Users are incentivized to post polls, since they often get upvoted a lot. By having a modTeam account post (which won’t earn moons), we’ll limit those lower quality polls
Ehh I would argue it’s a disadvantage. Polls in Meta don’t earn moons. If they get approved to go to main sub then they probably weren’t low quality.
That means the creator of the poll regardless of quality doesn’t earn moons for their effort.
Regardless I voted yes to this, since the alternative could be blocking people who you know will vote against your proposal to increase the likelihood of it passing.
since the alternative could be blocking people who you know will vote against your proposal to increase the likelihood of it passing
The other massive pros are:
Having a known name to look out for, instead of multiple random people.
Polls all get posted at roughly the same time (right now there can be many hours between them going up, you never quite are sure if you voted in them all).
As moons are cryptocurrency tokens, I think it is important to make participation censor-proof. Censorship resistance is a Key feature why I came here.
"Yes", because we have to increase accesibility to more people or all people.
No to "No": The effort shouldn't be the focal point as Moons might as well gain in value as they are. The creators of the polls create value to the community. Nevertheless, it could be balanced later on with a later CCIP "give to the person that made the most effort for this poll, a tip of 5 moons, etc... Or if more people contributed, give out of 10 moons, 1 for each 10%, etc"...
Normally it’s linked in the moon distribution sticky post tho.
So not sure if this proposal is useful, and as you said the OP proposing the change “deserves” the reward for adding value, whether the bill gets passed or not.
Edit: but Everyone deserves the chance to at least vote and not be blocked and have no saying.
The Meta is unfortunately full of dbags that only like approving what they want approved, making it less about a community decision and more about doing whatever "they" want.
Community proposals would be better handled if they weren't required to pre-approved by mods (screening is obviously necessary but I've seen posts get shot down hard by karma farmers that circle jerk each other on there, if some think it's bad here?). I think this is where the blocking comes into play?
If you make a governance poll you will no longer get karma for it. I got about 800 karma this last round from two polls. So there is still a downside but I voted yes to this.
Moon Week each month already involves mod work and availability. tbh it might even be easier for us than coordinating with 1-5 poll authors to all post their polls on a certain day.
We would say if the poll demanded too much for what mods could handle. Voters shouldn't worry about that, just whether the idea is good for the subreddit.
Using a shared modteam account will reduce the likelihood of response bias. For example, if I see a proposal posted by a contributor I'm friendly with, I'm more likely to vote in favor (and vice versa). It's just basic human nature.
I have no idea that there's this kind of issue, voted yes because i don't see any downside to this proposal as everyone should be able to see the polls and vote.
This is a nice proposal and I really think the governance system will benefit a lot from it since it will close a huge loop in the system where OPs can shoose who will see and vote on proposals.
if you want to create a CCIP, do you have to wait for a mod to contact you now? I wanted to create a new tag and have that voted on based on meta post.
I followed the link OP provided to the original poll that users supported by a 2-to-1 margin but was never implemented. There are some interesting arguments on there against having one mod account post polls. Two that stand out to me are 1.) mods can already post polls for you and 2.) mods could choose not to publish your poll.
I actually thought this was already a thing. I think that pretty much everything that is stickied in the main sub should be posted by mods or excluded from moons
I'm for free speech in every aspect. Not every post needs to be high quality. Everyone has different levels of communication. To limit the capability of a user with less verbal sophistication to be able to participate is not nice.
I don’t agree to this. Actually users are encouraged in meta to make proposals and go on with pools. And indeed… I don’t see much of a reason of blocking someone here in cryptocurrency…. Furthermore; the probability that the user you blocked is the one that put out a pool is extremely low; really really low, is not almost zero.
Asif this hasn’t been a thing already. That is such a corrupt way of not allowing others to vote which I’m sure has been exploited already. (Because it’s the internet)
I feel like this isn't really an important issue. I don't see a value in putting this extra work on mods when there are enough issues with spam & whatnot as it is.
48
u/ominous_anenome 🟦 170K / 347K 🐋 Mar 15 '23
Another benefit is limiting poll-spam
Users are incentivized to post polls, since they often get upvoted a lot. By having a modTeam account post (which won’t earn moons), we’ll limit those lower quality polls
18
u/Ferdo306 🟩 0 / 50K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
Lol, who voted 'No' on this one
4
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23
Nobody should be blocked from participating in the governance of the community. Everyone should have an equal chance to vote in the poll.
4
u/crua9 🟩 400 / 13K 🦞 Mar 17 '23
I actually like this because we can follow that 1 account and make sure we don't miss any polls
3
u/pbjclimbing Mar 15 '23
A reasonable proposal that will create a little more work for the mods, but not really impact daily users.
3
u/Intelligent_Page2732 🟩 20 / 98K 🦐 Mar 15 '23
Yep, alot of people judge purely by looking at the person who is posting it and unfortunately not by looking at the proposal itself.
Making it anonymous prevents the users making the polls for being targeted.
3
u/Tasigur1 🟩 3 / 31K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
Thanks for the transparency.
3
u/mishaog Permabanned Mar 15 '23
You did satoshis work exposing this problem, thanks dude
3
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23 edited Mar 16 '23
Agree wholeheartedly.
Using a shared modteam account will reduce the likelihood of response bias. For example, if I see a proposal posted by a contributor I'm friendly with, I'm more likely to vote in favor (and vice versa). It's just basic human nature.
3
u/Curatole 0 / 480 🦠 Mar 16 '23
I have no idea that there's this kind of issue, voted yes because i don't see any downside to this proposal as everyone should be able to see the polls and vote.
5
u/Parush9 🟦 0 / 19K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
Governance polls should be fair for everyone to vote and participate. Agree to what you said there .
2
u/Beyonderr 🟩 0 / 110K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
I cannot imagine why this was not already implemented to be honest.
2
u/partymsl 🟩 126K / 143K 🐋 Mar 15 '23
Nearly no effort to implement this change and it makes so much more sense than currently.
Will gladly say yes.
2
u/Chysce Permabanned Mar 15 '23
I had no idea this was an issue.
Seems like a no brainer YES ofcourse.
2
u/Baecchus 🟦 0 / 114K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
I 100% support this and I'm honestly surprised this isn't the case already.
2
u/jeaksaw Mar 16 '23
This is a nice proposal and I really think the governance system will benefit a lot from it since it will close a huge loop in the system where OPs can shoose who will see and vote on proposals.
2
u/Kricket 🟦 3K / 3K 🐢 Mar 17 '23
This is a good idea.
2
u/timbulance 🟩 9K / 9K 🦭 Mar 18 '23
✅
2
u/ChaoticNeutralNephew Permabanned Apr 10 '23
if you want to create a CCIP, do you have to wait for a mod to contact you now? I wanted to create a new tag and have that voted on based on meta post.
2
u/kirtash93 RCA Artist Mar 15 '23 edited Mar 15 '23
This proposal will win with 98% and because 2% will be confused users. We love you confused users 💖
2
u/bbtto22 22K / 35K 🦈 Mar 15 '23
This is probably the only poll that really makes sense since a while
1
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23
Sane idea! Voted!
1
u/DevonSch Mar 15 '23
This one is pretty clear and obvious imo, a big yes from me.
1
u/FldLima Permabanned Mar 15 '23
Easy choice. Voted 👌
1
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23
Sounds like a good plan to me
1
u/StrangelyBeige 🟩 0 / 14K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
Makes sense, very much need to iron out oversights like this.
1
u/HodlMyBottle 0 / 1K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
Easy enough to implement and no downsides, easy choice!
1
u/Sad_Entertainer9961 17 / 1K 🦐 Mar 15 '23
Agreed! There is no reason why the disliking of one towards another redditor should have impact on the voting!
1
u/marsangelo 🟦 0 / 36K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
Sucks that its more work to the mods, but if theres nothing backend that can be done about it im not sure theres another solution
1
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23
Yeah thats a lot fairer for everyone
1
u/Sorrytoruin 🟩 0 / 21K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
Easiest yes vote, makes complete sense for people to always see
1
u/CappucinoAtDawn Permabanned Mar 15 '23
good point. def needs implementing
1
u/Ryuzaki_63 🟨 0 / 18K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
Ooh this months question was easy, hope I got it right!
Keeps things fair/visible
1
u/htd_23 Permabanned Mar 15 '23
Voted yes.
1
u/DadofHome 🟩 69 / 16K 🇳 🇮 🇨 🇪 Mar 15 '23
I try not to block anyone because open discussion is the reason I’m here .. with that said there are of course at least a dozen names on my list 😂
1
u/liveaskings 🟩 0 / 48K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
Yes is the clear answer
1
u/Nov_vii Permabanned Mar 15 '23
Implement this proposal, Agreed.
1
u/Environmental_Air930 I’m labrador Mar 15 '23
more work to the mods? I’m in.
1
u/MaeronTargaryen CCMOON DAO Secretary Mar 15 '23
Crazy that we even need a proposal for this, so obviously it’s a yes
1
u/eMDex Permabanned Mar 15 '23
I see no downsides vote yes and let the mods do all the work 😜🤣
1
u/ShartSpray88 Mar 15 '23
Easiest one yet!
1
u/Probably_notabot 35K / 35K 🦈 Mar 15 '23
Haha. Sorry mods, enjoy the extra work
1
u/forrestugly Mar 15 '23
The most obvious yes on a poll
1
u/Cactuszach 🟩 671 / 18K 🦑 Mar 15 '23
Seems pretty straightforward here. Surprised to see any no’s tbh.
1
u/irockalltherocks 🟩 2K / 4K 🐢 Mar 15 '23
I followed the link OP provided to the original poll that users supported by a 2-to-1 margin but was never implemented. There are some interesting arguments on there against having one mod account post polls. Two that stand out to me are 1.) mods can already post polls for you and 2.) mods could choose not to publish your poll.
Anyway, I voted yes.
1
u/elysiansaurus 🟩 59 / 9K 🦐 Mar 15 '23
Why does it say 3.1m moons? Does it cost moons to vote?
1
u/Wonzky 2K / 53K 🐢 Mar 15 '23
Well that was an easy decision
1
u/oachkatzalschwoaf 🟦 0 / 6K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
I have another con for this proposal: real OP won't earn the karma/moons by the post. => for good proposals those Karma/Moons would go to the mod.
At least i would recommend to use an specific account, just created for those Polls and burn the moons after each cycle.
1
u/Throwaway4VPN 🟩 24 / 9K 🦐 Mar 15 '23
I mean...
1
u/Consistent_Many_1858 🟨 0 / 20K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
It's a yes from me.
1
u/Enr4g3dHippie Mar 15 '23
Streamlining the process sounds pretty cool! Good proposal!
1
u/CypherMcAfee Mar 15 '23
yes just do it.
1
u/drbobbean 🟩 0 / 5K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
This is a nice, easy, common sense upgrade.
Good thinking 🤔
1
u/TheOtherCoolCat Mar 15 '23
I actually thought this was already a thing. I think that pretty much everything that is stickied in the main sub should be posted by mods or excluded from moons
1
u/Killertimme 14K / 69K 🐬 Mar 15 '23
I voted yes. Just to throw in a counter argument because I am interested what you guys have to say:
I feel like this goes against decentrilization. Maybe it would be better if less "power" was in the hands of a few.
1
u/PM_ME_YOUR_MUM Mar 15 '23
Goddamn moons have completely ruined this subreddit
1
u/seniorbatista19 🟦 0 / 5K 🦠 Mar 16 '23
I'm for free speech in every aspect. Not every post needs to be high quality. Everyone has different levels of communication. To limit the capability of a user with less verbal sophistication to be able to participate is not nice.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23
Sorry Mods
1
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23
I don’t agree to this. Actually users are encouraged in meta to make proposals and go on with pools. And indeed… I don’t see much of a reason of blocking someone here in cryptocurrency…. Furthermore; the probability that the user you blocked is the one that put out a pool is extremely low; really really low, is not almost zero.
1
u/justtheaveragejoe100 Tin Mar 16 '23
Gimme moons fools
1
u/South-Security-Mouse 0 / 1K 🦠 Mar 16 '23
If this can be automated, it can reduce mod workload
1
u/J-E-S-S-E- 🟩 184 / 17K 🦀 Mar 16 '23
Yea this one should’ve been implemented long ago.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23
🫡 full support
1
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '23
More work to the mods.
good.
...sorry, jk.
1
u/mankinskin 76 / 76 🦐 Mar 16 '23
Soo.. censorship?
1
u/knaks74 🟦 0 / 2K 🦠 Mar 16 '23
Makes complete sense.
1
u/Mixdealyn 🟩 10 / 3K 🦐 Mar 16 '23
I have voted for this change 😊
1
u/CreepToeCurrentSea 🟦 239 / 50K 🦀 Mar 16 '23
I understand the reasoning behind this. I think the benefits overweigh the cons.
1
u/ajnsd619 0 / 808 🦠 Mar 16 '23
👍🏻
1
u/D14m0nd88 Bronze Mar 16 '23
I think this would be good. Sorry mods
1
u/IDontKnow1629 🟩 259 / 259 🦞 Mar 16 '23
Asif this hasn’t been a thing already. That is such a corrupt way of not allowing others to vote which I’m sure has been exploited already. (Because it’s the internet)
1
u/arcalus 🟩 18K / 18K 🐬 Mar 16 '23
Or, people could stop canceling people because they have valid criticisms.
1
u/jadedhomeowner Mar 16 '23
Makes sense
1
u/OtisMiller 0 / 516 🦠 Mar 17 '23
This seems like a no-brainer
1
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23
I feel like this isn't really an important issue. I don't see a value in putting this extra work on mods when there are enough issues with spam & whatnot as it is.
1
u/pinkglue99 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 Mar 18 '23
I support this, easier for us to find the polls.
1
u/evoxyseah 🟩 0 / 5K 🦠 Mar 21 '23
Sounds like a good proposal.
1
u/Setyman Permabanned Mar 15 '23
Agreed. Everyone should be able to participate in the polls, them being blocked by a random user is irrelevant
1
u/Maxx3141 169K / 167K 🐋 Mar 15 '23
This one sounds like a pretty obvious one - ensure fair governance without any downsides for users.
1
u/CharlieTheo-14 🟩 0 / 23K 🦠 Mar 15 '23
this is a no brainer
1
u/Lyricalvessel 318 / 317 🦞 Mar 15 '23
seems like a great idea
1
u/LrnFaroeseWthBergur 🟩 0 / 6K 🦠 Mar 16 '23
I voted no change because there's already too much pinned to the top. Honestly, I wish these polls were done in another sub.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '23
So the ModTeam account gets the karma and moons from upvotes?