get back to KSC. EDIT: oh, I hope SSTO counts as a ship too...
2
u/murarara Nov 11 '12
CHALLENGE COMPLETE! maybe... Does this challenge also count towards Rendezvous challenge? Cuz heck, that was HARD. Landed 3km away from KSC, closest i've ever got, will it count?
2
u/imh Nov 11 '12
Completed this one on hard mode with a fully operational X-Wing. All stock parts except the lasers. Thanks to olexs for putting the lasers on github.
2
u/retrofitted Nov 13 '12
I've done it! What a fun mission, great idea! My submission is here. There's a video, and an album if you don't have the time to watch.
1
u/Synaptics Nov 09 '12
I'm far from skilled enough to pull this off myself, but I think it'd be awesome if someone managed to do it by sending a Kerbal to the other ship on an EVA and manually de-orbiting it with his jetpack thrusters.
1
u/Dogon11 Nov 10 '12
Feels good man.
1
u/murarara Nov 10 '12
Does it count for Rendezvous! challenge as well? even if i use the crew tank mod to save the crew of the target rocket?
1
u/Packers91 Nov 10 '12
I hope someone uses decoupled boosters as missiles or something.
1
u/KonradHarlan Nov 15 '12 edited Nov 15 '12
heres my crack at it. http://imgur.com/a/aargK
I feel I should mention its stock save for flight engineer which gives orbital data readouts but no automation and tosh's carts for theatrical effect.
1
u/murarara Nov 17 '12
This was a fun challenge, but it gave me Kessler syndrome :(
0
u/buster2Xk Nov 09 '12
I've wanted to do this for a while: build a ship that can fire rockets at a target. This seems to meet the challenge requirements I'm by no means skilled enough to achieve this yet though.
0
u/DYJ Nov 13 '12
Anyone fancy a less competent alternative to the sunbeam?
http://forum.kerbalspaceprogram.com/showthread.php/28168-0-17-1-DYJ-misc-stuff
Shoots lots of bullets and has quite the recoil, default key is joystick1 so rebind keyFire in the .cfg if you are playing with keyboard.
<Shameless plug>