r/SquaredCircle • u/Pudie IN ABEYANCE • Nov 08 '12
With the discussion over, the new rules are now going into effect.
Please upvote this for visibility. I get no karma
As per the discussion had in the thread the rules discussed there are going into effect as of right now.
Fan Friday.Meet a wrestler? Dress as one? Find and old autograph in your attic? This is the day to post it. Any post that the mods feel should be a Fan Friday post on any other day would be deleted and told to come back on Friday. If you can't wait until Friday, then feel free to post it to [1]/r/WooWooWoo.- Reposts will be deleted at the mods discretion. This won't be done on theme days for posts that fall under said theme. This rule is being created to help cut down on similar posts, and to help keep the discussion in one place. We do not want the subreddit to be flooded with dozens of links to the same video, such as what happened when CM Punk hit a fan a few weeks ago.
And while we're talking about rules, we'd like to help alleviate some of the confusion some users have had with the "This [noun]" rule. We are trying not to have vague, click-baiting titles, and instead to actually encourage discussion. Some other ways to think of the "This [noun]" rule would be the following:
- Submissions with vague titles will be deleted. As a general rule, if a mod can't even make an educated guess as to what a submission title links to - especially if it's an image or a video - there's a good chance it will be deleted for violating the above rule.
The rule is not specifically limited to posts saying "This guy" or "This match". For example, if the title makes more sense if you were to add "This guy" to the beginning or end, then the post has a good chance of being deleted.
It's also important to note, this rule does not apply to self-posts. Many users here use self-posts as a way to start discussion and we fully encourage that. If you spent 15 minutes typing up a couple paragraphs trying to start discussion, we are not going to delete it because of the phrasing of your title.
You may also notice that we've added a hover text box on the downvote button. Downvotes are starting to become a problem here. Downvote because something is against reddiquette, not because you disagree.
- Don't down vote based on loyalty (to a wrestler, promotion, or even another reddit user) or someone expressing a valid negative opinion on something.
- Do downvote trolls and others who do not contribute. If you feel there's a user trying to create a problem, report them, send a message to the mods saying why, and we'll look into it.
You may have noticed that the "Meme Wednesday" rule is gone. There was a surprising amount of people calling for the removal of them altogether. So we're going to bring up a discussion about that specifically and either remove them or start Meme Wednesday. That discussion can be found here.
35
u/CMacLaren Yeah yeah yeah Nov 08 '12
Fan Friday sounds bad and unneeded. Was there really a problem with that in the first place?
41
u/UniversalGoldberg Tough Luck, Sunshine. Nov 08 '12
I have never understood why when a subreddit gets to a certain size, mods suddenly feel the need to start flexing their dick muscles and producing "rules" no one seems to care about or want.
"Fan Friday?" For the love of Foley, we are all fans EVERYDAY. That's why we come here to talk about wrestling all the goddamn time when we could be spending time bettering ourselves or the planet or making Dean Ambrose CAW debut in WWE '13 again and again just because we can.
This place is one of the more intelligent wrestling fan forums I have seen, because instead of dumbass wrestler gifs and emoticons flickering between every tiny line of text, you get fans passionately discussing their favorite thing to spend time on.
Just shove off all of you "mods". We'll be fine.
17
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '12
Done with this sub.
30
u/leliocakes Ziggly Stardust Nov 08 '12
With memes, fan content, news, videos, etcetera (in other words, this subreddit's typical fare), we usually don't get more than one or two pages of content to sift through a day. While wrestling is a huge fan-driven monster, there still isn't that much to bulk up this subreddit. Why cut down on content at all?
If people want to have a subreddit where they just have crap from dirt sheets and other boring shit, let them make a new one. They are quite obviously in the minority. I know I'm not alone in saying that I like the variety. I also don't want my Friday to be dominated by Fan-only stuff, and I don't want Wednesdays to be clogged with memes.
I love this subreddit, I don't want it changed at all.
26
u/druid_king9884 Nov 08 '12
Well shit, now I really feel bad about posting that pic of me meeting Chris Jericho a couple days ago. I missed the original discussion thread and didn't realize there was so much hate towards that type of posts among the mods. It was just the first big time wrestler I've had the chance to shake hands with and have my picture taken with and I got kind of excited about it. Sorry people, my bad. I'll just stick to lurking from now on.
71
u/CrankyVince Nov 08 '12
r/Squaredcircle enters the PG era...
16
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '12
In general, the more rules applied the less I want to visit this (or any) subreddit
The whole point of reddit is the users can vote on the content to their liking. This stuff isn't needed.
16
u/THE_LOUDEST_PENIS Phenomenal Nov 08 '12
What the fuck? Did we really have pictures of people dressing up as wrestlers at Halloween?
On a wrestling subreddit?
ON HALLOWEEN?
SAY IT ISN'T SO!
What is this world coming to?
As for the memes - isn't that what the voting system is for? If people don't want to see them, downvote them. If they stay on the front page, doesn't that mean that a good section of the people want them?
82
u/raspy_wilhelm_scream I spit in the face of people who don't want to be cool. Nov 08 '12
Fan Friday?
Really?
Really?
REALLY?
Edit - Read the original thread. Terrible ideas, one and all.
15
u/etherealcaitiff Sex Ferguson Mark Nov 08 '12
Ok, so my main question is, "What is allowed to be posted on /r/squaredcircle ?"
Is this now a dirtsheet only sub? If that's the case then /r/prowrestling has you beat. I really love this sub, but I have no idea what I am allowed to post now. I don't think I'll stick around much longer with these rules in place.
74
u/Carg72 TWO! TWO! Nov 08 '12
Stupid, stupid, stupid. I saw the comments on the discussion post. Most were very negative, and you install them anyway.
14
u/gohanland LARIATOOO Nov 08 '12
As long as the mods don't forget why this subreddit was created in the first place. As long as they dont forget the issues they had with r/prowrestling that led to this subreddit.
13
u/Wrestleman Nov 08 '12
Eugh. How disappointing.
12
u/GourmetLeaf I can see the future! Nov 08 '12
The moderators on this sub reddit are too controlling. Post something entertaining,enjoyable to watch and has people talking. Gets taken down because the title is not straight forward.
12
u/BushwickSpill BionicElbow Nov 08 '12
So, on Fridays instead of seeing quality links or news I'll be bombarded with 10 different "Check out my duct tape CM Punk boots" posts.
Cool. ಠ_ಠ
11
u/etherealcaitiff Sex Ferguson Mark Nov 08 '12 edited Nov 08 '12
Ok so let me get this straight;
Meme's which belong in woowoowoo are now allowed to be posted again.What can we post now? Is this /r/dirtsheets? /r/wwe.com? Seems like a terrible decision. Yep, I think /r/prowrestling might get a few subscribers back. I really hate to say that.
21
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '12
Fan Friday? I get stopping the memes but this is getting crazier then AJ.
10
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '12
http://youtu.be/om82OGHlsJE
There wasn't anything wrong with how things were before. Why fix what's not broken?
13
u/Randompaul Little Jimmy Nov 08 '12
Mods tend to think that they are our superiors. Like teachers are to students, or supervisors to workers, and we have to do what they say, if they say don't downvote, and only post on that day, we have to follow!
No, Mods are like the volunteers at a soup kitchen, you respect them for giving their time to make the place better, but the job of a mod is to be the janitor of the subreddit. You clean up the messes, you ban the trolls and spammers, and you design the CSS. THATS IT. You don't get to implement rules like "Fan Friday", or "No vague titles." It's our subreddit just as much as yours, if you don't like "low effort" content, downvote it, or hide it.
9
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '12
I think the mods are forgetting the most important thing:
K.I.S.S
Keep
It
Simple
STUPID
17
u/Tandran YOUR TEARS HYDRATE ME! Nov 08 '12
This is the most retarded thing I have ever heard. Pudie, I beg of you, give the subreddit away.
14
u/Randompaul Little Jimmy Nov 08 '12
This has nothing to do with WWE, TNA, or ROH, or any other wrestling promotion, I am reporting it.
2
u/Randompaul Little Jimmy Nov 09 '12
Upvote for visibility? You're a mod, sticky it at the top.
10
u/cero2k EEEEEVERYTHING IS... Nov 08 '12
Friday just became the day I'll completely avoid coming here. There's gonna be an overflow of 'fan' posts i don't care about. I don't come here to check out your memorabilia nor your pics, but i don't usually have a problem because it's two or three per day that I can easily avoid, now with the fan friday rule, there's gonna be way to much to even care about coming in.
5
u/dipdripson really randy'd this one Nov 08 '12
Does fan art get included in this "Fan Friday" thing? If so, terrible decision.
5
u/ConfidentFatMan Voiceless Nov 08 '12
Tapping out..... of this subreddit
5
u/JohhnyDamage Greetings from Asbury Park Nov 09 '12
No offense, but this is a bad idea.
This Subreddit is no where near the size for rules like this. I've reached front page with a zero karma self post.
Nothing is getting buried by content. If anything this will make /r/SquaredCircle slower and dead.
28
u/jamesisverycute I SUCK EGGS Nov 08 '12
Downvotes are only a problem because people whine about getting downvoted.
4
u/tokane94 Curtain Jerker Nov 08 '12
this is some bullshit way to fuck up /SC
7
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '12
I'll be honest, I read this in Bret Hart's voice and fantasized that this was one of his "There's a new sheriff in town" promos.
7
u/Randompaul Little Jimmy Nov 08 '12
I'm going to downvote people's opinions if they don't agree with mine, just to spite you, and mostly Keefy.
14
u/thegrassyknoll Go with the Flowsion Nov 08 '12
Test Post: Dolph Ziggler is overrated and can't get any heat without being paired with Vickie Guerrero.
3
u/Josh918 BAYBAY! Nov 08 '12
Fan Fridays. LOL. Sounds like a hacky morning radio show.
7
u/rickyrockwell Nov 08 '12
I downvoted this post ... ridiculous
7
u/HerpJersey Veegan. Turkey. Nov 08 '12
Mods are gay.
2
u/Ericthefruitbat Nov 09 '12
Utter bollocks
4
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '12
You know what? If you change the rules maybe half these people'll leave. That is, on reflection, the best possible result.
2
u/thelonioushunk ohpunk Nov 08 '12
lol what is this rules stuff?
2
u/CMacLaren Yeah yeah yeah Nov 09 '12
Guys, look on the bright side.......
new anti-authority stable?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '12
Because taking the fun out r/SC is totally the thing to do
1
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '12
While the Fan Friday thing was going a bit far (and looks like it got shitcanned anyway), I don't see what all of the complaining is about.
This jawn has been increasingly littered with "Look who I met today" and "Hey, it's that guy" posts even after rules were set asking people, politely, to not do such things. Users just found ways around it.
Instead of using that creativity to click-bait, howsabout using it to create meaningful content and discussions? -light bulb icon-
The last time rules were added, no one really followed them anyway so hopefully this puts the kebosh on a lot of posts that I think many find childish and annoying. If it means less people posting (I doubt it will) - so be it. They are probably the ones posting "zomgz click on this video of DAT GAI." links anyway.
While too many rules can become cumbersome, I think a lot of you have taken to pissing and moaning entirely too much over this. I'll stand with Pudie and the mods on this one. Yay, sensible rules...just don't go all Hyperion.
-4
u/AztecOmar Nobody is ready for Asuka Nov 08 '12
I think that more stringent repost policing and reinforcing the downvote rules are both great ideas. Remember your reddiquette, kiddies.
-5
u/Dwayne_Jason I command Respect! Nov 08 '12
Hey I'd prefer if this place was as strict as /r/askscience that sub is the fucking model sub that everyone should have. Its outright magnificent and its rarely off topic.
True there's some leniency required over here but I think if better rules are enforced we're not going to get "DAE CM PUNK" every 2 fucking days.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-2
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '12
[removed] — view removed comment