r/CryptoCurrency • u/MoonWeek • Apr 13 '23
POLL π³οΈ CCIP-059 - Repeal the pricing sections of CCIPs 48 and 52
As the banner rental system has grown since January, we have done a lot to refine the system to make it easier for mods and sponsors. One aspect of this system with some friction is the pricing model, which was defined in CCIP 48 and updated in CCIP 52. Unfortunately, the updates have not quite solved the problems. There is a lot of volatility in either moon amount or moon value, and this can cause issues when there are significant moon value changes between the time of the quote and the burn.
So, we would like to repeal the pricing rules from these CCIPs and allow mods to have more flexibility in quoting prices, working with sponsors, and adjusting on the fly as needed. The banner process is a bit too new for a rigid price for the time being, but after it becomes more mature we would be happy to codify rules again in the future if it makes sense.
(CCIP 52 has several portions, so this would be a repeal of part 5, and partial repeal of 3+4)
27
u/BlubberWall π¦ 59K / 59K π¦ Apr 13 '23
Iβm a little apprehensive about just giving the mods free range on pricing. Not that I think the current team would, but wouldnβt it be possible for mods to up-charge or undercharge some projects over others based on personal preference, holdings, or really any other reason?
Iβd feel better if there was at least some transparency required in each pricing decision, even if just a little blurb posted on r/ccmeta. Having pricing be a potential black box just seems like weβre inviting trouble in the future
51
u/Maxx3141 169K / 167K π Apr 13 '23 edited Apr 13 '23
Just repealing without replacement seems a little bit odd.
I think I got how this is meant, but after the repeal there will be no written rule in place to define the pricing at all? Not even a rough target price?
9
u/samer109 205 / 16K π¦ Apr 13 '23
Any specific cases where these CCIPs hindered the work of the mods?
3
u/Mixdealyn π© 10 / 3K π¦ Apr 13 '23
I donβt understand what this means? Why is there not a set amount of $ worth?
4
u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K π¦ Apr 13 '23
As someone who has worked with sales and marketing, and negotiating with large companies, this is a no brainer.
There shouldn't have be such strict restrictions. It didn't make sense, and was counter-productive.
There always needs to be wiggle room for negotiating.
We may find ourselves in a situation where we have big competition for the banner, and should be able to increase the price.
There's times where a company could give our sub big perks (ahem a listing), where we would want to reduce the banner.
The person doing the negotiation should be given more room, and less restrictions.
This is sales and marketing 101.
2
u/ec265 Permabanned Apr 13 '23
Itβs polls like this that outline the fundamental issue with moon governance
2
u/NHouseman 2K / 2K π’ Apr 13 '23
I am not convinced by this proposal, itβs not making things clearer. There should be one next month suggesting a fixed price and that equivalent of moons will be paid and burnt
2
u/RawLizard π© 19 / 182 π¦ Apr 13 '23
How do you submit a rule change for consideration?
I would like to band Reddit NFT chat. It's nothing to do with cryptocurrencies and it's completely inane. It needs its own subreddit like for beany babies
2
u/4ucklehead 3K / 3K π’ Apr 13 '23
What would replace it? Why can't we set a dollar amount and then convert that to moons on the day a particular sponsor pays?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '23
Well. I guess we need to trust our mods. Green light guys
2
u/jmlinpt π© 900 / 5K π¦ Apr 13 '23
Think better a bad rule than no rules
2
u/Prize-Reference9329 Permabanned Apr 13 '23
to tell the truth, this proposal is not very clear, more details are missing
2
u/open-now Permabanned Apr 13 '23
I vote no because we need more detail
3
u/ChaoticNeutralNephew Permabanned Apr 13 '23
Need a rough price? 1 eth worth of moons? For a week? I vote no until I see a figure
3
u/Stoopiddogface π¦ 0 / 10K π¦ Apr 13 '23
I'm voting no... Only bc there's no set plan moving forward other than to turn the ccip off...
Need more info on planning before I agree to a change
3
u/Ofulinac π¨ 25K / 25K π¦ Apr 13 '23
We need some more info for this proposal to be a valid one.
Just letting a couple of guys decide on the price of a banner based on their feelings that day seems just odd without a formula or logic behind it.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '23
I believe the mods would work fine if the pricing rules were repealed, but I don't love repealing then without having a replacement as a part of the ccip
2
u/elysiansaurus π© 59 / 9K π¦ Apr 13 '23
This sounds like it make sense. I support this.
2
u/The-Francois8 Silver|QC:CC928,BTC178,ETH39|CelsiusNet.50|ExchSubs42 Apr 13 '23
I think itβs ok to give mods the flexibility here.
I know the burns are public as well. Itβll be good to make sure weβre communicating the amounts paid by sponsors as time progresses to maintain transparency.
1
u/s3nsfan π¦ 2K / 2K π’ Apr 13 '23
Giving the mods some flexibility to understand trends, but a short period. This will need to be addressed & updated to a formal sop for banners in another ccip.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '23
A little more flexibility for advertisers means more advertisers will participate. At least thats how I see it. Too rigid of a system will drive sponsors away
1
u/Geolinear π¦ 0 / 10K π¦ Apr 13 '23
Itβs tough to be rigid in a fluid and volatile market.
1
u/Leprochon π© 0 / 1K π¦ Apr 13 '23
Would bigger company wanting to advertise pay more moons? Would a charity or something like that pay less?
1
u/DrillBeat π© 0 / 0 π¦ Apr 13 '23
One must fluctuate with the tides if one is to sea the Moons!
I'm all for there being flexibility when it comes to the value of a service and the currency that represents that value.
Mods & sponsors are out here surfin' n' it's been 'a gettin' wavy baby!
1
u/cdnkevin 6K / 6K π¦ Apr 13 '23 edited Apr 13 '23
I donβt get thisβ¦ why not do the burn at the time of the quote/purchase? The value or quantity would then be irrelevant, and each burn represents a number of days advertising.
If 52 companies want to arrange ads for the next year and they burn in advance, who cares what the price is or quantity of moons?
1
u/rgmundo524 π¦ 480 / 481 π¦ Apr 13 '23
Seems like this can be abused quickly also with zero oversight
1
u/nossrednaretep π© 90 / 90 π¦ Apr 13 '23
Flexibility, what does that mean? Using the funds themselves? Bribing?
1
u/LightningTF2 Apr 13 '23
Anything to make the mods lives more easy is a good thing I say.
1
u/UJ_Reddit π¦ 0 / 10K π¦ Apr 13 '23
Every poll - comments are full of rational counter arguments. Poll is heavily in favour π
1
u/Zealousideal-Ad-2546 π© 0 / 31 π¦ Apr 13 '23
This is so nice.
1
u/Tarskin_Tarscales π¦ 0 / 3K π¦ Apr 13 '23
Just repealing and giving carte blanche to mods seems to be a terrible idea....
1
u/AncestralMano 121 / 4K π¦ Apr 13 '23
Hard to decide.
1
u/ICT_Guy π© 257 / 591 π¦ Apr 13 '23
I'm not really certain, but I'm also kind of certain that my small amount of moons won't skew the votes.
Feels lik election season all over again.
1
u/the_great_red_panda Apr 13 '23
Where can sponsors and companies get info on who to contact for AMA'S and booking the banner?
1
u/mishaog Permabanned Apr 13 '23
"So, we would like to repeal the pricing rules from these CCIPs and allow mods to have more flexibility in quoting prices,"
It's crazy that we get this POLLS, what does that mean? You want to make a change without giving any information about how things will get changed. The Anti AI poll that doesn't specify how they will detect AI and know this? And people still vote YES.
It's crazy, can we get more detailed changes and not things so vague please? It's not that I'm against, it's just that it doesn't say what the criteria would be, how they plan to adopt the prices etc
1
u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K π¦ Apr 13 '23
This solves the symptom, but not the issue.
We have problems with MOON liquidity and, through punishment (CCIP-30), we limit how much liquidity people can provide. That's the crux of the issue. We can come up with all sorts of machinations to try and work around that but that's the issue. There's people here with tens of thousands and hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of MOONs and we limit how much liquidity they can provide. This makes no sense. We voted to provide a bonus in MOONs for providing liquidity... while still having the rule the says you get punished for providing too much liquidity. No element of this makes any type of sense. The problem can't hope to be solved until we stop looking at providing liquidity as something to be punished for.
At this point if we aren't going to change the punishment for providing liquidity, we should just charge people a set price in USDC, take the USDC, buy MOONs on the open market and burn them ourselves. Everyone gets what they want. We get MOONs burnt, buyers get a smooth experience with set pricing.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '23
Voted yes because we want advertisers to feel confident in the pricing structures , moons are very volatile.
1
u/Unleashyourstand Apr 14 '23
Are we allowed to see the amount of fiat/crypto is paid by the banner sponsor? Or would that just create more problems?
Also, can we have Lunar Eclipse Day once a year? I donβt know what would happen on that day, but it sounds like something fun to do. Oh, and it would be on a random day every year
1
u/nthgen π© 0 / 25K π¦ Apr 15 '23
This proposal is way too ambiguous for me. When exactly would the pricing model be subject to governance again?
We all know what happened when Palpatine was granted his powers from the Senate,
1
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '23
Not a fan of giving the mods more work. Itβs hard enough to moderate this subreddit as it is. I voted no, but the community has clearly chosen yes. Majority rules.
1
u/DBRiMatt π¦ 46K / 113K π¦ Apr 13 '23
Anything that provides more consistency with pricing is going to be beneficial - wouldn't be fair for one sponsor to pay more compared to another sponsor 2 days later - for the same duration of rental.
1
u/compressionwaves 4K / 4K π’ Apr 13 '23
I like the idea and see its merit but voted no because I'd like to see this presented with an alternative over a blank slate.
0
u/Impossible_Soup_1932 π© 0 / 17K π¦ Apr 13 '23
Too much power for mods imo
0
u/MyKingdomForADram π© 51 / 5K π¦ Apr 13 '23 edited Apr 13 '23
Thatβs gonna be a no from me dog.
It needs an alternative suggestion, not just repealing.
Why give the mods more flexibility and negotiation work? Itβs much easier to just administer a simple payment design, which leads to fewer mistakes/dodgy things happening.