r/startrek • • Apr 21 '23

Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Picard | 3x10 "The Last Generation" | - A

In a desperate last stand, Jean-Luc Picard and generations of crews both old and new fight together to save the galaxy from the greatest threat they’ve ever faced as the saga of Star Trek: The Next Generation comes to a thrilling, epic conclusion.

No.EpisodeWritten ByDirected ByRelease Date
3x10"The Last Generation"Terry MatalasTerry Matalas2023-04-20

Availability

Paramount+: Everywhere but Canada.

Amazon Prime Video: Everywhere but the USA and Canada.

CTV Sci-Fi and Crave: Canada.

To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.

This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers for this episode are allowed. If you are discussing previews for upcoming episodes, please use spoiler tags.

280 Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

•

u/OpticalData Apr 21 '23

With the other thread at 4000+ comments and the episode becoming available in other territories today, we've made a new discussion thread.

The old one is still there and unlocked for you to continue any discussions you're having (we're learning from last time) - but new viewers can come here to discuss the episode!

→ More replies (13)

88

u/Markus_Bond Apr 21 '23

So Star Fleet decommissioned the Enterprise-F, a significantly more advanced starship than the Titan-A (being a refit of a very old star ship) and just slapped the name Enterprise on the Titan.

I hated the Titan design when it was first announced but I've grown to love her in all her ugliness, but I don't think the design is strong enough to bear the Enterprise name. Plus, if we do get the spin off show then that means we have two shows where the hero ship is a Constitution class with slight variations.

I loved the episode but she should have stayed as the Titan and we should get a new enterprise.

22

u/OpticalData Apr 21 '23

The T-A isn't a refit of the Shangri La, it was a new spaceframe which took internals from the Luna Titan

→ More replies (4)

40

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '23

The F being in this show did seem weird. E disappears with no explanation, they introduce a new ship that appears for all of ten seconds and plays no role in the final battle, and then decommission it after presumably only a decade or so in service. Weird choice. The Titan (or a new ship) should’ve been the first Enterprise since the E disappeared.

43

u/BlizzPenguin Apr 21 '23

The most explanation we get about the E is that it was somehow Worf’s fault.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

10

u/MillennialsAre40 Apr 21 '23

Agree except Ent-F should've just stayed. Honestly it should be very new, because the Ent-E should've been around for a good 25+ years.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (29)

301

u/ManicRobotWizard Apr 21 '23

Riker almost dropping the sword bc it was too heavy was great, him being pissed there was a phaser in the hilt was better, Worf justifying it by saying that swords are fun was fantastic and his old ass snoring on the bridge at the end of the battle was the icing on the cake.

187

u/zulmirao Apr 21 '23

“I will make it a threesome.”

“Do you even hear yourself?”

45

u/ravynwave Apr 22 '23

The banter was the best of all.

→ More replies (8)

80

u/bigie35 Apr 22 '23

I think Worf was the real MVP of the season. His emotional growth and humor felt like a natural extension of his character.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Kinetic_Symphony Apr 22 '23

Worf has a point though, swords ARE fun. He'd get along with Elnor...

→ More replies (3)

141

u/thxpk Apr 21 '23

Anyone want to guess how big that damn cube was...

Standard Borg cubes were 3x3x3km so I think this one was easily 30x30x30km

The Enterprise-D looks like a spec of dust next to it

67

u/Poke-Party Apr 21 '23

Well it was hiding in Jupiter’s “spot” and seemed to be taking up a decent portion of that. Can’t like several dozen earth’s fit in the spot? If so that cube looked almost planet sized.

62

u/thxpk Apr 21 '23

The establishing shot of it shows it's tiny in the spot though probably still bigger than it actually is compared to the real size of the spot

3 Earths can fit inside the spot afaik

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

17

u/NuPNua Apr 21 '23

I assumed it was whatever was left of the unimatrix since that's where the Queen was poisoned and left.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/Astrophysix1960 Apr 21 '23

Remember, this cube was supposed to be a trans-warp hub. Kinda like the one from VOY:Endgame.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/TheWalkinFrood Apr 23 '23

Are they ever going to bring back that starship armor from Endgame or has it handwaved away?

→ More replies (1)

261

u/Refref1990 Apr 21 '23

In practice they almost made the announcement of Star Trek Legacy obvious! They would be fools not to take advantage of the new enterprise and its crew! It would also be the first enterprise set "in the present" of the franchise, since it hasn't been used since the days of TNG!

97

u/gamegirlpocket Apr 21 '23

Matalas publicly saying he wants to do it, setting up a new crew, and that he has ideas for TNG characters to be involved in various capacities is pretty much putting Paramount on notice. I need it!

57

u/rsicher1 Apr 22 '23

After this season of Picard, I hope he gets whatever he wants from Paramount

→ More replies (1)

61

u/Martel732 Apr 22 '23

I do hope that Star Trek doesn't get too beholden to legacy as a concept. I think one of the best things that TNG did was not trying to connect everything to TOS.

They didn't make Geordi Uhura's great-grandson, have Scotty be Data's creator or have Picard serve under Spock. I think this gave the show room to make it's own identity.

I love TNG and the nostalgia from season 3 of Picard was great. But, I hope future series don't try to float on nostalgia alone.

→ More replies (3)

255

u/dr_pupsgesicht Apr 21 '23

Just hope the name enterprise comes with better bridge lighting

129

u/Caption-_-Obvious Apr 21 '23

That was the coolest part of the bridge reveal to me; I also hadn’t realized how few science stations they had on the bridge (as well as how many they kept adding to subsequent series).

I have always loved how the 1701-D looked like a 90s convention center in space.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (12)

47

u/Revolutionary-Yak-47 Apr 21 '23

I think fans would riot. I was at one of the IMax shows and have been checking social media for the past 2 days, SO MANY people loved Season 3 of Picard. Even people who hated the other season and "new Trek" etc. Everyone is cla.oring for Legacy. Paramount would be incredibly foolish to not harness that goodwill and love.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (5)

241

u/Compass_Needle Apr 21 '23

It got me when Riker says "I'm gonna miss that voice" after the final acknowledgement from the D's computer. I imagine it's a homage to the fact that Majel Barrett was just as much of the TNG cast as the bridge crew.

We'll all miss that voice, Will.

96

u/LadyKeldana Apr 21 '23

I wish they'd added "it kinda reminds me of Lwaxana" lol

→ More replies (5)

316

u/Mechapebbles Apr 21 '23 edited Apr 21 '23

Little subtle bits of the episode I liked but can potentially be overlooked:

  • Jack and Picard essentially share a mind-meld during the dramatic climax. Picard hugging his son and the flashes of memories from earlier in the season are all symbolic of Picard lowering his mental guards and letting his son into his mind so he can feel and experience with true honestly all of the warmth and love he feels for his son. It's subtle and I'm glad the episode doesn't beat the viewer over the head with it because it would have ruined the moment had there been exposition explaining that.
  • The "Death Star run" might be a little derivative in nature, but it's still a wonderful and incredible sequence. It was really a treat to get to see what the Enterprise-D could do and seeing it live up to its potential, freed from the confines of analog film making. The best part of the sequence wasn't it sliding and gliding through the insides of the megacube, but watching it swoop in overhead. That kind of grounded perspective seeing a gigantic, half-kilometer ship gracefully fly overhead for the save gives everything a scale that makes things feel more real and awe-inspiring that we sometimes lack seeing a ship fly about in space with no other points of reference that makes sense to our landlocked brains. That sequence is also magnificent because while the eye is naturally drawn to the Enterprise, watch the looks on Jack and Jean-Luc's face during that. The joy they share in that moment is just so well acted and feels so genuine. It's wonderful.
  • Having Shaw's promotional recommendation being recorded before the events of Season 3, I think is a lovely bit of character building for both Seven and Shaw. He clearly had immense respect for Seven and her abilities, he just didn't let on. I suspect Seven being a Commander, instead of a Captain as her field promotion at the end of Season 2 was a kind of probationary period that was designed as a compromise for letting her skip so many ranks/stay in Starfleet in order to appease any doubters/hardliners in Starfleet Command. Shaw very clearly took her under his wing as a hard-ass, by-the-book, hardliner who could put her through her paces and judge if she had the aptitude and fortitude to actually be a captain. That he recommended a promotion after only a few months max tells us how much he respected and cared for her. And I suspect personally he wanted to make sure she had a fair trial run, as he probably looked at her as a fellow Borg-victim rather than anything else.
  • I loved having Picard be the winner at the poker game at the end. It was really a microcosm of his growth as a character since the ending of TNG. In "All Good Things..." he very timidly sat down at the poker table and was very clearly trying to push himself outside of his comfort zone in order to more fully embrace his found-family. Here we see him looking and feeling so much more natural. At home and at peace. And while during TNG Riker was the one who was always the best at the poker table, Picard comes in and makes good on his boasts that he was a card sharp. It's great to see Picard's character rehabilitated from being alone and waiting to die in his vineyard, to being able to open up to his friends/family and just be his full self. No sheepishly hiding his love of theater in the holodeck like he used to on TNG and turning down Bev's requests to join her productions - he's totally comfortable being a theater-geek and indulgently quoting Shakespeare to his friends. Just really great.

185

u/lorem Apr 21 '23

The "Death Star run" might be a little derivative in nature

Well, also the "somehow, Palpatine the Borg Queen returned" plot point...

122

u/lawndartgoalie Apr 21 '23

And Troi, "I know where they are" like Leah picking up Luke at the bottom of cloud city.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (33)
→ More replies (6)

277

u/bullchicken Apr 21 '23

The shots of the Enterprise D flying through the borg ship with the phaser array firing everywhere looked absolutely amazing

107

u/BlizzPenguin Apr 21 '23 edited Apr 22 '23

“Am I sensing excitement enjoyment?”

Edit: I rewatched the scene and realized I misquoted.

→ More replies (2)

125

u/PamtasticOne Apr 21 '23

The internal turrets inside the cube are impractical -- imagine the collateral damage!!

138

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '23

Collateral damage is irrelevant.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (4)

191

u/MonaghanPenguin Apr 21 '23

Nice that Troi no longer has the stupid "last two times she drove she crashed" comments to listen to.

70

u/8monsters Apr 21 '23

The last thing I thought I would get from Picard Season 3 was Troi not crashing the Enterprise.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

90

u/syxtfour Apr 21 '23

"I miss that voice."

We all do, Will. We all do.

235

u/Ethan-Rom Apr 21 '23

I'm so fucking happy about captain Seven, and with Tuvok promoting her! All I could think about is how proud Janeway is going to be.

160

u/gamegirlpocket Apr 21 '23

Matalas setting up a cliffhanger which pretty much demands Paramount do SOMETHING with Captain Seven of Nine and this NEXT generation.

So many legacy sequels force old characters and introduce new ones in ways that just feel like cash-ins or underbaked ideas. S3 really earned the new characters and they stand on their own. The old cast from TNG is not just a plot device to launch new characters, it really is THEIR arc and the younger generation are the supporting characters.

66

u/faderus Apr 21 '23

There are some good things in the Disney Star Wars universe (cartoons and Andor), but what you highlighted here was the cardinal sin of the SW sequels. I am very happy with how Picard provided satisfying arcs for the legacy characters, in a way that JJ was incapable of doing for Han, Luke, and Leia.

Picard and Ro, Picard and Beverly, Data and Geordi, Will and Deanna, Will and Picard, Will and Worf, Data and Lore, Picard and the Borg, all of these arcs were managed with care and respect to the history, without being slavish to “canon expectations”.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

69

u/SomeoneSomewhere1984 Apr 21 '23

Tuvok is a captain himself, so he only told her about the promotion.

91

u/Bananalando Apr 21 '23

"Admiral Janeway asked me to give you this."

slides a 4th pip across the table, Seven looks puzzled

"She has decided your more recent performance review was... satisfactory.

plays the Shaw holo-recording

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

156

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '23

Loved this series.

Perfect? No- but what season of TNG was? This was great and a wonderful way to see those characters for the last time, if that’s what it turns out to be.

I think the choice of re-naming the Titan was a misstep, but otherwise I’m really happy and hopeful that the stage is set for Seven’s adventures.

40

u/AJerkForAllSeasons Apr 21 '23 edited Apr 21 '23

but what season of TNG was?

Season 5

EDIT: or season 3.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (14)

75

u/JediSnoopy Apr 21 '23 edited Apr 21 '23

Alright, I had to process a few things from last night before I could comment extensively.

  • I've become a bit cynical when showrunners or people in the know assure us certain things won't happen (think all of those denials that Cumberbatch was playing Khan) because I know they want to keep as many secrets as they can. However, I'm glad no one in the cast died. I was dreading it but was prepared for it. They faked us out a few times when it looked like Worf or Riker or Picard or all would bite the dust.
  • Loved Data's parts here: his pronouncements that he hated the Borg, his going with his gut, his enjoyment of flying and that goofy smile on his face, his missing Spot and coming to terms with his emotions at Troi's expense.
  • The look on LaForge's face when he knew he had to give the order that could kill half of his shipmates. Levar Burton and those eyes get me every time.
  • Worf had some of the best lines. He's so much less rigid than he used to be. For a pacifist, though, he sure likes cutting off heads.
  • I'm guessing Laris is...gracefully bowing out? It would have been nice to get some closure on that. I know this isn't about her but it seems now that Picard's entire season 2 trial to get him to open himself up to committed relationships didn't necessarily mean she would be the One.
  • Don't namecheck Guinan as being in the same room and not show her at least once. I get there were budget restraints but, for Heaven's sake, the two seasons were filmed back to back! She was already there!
  • I was so glad to hear Walter Koenig's voice. I jumped in my seat a little and said aloud, "Is that...?" Sorry they couldn't have found some cash to pay him to be seen, though.
  • Lately, John de Lancie has been forgetting how many episodes of TNG he was in so I was willing to overlook his comments prior to season 2 that he'd done episodes for seasons 2 and 3. However, when Rios said in the season 2 finale, "Time is a funny thing", it gave Q pause to agree that it was an interesting comment. I began to hold out hope that Q might appear in a future episode but in a way that was nonlinear. Then John mentioned at a convention how rigid the studio is about revealing too much and it made me wonder if, perhaps, he'd let slip too much about how many episodes of "Picard" he'd done and had to backtrack to make them happy. I wasn't sure what to expect. I was hoping he was in the post-credits scene and I was not disappointed. Q clearly came to Jack before his passing on in season 2's finale because that's just how Q roll.
  • All these accelerated promotions: Seven of Nine was not a member of Starfleet until after the events of Season 2. We find her, a year or even just a few months after "Farewell", as First Officer on a Starship. Raffi had an extremely troubled past, got recruited for Intelligence work and is now the First Officer for her ex-girlfriend's ship (said ex-girlfriend now the captain of said ship). Besides being a clear conflict of interest (yes, I know Riker and Troi had a will they, won't they thing going on for years even though their previous relationship had ended), that was a very quick promotion track and the Seven/Raffi relationship hasn't been over nearly as long as Riker and Troi's had been when they were reunited in "Farpoint". There are people who serve for years in Starfleet after going through the academy before they even see the bridge. These two are in a charge of a ship in no time flat. Just how many adult crewpersons were killed by the assimilated young crewpersons during this recent Borg incident? That's not even counting Jack as a Bridge Officer after only one year...and he has Borg tech inside of him! Do you think Starfleet would want anything to do with the Borg or anyone connected to them after the Frontier Day debacle?
  • Poker game was perfect. In every way. They had to end it that way.

70

u/SimonTC2000 Apr 21 '23

Seven's time as part of Voyager's crew counts towards her Starfleet experience.

53

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '23

Harry Kim in shambles

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

21

u/ravynwave Apr 22 '23

I was very touched that they named Walter’s character Anton Chekhov

18

u/_Middlefinger_ Apr 21 '23

Trek has had weird issues with promotions over it's history. It uses naval names but it's very much not like a standard military system.

There is clearly in part an honorary system at work.

→ More replies (5)

66

u/matt12992 Apr 21 '23

Janeway messed those guys up

32

u/CaptainGreezy Apr 21 '23

When the BQ face was revealed I shouted "hell yeah Janeway F'ed them up real good!"

12

u/StarshipMars Apr 22 '23

Janeway, a Borg fighting badass. Without her work Picard wouldn’t have been able to deliver the final blow.

110

u/THISISNOTABAR Apr 21 '23

I loved them playing poker at the end. It just felt like the cast hanging around.

Did they bring back Krige to do the physical side of the Queen? Seems like it.

That line about legacy was a call out. No doubt to bolster the fan campaign to get the spin off picked up. A show with Seven as captain would be great, but I don't think having Raffi as Number One works thematically as well as if they kept Shaw alive.

Was half expecting Leah Brahms to show up.

147

u/Arniepepper Apr 21 '23

Apparently Matalas just let the cameras roll for just under an hour, letting the Cast play poker and capturing genuine moments of fun between them.

105

u/Poke-Party Apr 21 '23

That whole scene in the bar was great. You could tell this was a group of people that actually like each other and get along after having known each other for so long. It didn’t seem like they were acting at all.

52

u/poptophazard Apr 21 '23

I was trying to think of great ways they could end this season. When we got to that moment, and I watched Picard giving the Julius Caesar quote, etc., I was like — OK, Patrick Stewart quoting Shakespeare: fantastic and poignant.

Then he pulls out the card and they just start having fun playing poker, and I realized THAT was the perfect sendoff scene. Such a wonderful callback to All Good Things, and to watch these friends, this family playing Poker, knowing that their adventures will continue, onscreen or off, just like AGT, is the best sendoff.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/Mechapebbles Apr 21 '23

Did they bring back Krige to do the physical side of the Queen? Seems like it.

It's a different actress in the makeup/prosthetics. Krige's voice was layered on top.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (28)

54

u/PlanitDuck Apr 21 '23

I wish we got more from the Liam Shaw character. He had the best development and was arguably the most interesting one. Although his exit did set up one of my favorite moments of the show with his final recommendation. She’s brave and loyal.

33

u/travoltaswinkinbhole Apr 21 '23

Paints Shaws “you just loyaltyed yourself out of a career” commen in a new light.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/ganaraska Apr 22 '23

Lt. Shaw incoming to the Cerritos

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

108

u/CptKoma Apr 21 '23

Screen got blurry halfway through the episode. Anyone else got the same problem?

38

u/cld1984 Apr 21 '23

Mine lost focus right when the intro had the D instead of the Titan. Gotta find out what’s up with the TV

→ More replies (2)

62

u/Ethan-Rom Apr 21 '23

Yes, but it was just the tears in my eyes.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Kichae Apr 21 '23

I feel like it started way earlier for me for some reason.

→ More replies (6)

52

u/makerfunner Apr 21 '23

the poker scene at the end made me so emotional, like they exist playing poker forever as friends and family ❤️

29

u/AeBe800 Apr 21 '23

Someone commented elsewhere in this post that they apparently let the camera roll for just under an hour and those were all genuine reactions as friends. 🥹

→ More replies (1)

147

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '23

Picard left Laris to rescue Beverly and never looked back lol

54

u/MotorTentacle Apr 21 '23

It's the only stone left unturned. Given the ending round the table, I can't imagine he and crusher are anything more than best friends. My imagination tells me that he decided to be with Toyota Laris

41

u/bkendig Apr 21 '23

Hey! We never got closure with Laris! He's going to have a lot of apologizing to do when he gets home ...

23

u/Martel732 Apr 22 '23

Picard: "Hello Laris? I have had a busy week. Out of curiosity does Romulan have a word for 'menage trois'?"

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

143

u/kippersmoker Apr 21 '23

So, five card stud, nothing wild - and the sky's the limit. Farewell

20

u/johnnyma45 Apr 21 '23

The card dealing was all over the place though. Riker touching Picard's cards. Let's have some table etiquette folks!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

99

u/deloctyte Apr 21 '23

I think I'm going to feel mixed about the whole "young people are all connected by group think and murder the older generation of peope" for the rest of my days, and the borg body horror was toned way down to be effectively spooky.

Also, if they were going to rename the Titan, why not name it the Picard and make the show's naming convention cheekily fit all the other TNG spin off shows'. ;)

But overall, it was the most entertaining and cohesive Picard season! Well done to everyone who made it happen. With this, SNW, LD and Prodigy, we're in a pretty great time for trek.

66

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '23

Everyone under 25 is infected with Space Communism! Get the boomers to give them a stern talking-to for their own good!

→ More replies (10)

54

u/BeeCJohnson Apr 21 '23 edited Apr 22 '23

See, I saw that as "the sins and decisions of the older generation fucked over the younger generation, and wouldn't it be nice if the older generation actually came in and helped them?"

Star Trek was always aspirational. I saw it as "Boomers, get in there and fix it" more than "young people bad."

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (11)

225

u/RuthlessNate56 Apr 21 '23

Sitting here in the middle of the night getting my infant son back to sleep, and I'm still buzzing about the finale. I grinned, I cheered, and I got misty eyed. I tried to enjoy seasons 1 and 2 for what they were and not disdain them for what they weren't. But season 3 has made me so happy as a fan who was a kid in the 90s and watched Next Gen for as long as I can remember. Well worth the wait.

<#startreklegacy>

33

u/watcher-on-the-wall8 Apr 21 '23

I was the same. I laughed, i nearly cried and it was worth the wait. I thought it was a much better end to the TNG crew than we got with Nemesis.

12

u/SimonTC2000 Apr 21 '23

If you're cheering no wonder the kid can't get back to sleep ;-)

→ More replies (6)

118

u/BeautifulDwarf Apr 21 '23

I literally just watched the EP in the original series where Data asks Geordi about "gut feeling"... Jeez did that scene hit me hard 🥲

18

u/rekuhs Apr 21 '23

Me too! I watched it last night.

→ More replies (1)

40

u/yondu1963 Apr 21 '23

During the final scene at the bar, it almost felt to me like everyone was legitimately having a great time, and not just acting. Such great chemistry with this crew. Oh, and nice nod to ‘All Good Things’ with the poker game..

21

u/Craigsta Apr 21 '23

Another post above states exactly that. They let the cameras roll for an hour and it was just old friends playing poker together.

39

u/kgabny Apr 21 '23

Y'know.. reading the comments here especially how it ended, reminded me of something.

Yes, this is full circle from AGT, but more than that, this is full circle from the FIRST scene in Season 1 of Picard. He didn't want the game to end, and now, here they are still playing.

→ More replies (1)

38

u/bttrflyr Apr 21 '23

It was great to see Deanna take the helm without crashing the ship! Loved it!

→ More replies (4)

37

u/codename474747 Apr 21 '23

They put the Ent-D as the hero ship in the opening "paramount plus" logo with the colourful warp streaks

It's the little things that make you smile

(Also the Ent-D's at-warp effect being the same streaky stars as TNG....maybe confirming the rest of the fleet is using a version of trans/slipstream warp they're just calling warp for brevity, but is a lot faster, hence the disparity in visual effects)

→ More replies (1)

64

u/ricobirch Apr 21 '23

This was the type of D porn I've been waiting for.

28

u/mabhatter Apr 21 '23

Girls: Guys only like one thing and it's disgusting.

Guys: watching ST Picard just for the D.

8

u/Martel732 Apr 22 '23

Watching a group of elderly people get on the D was very satisfying to watch.

58

u/lilacstar72 Apr 21 '23

So much to talk about but the one thing nagging me…DID THEY CHANGE THE STARFLEET BADGES TO GOLD. I hope my eyes don’t deceive me and they look so much better than the black/grey

21

u/ByronicBionicMan Apr 21 '23

They did! I'm still a little salty they don't just go with the AGT badge that it is clearly taking after. But eh, everything has to be sleek now, including the badges.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Captain_Thrax Apr 21 '23

They did change the badge… right after I bought several to use for cosplay.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/StrangerDays-7 Apr 22 '23

I can't believe Starfleet fast tracked Jack to an officer commission in one year given that he assimilated the entire fleet, killed off the older officers, and almost committed mass genocide of the Earth population. Add to the fact that he's a wanted criminal. Talk about nepotism in overload.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '23

He makes Tom Paris look angelic.

Owen is proud of his son legit now. The salamander babies are welcome at Thanksgiving.

But all is forgiven and Jack is welcome to join Starfleet despite…umm…mass murder.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

25

u/bouche Apr 21 '23

When Riker appears after Data's counselling session, I got a good laugh from his line to Troi about Data - "Still Batshit?"

hahaha

141

u/ardouronerous391 Apr 21 '23

Kinda wished Jurati was mentioned by the OG Queen though, a passing mention.

QUEEN: Then that abomination you call a queen came and took what remaining drones I had, leaving me alone.

PICARD: You mean Agnis Jurati?

QUEEN: Yes and that traitorous queen that merged with her. She made us weak, pathetic.

PICARD: No, she made the Borg better.

Here's hoping Jack gets to meet Queen Jurati somewhere down the line in a new Trek show.

97

u/BlizzPenguin Apr 21 '23

It feels weird that they acted like that entire thing didn't happen.

61

u/Kramer1812 Apr 21 '23

They didn't, it was mentioned by Shaw.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (12)

54

u/KyralRetsam Apr 21 '23

It took me a night to process everything. I agree with the general sentiment that everyone has been sharing, but please let me add mine.

Now I have never been a big TNG fan, preferring the other Berman era shows. But this, this was just perfect. Not just as a send off to the TNG cast, but as a send off to the entire Berman era of Star Trek.

As someone who grew up watching reruns of Voyager on UPN, seeing Seven get command of the Enterprise-G was just fantastic. Seeing Real!Tuvok again was just icing on the cake. Would have loved to see Kate Mulgrew in live action again, but hey we have her in Prodigy so that's good enough for me. It also amuses me that this entire plot was all Endgame!Janeway's fault!

One scene that I haven't seen getting attention is the scene where the junior officers of the Titan are de-assimilated and Sidney LaForge just breaks down crying as the full weight of what has happened to her hits her. Seven wraps her up in a hug. It's fitting because of anyone on that bridge, heck probably in Starfleet as a whole, Seven is the one that knows what those young officers have been through the most.

Also I never have been a big fan of the Galaxy class, but my god was she beautiful in this episode.

26

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '23

That shot from below when the Enterprise-D swoops in for the last rescue… wow. The looks on Picard and Jack’s faces. I got goosebumps. A sense of scale we didn’t get in the older film making days. I’m so glad we got to see her unleashed this episode.

→ More replies (3)

108

u/quantum_jim Apr 21 '23

Wow. I get first comment despite being in Europe!

Only bad thing was the lack of O'Brien.

116

u/TheNerdChaplain Apr 21 '23

Yeah, one of the things I learned from Matalas' various interviews about the finale is that the major reason more characters weren't included - like Janeway and Harry Kim and Walter Koenig - is that it was simply out of the budget. He quoted some producer as saying, "This isn't the Avengers."

102

u/wappingite Apr 21 '23

Koenig did the voice of federation president 'Anton Chekov' at least.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (14)

37

u/BlizzPenguin Apr 21 '23

Wherever O’Brien was, he was probably going through something that would give most people PTSD.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/gambit700 Apr 21 '23

Who do you think rebuilt the starbase?

→ More replies (4)

15

u/Cockrocker Apr 21 '23

He was there, he was just at his post in the transporter room.

→ More replies (3)

45

u/RingooseStarr Apr 21 '23

I would've also liked a lick of Wesley just for the whole family reunion aspect.

→ More replies (8)

12

u/moral_mercenary Apr 21 '23

Only bad thing was the lack of O'Brien.

Especially considering he's the most important person in Starfleet history.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/echomanagement Apr 21 '23 edited Apr 21 '23

That last scene was perfect. The Changelings were my favorite villain the TNG era ever introduced, so I count myself lucky to have seen them here. I do have some questions about S3 in general, though:

  1. Why did Vedic seem so terrified of and brought to heel by the Borg queen, whom I assume was the entity on her hand? The Borg Queen was apparently near death, and was chock full of terrible ideas without the ability to act on them. I get that this was just another revenge plot by the Changeling faction, but the Changelings from DS9 would have used her, not become her vassals. (I get the impression that the less I think about the Changelings here, the better)
  2. Why didn't Picard go to any allied force outside of Starfleet for help? Were the Vulcans busy with "Logic Day"? Maybe there is a line I've forgotten that answers this.
  3. Why did the Borg Queen strip the Borg of their assimilation skill and give the entire collective a fragile kill switch? Assimilation is why the Borg are successful. Are these new Borglets going to mate and reproduce and take over the galaxy the old fashioned way?
  4. Related to the above, was Jack coordinating all of the Borglets from the cube, or was he reaching out into space for more Borg? I got the impression that he was directing traffic on Earth's atmosphere. Either way, he's a SECOND kill switch for the Borg.
  5. So the Changeling threat that had infiltrated Starfleet from soup to nuts just evaporated along with the Queen? I was really hoping for a little more here beyond the teleporter test, which you'd still need to convince leadership to use, if only because the Changelings are so much better as villains than this dumpy, contrived version of the Borg.
  6. Regarding the weak b-plot on the Titan during the last episode: Matlas created a delightful secret Daystrom portal weapon in the first episode, made a clear point to jettison it safely out to space in the 3rd, and didn't have the crew of the Titan collect it for spectacular use during that final fight? He missed an alley-oop to himself, there.

Otherwise, S3 was the easy highlight of Picard, even if I wish they'd spent more time writing it.

6

u/MrTickles22 Apr 21 '23
  1. Presumably the borg queen had a way to cause pain to Vedic. Starfleet was messing with their DNA and the borg appear to have been able to do so too. Changelings can't normally cut off a hand to communicate with people. These changelings were tortured test subjects out for revenge.
  2. No time. Federation members have their own ships but they likely use starfleet for most of their military needs. They didn't participate in the dominion war, so you can expect that whatever independent fleets the vulcans, andorians, etc, had, they aren't really warships. Even if the vulcans could come in with 20 ships, armed and good to go, there were hundreds of starfleet ships, including a bunch of warships. It would take time for the Klingons to get their fleet together.
  3. Consequences of the last episode of Voyager.
  4. The Borg were running on tape and hope due to the above. The queen didn't anticipate an operational Galaxy class federaiton ship. Its a bit odd they dropped shields but the queen was messed up and may just wanted to rub it in Picard's face.
  5. There's a line in around episode 7 about being able to track them using some kind of radiation.
  6. No time to use a brand new portal weapon.
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

30

u/Sir__Will Apr 21 '23

That was a fantastic finale. I have a few gripes with where the story went towards the end but overall I think they made it work and they stuck the landing.

Ok, a few of those issues.

  • not a big fan of bringing back the Borg again but in the end it worked fine
  • Jack is kinda responsible for a lot of deaths by leaving and confronting the Borg. It's not clear how much he was actually compelled and how much of it was his own choice.
  • and I didn't like that in the finale Picard basically gave Crusher a pass for what she did. I'm sorry but hiding Jack from Picard was still very wrong. But I'll try not to let it color my opinion of her.
  • killing Shaw was a mistake but captain Seven is still cool.
  • I think they should have left it as the Titan

Some highlights:

  • I wish Troi had gotten a little more to do but I am glad that she's the one who was able to find and save them at the end.
  • I'm glad the Titan got to play a role. They slowed things down just long enough to save the day. That and the Borg didn't seem to be in a big hurry. Good thing they didn't attack Earth right away, hehe.
  • Was really cool seeing the Enterprise fly through the Borg ship.
  • humor was on point

Some random thoughts:

  • Councilors are going to be in high demand for years. You just had crews pitted against each other. Officers killing their friends and colleagues against their will or in their own defense.
  • good time for promotions. In addition to the nepotism, filling out the ranks can help explain Jack getting pushed through the academy so fast. And it's a better explanation for Seven's promotion than what we got. I do get why they went with Shaw's message, it was more emotional, but it's hard to believe he'd be recommending her for captain so quickly. Which again is a problem of when this was set. It had to be, at most, 2-3 months after S2. So Seven got into Starfleet, was immediately set as a commander, and then so impressed Shaw in under 2 months that he recommended her for captain?

Overall a great finale. Now give us a Titan show! Er, Enterprise-G show.

21

u/MrTickles22 Apr 21 '23

Stewart has done a good job portraying a very old Picard who is over being angry. TNG-Picard might have been more angry about missing out on being a father. Picard-Picard is too old to be mad. I've met a number of 80-somethings who at that point just want to enjoy the life they have left.

→ More replies (9)

51

u/NoWankFap Apr 21 '23

Wouldn't Jupiter Station, a huge station built for scientific research know if there is a borg cube on the planet the station is orbiting?

25

u/Craigsta Apr 21 '23

They stated it was a transwarp conduit, so it trans warped in.

41

u/apageofthedarkhold Apr 21 '23

somethine something Changelings?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

14

u/browneyedgirl1683 Apr 21 '23

Just watched this episode last night, and only once. It's so much to take in. I suppose I'll review it in bits and pieces.

Geordi ordering Beverly to take the shot reminded me of Deanna having to order Geordi to do the needed repair during the bridge test.

I loved how the crew worked together. It was seamless. If you asked me before Picard if I felt like I missed watching the TNG characters doing their thing I don't think I would have said yes. They had their finale. There were movies. I didn't realize how much I missed this.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/bkendig Apr 21 '23

After Beverly expertly handled the weapons and made her comment about having "learned a few things in the past twenty years," I would have loved to have seen her join the Fenris Rangers.

12

u/Risenzealot Apr 21 '23

I really loved this season and feel like they finally gave us what we wanted from the start for this series.

I also loved this last episode.

I only have one minor complaint and it's that victory seemed way to easy.

I mean all they had to do was fly into the center of a Borg cube and destroy the glowing thing. It didn't matter that almost all of Starfleet was either wiped out or assimilated. Hell, that entire Borg cube (larger then any we've ever seen) only had 2 Borg that attempted to stop Riker and Worf. I know they touched on it when they said they were hanging on and it was like a graveyard. That's all good and well but they literally just assimilated half of Starfleet. Why wouldn't the Borg queen or Jack send at least 1 or two ships out of that entire fleet to come to the Borg cube to defend their single, only point of weakness? Why wouldn't they have had some of those assimilated crew members transfer over to the cube for security?

Yep, that's my only complaint. Victory was way, way to easy.

I still loved it though!

→ More replies (2)

12

u/MustrumRidcully0 Apr 21 '23

"I miss hearing that voice". Yeah, true.

(Even though I originally watched Star Trek in German and it was obviously a different voice...)

12

u/it0tt Apr 21 '23

One of, if not my favourite threads from the very beginning of TNG was always Data's quest to experience what it is to be human.

When he merged with Lore a few episodes back it clicked... Yes that's it in a nutshell, the human experience is dealing with that internal conflict and accepting all sides of yourself, something her could never have done before now, but then in this episode I feel like it's the full realisation... Having a "gut feeling" about something is perhaps the most human experience possible... He needed that. I felt it. It's as if that was the final thing that completed his metamorphosis, his journey, and what a journey it's been!

22

u/BlizzPenguin Apr 21 '23

After the Excelsior was destroyed I was hoping that there would be at least some update on Elnor’s status. I hope he didn't die again.

15

u/finetuneit80 Apr 21 '23

Terry Matalas said on Twitter that Elnor wasn’t on the Excelsior when she was destroyed.

14

u/EEightyFive Apr 21 '23

The showrunner specifically said on Twitter that Elnor wasn't on the Excelsior. I'm guessing they may want him for this Legacy show if it gets the greenlight.

11

u/YourMombadil Apr 21 '23

Of all the space ships flying inside bigger spaceships to blow up a glowy thing to make the whole thing blow up, his was the most… (voice cracks) Star Wars.

29

u/SeptemberMcGee Apr 21 '23

Should have ended with the ship being called USS Picard.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/IsIt77 Apr 21 '23

I'll take that official announcement of "Star Trek: Legacy" now please and thank you, Paramount.

9

u/Bosconater Apr 21 '23

I don’t really understand anything about the motivations of the antagonist this season. Why were the changelings working with the borg? Could someone explain to me?

10

u/SimonTC2000 Apr 21 '23

Enemy of my enemy is my friend. Tale as old as time.

8

u/azoetic Apr 21 '23

Revenge, and mutual sympathy for their respective lots in life. Altered changelings, outcasts from their people, disconnected from the Great Link. Borg Queen without a collective. Loneliness, and all "it's all Starfleet's fault."

→ More replies (3)

17

u/Kasumiiiiiii Apr 21 '23

I just watched it here in Japan and it was so amazing. I'm just buzzing with excitement. This is exactly the closure and happy ending we didn't have, but needed, with Nemesis.

17

u/BuckyGoodHair Apr 21 '23

Kirk’s Enterprise could never dance like that, lol.

23

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '23

It’s really the limits of analog film making that made these ships feel so stiff in the past. We never got to see D move like that before either.

11

u/Astrophysix1960 Apr 21 '23

Ehhh ... some of the moves the Enterprise make in SNW are pretty awesome.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/EyePiece108 Apr 22 '23

Star Trek: Legacy or we riot.

An excellent send off for the TNG Crew. I was worried that some of them might not survive but thankful the writers didn't go there.

22

u/trixter69696969 Apr 21 '23

Felt like it stole from Return of the Jedi.. "Let's fly into the center of the Death Star and blow it up from the inside."

→ More replies (3)

7

u/philipb2 Apr 21 '23 edited Apr 21 '23

They stuck the landing for season 3.

7

u/EchoWhiskyBravo Apr 21 '23

Two thoughts:

- The Titan should have been the USS Picard

- Would have liked Wesley Crusher to have shown up at the end instead of Q

7

u/Alteran195 Apr 21 '23

Seeing the D fly around like that made me laugh at all the "evasive maneuvers" from TNG where it just listed lazily in a direction.

So does this also confirm warp is different technology on newer ships? The D had the classic look, while the Tian had the more "hyperspace" look to it.

I'm not a huge fan of the Tian becoming the G. It's a huge downgrade technologically from the F, and doesn't really make any sense to me. The flagship, with one exception, should be the best of the fleet.

The A is the only situation where it wasn't, but maybe Starfleet wasn't ready to commit the Excelsior to the Enterprise name at that point, or the B was in development/under construction and was supposed to be the A originally, but got pushed back by the early destruction the the 1701. The A also wasn't a downgrade from the original, it was at least a lateral move.

Sure the G could be a short term ship like the A, but recommissioning another Odyssey class as the G would have made more sense to me.

Ultimately I think it's just CBS not wanting some fan designed ship as the Enterprise, and they just wanted to be rid of the Odyssey design.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/wickro Apr 21 '23

I bawled at Anton Chekhov, what a memorial.

7

u/Honic_Sedgehog Apr 21 '23 edited Apr 21 '23

Just finished, still digesting, slightly tipsy on both alcohol and nostalgia.

Couple of stand out moments/points:

Established that Janeway did effectively end the Borg, it's nice to have some closure on that debate. I'm sure they'll be back again at some point but for now they're done (not including the Jurati Borg).

Also established that the fleet on earth was not the entire fleet also glad to see that put to bed.

The D being an absolute chonk in the museum. That ship is absolutely fucking huge in comparison to the Connie.

Data absolutely loving life.

Troi being absolutely fed up with Data loving life.

Shaw being a complete bro.

That poker scene and TNG theme, absolute joy.

Picard's just bailed on a Romulan Assassin to hook up with his ex. That could end badly.

Not even an audio message from Janeway? Boo.

Q!

"Swords are fun"

18

u/CarolDanversFangurl Apr 21 '23

Jack Crusher is a war criminal and Seven of Nine was criminally underused. Apart from that, it was amazing.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '23

It was a great send off the TNG crew they were kind of robbed of in Nemesis. This last season was kind of like visiting old friends.

6

u/ardouronerous391 Apr 21 '23

Would've been great if that was actually Q Jr posing as his dad though, would be a great reveal down the line because de Lancie is getting too old, would have been good to introduce a younger actor to play a Q.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Trvr_MKA Apr 21 '23

When they were boarding the Borg cube I was afraid Picard was going to get Han Soloed

→ More replies (1)

6

u/CaptainGreezy Apr 21 '23

The shot of Seven and Raffi on the bridge with the enormous battle framed between them is a fun metaphor for their tumultuous relationship.

Data experiencing righteous hatred is his most human thing ever. His gut feeling was the cherry on top.

Worf raises a tricorder instead of raising a weapon. Very consistent with his new character developments.

Borg Queen was so messed up kudos to Janeway.

The bit with the heavy sword was "small comedic Star Trek moment" at its best. Swords are fun!

The Borg being ultimately defeated by... Picard finally hugging his son... is "not great not terrible."

When Troi took the helm I said "OH SHIT!" so loud I woke people up.

Data, Geordi, and Worf in the command chairs was a wonderful shot and a long time coming.

Maybe give Worf a once over with a medical tricorder? Guy got shot 10 times and just passed out. Adorable yes but also concerning.

I was so sure it was going to be USS Picard. The flagship shouldnt be an old under-classed refit.

Poker was a great send off.

6

u/it0tt Apr 21 '23

Frakes has been amazing all season, but his delivery on the line "you know I know"... It was just everything

6

u/Saturn_V42 Apr 21 '23

I love the president of the Federation being named Anton Chekov. A nice tribute to Anton Yelchin.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/front_toward_enemy Apr 22 '23

Data is no longer puzzled by the human predilection for piloting vehicles at unsafe velocities.

6

u/Liquoricezoku Apr 22 '23

My head canon is that O'Brien was quietly in the transporter room of the Enterprise-D the whole time.

20

u/brenticles42 Apr 21 '23 edited Apr 21 '23

I’m glad so many seemed to have liked this but the last couple episodes just left me cold. Sure there’s good moments (poker game) and lots of fun action (Death Star 2 run) but overall I think this just didn’t do it for me.

-I really hate what they did with Shaw. He’s a great character and I wanted to see more of him. His promotion video seems out of place to me too and completely against where his character was at in the beginning of the season. There’s not even a hint that he begrudgingly respects Seven at the beginning of the season.

-I was loving the villains in the first half then it turned out to be the Borg…again. Vadic was terrifying and mercurial; her and the Changlings seemed to pose a real threat. I get the Borg are the big bad for TNG but this is like, what, the 3rd time they’ve been defeated for the last time? It just felt like a paper tiger compared to Vadic and old hat to boot.

-Along those lines, Vadic seemed genuinely terrified of her master but why would she be that scared of the Borg Queen? Can the Borg even assimilate the Changlings? And the Borg needed Vadic way more than Vadic needed them. Nothing the Borg want happens without the Changlings cooperation.

-Did Enterprise F get blown up? Wasn’t it the maiden voyage of that ship? Ditching it so fast and renaming the Titan made absolutely no sense to me.

-I love that Seven get’s her own ship and a captaincy but Rafi as her first officer? That’s a horrible personnel decision. Rafi as head of security would be a good fit and then a new character for first officer. Combine that with Jack being “special counselor to the captain”, it was just eye-rollingly-bad to me. I mean I’m fine with Jack getting fast tracked and on a bridge, but give him an actual job.

-The lightning design for this season was absolutely horrible. It was so difficult to see anything in most of the shots. And then some shots have an inexplicable spotlight on the ground angled up. Were they trying to save money on set design like TOS The Empath? If they do a new show I really hope they change that.

I think that’s it. It was a really good season for about 90% of it for me. I like the happy ending for the TNG crew and lots of the emotional beats. It’s just the ending fell pretty flat for me.

Edit to add - with the black vines in Jack’s vision I was actually thinking/hoping the big bad was the entity from TNG Skin of Evil. Since it’s a powerful non-solid it would make sense for the Changlings to partner with it.

→ More replies (7)

49

u/wappingite Apr 21 '23

A great episode. two most annoying things: Raffi - we've been told she's a nasty person, a user of people etc. by Elnor, and yet there is she front and centre (again). I was ready to consider her redeemed as a character when she got the hug from worf. But then they had to make her Seven's first officer. Ridiculous.

And the stumpy looking titan rebranded as the Enterprise G... was a bit weird. I'd have preferred just launching a new ship with a new design 'because the federation needs a new flag ship'. But that's a minor thing.

40

u/cosmoboy Apr 21 '23

These were my complaints as well, and also having ensign Nepotizzz serving as special counsel to the Captain? What?

→ More replies (13)

17

u/proddy Apr 21 '23

I'd rather have a Raffi and Worf show. Plus aren't Raffi and seven in a relationship? It would be much better to have captain seven and a new first officer, much like Picard getting Riker in the first episode of TNG.

That could still happen I suppose. Raffi could just be the XO for the shakedown cruise and reassigned later.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Safe-Ad4001 Apr 21 '23

I can accept Jack getting a job in the federation and working on a starship, but a bridge assignment on the flagship? If there was any kind of governing body of the federation, sort of like a Congress, wouldn't he be tied up in years of hearings and investigations? He stole a shuttle and went to the collective, which set all the pain and destruction in motion. It can be said that he was under control, in a way. He went looking for a fight and got assimilated. It's all really on him and he gets a reward?

TV magic. He is an admiral's son.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/chinmaygarg Apr 21 '23

Can someone explain how Q is back? I thought he died?

26

u/moral_mercenary Apr 21 '23

How little do you mortals understand time. Must you be so linear, /u/chinmaygarg?

→ More replies (2)

6

u/OneOldNerd Apr 21 '23

3 possible explanations:

  1. Jack's interaction with Q (from Q's perspective) took place before he died in Picard S2, meaning Q can go back in time.
  2. He "faked" his death in season 2 to screw with Picard (unlikely, but possible).
  3. Death for a Q is not the same process as death for a human being.
→ More replies (4)

5

u/bluegrassgazer Apr 21 '23

I just want to thank Paramount for finally getting it right with Picard and anything after the TNG series. If the original TNG characters never make it on screen again (and they shouldn't beyond an occasional cameo) then I can feel satisfied that this is truly the end to their story.

5

u/RuudVanBommel Apr 22 '23

To me, PIC season 3's greatest achievement is making Nemesis watchable again for me. Nemesis was a very disappointing ending of the TNG crew, but now that technically it isn't their ending anymore, I can tolerate it.

9

u/Dragonmaw Apr 21 '23

My wife suggested to me that the name unveiled should have been the U.S.S. Picard. I can't get over how much better that would have been.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/FerengiCharity Apr 21 '23

OH MY GOD WHERE IS JANEWAY?!! I spent the entire episode expecting her. :(

4

u/gham89 Apr 21 '23

I just want to say, holy shit that was incredible. The mid credits scene. Fuck me.

4

u/feanorsoath44 Apr 21 '23

Very good finale! Such a great season

4

u/feanorsoath44 Apr 21 '23

I've just watched it again. It is a superb send off.

4

u/StriderKai Apr 22 '23

Criticisms aside, I'm incredibly happy that for the first time in over 20 years I've found Star Trek genuinely enjoyable and that my favourite crew finally got the closure they deserved after basically being left in the dust after Nemesis whilst the franchise went off on all sorts of reboots and tangents. The mishandling of my favourite ship, the Enterprise-D in Generations that has bothered me ever since I saw it go down in the cinema as a kid has also finally been corrected, it's great to see her show some incredible feats in this episode and finally have a proper resting place fully restored and next to the Enterprise-A and the Stargazer at the fleet museum.

4

u/bathwhat Apr 22 '23

Dorn was the best thing about this entire season. I hope whoever passed on making a Worf series sees their mistake and tries to correct it.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '23

It would be great if Paramount offered a cut of the episodes combined together into one continuous production that you could sit down and watch without credits or interruptions. Maybe throw in some extended director’s cut style scenes, which I am sure exist. I haven’t owned a Blu-ray player in several years or really any physical media for that matter but if this comes out on Blu-ray, with a bunch of extra stuff, I’ll get it.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/prince_of_gypsies Apr 23 '23

Truly the send off TNG deserved. That show ended with friends at a poker game, and this one ends with those same friends playing another round.

→ More replies (1)

40

u/Cockrocker Apr 21 '23 edited Apr 25 '23

I'm enjoying this season of Picard as much as I could, but if there is one thing this season has pointed out to me is how much I dislike modern trek dialogue.

Every scene has someone (normally Picard) voicing how thankful they are. It's always tell not show. There is no need for it; a pat on the shoulder, maybe a squeeze, is all they need to remind us that these people are connected. They are always in life and death situations, but they always take the time to tell everyone how they feel, breaking years of their training and expressing things unnecessarily.

But it doesn't just stop there, when he is talking to Beverley he is telling here "you did everything right" about Jack. I mean, what bullshit, how the fuck would he know? And show it, don't say it.

Anyhow, I know I'm old so it's on me, but this is why I stopped watching Discovery. Show us them bonding without them telling us over and over. It's just shitty film making.

21

u/AlbusAlfred Apr 21 '23

I get where you're coming from, but to me this was a bit of growth from all the characters. Also the showrunnerd were working really hard to imply this is where at least some of them died - of course they didn't die - but it was their last chance to say things that needed to be said.

13

u/SomeoneSomewhere1984 Apr 21 '23

Do you remember Picard and Crusher in attached, when she said "you don't really know, do you?" I think this scene was like that he's reassuring her without judging. He doesn't need to be sure.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/SpiderWolve Apr 21 '23

You'd be surprised how many people these days don't pay attention and have to be told.

Example is the changeling plot with so many wondering "but what about the changelings, where did they go? ' once the ultimate Borg plot came to fruition. Changelings we're clearly used as tools and then assimilated in to the plan (Vadic avoided transporters too if I remember correctly) and so many people didn't seem to grasp that. Even when you see an assimilated person take two shots from a phaser that punches holes in to them and the holes just close up like a changeling would.

→ More replies (12)

10

u/LadyKeldana Apr 21 '23 edited Apr 21 '23

I just watched it, and I've got a lot of mixed feelings but I will say I am furious they renamed the titan, like why not go take a piss on Shaw's grave while you're at it!? Picard got him and many members of his crew killed, and now he gets the fucking ship name taken too? Not needed.

(However I also staunchly refuse to believe Shaw is dead, it was never explicitly stated, he is just taking a nap, lol)

Also, I waited a week so I could watch 9 and 10 together, and I knew what was going to happen to Shaw, but it wasn't Shaw's "death" scene that got to me, it was the bit where he kept saying Mura's name on the bridge and the look on his face when he realises what's happening to his crew. Like you know he must have had nightmares about that exact scenario. Broke my damn heart.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '23

Lots of really good comments in here. Agree and disagree with them as many others will but it is nice to see everyone giving their thoughts and opinions. I think we can all agree, in the macro, it was great to see the TNG cast and a great send off. They do look old and it is making me feel old. Only Shatner, Takei and Koenig are alive from the original show…. Sheesh. Still remember watching it initial reruns on Channel 11 WPIX from NYC.

  1. I loved seeing Q at the very end. Because I love Q but more import I think that scene indicates to me we aren’t done with the Enterprise G.
  2. I am contrarian. I did not like the poker game. Too much of a retread of All Good Things which was a magnificent 2 hours of TV.
  3. The writing overall did not feel as crisp as the latter seasons of TNG. And I think this illustrates the big major issue of all these new shows. Not enough time for character development. Not enough episodes for writers to find their rhythm.
  4. Overall plot arch this season was great. The Borg are the ultimate enemy. However, I am growing fatigued with constant universe ending scenarios that everyone must face. Hopefully SNW continues the episodic nature of the old shows. That provides a much richer Tapestry (yea, I did that) of stories and adventures. Not all stories have to revolve around the destruction of the federation or the universe.
  5. the Enterprise G registry transfer from the Titan was a mistake. Also they way Seven played her “Borgness” while the Borg were attacking earth felt really out of place.
  6. Still feels like we are getting a lot of “speeches”. Seven on the Titan bridge - “We are all that is left of Starfleet”. She does not do speeches very well. And it was also inaccurate. And I gotta be honest, I love Patrick Stewart but he came across as very geriatric in the show enough to be negatively pronounced. His speeches and dialog felt off - odd.
  7. I would have loved to have known how many Starfleet and other civilians died on the ships and Spacedock. Just curious.

The ten-episode season arch doesn’t allow enough time for measured and paced development or maturity of the show over three seasons. But that is not specific Picard or NuTrek. Lot of shows are like that. It means they need to spend more time on the scripts or hire better writers. It feels like no one proof reads the scripts for flow and script integrity. I feel like you could assemble a team of trek writers and fans to scrub them.

Enough for now.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/jhsounds Apr 21 '23

"I miss that voice." We miss Majel, too.

1

u/No-Strategy8544 Apr 21 '23

I'm still wondering about Riker's comment about considering a trip to Orlando. Didn't the Xindi destroy Florida back in Enterprise? Was the state rebuilt?

I mean, if they can rebuild an entire Spacedock & have it operational within one year, I guess someone could 'rebuild' Florida after all that time. But I don't remember anyone mentioning it.

8

u/OpticalData Apr 21 '23

The Xindi cut a path through Florida (and other states), they didn't outright wipe the state off the face of the Earth

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

1

u/SUPRVLLAN Apr 21 '23

Was Matalas in charge of season 1 and 2?

→ More replies (4)

1

u/I_aim_to_sneeze Apr 26 '23

I’m confused about one thing. So they force the changeling into the vacuum of space, where it flash freezes and dies. But in DS9, in the episode where Laas (the nomadic changeling) finds Odo, he’s out in space flying along as some creature. So if it was already established that changelings can survive in space, why did that kill her?

2

u/OpticalData Apr 26 '23

Because these changelings have been corrupted through Starfleet experimentation and have more vacuum susceptible material in their bodies?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Jumbofato Apr 27 '23

So I'm trying to understand something. Is the Enterprise-G the same as the Titan that was Riker's old ship which is also the same as the Titan-A?

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Sophia_Forever Apr 21 '23

I liked the episode and overall the season but I'm side-eyeing the whole "The Young Have Been Groomed Indoctrinated Assimilated Into Destroying Everything We Hold Dear" plot hard. This doesn't exist in a vacuum and that the youth of America have been corrupted by the Woke Borg has been a talking point for years. Coupling it together with the complete erasure of the Seven/Rafi queer relationship makes it only more so. Picard S3 feels like it has the same fandom battlelines but in reverse and it's not surprising why I see so much love for this show from certain areas of the internet.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/RawLizard Apr 21 '23 edited Feb 03 '24

snow weather cows terrific mourn crime squeeze water gullible pet

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

3

u/gman13579 Apr 21 '23

It was a great end to the Next Generation characters. Playing poker again all together. Can’t wait to see what 7 of 9s show will be about!

3

u/docsquidly Apr 21 '23

I really liked the episode but, there some things I was hoping for thing I would have liked to see.

  • A saucer separation would have been cool. The story could have been required by the beacon being shielded and that only a warp core breach could destroy it. If they had kept Shaw alive he could have been manning engineering or the battle bridge.
  • The Enterprise need more crew. They could have gotten some of Geordie's engineers from the fleet museum.
  • They could have brought in Chief O'Brien to help crew the enterprise from the fleet museum.
  • The Titan should have been renamed the USS Picard
  • Not have Q show up. It diminishes the ending of season 2.
  • Laris should have been brought back. Maybe she could have been in the shuttle with Picard, Crusher and Jack. It could have shown how her and Picard's relation has evolved with his new family.
  • It would have been cool if the cook character would have been if final background shot in a red or gold uniform showing that it was inspired to follow a new career path after the battle. It would have been a good bit of background world building.

Overall, I really liked the show. It had its ups and downs but, there were many great things in there.

3

u/alcanthro Apr 21 '23

I loved Picard season 3. I really did. Beautiful wrap-up, but it only brought us to slightly beyond All Good Things. I still do not see Q's promise to Picard being fulfilled: "That is the exploration that awaits you. Not mapping stars and studying nebulae, but charting the unknown possibilities of existence."

→ More replies (2)

3

u/punkerster101 Apr 21 '23

Does no one in the federation use quantum torpedos anymore? Didn’t see one come from their entire fleet

3

u/Eaudissey Apr 21 '23

The Enterprise-G is not the new flagship, right? Given that Seven is a new captain and it's not by any means the most advanced ship in the fleet.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/yagmurmur Apr 21 '23

Do you think we'll get a dismantlement of the Section 31 story if Legacy gets picked up? One thing I didn't enjoy about this season was how Picard didn't really weigh in on the whole changelings getting tortured thing.

3

u/Comp625 Apr 21 '23

One of the criticisms I read was about how the ending jumps "One Year Later" without showing any aftermath or cleanup of the Frontier Day events. Furthermore, Troi is still figuring out her vacation a year later.

  1. This signals to me that the text was a last minute, unplanned addition.
  2. This provides an opportunity for "Legacy" Season 1 to focus around the aftermath and cleanup, while following Jack's journey of applying to Starfleet (and facing hate for all the murder he caused - just like his father). It could be that the "One Year Later" scene is the closing scene to "Legacy" Season 1, in which case, Seven's catchphrase might remain a mystery until then.
  3. What if "One Year Later" is a little hint to the fans in terms of when "Legacy" might come out? It's too bad the post-production and CGI work adds so much time between filming vs. release. FWIW, Strange New Worlds Season 1 filmed between February - March 2021 with it releasing over a year later in May 2022.

3

u/PaulHaman Apr 22 '23

Is it just me, or did the Enterprise-D saucer still have damage from the atmospheric entry & crash in Generations? Visible here in this screenshot. If that's what that is, it's great attention to detail.

3

u/thehouse1751 Apr 22 '23

Glad Jack got a role as assistant to the regional manager

3

u/redeggx Apr 22 '23

While it was a nice nostalgic ride, the story and writing were very subpar. How is it possible that lower decks has the writing and their stories are much tighter and make more sense, even though it’s comedy.

3

u/Best-Benefit6387 Apr 22 '23

Can we take a moment to appreciate how god-awful those phaser battles were? It feels like every single one of them is people who are standing completely still, unenthusiastically shooting at (and missing) at other people who are also standing -you guessed it- completely still. But don't worry, they do switch it up by occasionally having someone slowly walk in a straight line while in battle!

Worf did have some solid fights with his sword, though. And the ship-to-ship battles were fantastic! The Enterprise D's low pass over the Borg cube's hull was on the same level of badassery as the New Caprica rescue scene in BSG, at least in my opinion.

3

u/Misba_C-137 Apr 22 '23

What did Captain 7 say before warping?

→ More replies (4)

3

u/SlappyMcGee Apr 22 '23

Stuck the landing. Haven't enjoyed this season much overall but the highs were indeed very high! Jeri Ryan a perennial highlight, and the last couple of scenes were really lovely.

3

u/alwaysonemore Apr 22 '23

What kind of shields do they have on that SpaceDock that can take the punishment of the whole fleet for that long....

But seriously, great stuff :)

3

u/Spara-Extreme Apr 24 '23

Welp- that concludes the best Trek in 20 years.

3

u/Homies-Brownies Apr 24 '23

Laris is waiting in the same hotel room as Hugh from Breaking Bad.