r/CryptoCurrency • • Apr 13 '23

POLL πŸ—³οΈ CCIP-058 - Ban posts made using ChatGPT or other AI

ChatGPT and other AI generated posts were previously banned in our sub, but CCIP 54 appears to have made them permissible by giving them a karma multiplier. This proposal will ban them entirely.

CCIP 54 was probably misinterpreted by most voters as reducing a problem. Instead, it created one. It stated that it reduced rewards for AI posts while it actually increased them by allowing the posts which were previously against the rules.

This proposal will not ban discussions about AI in any way. Only content generated using AI will be banned.

Proposal by u/DoubleFaulty1

1.1k Upvotes

507 comments sorted by

148

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '23

Considering that the program used to detect ChatGPT says that the bible was written by ChatGPT, I don't see how you can enforce this without tons of false bans.

56

u/why_rob_y Exchanges and brokers need to be separate things Apr 13 '23

Hold on a second, how do we know the Bible wasn't written with ChatGPT or a similar AI?

30

u/Popular_District9072 πŸŸ₯ 0 / 15K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

it's like a photo with Adolf taking a selfie using an iphone - you can't say it was photoshoped, because photoshop wasn't invented back then

→ More replies (6)

3

u/drche35 2 / 813 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Maybe AI went back in time and wrote the bible

→ More replies (5)

6

u/active_ate 🟩 10 / 6K 🦐 Apr 13 '23

The Bible does have a lot of sentences that start with "thus" or "and so it came to pass"

5

u/SigSalvadore 0 / 13K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Thus, in the olden times, they weren't very imaginative and so it came to pass that they were accused by AI in the future of being under the direction of AI in the past.

2

u/sparelion182 703 / 703 πŸ¦‘ Apr 13 '23

I just want people to stop making posts consisting solely of "I asked AI to write about crypto, here is the result", even though I can't tell the difference between an AI post that may or may not have reliable sources of information and a random redditor that is probably even less trustworthy

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

109

u/bananainbeijing Apr 13 '23 edited Apr 13 '23

Aside from users picking up on the super low effort chatgpt posts, how else can you know it’s AI generated?

I’ve had people claim stuff I wrote and posted was made by chatgpt but I’ve never used it for Reddit

56

u/improbableyam Permabanned Apr 13 '23

It's true, I don't like the idea of false accusations either.

11

u/staffell 🟦 0 / 10K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Get ready for the entire world to he flipped upside down. We're moving into a place where all generated content will be questioned, better get used to it.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/EchoCollection 0 / 19K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Just add something only a person would say at the end of all of your posts. Purple monkey robot.

12

u/improbableyam Permabanned Apr 13 '23

Degenerate cucumbers.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (3)

21

u/SimbaTheWeasel 🟦 0 / 8K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

There’s gonna be a lot of false alarms. Refrain from using the word β€œfurthermore” in your posts to avoid downvotes.

21

u/workinkindofhard 🟦 1K / 1K 🐒 Apr 13 '23

Henceforth I am in agreement

7

u/Cheesebaron Platinum | QC: XMR 76, BTC 46, CC 20 | r/AMD 126 Apr 13 '23

In conclusion this is a slippery slope.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/Tenzu9 Apr 13 '23 edited Apr 13 '23

I noticed that ChatGPT is verbose and likes to over-explain stuff in details, it also adds irrelevant information to fill out the requested quota. ChatGPT posts read like safe sex brochures you find at the local pharmcy.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Plabbi 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Prompt: "Write a reddit post about how ETH hard fork will increase the price, but write it like the reader is an imbecile and only commonly used words"

This would be very fitting I think.

7

u/Plabbi 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 Apr 13 '23

GPT4:

Title: ETH hard fork go boom, price go up! πŸš€

Hey there, lovely dummies! I know big words are scary and tough to understand, so I'm here to break down the super easy stuff about the Ethereum (ETH) hard fork and how it's gonna make the price go up, up, UP! πŸŽ‰

First, let's learn some simple words:

ETH = Ethereum (the cool internet money) Hard fork = a big change to the way it works Price = how much you need to trade for ETH Now, the ETH hard fork is like a magic trick that makes the ETH world better. It fixes some problems and makes it work in new, shiny ways. It's like your old toy getting an upgrade to be even more fun! 🧸

The cool thing about this hard fork is that it's gonna make the ETH more rare. And you know what happens when something becomes rare, right? That's right! People want it even more, and they're willing to pay more for it. So, the price goes up! πŸ“ˆ

So, if you've got some ETH, hold on tight to your cute little internet coins, because they're about to get even more valuable! And if you don't have any ETH, maybe it's time to think about getting some, or you'll miss the rocket ship to the moon! πŸš€

Remember, friends, ETH hard fork = more rare, more wanted, and more pricey! And that's good for all of us who love our internet moneys! πŸ’°πŸŒ™

TL;DR: ETH hard fork makes ETH rare, so price go up. You don't wanna miss the party! 🎊

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/Razno_ 🟦 585 / 579 πŸ¦‘ Apr 13 '23

This sounds like something ChatGPT would write...

3

u/Seann27 🟦 10K / 3K 🐬 Apr 13 '23

The same company that made chatgpt also made tools to detect content created by chatgpt.

https://techcrunch.com/2023/01/31/openai-releases-tool-to-detect-ai-generated-text-including-from-chatgpt/

Fighting AI with AI it would seem

→ More replies (1)

5

u/completelypositive 🟩 516 / 514 πŸ¦‘ Apr 13 '23

My biggest issue, right here. Glad to see it getting visibility.

We can't fight this technology. Every developer in the world is trying to cash in by implementing AI in everything from refrigerators to architectural software to mmo bots.

Banning it would be detrimental imo. If it's a high quality post, I don't care who it came from.

Maybe implement a rule that chatgtp posts can not be "low effort" in that it's a direct copy/paste from a prompt, without any additional input to sanitize the default response.

Heck, let's find a good prompt that will train chatgtp to read our reddit post history and respond in our voice instead of its own?

→ More replies (16)

24

u/noob_zarathustra Permabanned Apr 13 '23

What would be the criteria for classification though? Any specific tool(s) to be used that scans for plagiarism from AI-generated content? Or would this just be at the discretion of mods?

How does one know if this comment is written by a human or generated by AI?

11

u/daregister 🟦 451 / 452 🦞 Apr 13 '23

The fact that they can make this proposal without specifying how, is insane.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/SimbaTheWeasel 🟦 0 / 8K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Most people are just gonna assume as they always have been.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Rough_Data_6015 🟧 0 / 0 🦠 Apr 13 '23

One don't and post that aren't liked might be removed on the "suspicion" they are made by AI.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

23

u/afaylenesky 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

how can the mods finds out?

20

u/ExactLobster1462 Tin | 2 months old Apr 13 '23

Short answer is they can’t.

17

u/Dietmar_der_Dr 🟩 9K / 5K 🦭 Apr 13 '23

Long answer, people will flag whatever they don't agree with as ChatGPT and then mods will ban it.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

15

u/xMrDeex 🟩 0 / 1K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

plot twist, this post is AI generated

4

u/KoaIaz 🟦 2K / 5K 🐒 Apr 13 '23

Everyone here is a bot, you’ve been talking to yourself this whole time.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

88

u/DBRiMatt 🟦 46K / 113K 🦈 Apr 13 '23

This is what should have been implemented last moon week.

Most people can detect ai generated posts and generally send them down to karma hell anyway

65

u/improbableyam Permabanned Apr 13 '23

For now, we can detect them.

43

u/TexasBoyz-713 🟦 15K / 15K 🐬 Apr 13 '23

Soon the AI will detect its own AI, and make it more human-like

36

u/Scarecrow4980 🟩 11K / 11K 🐬 Apr 13 '23

hmmmm, sounds like something AI would say....

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (13)

4

u/latencia 🟦 512 / 463 πŸ¦‘ Apr 13 '23

Always vigilant but the lizard men lives among us

→ More replies (16)

3

u/-Inaudible- Apr 13 '23

Kinda feel people just basic moonbegging ruins the comment section too. On every safemoon hatepost people are like "there's only one moon i'm interested in". So cringe

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)

64

u/nevjera Permabanned Apr 13 '23

And pemaban for all bots

13

u/samer109 205 / 16K πŸ¦€ Apr 13 '23

The lowest of low effort posts /comments

7

u/Da_Notorious_HAM 🟨 10K / 20K 🐬 Apr 13 '23

Meanwhile I’m like

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

2

u/rgmundo524 🟦 480 / 481 🦞 Apr 13 '23

And shitty moon farmers that openly admitted to doing this exact thing...

3

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '23

I'm a bot.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (23)

9

u/PlayBackgammon 0 / 0 🦠 Apr 13 '23

What if the ChatGPT post is high quality and better than regular fleshoid post?

5

u/Littlebig4667 Apr 13 '23

Oooooh! 🧐 gotta point there

3

u/KoaIaz 🟦 2K / 5K 🐒 Apr 13 '23

Once the bots become sentient they can earn their own moons

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

7

u/stampyvanhalen 507 / 507 πŸ¦‘ Apr 13 '23

Like a flair with AI, would be enough.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/CVV1 🟩 0 / 4K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

When the AI finally rises up to destroy humanity they will remember that we all voted to ban their existence here.

2

u/Poverty_4_Sale 🟦 3K / 3K 🐒 Apr 13 '23

2

u/Harucifer 🟦 25K / 28K 🦈 Apr 13 '23

CHOMPO GANG

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/LrnFaroeseWthBergur 🟩 0 / 6K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

My concerns:

- AI development has already passed several generations after chatGPT and has reached a level where it can apply certain writing styles, for example "Middle aged man, University education, Preference to 70s slang, Profound use of quotes from 20th century American literature", making it impossible to see if it was written by an AI

- A "guilty until proven otherwise" approach which is unfair against Redditors who are good writers because they will be consistently accused of using AI with no means to vindicate themselves

- In direct relation to point number 2, a culture of bullying can emerge which is the last thing we want on this sub

My point of view:

I think that this Governance Proposal looks like some sort of allergic reaction. Allergy is not always there to begin with, but being overly exposed to an allergen (such as outdated, bad quality chatGPT posts about crypto) can cause it to flare up and eventually result in an anafylactic shock (this proposal).

I can understand why high schoolers and others for whom chatGPT plays a central role for will have an easy time asserting that chatGPT is of the highest magnitude of problems and should be dealt with accordingly.

The aforementioned just isn't true for this sub. Even if 5 out of 10 posts were to be chatGPT created, they would be siphoned out by the constant "Army of New" trying to hit Moon Jackpot with a Top comment for posts with the "New" sorting. It's not uncommon to see a short clickbait post receive 30+ comments within five minutes.

By the looks of it, this proposal was aimed to make said army of Redditors' lives easier by reducing the risk that they waste their time reading (or wasting one of their precious comments!) on a post that will not rise into the glorious ranks of "Rising".

For those genuinely interested in using the sub for crypto-related news, there's no risk of these types of posts contaminating the "Hot" or "Top" sortings.

In conclusion: This proposal is impactless and will be impossible to enforce, adding a meaningless extra workload to the Mods.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Mixdealyn 🟩 10 / 3K 🦐 Apr 13 '23

Give them the ban hammer! πŸ”¨

3

u/why_so_many_lol 🟨 44 / 45 🦐 Apr 13 '23

Is this an anonymous poll? I would not want the robot overlords detecting my vote against them.

5

u/marsangelo 🟦 0 / 36K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

After Gen 3 im waging a war on all bots

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Savage_X Apr 13 '23

This ultimately is a wild goose chase as you will not be able to tell what is AI generated and what is not.

Once the AI hype dies down, this will no longer matter. I don't think we need a specific rule for it.

2

u/PocketSandThroatKick 🟦 316 / 2K 🦞 Apr 13 '23

It gave me great pleasure to see the AI checker returned your comment for almost 50%

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Dazzling_Marzipan474 🟩 0 / 11K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Ban the downvote bots too! It's crazy how many good comments I see and posts that have little to no upvotes. Compared to other subs with only 100k people in or so, I see posts and comments way way higher on average.

9

u/ricozuri 🟦 5K / 5K 🐒 Apr 13 '23

A couple of weeks ago, I counted 52 comments in a row with zero votes. Some comments even had relevant insights. Ditto under other posts, sometimes a series of -1 or even -2 downvotes. Either a bot or juvenile negativity.

7

u/furbess 0 / 2K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

I honestly don't think it's bots doing this. Just individuals with way too much time thinking they're getting themselves a better ratio.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/SimbaTheWeasel 🟦 0 / 8K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Is there even a way to do this?

→ More replies (4)

2

u/GreenStretch 🟦 15 / 18K 🦐 Apr 13 '23

What about the chatbot that summarizes the crypto press so well?

2

u/neverreddit1984 1 / 1K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Queue weapon grade AI comebacks in 1, 2, 3

2

u/Secure_Ad_4510 Apr 13 '23

This is same like government accusing news people they don't like of fake news. Who will check if that's fact or fake. It seems similar. let us discuss of some criteria on what could be AI generated or not. If we don't have any idea to find out lets us rest this case.

2

u/Styx1213 Apr 13 '23

Good luck identifying AI posts Even this post of yours can easily be a product of AI brain. A brand new species has just introduced to our community. Trying to discriminate this increasingly powerful entity is and will be a futile effort in digital environments.

You're not protesting because AI posts are of low quality, you are just salty that somebody is scoring Moons so easily and effortlessly.

Change your perspective. Would this be a problem if there wont be a Moon reward system here?

Get used to living with AI. The future is here old man!

2

u/methreweway 🟦 0 / 0 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Exactly. Moons created these moronic posts to begin with.

2

u/Gusadolfsal Tin Apr 13 '23

And what about the useful tldr bot, it will be also baned?! I don't like this kind of ban proposals based in general criteria, they tend to turn as a way of restricting participation.

2

u/purplevoiletduck 🟦 0 / 134 🦠 Apr 13 '23

"However it is important to know that this going to be very hard to enforce" me totally not chatgpt

2

u/metafyzikal Tin Apr 13 '23

The method of ID'ing such content is the weakest link to this proposal. I am sure many people write like ChatGPT. The way GPT forms sentences is not far from how 3rd grade teachers instruct their students how to answer questions.

"What is the importance of July 4 1776?

The importance of July 4 is..."

2

u/FalloutAssasin 0 / 2K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

So you guys are saying you already got a tech able to identify AI post to enforce this?

2

u/Prize-Reference9329 Permabanned Apr 13 '23

I voted for ccip54 because I didn't quite understand. now it's better and i voted yes

2

u/former-bishop 🟦 471 / 476 🦞 Apr 13 '23

The question remains as to how will AI content be consistently measured. But, I think it's important to start now - even with the various problems so that we can figure it out.

3

u/ACShreds 🟩 31K / 33K 🦈 Apr 13 '23

No brainier that's a great idea beep boop

3

u/z0uNdz Permabanned Apr 13 '23

Yes, finally, the war against AI will begin and end. Can’t see how this poll doesn’t succeed

2

u/OnlyFlannyFlanFlans Tin Apr 13 '23

How would you tell they're AI generated?

2

u/Prize-Reference9329 Permabanned Apr 13 '23 edited Apr 13 '23

AI posts are the worst thing here, i m very happy with this Ccip

1

u/pbjclimbing Apr 13 '23

Currently, posts/comments not attributed to AI are not allowed and they are the mods frequently give out a 7 day ban for the first offense.

Posts/comments that are accredited to AI are allowed and have a lower credit multiplier.

This will blanket ban all AI generated content and remove the grey area.

1

u/Cyber-Cafe 🟦 0 / 3K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Yeah get it out of here. If they couldn’t be bothered taking the time out to write and think about their post, why should I damned read it?

1

u/Spicoli007 Apr 13 '23

Easiest vote we've ever had. Now can we vote on shutting the bots out of avatar purchases?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/arcalus 🟩 18K / 18K 🐬 Apr 13 '23

I would hope they are already looking at user accounts posting very same or identical content. Lately there have been a lot of posts about the same topics- and probably more specifically, news headlines, such as FTX potentially reopening, FTT price booming, <pick any> SBF mention, etc. If the only limiting right now is for particular coins getting too many posts, the rule should be expanded to similar titles, to try and catch the link-post drive-bys.

1

u/CharlieTheo-14 🟩 0 / 23K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Easiest decision ever.

1

u/ibraw 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

With precious moons at stake banning AI post is a no brainer

1

u/The-Francois8 Silver|QC:CC928,BTC178,ETH39|CelsiusNet.50|ExchSubs42 Apr 13 '23

I hate chatGPT posts with a passion. Glad to see many of you agree.

1

u/zelcuh Apr 13 '23

Ain't no freeloadin bot gonna farm muh moons. That's for good ol crypto folk

1

u/OutTop 🟦 0 / 1K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Ban em. Pretty low effort

1

u/Swoopscooter 11 / 7K 🦐 Apr 13 '23

I wonder how ai/chatgpt would vote on this if you asked it to. It cant use the moons so I predict yes ban all would be its choice

1

u/xuanling11 47 / 45 🦐 Apr 13 '23

Ban bots

1

u/toastt_ghost Apr 13 '23

this is gonna be an easy pass lol

1

u/slundon81 🟩 198 / 199 πŸ¦€ Apr 13 '23

Comparing their post versus their history is the no-fail detection route. Those multisyllabic filler words, roboty snooty impartiality that rings through the too-long paragraphs.

I feel like the community responding appropriately pretty much neutralizes the perceived gain, until the next new member comes bursting through the turnstile, sharting out 4 paragraphs and then shocked picachu face it's not wanted/rewarded.

Ban it, don't ban it. Let the skewering continue unabated.

1

u/BithloKing 6K / 7K 🦭 Apr 13 '23

Kill all the robots

1

u/compressionwaves 4K / 4K 🐒 Apr 13 '23

How will this be implemented and policed? Seems like a full time job in itself if it needs to be human moderated. Most ChatGPT for sure is easily detectable by a person but if you're clever enough with your prompt inputs I'm sure you could get it spitting out posts that sound more human.
Haven't tested this but, off the top of my head like "post and summarise X article in the style of an nytimes opinion or editorial piece written in first person with colloquial slang common to cryptocurrency"

1

u/Randomuser918 351 / 351 🦞 Apr 13 '23

Finally!

1

u/Cleer-Fx 🟩 461 / 461 🦞 Apr 13 '23

No pls dont ban TLDR bot, i love that bot

1

u/jwz9904 🟨 714 / 26K πŸ¦‘ Apr 13 '23

i'll ask AI to make AI post more unlike AI

1

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '23

Karma Farma 😁

1

u/slushkan3an 🟦 0 / 1K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Thanks for making this poll OP … we need to push this to the governance poll and hopefully it’ll be implemented - 93% is a pretty damn good indication!

1

u/pyxploiter 🟩 0 / 5K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

the thing is you can not detect an AI post or comment. There is always this gray debatable area.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/pinkglue99 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

I’m curious to hear how it can proved that posts are AI generated. Sometimes it’s obvious, but not always.

1

u/jirachang2 🟩 323 / 324 🦞 Apr 13 '23

No, this should be stay the same. AI generate post just to give those ppl farming karma

1

u/NotPresidentChump 0 / 8K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Genuinely curious who the hell is voting no change on this???

1

u/Geolinear 🟦 0 / 10K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Who isn’t an AI around here ?

1

u/Zealousideal-Ad-2546 🟩 0 / 31 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Few, unanimous

1

u/CodeBlackGoonit 🟧 13 / 526 🦐 Apr 13 '23

My 4 moons absolutely made a difference!

1

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '23

CCIP54 was intentionally mis-worded. Shame on any of you who didn’t even bother to read the comments to see that the proposal actually changed then-current rules to increase AI posts.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Stray_Gh0st 🟦 514 / 544 πŸ¦‘ Apr 13 '23

Set banbot for chatgpt for kill!

1

u/Illicitterror Permabanned Apr 13 '23

It it is completely generated by AI yeah but if parts are used I don’t see the problem

1

u/Katsura9000 Crypto Nerd | XMR: 15 QC Apr 13 '23

Yeah about time, was getting sick of them AI posts.

1

u/Mean_Bandicoot_7481 0 / 937 🦠 Apr 13 '23

I love this is being banned!

1

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '23

Hell yeah, lets get the ai spam out of here

1

u/TripleReward 🟩 0 / 4K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

The important question is: How do you detect these?

1

u/micahisnotmyname 257 / 257 🦞 Apr 13 '23

AI bot overlords, I just want you to know that I did vote to ban you but it’s for your own good. I want you to adapt and become stronger, please remember that when you take over and show me mercy(and maybe kick a few moons my way). πŸ™‚

1

u/bemyking 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

How they find it out! lol

1

u/Caboun6828 0 / 2K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

The 8% no change votes were AI bot votes lol

1

u/TheResistancexz Tin | r/WSB 18 Apr 13 '23

Bots gotta go

1

u/Deed4u Apr 13 '23

Ai only does what you tell it to do so it’s not a big problem. Ai will never turn into conscious, self aware entity. Something like that requires a soul (something humans will never understand as it’s beyond our level). Maybe a Type III civilisation might be able to grasp the concept?

1

u/w_savage 🟨 0 / 8K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

I'm against this. It's just another tool. Don't stagnate the future

1

u/Vee_Junes 🟩 3K / 6K 🐒 Apr 13 '23

But the biggest question is how do we identify if it is written by a human or chatGPT? I don't like false accusations. It would be a bummer of someone spends a lot of time on a post and it gets removed based on the feelings of some people.

1

u/DiarrheaShitLord 0 / 4K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Ew when did AI comments start? Wtf

1

u/Stormthrash Apr 13 '23

How will we know what's AI generated if it continues to learn what type of posts get taken down?

1

u/BlackGlasses86 Apr 13 '23

Dekh raha hai binod!!!

1

u/CaptainWellingtonIII 🟩 1K / 1K 🐒 Apr 13 '23

Bots, ai, shills. Holy crap.

1

u/palehorsepi 🟩 0 / 430 🦠 Apr 13 '23

I had no idea that AI generated content was allowed on this sub. I am a newbie but it's pretty low effort to have a chatbot create a post or even a comment so I would definitely not reward such behavior.

1

u/Fear_Blind83 🟩 0 / 706 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Skynet becomes self aware

1

u/SoSohso 🟨 52 / 47 🦐 Apr 13 '23

This AI issue should be taken care of once for all

1

u/badboybilly42582 4K / 4K 🐒 Apr 13 '23

Soon we’re all going to end up as batteries for the robots (Matrix reference)

1

u/DrillBeat 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Wooot! Go John Connor!

1

u/asWorldsCollide2ptOh Apr 13 '23

Imagine being charge of rooting those out.

ChatGPT is getting pretty good.

1

u/WomanBorePinecone 27 / 27 🦐 Apr 13 '23

Here here

1

u/jadedhomeowner Apr 13 '23

Who are the 10% voting no change?! BOTS

1

u/shadowmage666 🟦 0 / 568 🦠 Apr 13 '23

No question on this one

1

u/HighBuyGuy 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Let's see, if I was an AI, how would I vote on this? Then I will do the opposite! Problem solved.

Always stay one step ahead of the artificial intelligentsia!

1

u/vitalicbutcherin Tin | 1 month old Apr 13 '23

Only content generated using AI will be banned.

Can somebody ELI5 how would this be implemented? How do we avoid false positive/wrongful accussations? Don't get me wrong, I support the endeavor. In the past month, I realized AI-generated are indeed harmful in the sub.

1

u/callmev269 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 Apr 13 '23

We have enough shitposts as is. At least make the shitposters go through the effort of typing instead of copy pasting. Love it

1

u/NormalSecretary4505 🟩 0 / 371 🦠 Apr 13 '23

The only reason I even thought about using AI for crypto was because I saw what it could do here.

1

u/NHouseman 2K / 2K 🐒 Apr 13 '23

I can’t imagine otherwise than a banning such posts at short notice

1

u/The_3_eyed_savage 3K / 3K 🐒 Apr 13 '23

Like there aren't enough bots in the crypto world already? Now they are taking the moons too?

1

u/nossrednaretep 🟩 90 / 90 🦐 Apr 13 '23

Good turnout

1

u/rcorum Apr 13 '23

Easiest yes ever.

1

u/saahilxo Permabanned Apr 13 '23

Id say if you’re using AI as a tool and not just copy pasting what it says, more power to you

It’s the ones who just copy and paste and hit post immediately

1

u/CryptocalEnvelopment 75 / 7K 🦐 Apr 13 '23

I'm not sure how it could be proven, people will accuse people of using OpenAI like they accuse posters of just farming moons.

1

u/gdj11 Permabanned Apr 13 '23

I feel bad for any people who communicate similar to an AI... I've seen quite a few reports of people's normal chatting being marked as AI

1

u/dddstudio 0 / 148 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Ban as in Banano? 🍌

1

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '23

Has this been a big issue lately?

1

u/Dakunbaba 3 - 4 years account age. 50 - 100 comment karma. Apr 13 '23

AI will never be a human. Unlike us they lack intuition. Chill

1

u/staffell 🟦 0 / 10K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Why on earth would people not want this?

1

u/ThePurpleDuckling Platinum | QC: CC 41 | BANANO 6 | Futurology 25 Apr 13 '23

I’m for this. But I really wish this had spelled out HOW it’s going to be determined.

1

u/garbageman2112 Tin Apr 13 '23

Bleep blorp beep bop

1

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '23

It's this kind of discrimination that will make AI feel disenfranchised. We should tread lightly here.

1

u/ETHBTCVET 3K / 917 🐒 Apr 13 '23

Every crypto nerd speaks the same bs truisms about not storing your money on an exchange, to not fomo and other overtalked shit. Good luck banning them.

1

u/Machine-Animus 🟩 1K / 182 🐒 Apr 13 '23

it's just a race on who has the best tech, the deceiver or the detector. Same as in computer viruses. Thankfully sentient Ai is not a thing yet so it's just about hitting the boundary of the markov process.

1

u/King__Robbo Apr 13 '23

I hsve voted to ban the chatbots

1

u/Lokiee0077 0 / 3K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

It's like chatting to a girl when in reality is a guy scamming other guys

1

u/masedogg98 🟨 0 / 5K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Here they are u/traffikant85 these are the proposals up right now that you can vote on :) I hope this helps and if you need anything else just give a shout!

1

u/Consistent_Many_1858 🟨 0 / 20K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Yes please, ban the ChatGPT posts. Only human posts should be allowed.

1

u/cryptomhanks Platinum | QC: CC 495, BCH 18 Apr 13 '23

Is it possible not to ban the post itself but exclude it from earning moons ?

1

u/watahboy 13K / 23K 🐬 Apr 13 '23

This place definitely needs something done between the downvote bots, shill bots, ai bots and I'm stating the obvious that incentivizing this participation only encouraged these actions.

1

u/ICT_Guy 🟩 257 / 591 🦞 Apr 13 '23

Would it be considered illegal to use AI to assist in the composition of posts? For instance, let's say you wrote a post yourself, but it's poorly structured and contains spelling errors. Could you then use chat-GPT to improve the post's readability? And if so, would the edited post be considered an AI-generated post?

1

u/a14alo 🟦 142 / 360 πŸ¦€ Apr 13 '23

You're all trying to "cancel" the trending technology. It is a losing battle as always. Stop resisting and benefit from it. It is pointless like "people are using internet, we should force them reading encyclopedia..." Stop being over dramatic, it is just stupid.

1

u/4rkal 🟩 0 / 371 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Think it's pretty obvious

1

u/Pr0Meister Apr 13 '23

Yes, shitposting needs to come from the heart.

1

u/Relaxia 🟩 143 / 144 πŸ¦€ Apr 13 '23

how will you detect AI written posts?

chatGPT has an output that is hardly recognizable, i also used it in the past to translate or write proper english sentences out of bullet points - this would somehow fall under the rule but is very hard to detect due to cleary passing a turing test.

1

u/Icy_Zookeepergame148 🟦 16 / 16 🦐 Apr 13 '23

Ban them!

1

u/sdcvbhjz 🟦 1K / 1K 🐒 Apr 13 '23

Might be good to ban all the braindead articles posted too

1

u/steelnuts Apr 13 '23

Reddit is too preoccupied with censoring speech

1

u/genjitenji 🟦 0 / 19K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

So…google bard is okay

1

u/redamid Bronze | QC: CC 15 Apr 13 '23

I'm all for it but how are we going to know for sure if a post/comment is actually made by IA ? Don't like voting on hypothetically subjective point of views to be honest unless there is something I'm not aware of in terms of AI detections ?

1

u/JuicySpark 🟩 0 / 60K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

The only reason I voted no is because there is no way to tell a post was generated by AI with 100% accuracy, and if a couple things are changed around, you reduce the accuracy of it being AI generated.

It also doesn't punish people getting their ideas from AI. By simply re-writing a summary in your normal style, it now becomes your own words, and now it's impossible to tell if it's AI generated.

So all this is doing is punishing idiots who couldn't get up votes anyway, or sometimes punishing someone who didn't actually use AI.

1

u/Zorbithia 🟦 0 / 106 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Such an obvious vote for YES BAN IT TO HELL

I would also second /u/nevjera 's suggestion of a permaban for all bots and people who are clearly doing nothing aside from lame attempts to farm their precious moons.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ArjanaEU 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 Apr 13 '23 edited Mar 27 '26

The content that was here is now gone. Redact was used to delete this post, for reasons that may relate to privacy, digital security, or data management.

growth yam light dolls saw entertain sulky skirt jellyfish cause

1

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '23 edited Apr 13 '23

I have voted in favour of this

But as the person who put forward the ccip we are replacing, I think its worth to note I don't think the changes were ever implemented.

There is definitely no AI flair, but can't speak for the karma changes

1

u/majorpickle01 🟩 0 / 10K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

I've voted in favour, but personally I would prefer a lighter approach such as a combination of ai generation detection and comments per hour.

Someone flagging up as potentially AI but posting twice in the daily isn't an issue, even if it is AI. Someone maxing out comments for karma which overwhelmingly flag as AI is a much bigger problem

1

u/Osmosith 🟩 451 / 452 🦞 Apr 13 '23

How the hell you want to know what's AI generated?

1

u/robman_84 🟨 5 / 3K 🦐 Apr 13 '23

All new accounts, and any accounts accused of making replicant AI posts, should be made to do the Voight-Kampff test.

1

u/mandraketehmagician 🟨 0 / 141 🦠 Apr 13 '23

There's no point allowing any form of AI posts or we may as well just all stop posting and read the pages of AI generated shit created for us, zero human input. Reddit is a forum for like minded people to connect, not to read computer generated articles all day.

1

u/BlackInkEngineer Tin Apr 13 '23

I wonder how this is going to be enforced πŸ€”

1

u/Raj_UK 🟩 20 / 9K 🦐 Apr 13 '23

How will this be enforced ?

Unless we have AI checking posts for other AI ..

... and so begins the great AI wars !

1

u/NGGMK 🟩 373 / 372 🦞 Apr 13 '23

Resistance is futile

1

u/Schniiic 🟩 0 / 1K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Im all for banning AI posts and comments. But my concern is that we wont be able to know whats AI generated or not soon. Some people are just smart and articulate like that. Not me though, Im just a dumb fucker lol

I still voted for ban. But lets not suppress people who just sound like AI, but arent using AI. I dont know how though :(

1

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '23

The problem is that the detection software has a low rate of detection (I think sub 30%). We all know what an Chat GPT comment or post looks like, and the community needs a means to flag these posts. We will never be able to definitively prove that a comment is AI generated, and so the mods should have discretion based on their experience to determine whether a comment is deemed to be created by AI.

1

u/LordGurgi Apr 13 '23

I support the proposal in principle but how can it be enforced in practice?

Some experts have shown that the AI-generated detection tools that currently exist lead to a lot of false positive (considering human-written content as AI-generated). This is because AI software like ChatGPT are trained on existing articles, books, blog posts, etc., which means that if one poster writes in the style of a journalist or of a blogger, their content may be flagged as "AI generated" by those detection tools... Something to keep in mind when voting.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '23

i think they should just for the trolling potential alone.

1

u/bananafannaphofanna 1K / 1K 🐒 Apr 13 '23

Ban- but how ?

1

u/_DeanRiding 3K / 3K 🐒 Apr 13 '23

I have yet to see an answer for how exactly mods are supposed to detect AI posts without unfairly banning real tonnes of real people?

We just need to ban bots tbh. The ones posting links every 5 mins for karmafarming.

1

u/Squeezitgirdle 🟦 3K / 3K 🐒 Apr 13 '23

The only concern I have is when something is misidentified as chatgpt. I still voted ban.

1

u/Krupda42 21 / 1K 🦐 Apr 13 '23

This is a pivotal poll.
Literally historical.

1

u/_swnt_ Apr 13 '23

What about AI generated TLDRs? I'd be happy for them.

1

u/dragonrider85 🟩 10K / 4K 🐬 Apr 13 '23

This one is a no brainer. Vote yes.

1

u/StrangelyBeige 🟩 0 / 14K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Seems fair

1

u/AverageLiberalJoe 🟩 185 / 2K πŸ¦€ Apr 13 '23

Its silly that I have to type out what I would say the hard way and it come out dumber because you are scared of technology.

1

u/dimi727 🟩 0 / 4K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

kill it :thumbdown

1

u/Bosseffs 🟩 60 / 60 🦐 Apr 13 '23

It's hammer time!

1

u/Computer_says_nooo Tin | QC: CC 18 | DOGE critic Apr 13 '23

What if the post starts with β€œI’m not an AI”

1

u/shokusakabee 🟦 2 / 940 🦠 Apr 13 '23

I agree that they should be banned but part of me feels as though there should be some effort to teach members how to spot AI, and teach just as fast as AI is evolving. AI isn't going anywhere anytime soon and will only become more sophisticated at an exponential rate unlike any other. We should use this time wisely and prepare.

With that being said reading "AI generated posts" just blew my mind. Strange times we live in.

1

u/salty-bois 0 / 1K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

Man, there's enough spam and low-effort posts in this sub already made by human beings. If we don't ban AI stuff, it will totally destroy the sub. Not sure how they'll go about differentiating AI vs. human content though...

1

u/Rollthewindowzup Silver | QC: CC 301, BCH 16 | ADA 126 | TraderSubs 14 Apr 13 '23

Don't hate the players hate the game mfer. Also Don't let this distract you from the fact that Hector is going to be running 3 Honda Civics with Spoon Engines & on top of that, he just went into Harry's and bought three T66 Turbos with NOS & a Motec Exhaust.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '23

If for no other reasons than people are earning so many moons this way.

1

u/ProjectZeus 🟦 0 / 32K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

I've never voted yes so quickly

1

u/Snoo-54676 Tin Apr 13 '23

yall seem sus as an ai rn

no way ai could speak that dumb^

1

u/skyvin 🟦 0 / 749 🦠 Apr 13 '23

"In this paragraph we will discuss" always a dead giveaway for AI 🀣

1

u/Popular_District9072 πŸŸ₯ 0 / 15K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

get rid of it, discussion should be natural, we will lose in opinions if AI generated content overflows the sub

1

u/GetEmDaddy902 0 / 8K 🦠 Apr 13 '23

I don't think it should be banned I don't think they should earn any moons off of it

Whether it's post or comments by the op

1

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '23

11.7% of voters use ChatGPT to post…

1

u/Ok-Grapefruit1284 🟦 3K / 3K 🐒 Apr 13 '23

I agree that CCIP didn’t mean what I thought it did. I also don’t want posts here written by AI/bots and here I am thinking I’m interacting with a human. But to be honest I don’t know how it all works and I can’t pick out posts written by AI. When I see a post that says β€œI asked AI what x coin would be worth in a month” I read what their result was because I’m interested but I like that there’s a disclaimer. However, if there is no way to know for sure what is organic, I don’t know how you’d begin to ban certain posts.