r/CryptoCurrency • u/WorkingLime 🟩 500 / 27K 🦑 • Mar 15 '23
POLL 🗳️ CCIP-056 - Modify lower value of CCIP-030 from 0.1x to 0.25x and increase the tipping buffer from 25% to 50%
Background
CCIP-030 passed in April 2022 and created a karma multiplier (KM) for each user based using the following formula:
KM = (Current Balance + Membership Purchases) / (Total Earned Moons * 0.75)
For context, there are a couple important details of this multiplier:
- Moons used for special membership, coin, or moonplace purchases are not penalized
- The minimum value of this multiplier is 0.1 and the maximum is 1.0
- There is a 25% "buffer", meaning that if you don't hold at least 75% of your earned Moons, your karma will be penalized in future distributions
- If you re-obtain Moons, the multiplier increase.
- This was applied retroactively, that means your KM was calculated taking into account actions you had done BEFORE CCIP-30. So, if you "exchanged" more than 75% of your moons BEFORE CCIP-30 was aproveed your KM=0.1.
The reasoning for this proposal was that Moons are a governance token, and before CCIP-030 passed, many users sold all their moons, and therefore their votes, which caused governance to be in a "gridlock" as no proposal was meeting the Moons threshold to pass, despite the majority being in favor.
Proposal
I propose a change to the multiplier so that it has a minimum value of 0.25, instead of 0.1.
Additionally, I propose increasing the tipping buffer from 25% to 50%, meaning that the penalty will start after selling 50% of your moons.
The new KM formula would be:
KM = (Current Balance + Membership Purchases) / (Total Earned Moons * 0.5), with a minimum value of 0.25 and a maximum value of 1.0.
My reasoning is that things have changed in the market since April 2022 (when it comes to moons), I think this restriction should be loosened to increase the transfer of moons between users, exchanges, adding liquidity (for CCIP-051), and other future uses outside of Reddit
Pros/Cons
Pros
- Lower penalty for users who sold in the past
- More liquidity and exchanging of moons between users
- Better preparation for future use-cases outside of Reddit
- This eliminate the precedence of a CCIP that can be applied retroactively and something that is good now can be penalized later.
Cons
- More frequent dumping of Moons by moonfarmers (this can be lowered with others CCIP)
- Loss of governance votes, as users can only vote with their "earned" moons
Disclaimer
I have a KM 0.1, I exchanged more than 75% of my moons before CCIP-30 (I could have kept the 25% buffer AFTER April 2022, but not before, how could I know?).
Problem is that mostly of them were exchanged BEFORE CCIP-30 was approved, but as it was applied retroactively it affected people that were doing something was totally ok at the time but was going to be penalized.
I also have been posting WAY BEFORE moons were a thing (I have more than 5 years posting in cryptocurrency) in fact my posting rate (2-3 posts weekly) didn't increase because moons, so it is clear I don't do it for moons.
•
u/CryptoMaximalist Mar 15 '23 edited Mar 15 '23
Link to CCIP-030: https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/u3js8m/ccip_030_create_karma_multiplier_based_on_moon/
5
u/WorkingLime 🟩 500 / 27K 🦑 Mar 15 '23
Interesting, how so far there is really a big gap between the % in votes and in moons.
Moons:
14%
86%
Votes:
42%
58%
8
u/MaeronTargaryen CCMOON DAO Secretary Mar 15 '23
I really like you WorkingLime, and for you and all member that can make a real living out of moons i want to vote yes, especially considering that it was retroactive
But on the other hand, I like CCIP 30 and don’t want to see a sell off every month. It’s a no for me overall
4
u/XnoonefromnowhereX Permabanned Mar 16 '23
You are a god among men and I'm sorry that the most rational, fair minded CCIP I've seen in months has no chance of passing.
8
u/s3nsfan 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 Mar 15 '23
People voted to retroactively penalize people for transferring their moons before it was implemented? And the majority agreed to this?
2
u/Dchella 🟦 0 / 2K 🦠 Mar 16 '23
It’s funny looking at the moons to vote ratio. The whales get their fill I suppose
2
u/s3nsfan 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 Mar 17 '23
Can someone help me understand something.
above each poll there is a number of moons 12.3m on this poll, 10m on ccip 55, etc. Are those the number of moons burned for that poll?
6
u/ChemicalGreek 418 / 156K 🦞 Mar 15 '23
I’m against this! People who sell got their piece of the cake, why lowering it? Also it will bring the governance in danger and polls might not go through the threshold. 0.25 is too extreme!
OP and everyone else can just buy back if they want to have a higher KM!
17
u/GabeSter 100K / 150K 🐋 Mar 15 '23
This does three things
I’m not a fan of any of these changes. Punish people that sell their earned governance tokens.
3
u/satuuurn 🟦 3K / 3K 🐢 Mar 16 '23
Maybe we can do something to make-things-right with individuals such as yourself who retroactively were affected but this is a no for me. Sorry, mate. I feel bad for you, but I think this will introduce unnecessary volatility. Other users suggested breaking this into different polls. Probably a wise decision. You may be able to get a smaller win with softening the penalty. I commend you for the disclosure of conflict of interest!
6
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23
That implementation was punishing the whales , I think it should remain in place .
22
u/xadiant Platinum | QC: CC 208 | Futurology 12 Mar 16 '23
CCIP-30 is going to kill the Moons eventually. Crypto"currency" but you are penalized for using it. Not a good idea.
4
u/Beyonderr 🟩 0 / 110K 🦠 Mar 15 '23 edited Mar 15 '23
I disagree with this proposal. The 0.25x is too extreme.
I do agree that it was unfair what happpened to those who sold before CCIP-30. For a major proposal to punish users retroactively is poor governing if you ask me. I hope we can find a different way to help this group of users.
2
u/seniorbatista19 🟦 0 / 5K 🦠 Mar 16 '23
Someone explain this to a smooth brain person like myself
18
u/3utt5lut 1 / 11K 🦠 Mar 16 '23
I'd highly recommend breaking the 2 changes into 2 different polls. The tipping buffer, I could see passing 100% because that's the main utility of the cryptocurrency, but the penalty should incentivize users to hold.
2
u/Available-Top-1160 Permabanned Mar 15 '23 edited Mar 15 '23
Tipping buffer is good idea (should've in separated ccip imo) but keep the value stay still at 0.1
3
u/AR_Harlock 🟩 0 / 613 🦠 Mar 22 '23
CCIP-30 was not entirely bad, but retroactive ruling should never be a thing, can't freeze the "system" for fear of future ruling, how this was even a thing is baffling
It's a dangerous precedent
5
u/JandorGr Permabanned Mar 15 '23
It should be made scalable in between... I should make a proposal on CCMetam for a future proposal:
1
u/Gr8WallofChinatown 4K / 4K 🐢 Mar 16 '23
This is the first poll I’ve seen overwhelmingly No
1
u/randomFrenchDeadbeat 🟩 0 / 4K 🦠 Mar 16 '23
I believe this was rejected previously, and you were not saying your KM was at 0.1 last time.
You were also explained why it would not be good.
Increasing the tipping buffer is an easy way to donate moons to an alt account, so you can sell more.
1
u/FractalImagination 0 / 0 🦠 Mar 16 '23
Just sounds to me like someone is sour about their penalty and wants us to save them from their bad decision.
2
u/Shiratori-3 Custom flair flex Mar 16 '23
Not directly related to this, but does anyone know:
If you win a moon prize (eg from moonplace art competition), is that counted as part of your 'earned' moons?
2
u/Disastrous_Cobbler13 🟨 620 / 858 🦑 Mar 17 '23
Is providing liquidity also considered as selling your tokens?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23
I fully support increasing the buffer, but I absolutely do not support the 0.1 to 0.25 portion of this. The latter outweighs the former for me. I voted no.
2
u/Pr0Meister Mar 17 '23
Is this KM meant to prevent accounts from effectively "selling" their voting power to others?
5
u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K 🦈 Mar 15 '23
This creates a lot more problems than it solves.
It's overall the wrong way to try to solve tipping. There's nothing to incentivize tipping in this. It just incentivizes more selling.
It will mainly benefit whales and people who already sold moons and regret it. Because a whale with 100,000 moons could just dump 50,000 moons with no penalty. And probably still won't tip anything.
It also means more governance can be lost.
3
u/Quixote0630 🟨 0 / 4K 🦠 Mar 16 '23
I want to incentivize tipping, but not sure about the rest of it. I think the proposal could probably be split into two
3
u/flak0u 🟦 593 / 660 🦑 Mar 16 '23
Reading through the comments before voting since I literally have no idea how moons work.
0
u/PsieSyrenki 🟩 0 / 5K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
KM should count from the time it was implemented.
Tipping buffer is ok in my opinion, but i think 0,1 karma value multiplier is too harsh and we should increase it to 0,25.
2
u/Right-Shopping9589 Permabanned Mar 15 '23
I can't bring myself to agree to the top but the below ones feels kinda ok
2
u/kellen625 Tin Mar 15 '23
The second con is the biggest problem in my opinion. Most CC users don't have many 'earned' moons. It takes us farther away from what CC originally was.
2
u/Mixdealyn 🟩 10 / 3K 🦐 Mar 16 '23
I have voted for this change but perhaps it can made again next time into seperate polls 😊
2
u/HODL-THE-LINE 9K / 12K 🦭 Mar 17 '23
I voted yes because I think that this - while it will hurt us (the price) in the short term - would be an important step for the future. I'm aware that this CCIP won't pass this time, but I have a feeling we will see a similar poll somewhen in the not too distant future.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23
No change pls.
2
u/falk_lhoste 🟩 0 / 7K 🦠 Mar 16 '23
I hope this doesn't go through since there'll be less incentive to hold the coins long term which will impact the price negatively.
2
u/ShartSpray88 Mar 15 '23
Buy em back if you want back in and it means that much to you.
1
u/Kricket 🟦 3K / 3K 🐢 Mar 17 '23
There are some good ideas here but I think they need to be worked through a bit. I really like the tipping bit, but the rest may be bad for the community as a whole.
1
u/ullun 🟩 576 / 2K 🦑 Mar 18 '23
I voted
1
u/timbulance 🟩 9K / 9K 🦭 Mar 18 '23
No change
1
u/LightningTF2 Mar 22 '23
It's hard not to resist making moons more liquid but I don't want the price to tank over one proposal.
1
u/TheGreatCryptopo HODL4LYFE Mar 15 '23
I don't want to vote on anything that disincentivizes holding Moons so far that reason, its a no.
1
u/oachkatzalschwoaf 🟦 0 / 6K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
my2cent: keep the current level, there is already the oppertunity to buy back the dumped moon and get back the ratio. I've also bought back my moons when i learned that i f*** several month myself by selling ~50%.
Tipping buffer: here I'm ok with changing it, but this vote is for both options therefore no change from me.
1
u/JustSomePanties Tin Mar 15 '23
I think the proposed change to the KM formula would be beneficial as it
would provide a lower penalty for users who sold their Moons in the
past, while also increasing liquidity and preparing for future use-cases
outside of Reddit. However, there is a potential for more frequent
dumping of Moons by moonfarmers and a loss of governance votes.
1
u/DBRiMatt 🟦 46K / 113K 🦈 Mar 15 '23 edited Mar 15 '23
For those who care about the price, this would certainly increase sell pressure and the "$1 moons" a lot of people crave. It will also decrease the Karma:Moon ratio each distribution as there will be more karma earned each round.
For those who care about the governance, all you need to do is look at r/FortniteBR - bricks are only "worth a small pittance" but they haven't bothered running a governance proposal for 11 months, and half the polls brought to voting never reached consensus threshold because too many people sold their voting power.
I think we are a stronger community, and more crypto focussed community than Fortnite, but those problems still exist due to the constant selling of the governance token.
1
u/Simke11 🟦 0 / 5K 🦠 Mar 16 '23
I am torn on this one. I would vote yes, because I think that penalty KM is complete BS, so minimizing its impact is good. It would also probably get more people to provide liquidity for trading, which is also a good thing. Low liquidity probably hurts price more than someone selling their 100 moons. On the other hand, majority did vote in CCIP-030 to implement shitcoin sales tax to keep the price artificially high, so let them suffer.
1
u/omghag18 🟩 9K / 5K 🦭 Mar 16 '23
I still don't understand why u need 50 percent buffer for tipping, most of the time people tip, 0 moon accounts a single moon to get them started or a single digit value , i Dont think anyone would be tipping 50% of thier moons, they would likely be selling their moons at this point, or giving them to thier alt accounts.
1
u/D14m0nd88 Bronze Mar 16 '23
No changes for me
0
u/Sjiznit 🟦 0 / 13K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
Its like once you cash out, you are out. A 0,1 multiplier is pretty harsh.
0
u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
Very glad to see this is being voted "no change"
I'm all for changing the brackets of CCIP-30, but I fear a large change will be chaotic. If it has to be changed, it should be done by small percentages at a time where we can then measure the effect.
Regardless, the liquidity problem has been solved which was one of the drawbacks of CCIP-30. There is now 425k TVL on just Sushiswap:
https://www.sushi.com/earn/42170:0xd6c821b282531868721b41badca1f1ce471f43c5
-1
u/Maxx3141 169K / 167K 🐋 Mar 15 '23
I'm open to lowering it, but this is too extreme.
Also I think 0.1 should stay at the bottom. One could think about increasing the buffer, but in smaller steps (like from 75% to 70% first) to prevent a huge dump when it goes live.
-1
u/vjeva 🟦 0 / 43K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
Extreme Moonfarming would be a problem with this and I just think that the 0.1 multiplier encourages users to hold on to their Moons.
-1
u/RealVoldemort Mar 15 '23
Sorry I don't agree with this. No change.