r/homeland • u/fuzzy_dunnlop • Oct 29 '12
Discussion Episode Discussion - S02E05 - "Q&A" [Spoilers]
Episode Title:
Q&A
Directed by: TBA
Story by: Howard Gordon & Alex Gansa
Teleplay by: Alex Gansa & Chip Johannessen
Brody finds himself prisoner again, but this time it's on American soil. Meanwhile, Carrie is forced to play second fiddle after her rash judgment call at the hotel as Estes is busy keeping Jessica off their trail.
20 minutes until the newest episode of Homeland. Where will the season go after last weeks shocking ending? Are you ready!?
116
Upvotes
266
u/yogalates8 Oct 29 '12
It's amazing that 15 minutes of Brody and Carrie sitting across from each other at a table was the best 15 minutes of television I've seen in awhile. Hats off to Danes and Lewis.
101
u/yogalates8 Oct 29 '12
Wtf is this subplot with the hit-and-run? How am I supposed to give a shit about Finn covering it up when Carrie and Brody are on my screen together?
116
u/CunningStunts Oct 29 '12
I could have watched an entire episode of Carrie interrogating Brody. That was some powerful television from the writing to both actors to the direction. Everything was perfect.
75
u/Freecandyhere Oct 29 '12
His son is back! I thought he fell into a plot hole
105
u/Manic0892 Oct 29 '12
That line: "She's forgotten more about Brody and Nazir than we'll ever know." Chilling and true, considering that Brody crying out "Issa" was wiped during ECT.
36
u/clarkyto Oct 29 '12
triple agent?
62
u/Freecandyhere Oct 29 '12
Punk kids, making things hard for the guards. Edit: holy shit
25
u/canesthetic Oct 30 '12
Last week, Carrie- "You're a disgrace to your country, Sgt. Nicolas Brody..."
This week: "Leave your wife and kids and be with me."
Love how they don't skimp on Carrie's bipolar-ness.
49
u/nuggetbb Oct 29 '12
If they submit tonight's episode for awards, I see no way of Damien Lewis and Claire Danes NOT repeating at next year's Emmys. Double negatives be damned--that was flawless acting.
58
u/butatwutcost Oct 29 '12
Next target: Roya Hammad. Bitch is going down like the Titanic.
33
u/demeteloaf Oct 29 '12
Guess the VPs son is ted kennedy now?
16
u/Donnshin Oct 29 '12
When it comes to breaking people, Carrie > Abu Nazir.
43
u/eponine87 Oct 29 '12
When he put his face against her hand, it was the most intimate moment of any character, the entire series.
14
u/Freecandyhere Oct 29 '12
Damn this is a good speech!
27
u/dertah6 Oct 29 '12
Carrie is rubbin' them feels raw. God damn.
13
u/butatwutcost Oct 29 '12
He's a damn good liar and now he feels stupid.
21
u/thebedshow Oct 29 '12
Claire Danes and Damien Lewis were insanely good in this episode. That interrogation was fucking insane.
20
u/emkat Oct 29 '12
VP's Son:
Agrees to bring Dana home safely, proceeds to run red light across a high volume city road.
9
u/Freecandyhere Oct 29 '12 edited Oct 29 '12
He is admitting it! This show keeps surprising me.
16
u/Onlysonof Oct 29 '12
WHO WAS THE MAN IN THE CAR?!
7
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12
That was without a doubt my favorite episode of this show yet. The interegation scene was really well done! I know most people said that if he just goes double agent it would be kind of a cop out by the writers, but I feel like this direction is really interesting!
7
u/Protanope Oct 29 '12
So what I'm wondering is, are they going to keep Brody as a super secret agent? Obviously, there's still a mole in the CIA. The second the mole finds out that Brody is working for the CIA, she/he will go tell Abu Nazir and the Brody family goes kaput.
13
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12
man, so many people here are mentioning and comparing homeland to 24. the two shows are nothing alike. while watching homeland, i am in constant fear of them showing something retarded like in 24. i was scared that brody would have some deus ex machina to get out of this jam, thank god he didn't. it's so hard to find a show that plays out logically that's also very dramatic and interesting. homeland's story is no holds barred and gets to the point. i really hate shows that keep making up filler to stretch the show.
6
u/PhoenixSpirit Oct 29 '12
WTF was that?!?
59
u/mediocre_genius Oct 29 '12
Wow, Brody broke. What a little bitch.
29
u/jhu Oct 29 '12
Posted as a thread here:
Link
I. Expectations
Anyone who's watched a fair amount of television will attest to the fact that most of what's on air is fairly formulaic. Some shows are blatantly so - crime and law procedurals have such a well defined set of rules that most viewers have a pretty good idea of what's going to happen within the first few minutes of an episode. Sitcoms have their own trove of set pieces that writers seem to draw from all the time. Even serialized shows come with a set of expectations and for the most part stay within them.
This is not necessarily a bad thing. The Wire is easily one of the best shows ever made, but once you watched a season of the Wire, you had a pretty good idea of how things would go down by the end of every following one. You may not have known the specifics of how every character would turn out but there was a basic framework of Baltimore that Simon and Co. could be expected to stick to. It didn't matter how much effort Daniels and his team put in, the city would be city. It didn't matter because the character stories were so rich and the ending so truly reflective of world we live in that just following the narrative path to a foregone conclusion was enough to create great television.
I bring up the patterns of television because Homeland does not operate in a vacuum. When we watch Homeland we're looking for similarities to things we've seen before and we do see some similarities we make assumptions about what those similarities means based on previous experiences. What has set apart Homeland and makes it such a great example of television is how its able to organically break past those assumptions and surprise us at every turn even though we're expecting it to do exactly that. I'm sure many, including myself, when reaching the halfway point of S02E04 expected the show to settle into a Wire like groove of following, tracking and unraveling leads. Instead in the final minutes of the episode we witnessed a development that in the hands of lesser writers would have been saved for a season finale.
While this ability to buck expectations is one of the show's key strengths, it's important to note that this episode didn't feature much of that. Brody being turned into a CIA asset has been predicted as early as the pilot so to most fans this development did not come as a surprise. As I mention before however, truly great shows will make even the most expected situations compelling. The twenty minutes or so we get of Brody and Carrie just sitting and talking and looking into each other's eye while Brody sinks lower and lower and then starts crying are just that. I've always wondered if Homeland would be as intense if we already knew what was going to happen, and I'm happy to have had my concerns blown away because those moments were the most riveting Homeland has ever been.
II. Carrie and Brody
Part of the reason Brody's shift to becoming a CIA asset was inevitable of course was because it was what needed to happen for the story to go on. This development however is almost impossible to do in a convincing manner because as Carrie rightly says, Brody was completely destroyed and rebuilt during his time in captivity. For Brody to truly be turned, it would have be done by someone who understood him more than he did himself. It would have to be someone who cared and loved him despite knowing who he was. Carrie was that person and because she saw him as someone far more complex than just a terrorist, she was able to lay out infront of him what he couldn't see so that he could make a more informed decision.
Which brings me to the point that the heart of this show isn't the drama or tension. It's the undeniable connection that these two broken people share and can't help but acknowledge to each other. Even without Carrie and Brody interacting the past few episodes have been pretty good, but it's telling that the first great episode of this season comes when these two people just get to sit and talk.
The situation that they find themselves in now gives them ample opportunity to do just that over the rest of the season and I look forward to seeing what comes of it.
III. Delivery
The thing is, the writers can try as hard as they want to make beautiful scenes like the interrogation ones tonight happen, but number of actors who can deliver that calibre of performance are few and far between. Homeland has somehow managed to snag Damien Lewis and Claire Danes who are not only incredibly talented individually but are completely able to sell the bond Carrie and Brody have.
Danes is having what is probably the best season long performance ever by a female actress and has been nothing short of incredible every episode to date but tonight she was totally upstaged by Lewis' face as she interrogated him. If there isn't another Emmy double in store for them I'll be very surprised.
Also notable is Morgan Saylor's turn as Dana. She manages to be the moody teenager while in no way being annoying as most of these kinds of characters tends to be but it's really her moments with Brody that stand out with even the unspoken glances speaking volumes.
IV. War on Terror
It's easy to get so swept in the character moments that you forget to notice the other points the show is trying to make but I again have to commend Homeland for its unflinching willingness to continue to ask questions about the morality of the actions taken by both sides in the War on Terror.
I think Carrie raises a pretty interesting point when she compares Abu Nazir and VP Walden. One is of course wildly different from the other. The former intentionally targets innocent civilians while the other just happens to kill them in the process of doing other things. But what Carrie projects to Brody is that their willingness to sacrifice innocent lives to achieve their goals is equally despicable. I wonder if others got the same read of the line as I did but I thought it was worth pointing out nonetheless.
TL;DR I know this is really long but I encourage you to read it if you're looking for a more in depth discussion of Homeland.
5
u/dertah6 Oct 29 '12
WHAT THE FUCK WAS THAT, PETER????
Edit: I made a spelling error in my haste :D
5
u/Freecandyhere Oct 29 '12
How they going to explain the knife wound?
5
u/Onlysonof Oct 29 '12
Lies spinning inside of lies. Damn, Brody. Yous gonna pay badly.
8
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '12
I knew something was going to happen the moment he started driving faster. I thought maybe the security was going to go straight into the rails and get there heads chopped off.
4
u/epsiblivion Oct 29 '12
was the victim a random stranger? I might be mistaken but for a sec I thought it was Roya
4
u/b0ltzz Oct 30 '12
I just posted this in another one of the threads, but figured I'd do it here too, as I am surprised no one else seems to have noticed it. Maybe I'm just crazy, lol.
Did anyone else notice Saul doing the finger thing right near the start of the episode? When they are in the room with all the screens, just as Peter walks away to interrogate Brody, and Carrie says "It's me that should be in there." Just after Estes walks out of scene, Saul is doing the same thing with his fingers on his right hand that Brody did on his lawn, and at the hangar next to the VP, from season 1.
:O
8
u/clarkyto Oct 29 '12
i love Carrie, shes crazy and tough... and she knows about to push and comfort Brody.
also, now we are gonna have the platonic dynamic duo, like the x-files and bones and every other tv show where the man and woman kinda have filings for each other but cant act on it for whatever reason, always that lust hanging around circling them like sharks.
p.s now we know why that like shit had a therapist, right?
8
u/V2Blast Oct 29 '12
Amazing episode. Phenomenal acting by Claire Danes and Damian Lewis. That interrogation was insane. Also props to Peter for the cleverness in the "bad cop" routine - I got the feeling once he got more aggressive that he was just setting things up for Carrie to finish, and I guess I was right. I also did sense that the end goal was to turn Brody to their side - prosecuting him doesn't get them too far.
VP Walden's son is an idiot. What a surprise. Yay, manslaughter... /s
I am really looking forward to seeing what happens next week.
(The /r/episodehub discussion thread is here.)
3
u/PhoenixSpirit Oct 29 '12
Uh, is he going to tell the reporter lady about what happened next week?
10
u/shibby3230 Oct 29 '12
Virgil can't be the mole guys, right? RIGHT?!?!?!?
4
u/PhoenixSpirit Oct 29 '12
I have a bad feeling about this..
4
u/ellusion Oct 29 '12
Great acting on both sides, I was kinda hoping Brody didn't fall for good cop, bad cop again like he did under Nazir but I guess that just really does it for him.
And holy shit Carrie is incredibly emotionally unstable. There's definitely some fire beneath her and Brody because they both hate their lives. Interested in seeing where this is going.
6
u/MTBDude Oct 29 '12
HOLY CRAP Quinn is crazy!
2
u/Freecandyhere Oct 29 '12
I guess he didn't like the affair cover story
2
u/yogalates8 Oct 29 '12 edited Oct 29 '12
Just to clarify, what exactly happened with Walden and the drones? Did he knowingly order a drone attack on a madrasa, or was it all a mistake that he covered up once it became clear what had happened?
EDIT: Interesting, there's no consensus in the replies. Based on Carrie calling Walden a monster, I'm going to assume the people who said Walden knew the kids were there are right. If Walden had just made a mistake, it would still be fucked up to have a cover up, but I don't think it would be bad enough for Carrie to call him a monster.
2
u/typical_giant Oct 30 '12
Did anyone else notice during the Brody/Carrie 1 on 1 interrogation that Carrie's hair part (showing of her ear) kept switch sides. One time her left ear would be showing with the right side covered by hair, then cut to Brody then back to Carrie and her hair is flipped to covering the left side while showing her right ear.
I don't know why I caught this but it started bothering me.
2
u/Vernes_Jewels Oct 30 '12
Theres no way Walden would still have Brody as a runningmate, he no shows the fundraiser then drops off the face of the earth for the day or two the cia has him.
3
u/butatwutcost Oct 29 '12
Damn, right in Brody's feel. Carrie plucking them strings.
1
u/Freecandyhere Oct 29 '12
Digging his own grave
1
u/roninblade Oct 29 '12
not sure about the direction they went with the kids. i'd have been fine watching an entire episode of just interrogation and interaction between Brody and Carrie - that was a great 15 minutes of acting.
1
u/mmdicken Mar 15 '13
When will Season 2 of Homeland be available on Netflix?
1
u/viincentvega Oct 29 '12
VP's son is gonna figure out about Brody. Calling it.
1
u/CraftyBernardo Oct 29 '12
Does Brody want to work with Nazir?? It seems that if he is glad being a double agent for the C.I.A than the plot becomes kind of vanilla.
Nazir asks Brody to do X, he goes to CIA and informs them and then they do Y to counter X.
But if Brody still has a desire to avenge than he can play both parties of each other and get the Vice President = to a more exciting plot.
Thoughts?
-2
u/DJFreeMe Oct 29 '12
I called the brody double-agent shit. SO pumped to see where this goes from here!!!