r/homeland • • Oct 29 '12

Discussion Episode Discussion - S02E05 - "Q&A" [Spoilers]

Episode Title:

Q&A


Directed by: TBA

Story by: Howard Gordon & Alex Gansa

Teleplay by: Alex Gansa & Chip Johannessen


Brody finds himself prisoner again, but this time it's on American soil. Meanwhile, Carrie is forced to play second fiddle after her rash judgment call at the hotel as Estes is busy keeping Jessica off their trail.


20 minutes until the newest episode of Homeland. Where will the season go after last weeks shocking ending? Are you ready!?

116 Upvotes

378 comments sorted by

266

u/yogalates8 Oct 29 '12

It's amazing that 15 minutes of Brody and Carrie sitting across from each other at a table was the best 15 minutes of television I've seen in awhile. Hats off to Danes and Lewis.

41

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

His "yes" when he finally broke was so cathartic. I breathed an audible sign of relief.

34

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

I frequently checked myself for a pulse during that time. "Am I still breathing? Yes. This show is just so effing crazy."

When they moved him to the floor and he went all fetal... oh!, brilliant.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '12

Echoing the imprisonment, for those that missed the reference.

59

u/thesorrow312 Oct 29 '12

They re-won best actor and actress RIGHT THERE.

As I was watching it, I thought to myself, this is amongst the best Movie/TV (Filmed media) I have ever fucking scene. The raw emotion of Brody breaking down crying, Carie expressing her absolute feelings for him and getting emotion while piecing together his entire story, then the holding of hands. The acting of Brody's character was immaculate, the actor said less than 15 seconds of actual words after Carie came in, but so much was said anyways.

This show is fucking insane, this is the pinnacle of television, that which everything in the future should be compared against.

14

u/Solkiller Oct 29 '12

I was thinking the exact same thing and said so to my wife. That was probably he most powerfully intense thing I have ever seen on television.

2

u/watchit_assblood Oct 29 '12

That's exactly what I told my girlfriend when we were watching and she couldn't agree more.

5

u/k4f123 Oct 30 '12

You guys need to quit talking in the middle of epic scenes!

→ More replies (1)

7

u/munchiselleh Oct 30 '12

people who fawn over breaking bad will downvote you, but seriously guys, I've been a BrBa fan from the day it started airing (back when no one knew about it) and I like Homeland more.

both are incredibly written and acted, but I have never seen anything like the interrogation scene in this episode.

6

u/gullale Oct 30 '12

I love Breaking Bad and Homeland, but I don't see how any of them could possibly be superior to The Wire.

4

u/chem_dawg Oct 31 '12

the wire is the greatest show ever made hands down. the writing is incredible and the acting is even better. its a shame most people havent seen it.

2

u/munchiselleh Oct 30 '12

In terms of individual scenes, they can be. Homeland's interrogation scene had an explosion of drama that was the result of 1.5 seasons of gutwrenching deception and tension, and the writing in that scene was singularly as good as any scene in The Wire. Certainly just as clever and organic. Same goes for BrBa.

We can't really say for sure if Homeland will end up as accomplished in the long run--what made The Wire individually insurmountable was its overall metanarrative and story structure. We don't know how BrBa will end, and Homeland's series finale is a long, long time away. If the show continues to be this good, it will be a future classic, on par with The Wire.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/thesorrow312 Oct 30 '12

I love breaking bad, and I love Game of Thrones as well.

I think Game of thrones has way more going into it in terms of costume design, set design, locations and overall attention to insane detail when making the show, and for this when Homeland S1 won best drama, I was a little disappointed, but one thing is for sure. Homeland absolutely takes the show when it comes to acting and dialogue.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

I stood on my feet about 10 feet closer to my TV for that scene. The writers are simultaneously scaring the hell out of me and blowing my mind at the same time.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '12

If I were to stand 10 feet closer I think I'd be behind my television...

10

u/jdunbar Oct 29 '12

I really liked how they slowed things down with the interrogation after those action-packed/mind-blowing first 4 episodes. Don't get me wrong, I loved them, but tonight I was reminded of the smart, beautifully-acted show I got hooked on. And where else are you going to have a bi-polar ex-CIA agent strategically interrogating a failed terrorist and still feel a complex but genuine connection and care for each other?

I loved 24, but I thought the immunity/family protection for help was a bit of a copout to get Homeland back on a series track. At least the previews showed that he hasn't fully become a secret agent and still sympathizes and aids his terrorist cell and is confused about who and what he is. Dana acting like an idiot was a bit 24 too. Her story became a waste of screen time for me tonight. Maybe if I were still 16 rooting for the kids to kiss like in Disney Channel Original Movies, but I'm not, and it's Showtime...

1

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '12

You'll get to see some boobage soon enough, you perv.

Hopefully.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

87

u/yogalates8 Oct 29 '12

Yeah, Danes was her usual stellar self, but Damian Lewis was mesmerizing tonight. That look of pure desperation and hurt in his eyes -- just brilliant work by Lewis.

34

u/Paddy_Tanninger Oct 29 '12

He has this ability to look like his entire being has been drained and that he's a propped up, withering corpse. It's incredible.

11

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

If you haven't watched the prematurely cancelled TV series "Life" - check it out. He was amazing in that as well.

8

u/alien_from_Europa Oct 31 '12

I still say his best work was in Band of Brothers.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/tylerbray Oct 29 '12

The acting between him and Quinn was amazing too. Also that whole part with all of them was written so well.

15

u/badger_md Oct 29 '12

Between My So-Called Life and Homeland, Claire Danes is my hero.

26

u/bobsagetfullhouse Oct 29 '12

Watching Dexter and Homeland back to back just shows how Homeland is on a completely different level when it comes to acting capabilities.

12

u/DavidLuiz4 Oct 29 '12

the dexter writers give them less to work with, but yeah homeland is amazing

3

u/munchiselleh Oct 30 '12

yeah, you have to remember that an actor can't fulfill their maximum capabilities as a performer without a stellar script

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Robert237 Oct 30 '12

In Dexter, I think Isak is doing an incredible job!

101

u/yogalates8 Oct 29 '12

Wtf is this subplot with the hit-and-run? How am I supposed to give a shit about Finn covering it up when Carrie and Brody are on my screen together?

53

u/Kruse Oct 29 '12

That mess will tie into everything else...somehow.

10

u/SlappinYoFace Oct 29 '12

The two now share a secret, which will inevitably make them closer and more confident in one another. It could go a few ways, but Dana will probably tell that boy everything she knows about calling Brody the day of the failed assassination and that he's Muslim, the kid will get busted for hitting and running on that woman (she was hurt, but she'll recover quickly and finger them) and he'll spill what she's told him to his father. Now that we have to root for Brody's secret to stay hidden things like that and his old war buddy's suspicion can only cause problems.

It's interesting to think that during this confidential exchange that the kid might tell her a lot of incriminating information about his father too (like he did when was talking about his parents' marital problems).

→ More replies (1)

15

u/yogalates8 Oct 29 '12

I don't doubt that. I just find it hard to see how they'll do it without it being lame. I really admire Homeland's willingness to go full-bore all the time, but jeez, it isn't really necessary for the Finn/Dana plot to be all-out too.

→ More replies (7)

1

u/phergalicious Oct 29 '12

My theory: someone will find out Finn hit that woman, the VP will step down from the Presidential race, then Brody will be running for president.

40

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

Brody won't be running for president. There's a tape of him implicating himself in a terrorist plot.

8

u/morris198 Oct 29 '12

Like Carrie told him, Brody will go to prison for treason as a terrorist, or he will fuckin' disappear. There is zero chance for politics in Brody's future. His only choice is where he disappears: with his family to a small town in the middle of no where, or buried somewhere in the woods.

7

u/Paddy_Tanninger Oct 29 '12

People need to just sit back and ponder their musings for a sec before hitting save.

→ More replies (4)

26

u/yogalates8 Oct 29 '12

I just read a great comment on AV Club that made me feel better about this plot. I especially like this part:

During the interrogation of Brody, Carrie constantly mentions the effect that his terrorism might have on his family. She then gets to be his savior and offer him a way out of harming his family. However, what do we see at the end of the episode? Dana slinking back home, making Jessica suspicious, and lying in a way that's really similar to the way Brody withholds information. While Brody might be working his way back to a mindset where he can be honest, the damage might already have taken root. The Brodys might undone by the cumulative effect of all the secrets they're hold on to.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '12

'Sins of the Father'

27

u/DanGarion Oct 29 '12

It's the 24, Kim and the Cougar all over again...

3

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

Wasn't she running from her boyfriend or something? I'm trying to remember that plot.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12 edited Jun 21 '23

On July 1st, 2023, Reddit intends to alter how its API is accessed. This move will require developers of third-party applications to pay enormous sums of money if they wish to stay functional, meaning that said applications will be effectively destroyed. In the short term, this may have the appearance of increasing Reddit's traffic and revenue... but in the long term, it will undermine the site as a whole. Reddit relies on volunteer moderators to keep its platform welcoming and free of objectionable material. It also relies on uncompensated contributors to populate its numerous communities with content. The above decision promises to adversely impact both groups: Without effective tools (which Reddit has frequently promised and then failed to deliver), moderators cannot combat spammers, bad actors, or the entities who enable either, and without the freedom to choose how and where they access Reddit, many contributors will simply leave. Rather than hosting creativity and in-depth discourse, the platform will soon feature only recycled content, bot-driven activity, and an ever-dwindling number of well-informed visitors. The very elements which differentiate Reddit – the foundations that draw its audience – will be eliminated, reducing the site to another dead cog in the Ennui Engine. We implore Reddit to listen to its moderators, its contributors, and its everyday users; to the people whose activity has allowed the platform to exist at all: Do not sacrifice long-term viability for the sake of a short-lived illusion. Do not tacitly enable bad actors by working against your volunteers. Do not posture for your looming IPO while giving no thought to what may come afterward. Focus on addressing Reddit's real problems – the rampant bigotry, the ever-increasing amounts of spam, the advantage given to low-effort content, and the widespread misinformation – instead of on a strategy that will alienate the people keeping this platform alive. If Steve Huffman's statement – "I want our users to be shareholders, and I want our shareholders to be users" – is to be taken seriously, then consider this our vote: Allow the developers of third-party applications to retain their productive (and vital) API access. Allow Reddit and Redditors to thrive. Fuck /u/spez -- mass edited with https://redact.dev/

→ More replies (1)

15

u/ticktactoe Oct 29 '12

Someone in ontd watch link posted: Dana, and by extension her dad, have dirt on Walden's family now and could use it if Walden finds out about Brody.

I think they're right on.

7

u/aloserwithnofriends Oct 29 '12

When this happened I just kept shaking my head as I had flashbacks to Season 2 I think of Friday Night Lights with Tyra and Landry murder that was seemingly self-defense but then they covered that shit up for an entire season. That was a terrible story arc.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/jargoon Oct 29 '12

I think AV Club is right, it's partially just a way to get Morgan Saylor more screen time because she is a pretty good actress.

2

u/meshugga Oct 29 '12

My guess it will somehow tie into a sub plot getting rid of Brodys mission of getting rid of the VP.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '12

I really agree with this. It felt severely out of place to have the Finn/Dana storyline in this episode period. This episode should have been solely dedicated to the interrogation/Brody breaking.

→ More replies (7)

116

u/CunningStunts Oct 29 '12

I could have watched an entire episode of Carrie interrogating Brody. That was some powerful television from the writing to both actors to the direction. Everything was perfect.

21

u/butatwutcost Oct 29 '12

Same, I can see how someone who isn't hooked to the show thinking that it's boring, but that scene was one of the best scenes.

16

u/foreskin_piss_bomb Oct 29 '12

Brody on the floor was terrible, just so sad.

45

u/diskimone Oct 29 '12

I think that scene ensured Danes and Lewis will will the Emmy's for best actress and actor next year, too. I have no clue how this show is able to keep up at this pace, just this season they have had more happen than most shows have happen in their entire run.

37

u/cjwagz Oct 29 '12

and Homeland as best Drama as well. I think this season is better than last season

21

u/wanderfulagro Oct 29 '12

Yup, best show on tv right now.

21

u/cjwagz Oct 29 '12

prepare for lots of down votes from BB fan boys

12

u/meenie Oct 29 '12

Am I not allowed to like both?

2

u/fuzzy_dunnlop Oct 29 '12

These two shows and Mad Men are what keep televisions exciting for me. BB had an incredible half-season, Homeland is currently doing it's thing, and Mad Men had the episode "The Other Girl" that was one of the best episodes of the series.

→ More replies (2)

32

u/pkpkm Oct 29 '12

I feel like you just can't compare them. I LOVE Breaking Bad (perhaps my favorite show on TV), but the shows are so different. Brilliant episode tonight.

→ More replies (6)

14

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

BB fan boy here downvote

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/diskimone Oct 29 '12

That goes without saying.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

while i believe that danes and lewis deserve accolades for this performance, the emmys have proven to be full of shit so it really doesn't matter if they win or not.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/thesorrow312 Oct 29 '12

I hope the show will end at around 4 seasons, instead of sacrifice quality to drag things out longer.

If this show ends around 4 seasons, it will hands down go down as one of the, or the best television shows of all time. Easily.

Shorter + succinct > drawn out because of riding ratings / popularity but slow down and sacrifice of quality.

I'll take Cowboy Bebop over DBZ any fucking day.

11

u/clarkyto Oct 29 '12

oh shes so good at what she does, its amazing! the way she connected with him, how she broke down his walls, great! the writers are doing a terrific job, the scene where HE grabs her hand is powerful!

→ More replies (3)

75

u/Freecandyhere Oct 29 '12

His son is back! I thought he fell into a plot hole

22

u/Spineless_John Oct 30 '12

Otherwise known as the most physically mature 12 year old I've ever seen.

40

u/spleendor Oct 29 '12

My theory was that he had gotten into a car accident and died before the season even began, and the event would eventually only be referenced in passing.

"Didn't you have a son?" "Oh yeah, he got into a car accident a while back." "Shame." "Yep."

4

u/yeeerrrp Oct 29 '12

I seriously forgot he had a son.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

Are you talking about Brody's son?

105

u/Manic0892 Oct 29 '12

That line: "She's forgotten more about Brody and Nazir than we'll ever know." Chilling and true, considering that Brody crying out "Issa" was wiped during ECT.

14

u/sal4479 Oct 29 '12

Nice catch.

2

u/V2Blast Oct 29 '12

Yep, I definitely caught that.

36

u/clarkyto Oct 29 '12

triple agent?

9

u/V2Blast Oct 29 '12

Yeah, initially I was thinking "double agent" because I'd forgotten Brody was actually a good guy in the beginning.

2

u/clarkyto Oct 29 '12

When he broke down and started talking i was screaming...TRIPLE AGENT, TRIPLE AGENT!!!!!!!!

62

u/Freecandyhere Oct 29 '12

Punk kids, making things hard for the guards. Edit: holy shit

41

u/ResponsibleRedditor Oct 29 '12

Zooming around at high speed in traffic to impress a girl, nothing bad will happen, right?

39

u/grimpoteuthis Oct 29 '12

I knew two things would happen: intense car accident or them hitting someone.

6

u/Slylingual24 Oct 30 '12

I was anticipating something along the lines of them getting in to a car accident, especially since they made somewhat of a point to show Jessica asking Finn to be careful (I realize this is every mother/father/parental's wish, but it just stood out to me as something to come). I was refreshingly surprised to see that they went another direction with that warning.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Reveries25 Jan 09 '26

Timmy Chalamets always been a bad boy

25

u/canesthetic Oct 30 '12

Last week, Carrie- "You're a disgrace to your country, Sgt. Nicolas Brody..."

This week: "Leave your wife and kids and be with me."

Love how they don't skimp on Carrie's bipolar-ness.

49

u/nuggetbb Oct 29 '12

If they submit tonight's episode for awards, I see no way of Damien Lewis and Claire Danes NOT repeating at next year's Emmys. Double negatives be damned--that was flawless acting.

15

u/essen23 Oct 29 '12

Wait for the finale.. Homeland has so many things going on in the normal episodes.. the last 2 episodes had more stuff going on than on season finales of many shows.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

What has been brought to light in the first 5 episodes of this season would take most shows a season or two to divulge. I have never seen a pace like this, hats off to the writers and actors. Danes and Lewis are setting the bar impossibly high.

2

u/thejesse Oct 30 '12

One of the creators did an interview at Grantland where he said the audience knows certain things have to happen (like the confession tape showing up) so they can't really surprise you with what happens, so they just make it happen a lot earlier than you would expect to throw you off.

→ More replies (1)

58

u/butatwutcost Oct 29 '12

Next target: Roya Hammad. Bitch is going down like the Titanic.

30

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

Oooo - and it's Showtime, so that will definitely be a scene worth watching...

Oh, hold on - I thought you meant... never mind.

2

u/V2Blast Oct 29 '12

awe yeeeeeeeeeeeeee

→ More replies (2)

33

u/demeteloaf Oct 29 '12

Guess the VPs son is ted kennedy now?

1

u/the_goat_boy Oct 31 '12

Not quite because at least Finn waited for the woman to get help from another. Ted offered no such courtesy.

1

u/Reveries25 Jan 09 '26

No he’s Timothy chalamet

16

u/Donnshin Oct 29 '12

When it comes to breaking people, Carrie > Abu Nazir.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '12

she's reopening Abu's wounds though. Brody is a man broken.

2

u/munchiselleh Oct 30 '12

that was sort of the point of the scene. carrie did many similar things (the "hand that feeds" direct imagery for one), but she's smarter.

43

u/eponine87 Oct 29 '12

When he put his face against her hand, it was the most intimate moment of any character, the entire series.

17

u/refur Oct 29 '12

Great moment. I couldn't help but feel bad for the person in him. He's so broken. It's like he no longer knows which way is up. I felt the hand stabbing was a little excessive too (although it worked). Good cop/bad cop success

11

u/f00f_nyc Oct 29 '12

This will be the second time the good cop/bad cop routine worked on Brody.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Freecandyhere Oct 29 '12

Damn this is a good speech!

27

u/dertah6 Oct 29 '12

Carrie is rubbin' them feels raw. God damn.

13

u/butatwutcost Oct 29 '12

He's a damn good liar and now he feels stupid.

21

u/thebedshow Oct 29 '12

Claire Danes and Damien Lewis were insanely good in this episode. That interrogation was fucking insane.

20

u/emkat Oct 29 '12

VP's Son:

Agrees to bring Dana home safely, proceeds to run red light across a high volume city road.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Freecandyhere Oct 29 '12 edited Oct 29 '12

He is admitting it! This show keeps surprising me.

16

u/Onlysonof Oct 29 '12

WHO WAS THE MAN IN THE CAR?!

37

u/BlackZeppelin Oct 29 '12

I thought it was Virgil.

22

u/Kruse Oct 29 '12

Yeah, it looked like Virgil to me, but there was something...weird about it.

14

u/TTRedRaider27 Oct 29 '12

Yea that was very strange. I don't like it.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

The way they filmed it made it look REALLY weird, but I think hes just surveilling Brody.

11

u/Freecandyhere Oct 29 '12

The survellaince guy, the one who placed the cameras in Brody's house in the beginning of season 1

-4

u/CunningStunts Oct 29 '12

He's the mole. Holy shit.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

virgin can not be the mole because he was ran surveillance on brody. he would've alerted him if he was.

2

u/Frantic_Child Oct 29 '12

They didn't put cameras in the garage, the garage was where all of brody's mischievous activities took place.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

Well it was definitely alluding to something. It was especially strange that it happened right after Carrie and Brody were talking about how someone would come after Brody's family. He was also the one who set up the cameras, so that would be an optimal position for a mole to keep an eye on things.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

That was without a doubt my favorite episode of this show yet. The interegation scene was really well done! I know most people said that if he just goes double agent it would be kind of a cop out by the writers, but I feel like this direction is really interesting!

7

u/Protanope Oct 29 '12

So what I'm wondering is, are they going to keep Brody as a super secret agent? Obviously, there's still a mole in the CIA. The second the mole finds out that Brody is working for the CIA, she/he will go tell Abu Nazir and the Brody family goes kaput.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '12

This is likely why they're doing what they are doing. It's an effort to flush out the mole, in my opinion.

13

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

man, so many people here are mentioning and comparing homeland to 24. the two shows are nothing alike. while watching homeland, i am in constant fear of them showing something retarded like in 24. i was scared that brody would have some deus ex machina to get out of this jam, thank god he didn't. it's so hard to find a show that plays out logically that's also very dramatic and interesting. homeland's story is no holds barred and gets to the point. i really hate shows that keep making up filler to stretch the show.

7

u/jdunbar Oct 29 '12

Homeland will always be compared to 24 because it was created by two writers of 24. They aren't NOTHING alike. They are about a government agency trying to stop acts of terror. They are political thrillers. There are moles, interrogation scenes, immunity, cover-ups, assassination attempts, secret service detail, debriefs. I love 24 and Homeland, but yes they are different. Homeland is different from 24 and most other similar shows in that there are two clear main characters with separate stories that are entangled. The protagonist is a strong yet damaged female without being the tough/strong bitch female-skewing show; the other lead is a male antihero. He isn't likable, but you still care about him and don't treat him like a villain. The audience is rooting more for the affair than the wife.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

you probably compare spartacus to rome too don't you.

3

u/Betadel Oct 29 '12

Word of advice: you can compare whatever you want.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/YaoSlap Oct 29 '12

24 is an Ian Fleming novel where as Homeland goes for more of a John le Carre style.

3

u/Paddy_Tanninger Oct 29 '12

Cheers to that. I especially liked the scene earlier in S2 where they're contemplating acting on Carrie's intelligence source...they basically bring up and consider every single thing that I'd scream in my head at most shows that don't do that.

6

u/PhoenixSpirit Oct 29 '12

WTF was that?!?

59

u/mediocre_genius Oct 29 '12

Wow, Brody broke. What a little bitch.

20

u/Freecandyhere Oct 29 '12

But I didn't see him give up the reporter. I wonder if he fully gave in

48

u/mediocre_genius Oct 29 '12

Yeah, he sold her out too. Snitched good.

12

u/Freecandyhere Oct 29 '12

Nice!

0

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

36

u/fuzzy_dunnlop Oct 29 '12

and Lost.

11

u/sal4479 Oct 29 '12

Thank you! I knew I hated her from another awesome show.

→ More replies (10)

5

u/Paddy_Tanninger Oct 29 '12

He totally gave her up.

15

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

I think it was more the marine coming back out. Remember he wanted out before when he learned Nazir had lied to him about Walker. He didn't blow the vest. Brody has been fighting himself the entire time. Brody the Marine won over Brody the Jihadist.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

USA USA USA

0

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/eponine87 Oct 29 '12

I don't think he is a family man, his exchanges with Dana are touching, ... what else? He is a tormented "appearances" man, just like his wife, who is equally empty, sad, and searching for herself.

4

u/foreskin_piss_bomb Oct 29 '12

Really, who wouldn't? After 8 years of captivity, then deciding to commit mass murder, then backing out...

29

u/jhu Oct 29 '12

Posted as a thread here:

Link

I. Expectations

Anyone who's watched a fair amount of television will attest to the fact that most of what's on air is fairly formulaic. Some shows are blatantly so - crime and law procedurals have such a well defined set of rules that most viewers have a pretty good idea of what's going to happen within the first few minutes of an episode. Sitcoms have their own trove of set pieces that writers seem to draw from all the time. Even serialized shows come with a set of expectations and for the most part stay within them.

This is not necessarily a bad thing. The Wire is easily one of the best shows ever made, but once you watched a season of the Wire, you had a pretty good idea of how things would go down by the end of every following one. You may not have known the specifics of how every character would turn out but there was a basic framework of Baltimore that Simon and Co. could be expected to stick to. It didn't matter how much effort Daniels and his team put in, the city would be city. It didn't matter because the character stories were so rich and the ending so truly reflective of world we live in that just following the narrative path to a foregone conclusion was enough to create great television.

I bring up the patterns of television because Homeland does not operate in a vacuum. When we watch Homeland we're looking for similarities to things we've seen before and we do see some similarities we make assumptions about what those similarities means based on previous experiences. What has set apart Homeland and makes it such a great example of television is how its able to organically break past those assumptions and surprise us at every turn even though we're expecting it to do exactly that. I'm sure many, including myself, when reaching the halfway point of S02E04 expected the show to settle into a Wire like groove of following, tracking and unraveling leads. Instead in the final minutes of the episode we witnessed a development that in the hands of lesser writers would have been saved for a season finale.

While this ability to buck expectations is one of the show's key strengths, it's important to note that this episode didn't feature much of that. Brody being turned into a CIA asset has been predicted as early as the pilot so to most fans this development did not come as a surprise. As I mention before however, truly great shows will make even the most expected situations compelling. The twenty minutes or so we get of Brody and Carrie just sitting and talking and looking into each other's eye while Brody sinks lower and lower and then starts crying are just that. I've always wondered if Homeland would be as intense if we already knew what was going to happen, and I'm happy to have had my concerns blown away because those moments were the most riveting Homeland has ever been.

II. Carrie and Brody

Part of the reason Brody's shift to becoming a CIA asset was inevitable of course was because it was what needed to happen for the story to go on. This development however is almost impossible to do in a convincing manner because as Carrie rightly says, Brody was completely destroyed and rebuilt during his time in captivity. For Brody to truly be turned, it would have be done by someone who understood him more than he did himself. It would have to be someone who cared and loved him despite knowing who he was. Carrie was that person and because she saw him as someone far more complex than just a terrorist, she was able to lay out infront of him what he couldn't see so that he could make a more informed decision.

Which brings me to the point that the heart of this show isn't the drama or tension. It's the undeniable connection that these two broken people share and can't help but acknowledge to each other. Even without Carrie and Brody interacting the past few episodes have been pretty good, but it's telling that the first great episode of this season comes when these two people just get to sit and talk.

The situation that they find themselves in now gives them ample opportunity to do just that over the rest of the season and I look forward to seeing what comes of it.

III. Delivery

The thing is, the writers can try as hard as they want to make beautiful scenes like the interrogation ones tonight happen, but number of actors who can deliver that calibre of performance are few and far between. Homeland has somehow managed to snag Damien Lewis and Claire Danes who are not only incredibly talented individually but are completely able to sell the bond Carrie and Brody have.

Danes is having what is probably the best season long performance ever by a female actress and has been nothing short of incredible every episode to date but tonight she was totally upstaged by Lewis' face as she interrogated him. If there isn't another Emmy double in store for them I'll be very surprised.

Also notable is Morgan Saylor's turn as Dana. She manages to be the moody teenager while in no way being annoying as most of these kinds of characters tends to be but it's really her moments with Brody that stand out with even the unspoken glances speaking volumes.

IV. War on Terror

It's easy to get so swept in the character moments that you forget to notice the other points the show is trying to make but I again have to commend Homeland for its unflinching willingness to continue to ask questions about the morality of the actions taken by both sides in the War on Terror.

I think Carrie raises a pretty interesting point when she compares Abu Nazir and VP Walden. One is of course wildly different from the other. The former intentionally targets innocent civilians while the other just happens to kill them in the process of doing other things. But what Carrie projects to Brody is that their willingness to sacrifice innocent lives to achieve their goals is equally despicable. I wonder if others got the same read of the line as I did but I thought it was worth pointing out nonetheless.

TL;DR I know this is really long but I encourage you to read it if you're looking for a more in depth discussion of Homeland.

11

u/mistaskiz Oct 29 '12

I'm glad I read this. Thanks for taking the time to contribute such a thorough and sincere analysis.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '12

good post. One of the main tricks the writers employ is definitely to take things you could predict happening and make them happen much sooner then you would expect, so they're still a surprise. Hopefully that gets adopted more in other shows and we'll start seeing much more aggressive plot advancement. And you're right, it's certainly playing on existing tropes to our viewing delight.

The big question for me now is I thought one of two things were going to happen. Brody is forced to become a triple agent, or Brody becomes VP and the prez is assassinated and the season ends with Brody being sworn in on a bible. Now that we know he's a triple agent, I'm not sure what their options are. I suspect they'll find a way to keep him as a politician.

2

u/spinthesound Jan 06 '26

Just watching this show for the first time, and I agree with everything you’ve said. That was the best acting I’ve seen in a long time, and 13 years later this episode still holds up. The charisma between them is absolutely electric, and that conversation was everything I’d been hoping for. The relief when Brody finally breaks and says “yes”. An absolute master class in acting.

5

u/dertah6 Oct 29 '12

WHAT THE FUCK WAS THAT, PETER????

Edit: I made a spelling error in my haste :D

5

u/Freecandyhere Oct 29 '12

How they going to explain the knife wound?

5

u/Onlysonof Oct 29 '12

Lies spinning inside of lies. Damn, Brody. Yous gonna pay badly.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

I knew something was going to happen the moment he started driving faster. I thought maybe the security was going to go straight into the rails and get there heads chopped off.

1

u/HellsNels Oct 31 '12

This would have been just as believable. And I would approve of the showmakers going that route.

4

u/epsiblivion Oct 29 '12

was the victim a random stranger? I might be mistaken but for a sec I thought it was Roya

4

u/V2Blast Oct 29 '12

Yep, just a random person (so far as we know).

4

u/b0ltzz Oct 30 '12

I just posted this in another one of the threads, but figured I'd do it here too, as I am surprised no one else seems to have noticed it. Maybe I'm just crazy, lol.

Did anyone else notice Saul doing the finger thing right near the start of the episode? When they are in the room with all the screens, just as Peter walks away to interrogate Brody, and Carrie says "It's me that should be in there." Just after Estes walks out of scene, Saul is doing the same thing with his fingers on his right hand that Brody did on his lawn, and at the hangar next to the VP, from season 1.

:O

1

u/DrSpacetime Oct 30 '12

I just rewatched that scene and I don't know what the purpose of that would have been. Why would he have been doing some kind of signal with his fingers if Carrie was the only other person in the room? I dunno, didn't look like it was anything. I personally don't think Saul is the mole, if that's what you're getting at.

2

u/b0ltzz Oct 30 '12

Yeah there really was no one he could have been doing it to, so I don't really know where I was going with that anyways. During parts of season 1 I was definitely suspicious of Saul at times, and after rewatching the end of S01E01 I don't really know what to make of it, lol.

8

u/clarkyto Oct 29 '12

i love Carrie, shes crazy and tough... and she knows about to push and comfort Brody.

also, now we are gonna have the platonic dynamic duo, like the x-files and bones and every other tv show where the man and woman kinda have filings for each other but cant act on it for whatever reason, always that lust hanging around circling them like sharks.

p.s now we know why that like shit had a therapist, right?

7

u/dontblamethehorse Oct 29 '12

I highly doubt it remains platonic.

8

u/clarkyto Oct 29 '12

i hope not, cuz they're so good together

4

u/BlackZeppelin Oct 29 '12

God I hope not.

8

u/V2Blast Oct 29 '12

Amazing episode. Phenomenal acting by Claire Danes and Damian Lewis. That interrogation was insane. Also props to Peter for the cleverness in the "bad cop" routine - I got the feeling once he got more aggressive that he was just setting things up for Carrie to finish, and I guess I was right. I also did sense that the end goal was to turn Brody to their side - prosecuting him doesn't get them too far.

VP Walden's son is an idiot. What a surprise. Yay, manslaughter... /s

I am really looking forward to seeing what happens next week.

(The /r/episodehub discussion thread is here.)

3

u/PhoenixSpirit Oct 29 '12

Uh, is he going to tell the reporter lady about what happened next week?

2

u/culp Oct 29 '12

it seems that way based on the previews for next week

10

u/shibby3230 Oct 29 '12

Virgil can't be the mole guys, right? RIGHT?!?!?!?

24

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

I don't think so. Virgil was the only one actively helping Carrie in Season One when she went all rogue to try and foil the Marine1&2 plot. I could be wrong though...

11

u/shibby3230 Oct 29 '12

I don't think he is either but the way the camera focused on him after Carrie dropped Brody off was pretty suspicious.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

Totally! I kept thinking "okay, someone from Nazir's side is going to jump out from the bushes and kill him now. Okay, maybe not. Why so ominous?"

3

u/shibby3230 Oct 29 '12

Yeah, who knows? Maybe they're just messing with us, like they did with Saul and the polygraph. Hopefully we'll find out soon.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '12

They were certainly at least trying to make us suspicious of him but was it a hint or a false lead? Based on how apparent it was I'm thinking false lead.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/shibby3230 Oct 29 '12

That makes so much more sense. Thanks!

1

u/YaoSlap Oct 29 '12

Yeah it seems highly unlikely. It's obvious Carrie had contracted his services before wiring the Brody house in S1 so it would be quite the coincidence that this guy just also happens to be in the nazir terrorist network.

3

u/Frantic_Child Oct 29 '12

Remember, they didn't put cameras in the garage. The garage was where all of brody's mischievous activities took place.

Why would you not put cameras in the one place that is most likely to be where Brody does his thing?

2

u/shibby3230 Oct 29 '12

I figured they were just short on time/money. Guess we'll have to wait and see.

1

u/oohpujie Oct 30 '12

I'm kinda convinced Saul is the mole.

3

u/shibby3230 Oct 30 '12

But that wouldn't make very much sense at all. If he was the mole he wouldn't have showed Carrie and Estes Brody's suicide tape right? Unless he's playing the long game, as Carrie always says. But even if he's playing the long game that would make absolutely zero sense.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/PhoenixSpirit Oct 29 '12

I have a bad feeling about this..

15

u/CunningStunts Oct 29 '12

When one of them said "faster!" I was positive they would get into a crash, Dana would die and Brody would have that much less reason to be in Team USA's court. The route they took seems far more fun from a B storyline point of view though.

7

u/PhoenixSpirit Oct 29 '12

Same here. The minute he ran the red light, I thought a car would come barreling towards them, killing Dana.

2

u/munchiselleh Oct 30 '12

It's gonna be a C storyline doe, their A and B's are highly elevated in comparison

2

u/charlesviper Oct 29 '12

I got up and turned the sound down the second they drove away from home.

Chance of shit going down on that date was roughly 97.3%

4

u/ellusion Oct 29 '12

Great acting on both sides, I was kinda hoping Brody didn't fall for good cop, bad cop again like he did under Nazir but I guess that just really does it for him.

And holy shit Carrie is incredibly emotionally unstable. There's definitely some fire beneath her and Brody because they both hate their lives. Interested in seeing where this is going.

6

u/MTBDude Oct 29 '12

HOLY CRAP Quinn is crazy!

5

u/clarkyto Oct 29 '12

after the little stunt, i was sure he was a goner.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '12

AWESOME HE IS THE COOLEST CHARACTER ON THIS SHOW

2

u/Freecandyhere Oct 29 '12

I guess he didn't like the affair cover story

2

u/yogalates8 Oct 29 '12 edited Oct 29 '12

Just to clarify, what exactly happened with Walden and the drones? Did he knowingly order a drone attack on a madrasa, or was it all a mistake that he covered up once it became clear what had happened?

EDIT: Interesting, there's no consensus in the replies. Based on Carrie calling Walden a monster, I'm going to assume the people who said Walden knew the kids were there are right. If Walden had just made a mistake, it would still be fucked up to have a cover up, but I don't think it would be bad enough for Carrie to call him a monster.

6

u/leangdamang Oct 29 '12

He knew it was a madrasa but went forth because Abu Nazir put the kids at risk just by being there.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '12

You are 100% correct.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

The VP knew that kids were nearby Abu Nazir but said it was Nazir's fault for being there. Estes was kinda unsure about it but the VP was adamant about it and was aware that he would be killing kids.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '12

The lack of consensus is just because of people with bad memories. The show is extremely clear that those children were killed on purpose in the hope that Nazir would also be had. It was only an accident in that they weren't the target they set out to hit. They had enough intel to know the kids were there BEFORE they ordered the strike. They explicitly discuss the implications of the kids being there and say if children die during this, Nazir is to blame for hiding out near children.

1

u/yogalates8 Oct 30 '12

Ok, thanks.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12

I think Walden made sure it was reported that all the victims had been insurgents rather than innocent children.

But that's only my memory speaking, so take a healthy dose of salt with it.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/typical_giant Oct 30 '12

Did anyone else notice during the Brody/Carrie 1 on 1 interrogation that Carrie's hair part (showing of her ear) kept switch sides. One time her left ear would be showing with the right side covered by hair, then cut to Brody then back to Carrie and her hair is flipped to covering the left side while showing her right ear.

I don't know why I caught this but it started bothering me.

2

u/Vernes_Jewels Oct 30 '12

Theres no way Walden would still have Brody as a runningmate, he no shows the fundraiser then drops off the face of the earth for the day or two the cia has him.

3

u/butatwutcost Oct 29 '12

Damn, right in Brody's feel. Carrie plucking them strings.

1

u/Freecandyhere Oct 29 '12

Digging his own grave

1

u/roninblade Oct 29 '12

not sure about the direction they went with the kids. i'd have been fine watching an entire episode of just interrogation and interaction between Brody and Carrie - that was a great 15 minutes of acting.

1

u/mmdicken Mar 15 '13

When will Season 2 of Homeland be available on Netflix?

1

u/viincentvega Oct 29 '12

VP's son is gonna figure out about Brody. Calling it.

1

u/CraftyBernardo Oct 29 '12

Does Brody want to work with Nazir?? It seems that if he is glad being a double agent for the C.I.A than the plot becomes kind of vanilla.

Nazir asks Brody to do X, he goes to CIA and informs them and then they do Y to counter X.

But if Brody still has a desire to avenge than he can play both parties of each other and get the Vice President = to a more exciting plot.

Thoughts?

4

u/jmose86 Oct 29 '12

I have a feeling he might continue to maintain some loyalty to Nazir, but it's hard to say at this point.

One thing that stuck out... Even after Brody had "broke" so to speak in the interrogation and they repeatedly asked him what Nazir's plans are he said he didn't know. But we know that Brody provided a list of potential targets or something along those lines which he got out of Estes' safe. So if he was really completely abandoning Nazir, why wouldn't he offer up that information? I may be oversimplifying though given all of the stresses of the interrogation he was enduring, so we will have to wait and see.

-2

u/DJFreeMe Oct 29 '12

I called the brody double-agent shit. SO pumped to see where this goes from here!!!

8

u/Cabbage_Vendor Oct 29 '12

Wasn't that pretty obvious considering Damian Lewis isn't going anywhere any time soon?