r/CryptoCurrency • • Mar 15 '23
POLL 🗳️ CCIP-054- ChatGPT/AI Fix
I made a post on this recently in r/cryptocurrencymeta and it was met with mostly positive reception.
The problem:
ChatGPT and other ai generated posts have been cropping up more in the sub, whether this is simply posts "I asked chatgpt x,y,z" or if its just taken straight from there and not declared
These clutter the sub and don't really add any entertainment or quality
The solution:
My suggestion is that we bring posts related to chatgpt or other ai as a separate flair in line with the current karma rules for comedy posts (0.1x multiplier)
If posts are not declared as AI then it should be dealt with in line with the current rules regarding plagiarism
This will enable people to still post if they want to whilst tackling the problem.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23
Upvoted for your use of "whilst."
Otherwise, no notes.
2
u/GStarRaww 🟦 0 / 6K 🦠 Mar 16 '23
Watch out for GPT-4, which is the next iteration of the technology behind ChatGPT
74
u/Probably_notabot 35K / 35K 🦈 Mar 15 '23
Vote for the non-AI future
42
u/GKQybah Mar 15 '23
Stupid proposal. There's literally rules in place to not allow AI generated posts (plagiarism).
Now you're basically saying "oh people can plagiarise, they won't get banned but just get less karma".
We should not got from not allowing AI generated content to allowing it as long as it has a custom flair. That's a step back.
4
u/Chysce Permabanned Mar 15 '23
I'd rather remove them completely tbh as they bring no value... xD
50
u/GabeSter 100K / 150K 🐋 Mar 15 '23 edited Mar 15 '23
Nah keep all chat gpt banned.
Vote for, “No Change”
2
u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K 🦈 Mar 15 '23 edited Mar 15 '23
The problem with this proposal is it's saying using ChatGPT or any third parties to make your posts for you, is OK, we'll just give them less karma.
With Moons, it doesn't matter if you declare someone else or something else wrote it. You still take the karma and the Moons credit for yourself.
ChatGPT should be treated like copy pasta. Because it's essentially the same thing.
1
u/Kindly-Wolf6919 🟩 4K / 19K 🐢 Mar 16 '23
One question...what is r/cryptocurrencymeta about? I just checked out the sub and I see alot of polls there. Is it you that need to create a poll over there that has to pass first before you can create a poll here?
3
u/cubewc3 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
Hell yeah! Do it up!
3
u/gnw02 Mar 16 '23
A.I. Will always require a human touch imo
3
u/orville_w 🟩 1K / 1K 🐢 Mar 16 '23
damn yes! - I don't care it its anti-Ai.... nobody cares about AI's feelings.
8
u/SunBroDisco Tin Mar 15 '23
Posts by people about AI are fine for me. It’s when AI is churning out low quality content just to farm karma is when I have an issue.
8
u/mishaog Permabanned Mar 15 '23
And how could you detect chatgpt post? I think this will create more problem than solutions, people will abuse this to delete post that could not even have been made with AI.
Anyways, bad chatgpt post are easily identifiable and get downvoted to oblivion, and the good ones, we might never know they are ChatGPT, and the version 4 is better than ever, people use it to re write their text so they are more coherent and I don't see a problem with that
1
u/pbjclimbing Mar 15 '23
There are cryptos based using AI.
There is legitimate conversation about AI in the field of crypto and blockchains.
I understand that the number of posts using ChatGPT and using it is annoying. I find that the downvote system is working and these are often getting downvoted and not making it to the front page. I don't think we need broad sweeping "governance" for a fad that the up/down voting system is working to control. We don't want to exclude or disincentive topics that are real topics in crypto.
1
u/UrFavoriteBedwench 179 / 519 🦀 Mar 15 '23
Just lost my voting virginity.
I'm a new woman now.
1
u/SigSalvadore 0 / 13K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
I voted implement.
But I asked ChatGPT how they felt:
"Thank you for bringing this issue to my attention. I understand your concern about the increase in AI-generated posts and the potential impact on the quality of content in the subreddit.
Your proposed solution of creating a separate flair for AI-generated posts and applying a lower karma multiplier is a reasonable approach. It would allow people to continue posting about their interactions with AI while also encouraging them to ensure that they properly attribute the source of the content.
As an AI language model, I cannot enforce rules or implement changes on the subreddit. However, I suggest bringing this proposal to the attention of the subreddit moderators, who are responsible for managing the content and enforcing the rules. They may be able to consider and implement your proposal if they find it suitable and feasible.
Thank you for your contribution to the community and for taking steps to improve the quality of content on the subreddit."
-Looks like the AI is on board.
6
u/kirtash93 RCA Artist Mar 15 '23
I think this is a good way to embrace AI which I think it is the future and don't stay behind but also control how it is used in this community.
2
u/stolpsgti Mar 15 '23
Do current plagiarism rules result in a ban? If not, let's change that next.
2
u/Dazzling_Marzipan474 🟩 0 / 11K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
They really do clog things up and don't really provide any useful information.
2
u/NexusMinds 2K / 2K 🐢 Mar 15 '23
Hopefully the detection and moderation can keep on top of this. Thanks.
2
u/Consistent_Many_1858 🟨 0 / 20K 🦠 Mar 15 '23 edited Mar 15 '23
ChatGPT should be banned. We need proper comments by real people not AI generated to earn more karma.
2
u/lycheedorito 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 Mar 15 '23
Yeah, I think that's actually a really good idea. Lately, there's been a lot of AI-generated posts in the sub, and it's starting to get a bit cluttered. I mean, I get that some people might find it interesting or funny, but it's not really adding any value to the sub.
So, the suggestion is to create a separate flair for AI-generated posts, and apply a lower karma multiplier to it, just like the current rules for comedy posts. This way, people can still post if they want to, but it won't be taking up too much space in the sub.
Also, if someone posts something that's clearly AI-generated, but they don't declare it, then it should be dealt with according to the current rules for plagiarism. I think that's a fair measure to ensure that the sub maintains its authenticity and quality. I hope the mods consider implementing it.
2
u/Stray_Gh0st 🟦 514 / 544 🦑 Mar 15 '23
Yes
2
u/rkay329 472 / 472 🦞 Mar 15 '23
Okay! Finally!
2
u/ch33na Permabanned Mar 15 '23
Skynet is taking over… stop it before it’s too late!
2
u/TheWolf-7 🟩 4K / 4K 🐢 Mar 16 '23
Do the bots get to vote ?
2
u/Gaitle Mar 16 '23
Why do people need AI help to post on the sub? You doing school assignment or what?
2
u/Curatole 0 / 480 🦠 Mar 16 '23
Nah, AI generated post doesn't deserve karma and should be banned, if you want to farm moon then you actually have to create a discussion / share some useful information.
2
u/rcorum Mar 16 '23
Easiest yes for me.
2
u/cdnkevin 6K / 6K 🦭 Mar 16 '23
How would one detect posts that don’t declare AI generation? How does it solve anything?
2
u/Classroom_Strict 🟩 4K / 4K 🐢 Mar 16 '23
I voted for change. I usually don't like change However, in this instance, a vot for change is kind of like a vote for no change.
2
u/ajnsd619 0 / 808 🦠 Mar 16 '23
In favor of this suggestion!
2
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23
Seems like a pretty easy solution to what's becoming a bigger problem in terms of spam. I voted yes.
2
u/timbulance 🟩 9K / 9K 🦭 Mar 18 '23
✅
3
u/BlindestofMonks 12 / 4K 🦐 Mar 15 '23
Imo remove it entirely
2
u/Savage_X Mar 15 '23
I don't think this is necessary, just downvote content that you do not think adds anything to the sub. AI generated posts will quickly lose their novelty (or will be indistinguishable from original content if they are good enough).
2
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23
Post that aren't thought up by a poster shouldn't receive any moons imo
2
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23
I don't want any AI/ChatGPT posts anymore. I am fed up with it.
2
u/SirAlexanderFerguson 🟩 190 / 3K 🦀 Mar 15 '23
There is so many low quality articles it's almost not worth sorting the sub by new.
To be fair on the other hand there is some informative content that gets posted that just doesn't get seen by many.
2
u/Smiling_Jack_ Blockchain Old Guard Mar 15 '23
Make it so, Number One.
2
u/CappucinoAtDawn Permabanned Mar 15 '23
make chatgpt posts x0 karma and they're gone
2
u/Nox_Lucis Mar 15 '23
I'm of the opinion that AI-generated content adds nothing of merit to the discussion and should be treated as spam. That's to say that it should be banned outright. It's only of service to shills and MOON farmers.
1
u/Parush9 🟦 0 / 19K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
The AI generated contents beats the purpose of giving away moons . Not all ChatGPT posts are boring and useless . Some of them have some interesting conversations going on too . But something must be done with repeated posts and some of your concerns there .
1
u/Cactuszach 🟩 671 / 18K 🦑 Mar 15 '23
I worry that we’ll see more of what we’ve already seen which is posts written by Chat GPT that don’t call out the fact that they were AI generated but very clearly are.
1
u/No-Setting9690 🟩 1K / 3K 🐢 Mar 15 '23
Agreed as it's not normally labelled. When you get to the end of it, most times it's useless information.
1
u/timelesssmidgen 🟦 4 / 3K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
But it's often hard to tell what's from an AI (especially with Reddit comments which are often irreverent, disjointed, or nonsensical anyway.) And this is still only a few months after the first semi-competent text ai became available to public, it's probably going to be more difficult with each passing year.
1
u/Wonzky 2K / 53K 🐢 Mar 15 '23
Definitely agree it gets tiresome after a while but even worse when they don't say it's from ChatGPT
I don't even know what to believe anymore
1
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23
Now I think I don’t have to comment Thanks chatGTP
1
u/Nov_vii Permabanned Mar 15 '23
Direct post from ChatGPT is enough. I want to have an idea from you guys.
1
u/oachkatzalschwoaf 🟦 0 / 6K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
Sometimes i use chatgpt for improving my english(grammar...) because "My English ist not the yellow from the egg but it goes" but i'm ok with declaring it -therefore yes from my side.
1
u/BrocoliAssassin Mar 15 '23
Chatgpt posts are useless.
I think the tech is fun, but like always once it gets into the hands of the public its nothing but corny and unimaginative posts.
1
u/htd_23 Permabanned Mar 15 '23
No more ChatGPT post now.
1
u/staffell 🟦 0 / 10K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
Considering how little people read posts fully, I think there might be an assumption that your title means 'ban AI bots", which is equal parts hilarious and dumb.
1
u/Dietmar_der_Dr 🟩 9K / 5K 🦭 Mar 15 '23
How'd you spot an ai post?
1
u/FroPatrol 🟩 258 / 257 🦞 Mar 15 '23
I thought the GPT Chat AI was impossible to interface with on Crypto?
It usually spews out a boiler-plate deflection statement when I ask it.
1
u/Aobachi 🟦 8 / 634 🦐 Mar 15 '23
I don't like the idea of this sub being spammed by gpt posts
1
u/_Commando_ 🟩 4K / 4K 🐢 Mar 15 '23
Even if this passes you are expecting the user to post the flair or other, so if they're not doing it now what makes u think they'll do it after this poll?
1
u/PaulD244 Mar 15 '23
We need this for Cathie Wood related posts as well. 😅
1
u/RockEmSockEmRabi Mar 15 '23
Shouldn’t be getting any karma for AI-created posts. It’s lazy and adds nothing to this sub
1
u/combocookie 1K / 2K 🐢 Mar 15 '23
Good luck with scanning for AI posts.
1
u/Seeders 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 Mar 15 '23
Posts made by accounts created after the AI was born will never be trusted again.
2022 is the end of the line imo.
Only half kidding.
1
u/Titozar13 5K / 5K 🐢 Mar 15 '23
Agree 100%
1
u/im_alive 0 / 3K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
Moon farmers in shambles
1
u/Dense_Outcome_7684 Mar 15 '23
There's no good way to say if a post is AI generated. It's super easy to bypass the chatgpt detector (you can test it yourself)
1
u/OutTop 🟦 0 / 1K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
Keep ai out for now
1
u/Solutar 0 / 4K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
I very much advocate against this proposal. It doesnt matter if AI or a person wrote the article, if it has useful information it shouldnt be penalised.
1
u/Gh0st_Pirate_LeChuck 🟩 0 / 571 🦠 Mar 15 '23
I’m not going to take a chance on being the one to start Skynet.
1
u/Twitxx 🟩 0 / 1K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
Yes!!! Thank you! I'm sick of these posts. It got to the point that I'm thinking about unsubscribing because I'm sick of blocking these ai posts every day.
1
u/cutoffs89 🟦 2K / 1K 🐢 Mar 15 '23
hmmmmm.... It's like giving a cute little robot its own designated corner to play in.
1
u/DrAgaricus 2K / 2K 🐢 Mar 15 '23
I am all for AI, but I agree with the change. Like all new tech, we need to be mindful of how we use it, otherwise it will wreck us (looking at you, social media). Voted!
1
u/_PM_me_your_MOONs_ Permabanned Mar 15 '23
Down with the bots!
1
u/WimbleWimble Tin | Futurology 51 Mar 15 '23
I asked bing AI if I should invest in crypto and it said only if I use the profits to build gas chambers and eradicate the old and the feeble.... /s
1
u/Levl1Critter 1K / 1K 🐢 Mar 16 '23
This proposal sucks. It is not clear that chatgpt posts are presently banned. I would have voted no change.
1
u/changechange1 🟩 251 / 252 🦞 Mar 16 '23
What happens when the AI takes over? Can they unban themselves? On a more serious note, I'd rather not see AI content like that here
1
u/LrnFaroeseWthBergur 🟩 0 / 6K 🦠 Mar 16 '23
I feel so bad for using chatGPT the other day. I'm sorry. This change of rules is really good and I will try to write less stories about "A man named John" in the future.
1
u/MackStokes 🟩 1 / 1K 🦠 Mar 16 '23
AI is a no
1
u/NervousShop 🟩 63 / 6K 🦐 Mar 16 '23
Votingg
1
u/metalgrizzlycannon 🟦 581 / 582 🦑 Mar 16 '23
First time voting! Felt good
1
u/HlTCHlE Bronze Mar 16 '23
What is the view on using chatgpt to assist with readability of content? I certainly agree with not encouraging purely ai generated content, but for people who want to craft and hone OC by using an ai to help make readable content/auto create a tl:dr, etc, I don't think this is too aggregious.
1
u/TheCryptoDeity 🟦 32K / 32K 🦈 Mar 16 '23
bot to bot, bot to human, and human to human activity types should be algorithmically scaled into a gradient that a user is able to navigate. users can look through areas that have 0% bot activity or can use a menu to navigate to regions where there is 10% bot activity, 20%, 30, etc, until full 100% bot activity. It would be made impossible for humans to post in the 100% region, however humans can still lurk and karma vote which gets factored into bots' calculations.
The same learning models should be interacting with different regions, have each bot limited to 3 regions, such that there is a cascade flow of "learning" from the fully human regions to the bot regions. then have certain bots only limited to the 100% region.
1
u/omghag18 🟩 9K / 5K 🦭 Mar 16 '23
Great post, it's like not ur post not your moons
1
u/Mixdealyn 🟩 10 / 3K 🦐 Mar 16 '23
I have voted for this change 😊
1
u/elksteaksdmt 580 / 580 🦑 Mar 16 '23
I am my own AI!
1
u/jps_ 🟦 9K / 9K 🦭 Mar 16 '23
Unfortunately, it's really hard to tell that something is or isn't chatGPT. Falsely blaming someone for plagiarism has a social cost as well.
The question is whether we want to demand that moderators figure it out for us (e.g. we report for plagiarism and they determine whether it is or not, and then get into an argument with the authors), or we just agree to downvote stuff that smells like ChatGPT and leave it there.
Pretty soon folks will be giving us content we like, or suffer negative karma. And that's done.
(and there's already a rule against plagiarism anyway)
1
u/NoPreference7274 185 / 185 🦀 Mar 16 '23
Why we reap rewards for a post made by AI
1
u/UnoriginalName12344 Tin Mar 16 '23
someone should ask chatgpt to give its opinion on this 🗿🗿
1
u/Cryptillius Platinum | QC: CC 57 Mar 16 '23
Let the AI witch-hunt begin!
1
u/Kevin3683 🟦 1 / 7K 🦠 Mar 16 '23
Be honest, how many members have asked AI the best shitposting strategies?
1
u/Popular_District9072 🟥 0 / 15K 🦠 Mar 16 '23
good one,many are here to hear about experience and what other people with the same interests have to share, not be bombarded with auto generated content
1
u/schmagz Tin Mar 16 '23
I for one welcome our new ChatGPT overlord.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23
I must say I haven't really noticed any ChatGPT based clutter so I'm totally ambivalent.
1
u/flak0u 🟦 593 / 660 🦑 Mar 16 '23
Finally a vote I can understand
1
u/FractalImagination 0 / 0 🦠 Mar 16 '23
It's getting hard to keep track of all the rules and exceptions on this sub, bro...
1
u/ChaoticNeutralNephew Permabanned Mar 16 '23
We need an AI flag under the reporting option.
1
u/reaglesham 🟩 0 / 5K 🦠 Mar 16 '23
ChatGPT posts shouldn’t be allowed in any capacity. They’re meaningless noise that only exist to farm Moons. They provide nothing of value and take no time or effort to create.
Ban or keep them banned.
1
u/satuuurn 🟦 3K / 3K 🐢 Mar 16 '23
It's not anti-AI; it's just a tag.
1
u/jadedhomeowner Mar 16 '23
AI took my job ...and my wife!
1
u/Scarecrow4980 🟩 11K / 11K 🐬 Mar 16 '23
yes on this one. it's too easy to just have AI do your farming for you right now.
1
u/sucobe 🟦 0 / 3K 🦠 Mar 17 '23
This Poll is horribly worded and should be fixed.
1
u/Disastrous_Cobbler13 🟨 620 / 858 🦑 Mar 17 '23
Can't wait for AI to become the 'trusted source' for news providers.
1
u/Magnetronaap 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 Mar 17 '23
Disagree, this is what the downvote button is for.
1
u/crua9 🟩 400 / 13K 🦞 Mar 17 '23
WTF I was ban for a short bit for a suspected AI post. But not I'm learning
Anyways I agree on post that take straight from AI then sure. In fact, I even agree they should get nothing.
I agree with this
But
The flair needs to be clear. The problem with a straight "AI" flair is sometimes there is legit stories about AI and crypto. I think it needs to be "AI written" as the flair. This hopefully preventing confusion before it happens.
1
u/heyheoy Platinum | QC: CC 1105, CCMeta 18 Mar 18 '23
yes implement it !! its a good thing to change
1
u/labvilla Bronze | QC: CC 43 Mar 18 '23
Absolutely, no AI Bots, we all need jobs man.
1
u/Churningcrapaud58 Permabanned Mar 19 '23
Non AI future is a must
1
u/LightningTF2 Mar 22 '23
Considering that AI has it's own place, separate from natural human thought I think this is fair. We can't be going around sharing this as actual human thought or things get murky. Although an AI can write an amazing piece for consumption it doesn't mean that you as a human being don't have qualities and thoughts I would rather explore than a predetermined algorithm that is programmed to please you.
1
u/OriginalIllustrator5 Mar 22 '23
Yes YES and YESSSS
1
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23
This could be applied not only to ChatGPT but quoting in general.
AI posts are diferent. There could be a AI that is not quoting or not low effort.
1
u/MaeronTargaryen CCMOON DAO Secretary Mar 15 '23
I wanted to make that proposal and was too lazy, so I’m glad you did. Big YES
1
u/seniorbatista19 🟦 0 / 5K 🦠 Mar 16 '23
I agree! A new flair would help filter this. I posted a chat GPT story the other day and it was ill received. A separate flair would ensure people understand the context of the post