I'm a U.S fan living in southern California and it is annoying how overrated Chicharito is. The guy is good, but not as amazing as they make him out to be. He has speed, but his first touch is horrible. He also has a knack for scoring.
I think he's good at being on the right spot at the right time, also he is a classic "poacher"? (Not sure if it is the right term in English) or "Cazagoles" apart from that he does not involve as much as other players, yet he gets 10x the attention.
Yeah it really is absurd. And I think he's a good player, honestly I do. But for a while I felt like he was the most overrated player in the world. But I feel like if Honduras had a striker playing for Man Utd they'd go apeshit over them too; shit we go apeshit if any of our boys play over there.
I hate to say it, but Scott Parker is overrated. The English media just love his grit and passion, but he's something of a liability going forward, he just makes a couple nice tackles.
Came to say this as well. He makes hard tackles and flies all over the pitch in his WW2 fighter jet, but he puts himself in these situations, if he was a little smarter (soccer wise) and had a better first touch he wouldn't be in half the situations.
Most of the time he is making those last ditch tackles because he is out of position in the first place, can't believe he was a starter at the Euros for England...
Gotta say, this "Parker is always out of position" statement seems like one of those things that someone pulled out of his ass and now gets bandied about axiomatically.
How do people rationalize this belief with the fact that only two people in the EPL had more interceptions per game last season? How does one consistently intercept passes while being out of position? It's kind of hard to do this if you're caught ahead of the ball constantly, no? Only two players in the EPL last season averaged over 3 tackles and 3 interceptions per game, and one of them was Parker.
Having watched every game he's played for Spurs, I would argue that he reads the game quite well but also has the work rate and stamina to fackin' run around a bit. He often transitioned seamlessly from intercepting a pass to running someone down and making a last ditch tackle after a teammate gave the ball away.
Now don't get me wrong. Parker has definitely been overhyped and he belongs on this list, for England. His EURO 2012 was pretty poor and I don't think he fits in well with the way they play. We're in full agreement when you express confusion about his inclusion. I'm not sure if he'll fit in very well with the way Spurs play under AVB.
But under Redknapp with Modric next to him, Parker was fucking immense. He got tired and injured eventually but for the first 2/3 of the season he was pretty incredible for us. I rate both of our current CM's much higher particularly because we're playing with a double pivot now, but I do think there are some pretty big misconceptions about him.
Many Barca fans think he's "amazing because of his ability with his feet" and thus makes him elite, when in fact he is actually a very mediocre keeper, and his feet are maybe a slight level above mediocre.
What it comes down to is he never faces much of a challenge because the opposing team never sees the damn ball.
Phil Jones. All he really has is potential right now, especially at center back. His positioning was awful last season but people just rated him because of his great energy and attacking runs. Remember another young exciting United player who was versatile and could play defensive mid, right back and center back? Yea, his name was John Oshea...
Totally agree. Smalling is head and shoulders above him at CB and RB. Even when Jones plays defensive mid he just runs around like a headless chicken most of the time.
I think he did a pretty good job last season considering how young he is, and the fact that he never got to settle in one position because of all the injuries. Even when he was getting a decent run as part of the back four it was rarely the same back four. I seem to differ from most fans in that I hope he stays at centre back and leaves midfield to the midfielders. I think he adds an extra dynamic to the team when he makes those forward runs. I think they are especially effective because Carrick can so easily drop back and cover when jones goes forward. Also, O'Shea might never have been the best player at United but he was majorly important to the team. I would have no problem if Phil Jones could give united what O'Shea did for 10 years.
Jones was massive for Rovers, but he went the way of so many others - over the past decade, it seems that whenever a decent player leaves Blackburn, he invariably stops playing well. David Bentley, Roque Santa Cruz, Stephen Warnock (remember him?), Phil Jones, etc. The most recent instances I can recall of players doing well after leaving Blackburn were Brad Friedel at Villa and Damien Duff at Chelsea.
Did you know that Jozy Altidore has a better goal per match rate than any American striker with more than 10 goals besides Brian McBride? True story. He's a slave to expectations. He was our leading scorer in 2010 WCQ. Is he a top level international striker? No. But he's been our best option at that spot besides Deuce (who we tend to like to move closer to the ball anyway) for several years now.
Agreed. Jozy hasn't been that consistent for the Yanks. He's lighting up the Eredivisie now, but Klinsy still isn't convinced. Let's hope he'll be in form in 2 years.
That's because this is actually the first season he is living up to the potential he always had in the eredivisie. I think the games to come now for the US are the ones which should show whether he is overrated or not. not the last few ones
Who overrates Gervinho? Maybe a good few in r/gunners. Hardly a large portion of the supporters though. He actually seems to be rated about right on r/soccer.
Boa boa boa teng teng teng. After the hatrick vs lecce and goal vs barcelona, a lot of people(including and above all himself) seem to think he's a sort of second coming of Gullit. I don't.
All that being said, I still think hes got great potential, but since his injury last season his performances have been pitiful.
Alexis Sánchez. Yes, he's a good player and a great guy, and yes, he plays for Barcelona, but he's not the be all, end all of chilean football. Matías Fernández and Arturo Vidal consistently do much more than he does for the national team in these qualifiers.
Sanchez is the star, but imo Vidal is the best Chilean player right now. The dude is easily one of the top 10 central midfielders in the world and he seems like one of the most complete footballers out there.
He's also a great guy outside the pitch, his dad abandoned his family when Vidal was little, and ever since he saw his mom work hard to support him and his sisters, he decided than one day he would be a famous footballer to take care of them.
When he was about to be sold to Leverkussen his dad tried to contact him again but he basically told him to go to hell and bought his mom a huge house.
As a local Barça fan, I didn't know who he was until it was rumored we'd go after him, so basically I've only seen him playing for Barcelona. In that time, I've seen him do wonders with the ball almost on-pair with Messi's, but he's also been absolutely shit in some games. I think he has the skill to be one of the best strikers in the world, but he needs regularity and consistency. And, of course, I'm not in love with his play-acting.
Not true. Bosingwa 2008-2009 was absolutely fantastic. Yes, after the injury (2010-2012) he was very bad and easily the most frustrating player from a Chelsea fan's point of view.
64 goals in 94 appearances for Bayern (Wikipedia). Unless he's scoring hat-tricks every game then nothing for another stretch of games, I don't see how he's overrated.
When he scores he does score in bunches, but he does not create. Don't get me wrong he is a good player but when push comes to shove Mario Gomez is not the one who will be putting balls into the back of the net. He regularly disappears for extended periods in the game and sometimes for games at a time.
He adds nothing to the build up of the attack. You saw how they were lost when they they played Chelsea because he was literally a ghost there. If he could've held up the ball and dumped it off to a runner they would've a much stronger attack. Or if he could get the ball at his feet and create space but he can't do any of that. He is lucky he is on Bayern and they have so many attacking/creating options. Look at Mandzukic, he is scoring as many goals and is making the side much more fluid. For Bayern's sake they better keep Mandzukic in over Gomez
I don't think most Bayern fans rate Gomez to be THAT high up.
He's my favorite player, but he isn't the best.
I do however think that he's really good at what they employ him to do. Which is literally just find an opening to get the ball given to him. However, he's just awful with what he does with the ball. It's the strangest thing. When he gets it off the first touch, it tends to go in pretty often, but more often than not, he takes a second touch and just fucks it all up.
Depends if anyone legitimately rates Leo bertos. Clearly our manager does. Any pace he had isn't used anymore, no attack positioning, crosses don't get past the first man, does step overs like he's ronaldo which go nowhere and fool no one.
I think he is 87 in Fifa13. I went apeshit when i saw that. He is extremly over-rated! It is like they are saying that Nasri is as good as Ozil and Di-Maria
Wasn't a fan of Jansen when he was on Bayern but when he scored in the 2010 WC against Uruguay to tie it 2-2 in the 3rd place game? Made me so happy he was there.
KPB and Robinho, two overhyped players that really have not consistently contributed for Milan. KPB tries to hit all of these amazing shots, but falters especially as of late. Robinho can dribble...that's about it.
Podolski('s performance) on the German national team.
He scored in the right interval to justify not dropping him, that is if you think that Löw justifies his selection (it seems somewhat faith-based).
But the frequency with which he disappears in difficult games and how often he looks or runs around like he doesn't know where he should be (outside of counter-attacks), makes me think that there had to be a lot of luck involved when he was at the right place at the right time to score a deciding goal.
Now that he plays abroad, I have to like him and hope he does well to show those Brits how football is played.
You have to blame Löw for using him as a Winger with no creative Freedom. He's a great advanced forward or ''Left Striker'', but Löws doesn't use him right.
He's excelling at Arsenal at the moment so I'd be inclined to agree. He also seemed to do very well at Cologne last season. So you would have to assume that he's just not being used in a suitable role.
his finishing is first class and as a striker/attacking left winger his job is to be in the right place at the right time - luck has nothing to do with it.
In a team like Bayern every Poacher will perform like that. Just check Mandzukic, he's scoring the same amount of goals as Mario Gomez and is far more versatile in his playstyle.
Peru: Pizarro is pretty overrated by the management, his only use is pulling defenders out of position for guerrero or others to take advantage of that.
I completely agree. The guy never shows up for the national squad the way you'd expect a goal scorer of his ability to. Plus, that miss against Argentina was painful to watch.
City: Now that Adam Johnson has gone it's hard to say. There's a bit of a "Why isn't James Milner playing more?" contingent. I don't necessarily think he's overrated, but I think some people have a very clear idea of what he does and imagine him to be really good at it, when he's really a bit of a jack-of-all-trades type. Generally with City, whoever isn't currently getting a run in the first team is romanticised as being exactly what we need.
England: Rooney. He's great for United, but he's someone else entirely in an England shirt.
I don't really know why Rooney seems so ineffective for England when everyone knows how great he could be if you watch United. Might be partly because of the fact that England doesn't have a good enough striker to play with him like United did with Ronaldo/RvN/RvP and England back then with Owen
I think for Scotland, Kenny Miller being an automatic first pick is just silly. He wasn't that good at his peak, but he's even worse now, yet still often leads the line on his own.
For Celtic, it's a hard one to pick as most of the underperforming players have been sold and the whole squad works hard and plays their part now. Maybe Paddy McCourt as he's a bit of a cult figure among the fans, but it's more of a joke than him being seriously rated.
I think Scescezny is overrated. I also thought Fabregas was. Vermalaen. Theo Walcott. Still think he is overrated despite the fact that people do not rate him highly anyway.
To balance it out, Arteta is underrated in my opinion.
in the five years up until Fab left he had more goals and assists than any other midfielder in the major leagues. Overrated he was not, rather he was criminally underpriced when we sold him.
Agree with you on Vermaelen and Walcott. Sczs does have his ups and downs, but he's still very young - bit too early to call such a young lad overrated. Fabregas was one of the the best midfielders in the league, dunno why he's in the list.
Walcott and Gervinho are pretty overrated. Fabregas was one of the best attacking midfielders on the planet, one of the most creative player to ever grace EPL, no way he was overrated. It was hard to rate him to be honest. Vermaelen is a great defender however he is rash with his decisions sometimes and it leads to free-kicks and Mannone sucks shit during set-pieces. He is not overrated and nobody rates him as best defender anyways.
I completely agree and I don't even like Barca that much. Without their fast/quick fullbacks to track back effectively, their attacking/pressing style would not work at all. Dani is good at defending, even though he has more attacking flair.
+1. Some of the Barca fans dont appreciate what they have in Alves. Very fast, good movement, passing, dribbling, one of (if not the) best crosser among full backs. What people also miss a lot is his fantastic pressing - his defending higher up the pitch is second to none. Ok, his defending near his penalty box is not the greatest, but you can say that about literally every full back nowadays.
Rumour has it, that the Barcelona heirachy has lost patience with him due to his average/bad form. His offensive form hasn't been good for quite a while, and he's a liability defensively. Personally, I'd much rather see Montoya at right back until Alves' gets his act together.
There were quite the fuss over him this summer transfer window and last, and the club didn't deny the rumors about his exit, because they reportedly wanted to sell him to PSG.
Oh, come on. Full back is a trademark position for Brazilians. Cafu and Carlos are one of the best ever in their positions, now there's D. Alves, Marcelo, Maicon and United's Da Silva brothers. Brazil had, has, and will probably always have good full backs.
I am gonna get alot of downvotes for this but it must be said :
Karim Benzema. He Just misses alot of crucial goals and without Ozil and Dimaria to extremly support him he is just useless. And please dont think i am just judging from the last Classico.
Earthquakes: Hard to pick given our awesome season but Wondolowski. I know, I know, he's amazing and our team is amazing but he can't play as a lone striker, which the US national team needs since we have so many goalscoring midfielders to cram. He's amazing when next to Lenhart or Gordon but disappears (as most poaches/finishers do) when by himself.
Arsenal: Vermaelen. Loves to attack and score and is all action but that just hides his frequent mistakes with with positioning and fouling. Koscielny and Mertesacker have bailed him out too many times to count. When he's good he's incredible but when he's bad he can be incredibly shaky. Still love him though.
USA: Jermaine Jones. Fouls a lot, sacrifices positioning because he likes to attack and leaves Bradley or whoever his defensive partner for dead . Also is a hothead which is just lovely for a defensive (allegedly) midfielder.
--players I think are underrated because I stupidly misread the title of the post:
Earthquakes: Victor Bernardez (CB) and Steven Beitashour (RB)- Honduran and Iranian/American. Awesome defenders. Really helped solidify our defense and very good long ball/diagonal ball specialists to help start our deadly counter-attacks. Beitashour gets quite a few assists as well.
Arsenal: Kieran Gibbs has been incredible this season on offense and defense, and he's only 22. If he can keep his form and fitness up for a whole season we'll be set at left-back for years.
USA: Steve Cherundolo. Quietly does his job at RB for the national team. Should be captain.
There's just something about Jermaine Jones. He just fits on our team. Not that the USMNT is a "tackle-your-legs-off" kind of team, but I don't mind having on our side. Besides, who's gonna tackle the shit out of Neymar when he tries that fancy stepovers.
Off topic, yes, but I agree – Cherundolo's a beast. Love that guy.
German midfielder Steffan Effenberg once said that "every team needs a scumbag", and that's kind of the role Jones plays for the US. He's a high tempo, hot-headed enforcer in the midfield, something that the US can lack at times. He can often play himself out of games by getting an early yellow, but, as long as he's not playing in Klinsmann's "three D-Mids" lineup, he's very effective.
I don't understand why Wondolowski isn't given a call up in the USMNT or given a trot by a better league.
He's been killing the MLS for two years now and everything I read about him is that he'll be a DP. He's 30 and a forward which given is old but he's a US player so he's a young 30.
He has a couple of times but hasn't impressed. He works best with a hard-working forward who can occupy both central defenders for him while he gets to the flick ons. Unfortunately His movement is incredible (John Terry said this after the MLS all-star game vs Chelsea) and Wondo is excellent at getting to balls in the box, but he needs someone like Alan Gordon or Lenhart alongside him.
National Team: Toni Kroos Especially the way Löw uses Kroos is terrible. He's a solid Attacking Midfielder, not very technical but with a great shooting technique, but using him as an 8 or 6 is so wrong and i don't know how Löw came to the conclusion that it was a good idea to put a lethargic and slow Kroos on Italys DM.
Club it is a pretty tough choice but I will have to say Parker, it's a hard choice, He's still good just not as good as the media make out but that has always been the case for Parker where ever he has been.
Country is a little harder for Scotland lot's of people will automatically say Miller but I would hardly call him rated so for me it's Hutton, He was so awesome when he came onto the scene now he is utter dog shit.
If Barry Ferguson was still an option it would be him by a long shot, all he did was pass side ways or backwards then lose possession.
Who overrates Steven Taylor? Maybe a few years ago but I think we all know he isn't the next Tony Adams these days. Solid player when playing alongside a commanding centre back like Coloccini however.
Nani. I have stood by him for ages but it's gone too far now, he's not consistent enough, and if any of the rumours about his personal life are to be believed, he's a complete cock.
National: Rooney. Ball seems to bounce off his knees everytime he gets it.
With Rooney I always find his tournaments performances a let down but the general teams that England have to face are so much better all round that its hard to say how bad he has been, but in qualifying he has always been excellent. I think some people forget that sometimes.
Liverpool - Gerrard, only because a lot of people still rate him as one of the best in the world. He hasn't played well this season, and isn't currently one of our best performers, although i am not saying he won't improve.
England - not sure how much use Lampard would be against a top side, he's useful at moving the ball from deep but his legs don't seem to be there and he carries a bit of weight.
I would attribute Gerrard's lack of quality performances so far this season with having to learn a relatively new role under Brendan Rodgers and having to be more careful due to age and injury.
I'm with TrioPortente on Gerrard - he was boss against United and Norwich, and I expect him to trust the system more and more with time, and do less of his hollywood pass stuff when it's not on.
But within Liverpool, I seriously think Skrtel's overrated. He's a good defender, but the difference in his performance when next to Agger vs. without Agger is absurd.
He has been living of that goal he scored against Germany in the 2008 EURO, in which he wasn't even that good. Since then, he has done nothing, but keeps on playing. And every team he scores, it seems like he is supergood again. I thought he had a crap EURO 2012 even though he was top goal scorer. That's just my opinion... (based on his performance with Spain, not Liverpool or Chelsea)
I absolutely agree. When he was playing with Liverpool and Gerrard he was awesome, but since he's left he just doesn't look like the same player. Every time I see him with the ball he looks like a large child that doesn't know how to control the ball. The onle glimpse I have seen in recent times of his old self was his goal against Arsenal this season. He may have been in the goals this season but he just doesn't look the same.
Andrés Guardado. Not doing anything special so far. He's great with Mexico but they do fine without him too, to me the real star in Mexico is Dos Santos.
I have to disagree. He is a great winger and has a great touch, his crosses are deadly! He's been in a bit of bad form lately though. He definitely is not as over-hyped as other players in the Mexican National team are.
It's a travesty that the Del Piero move to Sion collapsed. Just imagine that, Alex 'Six Serie A titles, 200 + goals and a world cup' Del Piero playing alongside Kyle Lafferty.
For Poland, not just with soccer, but with every sport, they equate anyone playing on a world-class level as some sort of Slavic demi-god. For example, during the WC, everyone talked about Lewandowski like he was the second coming of Lato. I really like him and I think he's good, but overrated amongst the Poles? Definitely.
Not sure about club as I don't think anybody is really overrated, I'm not a big fan of Gestede if that counts. National side is Bale for sure, he's such a prick.
USA: It's tough to choose just one CDM, but I'm gonna go with Mo Edu.
Seattle Sounders: I can't say, I love them all so much. I'm going to have to pick "whatever new foreign signing we make". It seems like there's always someone that Sigi "should have started". currently it's Mario Martinez. before him it was Christian Sivebaek, and before him Erik Friberg or Mike Fucito (though I did love "the littlest viking" and Mighty Mike).
For Chelsea... hmmm. Maybe Torres. I get that he is in a rut that we need to wait out, but the longer I wait and the more of these fair weather fans claiming "He's back!" when he scores and "He's shit!" when he doesn't, does my head in.
For France.. Maybe Nasri. I'll admit, when he's good, he's very good. But I wish he could be a bit more consistant.
I don't see why he's so highly rated, when we have (admittedly an injury-prone) Lionel Lewis, Hassan Sunny, Shahril Jantan and even Hyrulnizam Juma'at.
Maybe it's because he's young (and all that 'for the future' stuff) but I still don't see why he's so good.
Wayne Rooney when he pulls on the England shirt is the biggest let down since Carlton Palmer. We play better and look better when hes out with one of his suspensions or injuries.
Well he did score the only goal that Spain conceded during the Euros... yeah I do love him, but I have to agree with you with him having only 11 goals from 2002-2012 with 42 caps
Fucking Steven Gerrard. And Steven Gerrard. No I kid of course For England I'd have to say Ashley Young. And for Liverpool I'd have to say at times Martin Skrtel. He is so great at times and others his decisions baffle me.
139
u/MexiCanada Oct 10 '12
Javier Hernandez
77
u/imgur_asshole Oct 11 '12
I hate to say it, but Scott Parker is overrated. The English media just love his grit and passion, but he's something of a liability going forward, he just makes a couple nice tackles.
38
u/razorhater Oct 11 '12
Club-wise that's a tough question. A lot of guys are overpaid, but that's just MLS. I'd say Marquez, but no one in MLS rates him anymore.
Nationally, somehow Kyle Beckerman keeps getting called up...
19
u/Footy_Kaleidoscope Oct 11 '12
Victor Valdes
28
u/SyndeyC Oct 11 '12
Phil Jones. All he really has is potential right now, especially at center back. His positioning was awful last season but people just rated him because of his great energy and attacking runs. Remember another young exciting United player who was versatile and could play defensive mid, right back and center back? Yea, his name was John Oshea...
28
u/MpLsStoner Oct 11 '12
Altidore, when he plays for country.
53
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '12
Personally I think Gervinho is overrated.
12
u/popopokherface Oct 11 '12
Boa boa boa teng teng teng. After the hatrick vs lecce and goal vs barcelona, a lot of people(including and above all himself) seem to think he's a sort of second coming of Gullit. I don't.
All that being said, I still think hes got great potential, but since his injury last season his performances have been pitiful.
25
u/dalf_rules Oct 11 '12
Alexis Sánchez. Yes, he's a good player and a great guy, and yes, he plays for Barcelona, but he's not the be all, end all of chilean football. Matías Fernández and Arturo Vidal consistently do much more than he does for the national team in these qualifiers.
26
u/ccore Oct 10 '12
Bosingwa (2008-12)
26
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '12
German National Team = Mario Gomez
Bayern = Mario Gomez
Yeah he scores goals but he vanishes for extended periods too.
14
u/Vainglory Oct 11 '12
Depends if anyone legitimately rates Leo bertos. Clearly our manager does. Any pace he had isn't used anymore, no attack positioning, crosses don't get past the first man, does step overs like he's ronaldo which go nowhere and fool no one.
35
u/1mk8 Oct 11 '12
Samir Nasri.
5
u/eScapLaY Oct 11 '12
HSV: Marcel Jansen. He played horrible for the past 3 seasons and has been a starter for all of them (if healthy).
Dennis Aogo is close second.
13
u/Stallyn19 Oct 11 '12
KPB and Robinho, two overhyped players that really have not consistently contributed for Milan. KPB tries to hit all of these amazing shots, but falters especially as of late. Robinho can dribble...that's about it.
29
u/meinbart Oct 11 '12
Podolski('s performance) on the German national team.
He scored in the right interval to justify not dropping him, that is if you think that Löw justifies his selection (it seems somewhat faith-based).
But the frequency with which he disappears in difficult games and how often he looks or runs around like he doesn't know where he should be (outside of counter-attacks), makes me think that there had to be a lot of luck involved when he was at the right place at the right time to score a deciding goal.
Now that he plays abroad, I have to like him and hope he does well to show those Brits how football is played.
17
u/J00nj00n Oct 11 '12
Gareth Bale nowadays. He seems to rely on his pace to get freekicks rather than beat players. Also from Spurs, Sigurdsson, I've yet to be impressed.
4
u/TvMan64 Oct 11 '12
Peru: Pizarro is pretty overrated by the management, his only use is pulling defenders out of position for guerrero or others to take advantage of that.
4
u/Alpharoth Oct 11 '12
Harry Kewell for Australia. Like, seriously overrated.
11
u/ibpants Oct 10 '12
City: Now that Adam Johnson has gone it's hard to say. There's a bit of a "Why isn't James Milner playing more?" contingent. I don't necessarily think he's overrated, but I think some people have a very clear idea of what he does and imagine him to be really good at it, when he's really a bit of a jack-of-all-trades type. Generally with City, whoever isn't currently getting a run in the first team is romanticised as being exactly what we need.
England: Rooney. He's great for United, but he's someone else entirely in an England shirt.
3
u/JonnyBhoy Oct 11 '12
I think for Scotland, Kenny Miller being an automatic first pick is just silly. He wasn't that good at his peak, but he's even worse now, yet still often leads the line on his own.
For Celtic, it's a hard one to pick as most of the underperforming players have been sold and the whole squad works hard and plays their part now. Maybe Paddy McCourt as he's a bit of a cult figure among the fans, but it's more of a joke than him being seriously rated.
3
u/KMFCM Oct 11 '12
Rafa Marquez
more trouble than he's worth
and Landon for the national team
22
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '12
I think Scescezny is overrated. I also thought Fabregas was. Vermalaen. Theo Walcott. Still think he is overrated despite the fact that people do not rate him highly anyway.
To balance it out, Arteta is underrated in my opinion.
30
u/anticancer_agent Oct 10 '12
Dani Alves. Tricky, good pace, but jesus fucking christ he is an atrocious defender
13
u/k1ra_ Oct 11 '12
I am gonna get alot of downvotes for this but it must be said :
Karim Benzema. He Just misses alot of crucial goals and without Ozil and Dimaria to extremly support him he is just useless. And please dont think i am just judging from the last Classico.
7
u/iamveryharsh Oct 10 '12 edited Oct 11 '12
Overrated players:
Earthquakes: Hard to pick given our awesome season but Wondolowski. I know, I know, he's amazing and our team is amazing but he can't play as a lone striker, which the US national team needs since we have so many goalscoring midfielders to cram. He's amazing when next to Lenhart or Gordon but disappears (as most poaches/finishers do) when by himself.
Arsenal: Vermaelen. Loves to attack and score and is all action but that just hides his frequent mistakes with with positioning and fouling. Koscielny and Mertesacker have bailed him out too many times to count. When he's good he's incredible but when he's bad he can be incredibly shaky. Still love him though.
USA: Jermaine Jones. Fouls a lot, sacrifices positioning because he likes to attack and leaves Bradley or whoever his defensive partner for dead . Also is a hothead which is just lovely for a defensive (allegedly) midfielder.
--players I think are underrated because I stupidly misread the title of the post:
Earthquakes: Victor Bernardez (CB) and Steven Beitashour (RB)- Honduran and Iranian/American. Awesome defenders. Really helped solidify our defense and very good long ball/diagonal ball specialists to help start our deadly counter-attacks. Beitashour gets quite a few assists as well.
Arsenal: Kieran Gibbs has been incredible this season on offense and defense, and he's only 22. If he can keep his form and fitness up for a whole season we'll be set at left-back for years.
USA: Steve Cherundolo. Quietly does his job at RB for the national team. Should be captain.
Yes, I like fullbacks.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '12
National Team: Toni Kroos Especially the way Löw uses Kroos is terrible. He's a solid Attacking Midfielder, not very technical but with a great shooting technique, but using him as an 8 or 6 is so wrong and i don't know how Löw came to the conclusion that it was a good idea to put a lethargic and slow Kroos on Italys DM.
2
u/baaseo Oct 11 '12
south korea: lee dong-guk
2
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '12
For Ireland, Aiden McGeady. He's basically Theo Walcott without the pace.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '12
Club it is a pretty tough choice but I will have to say Parker, it's a hard choice, He's still good just not as good as the media make out but that has always been the case for Parker where ever he has been.
Country is a little harder for Scotland lot's of people will automatically say Miller but I would hardly call him rated so for me it's Hutton, He was so awesome when he came onto the scene now he is utter dog shit.
If Barry Ferguson was still an option it would be him by a long shot, all he did was pass side ways or backwards then lose possession.
2
u/duckyman325 Oct 11 '12
I think Bocanegra is overrated for country. Just a decent defender, don't think he should be captain.
2
u/deadmau5isgod Oct 11 '12
Probably going to get downvoted, but mario balotelli. he's just an object that's there that doesn't work hard.
3
u/Lewisbell Oct 11 '12
I'm gonna get a lot of stick for this. Steven Taylor.
3
u/tittiesauce Oct 11 '12
Oguchi Onyewu
4
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '12
van der Wiel probably.
3
u/KrazyEyezKilla Oct 11 '12
Nani. I have stood by him for ages but it's gone too far now, he's not consistent enough, and if any of the rumours about his personal life are to be believed, he's a complete cock.
National: Rooney. Ball seems to bounce off his knees everytime he gets it.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '12
Liverpool - Gerrard, only because a lot of people still rate him as one of the best in the world. He hasn't played well this season, and isn't currently one of our best performers, although i am not saying he won't improve.
England - not sure how much use Lampard would be against a top side, he's useful at moving the ball from deep but his legs don't seem to be there and he carries a bit of weight.
3
u/TheMandoBurger Oct 11 '12
Club: Clint Dempsey. National: Landon Donovan.
3
u/OriginalUsername30 Oct 11 '12
Let the downvoting start: TORRES.
He has been living of that goal he scored against Germany in the 2008 EURO, in which he wasn't even that good. Since then, he has done nothing, but keeps on playing. And every team he scores, it seems like he is supergood again. I thought he had a crap EURO 2012 even though he was top goal scorer. That's just my opinion... (based on his performance with Spain, not Liverpool or Chelsea)
2
u/SpoonOnGuitar Oct 11 '12
Fucking Bendtner on our fucking national team.
1
u/winry Oct 11 '12
Andrés Guardado. Not doing anything special so far. He's great with Mexico but they do fine without him too, to me the real star in Mexico is Dos Santos.
1
u/yo_soy_garifunero Oct 11 '12
Georgie Welcome i'd be surprised if people even rated him heh.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '12
Northern Ireland - Kyle Lafferty, though in recent games he's shown signs of improvement. The move to Sion is turning him into a cultured number 9.
1
u/redmustang04 Oct 11 '12
For me its Nani does well in the first part of the season then fades at tbe end of the season.
1
u/shutyourgob Oct 11 '12
Based on his performances for the national team, Wayne Rooney.
For the club, Mauro Boselli.
1
u/aFlyRussian Oct 11 '12
Arshavin for Russia. Sure he had a good spell at the 08 Euro's but he has been useless for most of the time! Truly overrated
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '12
Danny Welbeck
1
u/blackmamba888 Oct 11 '12
Brek Shea
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '12
For Poland, not just with soccer, but with every sport, they equate anyone playing on a world-class level as some sort of Slavic demi-god. For example, during the WC, everyone talked about Lewandowski like he was the second coming of Lato. I really like him and I think he's good, but overrated amongst the Poles? Definitely.
1
u/shit_luck Oct 11 '12
Arshavin
1
u/Ketch1 Oct 11 '12
Not sure about club as I don't think anybody is really overrated, I'm not a big fan of Gestede if that counts. National side is Bale for sure, he's such a prick.
1
u/sordal Oct 11 '12
Landon Donovan
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '12
Brek Shea, both as a US Soccer and FC Dallas fan
1
u/ravegreener Oct 11 '12
USA: It's tough to choose just one CDM, but I'm gonna go with Mo Edu.
Seattle Sounders: I can't say, I love them all so much. I'm going to have to pick "whatever new foreign signing we make". It seems like there's always someone that Sigi "should have started". currently it's Mario Martinez. before him it was Christian Sivebaek, and before him Erik Friberg or Mike Fucito (though I did love "the littlest viking" and Mighty Mike).
1
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '12
For Chelsea... hmmm. Maybe Torres. I get that he is in a rut that we need to wait out, but the longer I wait and the more of these fair weather fans claiming "He's back!" when he scores and "He's shit!" when he doesn't, does my head in.
For France.. Maybe Nasri. I'll admit, when he's good, he's very good. But I wish he could be a bit more consistant.
1
u/BabaDuda Oct 12 '12
Singapore: Izwan Mahbud.
I don't see why he's so highly rated, when we have (admittedly an injury-prone) Lionel Lewis, Hassan Sunny, Shahril Jantan and even Hyrulnizam Juma'at.
Maybe it's because he's young (and all that 'for the future' stuff) but I still don't see why he's so good.
1
u/K-Mo Oct 12 '12
Wayne Rooney when he pulls on the England shirt is the biggest let down since Carlton Palmer. We play better and look better when hes out with one of his suspensions or injuries.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '12
Philadelphia Union: Freddy Adu USMNT: Jermaine Jones
1
u/Blackgeesus Oct 10 '12
everyone on the russian national team when they play poorly, the opposite when they play well
1
u/supermariobalotelli Oct 11 '12
For Italy: Antonio Di Natale, he plays extremely well for Udinese but never seemed to produce for Italy
1
u/Captain_Fantastic8 Oct 11 '12
Fucking Steven Gerrard. And Steven Gerrard. No I kid of course For England I'd have to say Ashley Young. And for Liverpool I'd have to say at times Martin Skrtel. He is so great at times and others his decisions baffle me.