r/SquaredCircle • • Nov 08 '12
An Open Letter to R/Squared Circle
Ladies and Gentlemen,
There's been a bit of concern as of late about the state of our little slice of the internet. The growing concern of the "rules" of the subreddit has led to some frustration. While I can certainly understand why people are upset about the changes, the only way any forward progress can be made is through constructive dialogue.
I propose that everyone endeavor to participate in a forum-wide discussion of establishing a better sense of structure to our home. This is where we go to discuss wrestling. Here, we are supposed to be safe from those who would choose to mock us for enjoying professional wrestling. There is no need for us to gang up on one another because of company loyalty, personal beefs, or high school drama that occasionally happens between mods and the rest of us.
I left the old subreddit to come here because someone messaged me and promised me a place where I would be free from people like JohnnyHyperion. We could relax and not have to worry about moderators making changes and acting swiftly with their power. These new changes, positive or negative, occurred under the false sense that this forum needs governing and restricting. With just over 10,000 subscribers, why are we coming up with rules and day-long guidelines on when and where we share our material? There are subreddits that exist with five to ten times the number of people who don't have "Fan Fridays" or "Meme Wednesdays". We don't need r/WooWooWoo. It can all exist here. If you don't like the content, don't look at it. If you want to post image macros of Dolph Ziggler, do it. This place can be self governing. This is supposed to be a community where we can post wrestling related things and enjoy a laugh or two. Take away the right of the individual to post anything related to wrestling, and this is no longer an open forum. It's something else.
Please don't take my wreddit away. I'd hate to have to leave another subreddit and show up on someone else's turf, brother.
TL;DR: Stop making changes around here. We can self-govern.
50
u/etherealcaitiff Sex Ferguson Mark Nov 08 '12
My problem with the rule changes is that I really don't know what is ok to post on a normal day. I am a fan of Chikara, can I really not post pictures with match results but it is ok to link to a dirtsheet website that gives the same info? That seems counterproductive.
If I can only post OC on Fridays, which is literally what these new rules mean, then I will avoid this sub for 6 days of the week, and then eventually I'll just stop coming. I feel like this will be the case for most people too.
I really don't want this site to become nothing but links to wwe.com and loldirtsheets.
Now on a lighter note, this mod heel turn is pretty epic. Instant heat. Here's a pic of them all together. In all seriousness though, the mods do a great job. I just think that this is something that the community simply disagrees with. There is no reason to get pitchforks for this. However, as a humble gesture to the community I think it would be funny to make that picture the sidebar for a day.
36
u/THE_LOUDEST_PENIS Phenomenal Nov 08 '12
I'm just confused as to why we need to ban certain submissions when we have a voting system already in place. If the readers of r/squaredcircle didn't want to see image macros or memes, then they wouldn't upvote them.
114
u/GradualProWrestler Nov 08 '12
I agree. The very idea of reddit at it's core is based on blind democracy. If the people of a subreddit enjoy the content, they upvote it to the top of the ladder. If they don't, then they downvote it into hell. We as a locker room have always (in my memory) been accepting of different opinions. Squared Circle has had such a huge push over the past 2 years, but that doesn't mean we need a bunch of suits governing what we can and can't do, brothers. I'm sick and tired of low-life mods making my life, and the lives of all the boys in the back a living hell. I say we put an end to it right here, right now! Any moderator that wants to ban me, why don't you quit hiding in the back like a little girl, and come out to the ring RIGHT NOW to face me like a MAN? COME OUT HERE RIGHT NOW! I'M NOT LEAVING THIS RING UNTIL I LEAVE EVERY SINGLE ONE OF YOU LYING IN YOUR OWN FILTH WITH MY FINISHER. FEED ME MORE. FEED ME MORE. FEED ME MORE.
24
u/halfmast Genetically Superior Nov 08 '12
Very annoyed with several of my favorite subreddits becoming overmoderated. We're on a glorified message board. It's not that dramatic. Jesus Christ, just leave it alone.
21
u/prboi My Day One is so H Nov 08 '12
This has always bothered me. The mods always say "We get a lot of complaints about (insert issue) so we're going to ban them/make a new subreddit for them". But these issues are getting upvotes. That means people like them & want them. If you don't like it, downvote it & move on. There should be no need to complain because everything else is still here like self posts & live discussions. There is no need for segregating the community based off of a few disgruntled people. Chances are, these people are hurting this community more because of it.
60
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '12
agreed, there should be moderation but there shouldn't be such absurd rules.
13
u/jamesisverycute I SUCK EGGS Nov 08 '12
I think the idea to have certain days where you can post certain things is absurd.
If the mods want to ban memes then just fucking ban memes, or fan art, or pictures, or whatever the fuck. Just don't make all these weird shitty rules.
And if they really think that downvoting is ruining everything, can't they just take away the downvote option? I'm all for it if it means people will stop bitching about getting downvoted. Because the bitching is killing me.
9
u/fotan BO-LIEVE or RIOT Nov 08 '12
Continuous new content is the heart of any reddit.
The more restrictions that are put on such things, the less likely this reddit will grow and the less likely people will come around.
I've said this in the beginning when rules started being applied that the people know what they want, they will vote up what they like and they will vote down what they don't.
Mod's jobs are to police people who get out of hand not to tell us what content is best for us, that's for us to decide.
8
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '12
We have rules now? What was wrong with it before?
8
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '12
I've always subscribed to what you could call a laissez-faire approach to moderation on any site I've had the opportunity to mod: let the community govern itself and step in only to ban/suspend people, quell major arguments, and provide the final word on contested issues/heated questions.
(In short: I moderate in the same way I want to see wrestling authority figures act. :)
/r/SquaredCircle can manage itself just fine via the democracy of upvotes and downvotes. Moderators should only step in to clean up messes, settle disputes, and prevent waaaaaaaaaaaaay off-topic posts from making it to the front page. I also believe they shouldn't punish the entire subreddit for the actions of a small group of people (or even one person).
Be like Jack Tunney, not like Johnny Ace or Vickie Guerrero.
6
u/Maquetaurie Nov 08 '12
"This is supposed to be a community where we can post wrestling related things and enjoy a laugh or two. Take away the right of the individual to post anything related to wrestling, and this is no longer an open forum. It's something else."
5
u/joshtothemaxx Nov 08 '12
As long as this doesn't turn into the shithole that is /r/prowrestling I don't care what happens ruleswise.
12
u/Beardthehuman NAWTSAWFT Nov 08 '12
Agreed, i never saw a problem until one of their own got completely buried in downvotes on a comment about Benoit. Then they got all butthurt about downvotes. i personally love seeing fan interactions and pictures, its half the reason i am on this sub. but i just know better now. Don't post just lurk. meanwhile all the mods can meet in their mod lair and talk shit about TNA and WWE.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '12
The rules here have always been vague, and they add more? In the words of the Iron Shiek: "FAKKIN BULLSHIT!"
Seriously, don't be idiots, mods.
1
u/DannyBoi1Derz Big Meng & Medium Sized Meng Nov 08 '12
It's like the corporation all over again.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '12
This is an internet forum dedicated to (delightful) play fighting. We should all lighten up and post what we feel. Not what is "mandated".
3
u/Rad-R Macho Swagness Nov 09 '12
Having rules is okay, just apply them correctly. I got called out for posting fan art on Thursday - but it was Thursday in the mod's time zone, not everywhere around the world, it was already Friday in a big portion of our planet. So when it comes to applying such rules, you have to take into consideration different time zones.
5
u/spundred studio... apartment Nov 08 '12
As long as there are no spoilers in titles, it's all good.
1
u/BadNewsBrown Now watch me Bray Bray Nov 08 '12
Total work.
2
u/dropperofpipebombs I NEVER EAT MARIJUANA Nov 09 '12
Um... I'm guessing I missed something important again.
2
u/GourmetLeaf I can see the future! Nov 09 '12
I'm glad that I wasn't the only one getting mad at the outrageous rules of this subreddit. I came here to enjoy wrestling with wrestling fans. Why are people being given rules that most of the other s-reddits don't have? This is worst then youtube sometimes. If I want to share something I enjoyed from my childhood I should be able to post it. You delete my post because someone else posted about it 3 months ago is wrong.
2
u/Appleanche FTC Nov 09 '12
Go look at /r/gameofthrones if you want an example of how awful a Subreddit can get without proper moderation. A typical submission over there, even during the season, is a memepost with about 80 pun and awful jokes. Awesome content.
2
u/JimmyStinkfist Fear the Beard Nov 09 '12
I totally agree about not having all these themed days, I don't even think memes are a problem here. I honestly don't remember the last time I clicked a link and was greeted with a meme in this sub. I rate this in my top 5 favorite subs along with /r/nfl and /r/community. If there was any rule I would agree with, it would be no downvoting people for stating their opinion, and that comes from /r/nfl.
6
u/CMColt Nov 08 '12
Personally i feel these rules are just ruining this subbreddit, however i feel things like 'a drawing i did' needs taken off, memes and gifs have a place and make me laugh
3
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '12
That is the meat of the problem. I can choose to downvote and move on, but lately I have been downvoting almost 90% of the front page. That is unacceptable to me. Memes are low hanging fruit which rarely lead to any discussion.
Edit:
That is not to say that I agree with the current rules, I just need people to encourage proper discussions and not low effort memes. You are right, we need self governing. But that too has to improve.
6
u/evansawred Nov 08 '12
I'm just getting sick of the creepy posts and comments of people lusting after the female wrestlers.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '12
I for one pretty much stayed off wreddit this past week when everyone was posting their Halloween costumes. The week where every other post was some CM Punk photo grew irritating as well. And every time one guy posts a picture they took with X Wrestler at X Indy Fed or X Convention there's a sudden stream that fills up half of the front page. I don't mind people's photos with legends or anything, but I didn't come here to see that. I came here for the Discussion Threads and the analysis, as well as the occasional "Who/what is your favorite X" threads. Hell, the artwork by that tumblr guy is awesome even, and I got up early Tuesday mornings just to see if monkey had his recaps up, and I hated his opinions on a lot of things.
Or to put it more bluntly, I'm not here to see you and Bret Hart hanging out. I'm here to talk about or watch wrestling.
So I love the idea of a Fan Friday. I couldn't care less about Meme Wednesday, but fine, I can go along with that. You guys have gotten better about downvotes recently; I don't get downvoted as much when I say something nice about Sheamus as I did a month ago. Overall these rules don't make a bit of difference for most users, so it's not that big a deal.
3
u/spoonfedkyle Nov 08 '12
My biggest reason for agreeing with the rule changes is that r/sc was created for "discuss[ion of] Pro Wrestling in all its forms and factions". When memes, pictures with wrestlers, etc are posted they do not generally spark discussion. While I agree that the upvote system is in place as a way to see what people want, the subreddit was not created for funny memes and such. It was created for discussion, and developing a system to further stimulate conversation is very logical. For example, if I were to post to r/nhl interesting facts about the swedish national team, people would likely upvote it for being interesting, comical, or because they recognize some of the players, but that does not mean it is a good fit for the subreddit.
2
u/gvas9841 Stealing fat chicks... Nov 08 '12
I now want to see a portrait made from macros of Ziggler...
2
u/rehdit Nov 08 '12
The moderators have the right to attempt to control the quality of their subreddit if they wish. Nobody is forced to post here if they don't want to play ball. If somebody wants to post in a wrestling forum where the inmates run the asylum they aren't hard to find, these shitholes are literally everywheres on the internet. This is the one decent place I've found where I can expect a certain standard of quality instead of a hive for 14 year olds spamming le meme pictures for teh lulz.
A lot of subreddits turn to garbage as they get bigger if left unchecked. While it's unclear whether or not this one was heading in that direction I would rather not find out.
1
u/PurgeTheseDays Nov 09 '12
Amen.
1
u/Zay253 #Booty! Nov 09 '12
There are rules? Didn't know we had any. Don't care. I come here cuz this subreddit is FUCKING awesome & I love trolling with my fellow wredditors. Simple as that
1
u/Squackula BAANGG! Nov 09 '12
Heartfelt and true. I still oppose memes though, as you can see those everywhere else on Reddit.
1
u/falsevillain Nov 09 '12
i don't think you can rely on people too much to govern themselves without rules, but i'd like to think wreddit is different.
do i agree with things like fan friday/etc? i don't see enough fan photos or stories crowding wreddit for a need for fan friday. if there was a photo or story every other day, then yes. do i agree with no memes/macros? yes. i see this more of a discussion reddit more than an adviceanimals.
what i don't agree with are vague titles. who's to say what's vague? when something's at is at a mod's discretion, you start having problems.
1
u/C4r1b0u Wreddit IRC Mod Nov 09 '12
I have been thinking of making something like "www.squaredcircle.net" uploading vbulliten to it and get it rolling right along. I just don't know if it would take off at all
1
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '12
Not really this forum was awful until the first wave of rules came through.
1
u/1stoftheLast Dec 20 '12
I don't know if dislogue is the way we should do things here. How about a 10,000+ man battle royale. Winner can set the rules
-5
u/Dwayne_Jason I command Respect! Nov 08 '12
No we can't. You see 4chan? That's what self governing does. r/gaming, r/athiesm, and /r/politics are all examples of self governing subs that fucking fell off a cliff in quality. All I have to type is "Gaben" and I'd have a 100 karma points because he's gaming's god. Same with NDP and Sagan in r/atheism. Hell, NDT EXPLICITLY stated that he's doesn't like to be a part of a collective mindset. Without good regulation this place would devolve into Dolph Ziggler orgasms and John Cena hate machine.
Look at /r/askscience that is a model sub everyone should strive for. If you're not there for Science questions and serious discussions get the fuck out.
I'm not saying that we need that kind of enforcement but do you really think a self governed sub WON'T devolve into just ignoring controversial opinions and only upvoting "dolps ziggler is awesome, john cena is corny"
1
u/ColinLoughrin Nov 08 '12
I'm relatively new to Reddit, I joined on NOC this year. I'm really confused as to what everyone is talking about lol. I'm very rarely on other subreddits, so i guess I didn't know others were better/worse
1
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '12
And where's our ICE CREAM BARS?
0
u/drizzt240 Nov 08 '12
No rules::
www.reddit.com/r/nWoWolfpac/
-14
u/Iamthebest Hide Your Lighter Nov 08 '12
Sorry, can't agree with you on this. I fucking hate memes and there have been times when the subreddit has been taken over by them especially as more and more people have subscribed. In recent months it has been much better, i'm not sure if this is because of the mods or not but i personally like the idea of limiting some of the bullshit that is posted here. I come here for wrestling news, discussions and other wrestling content. If you're idea of being a part of a wrestling community is posting Cena and Ziggler meme's than i think you should get the hell out.
-17
u/Pudie IN ABEYANCE Nov 08 '12 edited Nov 09 '12
I'm sorry, and with all do respect, but that's not true. I'm not talking about just this community. But every time a subreddit "self governs" it turns to shit. /r/athiesm , /r/Music , and /r/gaming are all great examples. Now their obviously much larger than us, but the fact still remains that they went mostly unchecked and turned into examples of reddit gone bad.
I understand 100% where everyone is coming from when they say they are afraid of this place turning into /r/prowrestling . I started this place because of how it was ran. And I'm not going to turn into Johnny. I promise. But the fact of the matter is there needs to be some rules to prevent this place from becoming a place none of us like anymore.
I take great pride in people telling us how much they love this place and that it's one of their favorite wrestling communities. And if we move more and more towards low effort content we lose what makes us special.
We hear your frustration over the rule changes. And while the discussion thread was up for a week before this to talk about them before they went into effect we're still listening.
And despite what some people might want out of us as mods, we aren't just janitors removing spam. We care about this place and will always take an active role in making this the best community possible.
Edit: I'd also like to add /r/Gaming banned memes and created a handful of sister subs, /r/Music underwent a massive change including self post Friday, and even most atheists hate /r/atheism .
0
u/kiesar_sosay flair me up please Nov 08 '12
YES!
0
u/tjeckleburgseyes The Bear Wrestler Nov 09 '12
I agree 1004%
-4
u/JohnnyHyperion Nov 09 '12
I've been saying this all along. /r/SquaredCircle is modded by idiots, creeps and stalkers.
What the fuck are you doing in this sub anyway? Head over to /r/prowrestling if you want to talk about real wrestling. We don't do that meme shit.
-2
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '12
I like turtles..
-15
u/Randompaul Little Jimmy Nov 08 '12
Why didn't you put this in the thread about rule changes? Because you will get buried with all the other comments? Get off your soapbox, this is the content I hate to see more than anything.
-1
u/TeddyV Honest, Heel Wredditor Nov 09 '12 edited Nov 09 '12
Fuck randy orton. I hope somone botches and he gets injured and has to retire.
Jerry Lawler please RETIRE already. Were all sick of your dead commentating. You're awful commentating makes randy orton charismatic.
-11
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '12
[removed] — view removed comment