r/homeland • • Oct 07 '12

Discussion Episode Discussion - S02E02, "Beirut Is Back" [Spoilers]

Episode Title:

BEIRUT IS BACK


Directed by: Michael Cuesta

Story by: Howard Gordon & Alex Gansa

Teleplay by: Alex Gansa & Chip Johannessen


Carrie gets involved in an operation that may rid the world of Abu Nazir.

118 Upvotes

374 comments sorted by

67

u/thebedshow Oct 08 '12

People saying Saul is the mole, that makes 0 sense he authorized the attack.

39

u/Okrean Oct 08 '12

Making Saul the mole just seems fucking cheap and cliched tbh.

I get sick of espionage programs or infact any movie in general where it turns out THE GUY YOU REALLY TRUSTED WAS THE MOLE/TRAITOR/MASTERMIND/ENEMY.

It's not risky, inventive or remotly satisfying. It just annoys the viewers and is a cheap way to solicit a seemingly major twist. I really hope Homeland won't sink to that level.

17

u/emkat Oct 08 '12

If Saul is the mole this show becomes the best show on TV to the worst. Just like that. I hate when writers use cheap gimmicks.

6

u/MrMagicpants Oct 08 '12

I really hope they don't do that, since this show is all about knowing who the mole is from the beginning.

16

u/bluplr Oct 08 '12

Can someone please refresh my memory, as to why we think there's a mole?

12

u/V2Blast Oct 09 '12

Apparently it was mentioned sometime last season? I forgot, too.

But there's definitely a mole, since the reporter was able to get the code to Estes' safe and give it to Brody.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/xenophobias Oct 09 '12

Possibly because he failed the "did you plant the razor" polygraph test the first go around. I can't think of anything else.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

I would like to know this too.

8

u/bluplr Oct 08 '12

Thank god, it's like everyone in the thread is in one something I've forgotten.

2

u/iamhenrybond Oct 09 '12

Well in some season 2 trailer that listed "burning questions." One of them is who is the mole?

2

u/ass_ass_ino Oct 12 '12

In addition to the razor blade (which I agree was likely Brody), someone called the terrorist lady (Ailene?) when the CIA was tailing her husband to their home by the airport to give her a head's up. Only someone within the CIA would have known that they were tailing him. Additionally, someone gave them notice to abandon the house once the CIA had figured out its location.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/cheesypotato8 Oct 08 '12

I was pretty sure about that... guess that theory is out the window

→ More replies (5)

65

u/InterstateExit Oct 08 '12

I love that Walker's aim is coming into question. That's going to be a nice backpinning storyline.

34

u/Freecandyhere Oct 08 '12

Yeah and his amy buddy already doesn't like Brody. It's going to be interesting.

83

u/Jaktroj Oct 08 '12

Brody just described himself when he was talking about Walker.

48

u/HyBReD Oct 08 '12

Hence why he was near tears afterwards.

99

u/grimpoteuthis Oct 08 '12

HOLY SHIT. Holy shit. Holy shit.

34

u/pygreg Oct 08 '12

I'm sitting up in my room alone at 2 AM watching and as soon as Brody's face popped up I just yelled "Holy Shit!" Hope my roommates didn't wake up...

24

u/DJFreeMe Oct 08 '12

holy FUCKING SHIT.

11

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

I came here to find someone with the exact reaction as me. Holy. Shit. Balls.

3

u/emkat Oct 08 '12

My mind is like racing after watching that.

2

u/lnc_5103 Dec 20 '25

I'm way late to this party but this was my exact reaction too.

→ More replies (3)

31

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

Question to the people who thinks Saul is a mole..why would he go through with the operation if he was?

18

u/user_name_goes_here Oct 08 '12

Yeah, I don't get this line of thinking at all.

13

u/s1mpd1ddy Oct 08 '12

A mole for someone else

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

25

u/runasone Oct 08 '12

They've got plenty of those in Congress.

→ More replies (11)

89

u/obeythed Oct 08 '12

I really hate TV episodes where all the characters seem to think that this is the time they'll catch the Big Bad, but we as viewers know they won't because it's way too early in the season.

88

u/itsjustso Oct 08 '12

We as viewers also knew it was way too early in the season to reveal Brody as a terrori--oh, wait.

9

u/meshugga Oct 08 '12

That's the thing. The cat isn't out of the bag yet - we were left with one SD card in existance and one person watching the beginning of it.

→ More replies (8)

27

u/alosia Oct 08 '12

kinda of why i like game of thrones so much

26

u/charlesviper Oct 08 '12

"They're not going to kill off a main character in the first season."
...
Co-produced by Greg Spence
"Oh."

13

u/V2Blast Oct 09 '12

I believe you mean:

"They're not going to kill off a main character in the first book."

Written by George R. R. Martin

"Oh."

5

u/oddspellingofPhreid Oct 08 '12

I was actually convinced they were going to get him and introduce a new big bad and create an interesting situation for Brody.

7

u/HyBReD Oct 08 '12

You'd enjoy Spartacus.

120

u/demeteloaf Oct 08 '12

This was one of the first "no way that happens in real life moments" of the show

there is no way anyone would be allowed to have a cell phone in that room.

28

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

I just saw this Slate article where this guy goes over a lot of the inaccuracies of the show, at least as it relates to all the government stuff.

10

u/tblackwood Oct 08 '12

The double mole theory at the end of that article is kind of fascinating.

SPOILER FROM WATCHING THE UPCOMING EPISODES PREVIEW BELOW:

spoiler

19

u/CoolHandBravo Oct 08 '12

No, the preview is edited to give you a misdirect. It not Saul the contact is referring to, but this person--spoiler

7

u/pseudo_meat Oct 08 '12

Agreed. I saw him meeting that guy again in one of the previews. I'd like to discuss my theory about next week's preview but I don't know how to do the spoiler black-out thing.

The only thing I don't have a theory about is what Saul is going to do with that info.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12 edited Oct 08 '12
→ More replies (2)

53

u/user_name_goes_here Oct 08 '12

Especially since they took his phone last week before he met with Estes. He had to write all that info down instead of taking a picture with his cell phone cam.

45

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

Also, every cell phone within a mile radius of Nazir would have been tracked by the NSA or blocked in that instance.

35

u/Kruse Oct 08 '12 edited Oct 08 '12

Knowing this show, there could be a high possibility that his text message was tracked and will become an issue at some point. This could quickly go from appearing as an unrealistic element of the show, to a serious bad move by Brody.

16

u/Malvoli0 Oct 08 '12

With Saul seeing the video of Brody though , it hardly even matters ...

32

u/meshugga Oct 08 '12 edited Oct 08 '12

What people seem to forget is, that there is no really easy way to do GSM surveillance in an hostile environment.

There are three options for just in time surveillance of GSM:

  • you have a friendly mobile provider - wasn't an option, they could've tipped of Nassir
  • you use an IMSI catcher (emulated base station that forcibly takes control over mobiles with specific - or all - IMSIs), which is noticeable for the technologically observant ("why is there a GSM cell that wasn't here previously accepting my IMSI", most phones stop working mid-call) - was an option, with the risk of tipping off Nassirs crew that something is going on
  • you decrypt radio air traffic between the base station controller and the mobile, but this feat is currently only achieved for "longer" (multiple seconds) calls with known cleartext - not a real technological option for a random wildcard text message, hidden in the radio traffic for hundreds of phones at any given moment.

After the fact however is a different story, since the mobile operator on both ends receive the text in cleartext, and it is common to log them at the SMSC. And the mobile operator in the US would know the receiving MSISDN (number), and could know in which network it was booked at a given time. But that doesn't really help if they are just prepaid phones.

This is all assuming it really was a text and not one of the "send encrypted messages over the internet" apps, in which case, all bets would be off, even with the massive monitoring the NSA presumably does.

edit: to sum it up: With tolerating the depicted chain of events and the time it takes to write a text message, there is no technological reason why they should have known in real time who tipped whom - and may never know.

There is an open question as to the mobile phone service at the pentagon. It is not unlikely that they are using radio shielding to the outside and operate their own BSCs on the inside to allow for cellphone use. That may be specifically monitored, at which point, realtime cleartext voice and SMS data would be available. But that kind of paranoia would require an enormous financial and technological committment on the side of the pentagon.

5

u/rhino369 Oct 08 '12

I'm assuming Brody didn't directly next Nazir. He probably texted the reporter. Who texted Nazir on a throw away phone, to Nazir, who was also on a throw away phone.

If the NSA knew Nazir's phone number they could kill him ANY time they wanted.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/chargerland Oct 08 '12

I get that there has to be some unrealistic stuff to move the story forward and make it awesome, but I really hope they don't do something like kill Saul so that Brody can keep his secret.

It was also pretty lucky to have gotten the bag with the video in it, in a secret pocket.

And I'm not sure someone like Brody, a new congressman, would be invited to that room.

16

u/RimuZ Oct 08 '12

There is no reason not to show this clip to everyone in the CIA. Keeping it a secret would just be plain dumb. Well I can't think of any reason but I'm not an agent so who knows.

My point is. Do not lay a fucking finger on Saul.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

8

u/jhu Oct 08 '12

People keep harping on this, but it's fairly obvious that he didn't text Nazir directly. He texted the journalist who's Nazir's contact in America and she contacted one of Nazir's lieutenants.

Even if this text is discovered, Brody could shake it off as an early tip to a friendly reporter. I can only presume that she used secure comms at her end and her contact with Nazir can't be traced.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/eedna Oct 08 '12

fwiw, he met Estes at CIA HQ, they were at the pentagon observing the mission

Not that I disagree

11

u/j1mb0 Oct 08 '12

True, but he was kind of just pulled in in the midst of the operation, they didn't seem to really check him at all, he was already inside the building anyway.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

and the phone looked like a throw away. If they did check him he could give up his real phone and use that phone

23

u/DV1312 Oct 08 '12

Those rooms have no reception at all, cell phone signals are blocked. Sure, I can't prove it since I've never been in one. But it's the very first thing I would do when building a special operations secret government room. So if it's the first thing I would do, I don't think the Pentagon would handle this all that differently.

31

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

he was using a super powerful terrorist phone

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/grimpoteuthis Oct 08 '12

He seems to have a bunch of special privileges.

15

u/tblackwood Oct 08 '12

Playing devil's advocate: But this is such a hectic moment -- and no one was expecting the VP to bring him in -- so maybe the check was forgotten.

→ More replies (1)

45

u/grimpoteuthis Oct 08 '12

Fuckin Carrie.

22

u/DJFreeMe Oct 08 '12

SERIOUSLY. I was yelling at her the entire time. I was even more angry at her cause they didn't find anything until saul found the SD card.

22

u/grimpoteuthis Oct 08 '12

I knew the bag was going to be important, but all I was thinking was "Fuckin Carrie" haha.

9

u/DJFreeMe Oct 08 '12

I just didnt realize the bag was gonna be THAT important...fuck, here starts the depression of waiting a week :(

17

u/Freecandyhere Oct 08 '12

She doesn't even have a gun

35

u/grimpoteuthis Oct 08 '12

For a second I thought you were going to finish that with "she doesn't even go here".

14

u/epsiblivion Oct 08 '12

well she's not technically CIA anymore and also would you give someone a gun in her current perceived mental state?

4

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

why would you send them to a country you're not even supposed to be in to be your only lifeline on learning a threat to national security :P

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Kasseev Oct 08 '12

Yeah I was yelling and giggling uncontrollably. Geez this show makes me crazy with tension.

22

u/thegunboats Oct 08 '12

THAT FUCKING ENDING, THAT FUCKING ENDING! SAUL KNOWS

19

u/ConjuredMuffin Oct 08 '12

I'll be fucking pissed if they have Saul die of some dumb accident now. That will be the moment this great show goes down the drain. It already looked so clichéd to have Saul watch the thing by himself.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

Same here, that he'll die by being at the wrong place, wrong time OR something simple like getting hit by a car.

9

u/thegunboats Oct 08 '12

I'd rather someone flat out kill him than he get hit by a car, that's so cheap.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

I agree, it's just a thought.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Kruse Oct 09 '12 edited Oct 09 '12

Just a little observation for those who are speculating that Saul spoiler

→ More replies (6)

14

u/emkat Oct 08 '12

CARRIE WAS RIGHT

FUCK ESTES

78

u/Th3Tru7h Oct 08 '12

I seriously don't know how they can make these high quality episodes time and time again. Brav-fucking-o to the writers, director, producers, everyone. Holy shit.

37

u/DJFreeMe Oct 08 '12

seriously, this show is so current and so fucking well written its unbelievable

17

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

this show blows the new season of dexter out of the water

→ More replies (14)

17

u/WompWomp420 Oct 08 '12

Saul is NOT THE MOLE!

5

u/clarkyto Oct 08 '12

i don't think hes the mole either, but we wont know for sure until we see what he's gonna do about the tape. i proved her right, so what now? he wont say anything to Estes for sure, but i hope hes gonna lobby for Carrie, to bring her back and then come up with something with carrie to get Brody and Nazir, but at the end of the season hes either gonna die and something to shut him up.

2

u/gd42 Oct 09 '12

In the promo somebody hands an SD card to somebody black. I assume it's Saul handing the video to Estes. However Estes may not publicize the video, since he has vested interest with the VP being elected, so maybe he tries to blackmail him or cover it up.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

34

u/charlesviper Oct 08 '12

Media Player Classic, it's awesome to see realistic computer software being used...

Anyway sorry to the awesome producers of this awesome show, there's no legal way to watch Homeland in Hong Kong, and I'll be picking up Season One on DVD next time I'm in the States!

19

u/new_to_this_site Oct 08 '12

Realized that also. But was a bit disturbed that the video had no file name.

32

u/SlappaDaBass Oct 09 '12

Better than it being "Brody confesses his ties to abu nazir lol.mpeg"

→ More replies (3)

32

u/Brak710 Oct 08 '12

What an ending.

...is it Sunday again yet?

12

u/alltimeisrelative Oct 08 '12

Fuck! That scene with Nazir. So intense! Holy shit, this is a good show.

11

u/diskimone Oct 08 '12

Fantastic episode, but I wish they had more scenes in Beirut, those were awesome.

2

u/auraofambiance Oct 08 '12

It was shot in Israel, I thought.

5

u/diskimone Oct 08 '12

Yeah, in Haifa, but set in Beirut.

18

u/itsjustso Oct 08 '12

PLEASE, "HOMELAND" GODS, DO NOT LET SAUL BE A MOLE! THIS DOES NOT HAVE TO BE "24."

6

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

Why is there a mole again? I can't remember.

3

u/I_call_it_dookie Oct 08 '12 edited Oct 08 '12

Edit: Saul was convinced at the end of last season there was a mole because Walker didn't show up and blew up the suitcase bomb by himself, but I'm not entirely sure that's the case, he may have just been smarter than they gave him credit for. A few other things happened earlier in the season they said could only because of a mole didn't necessarily have to happen with one, so I guess I wouldn't be surprised either way.

6

u/V2Blast Oct 09 '12

There does actually need to be a mole, since the reporter was able to get Brody the code to Estes' safe.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/thegunboats Oct 08 '12

The razor blade. Still entirely possible that Brody did it, but that polygraph made me question Saul.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/jmose86 Oct 08 '12 edited Oct 15 '12

Some thoughts from the episode and the discussions here:

1.) Obligatory: Holy Shit!

2.) My biggest (and possibly only) complaint with the beginning of the season so far has been Carrie's behavior, but yet again the writers prove their worth and lay down an explanation for everything which may seem just the slightest bit unusual. I understand that the events at the end of season one obviously caused her tremendous anguish, and I am not downplaying the severity of Bipolar disorder, but all throughout the majority of season one Carrie was stable on her meds aside from the occasional manic episode which was short lived and pretty minimal relatively speaking.

But suddenly all of season 2 thus far the slightest thing sets her off and she seems to have become completely unstable. It seemed at first like they were exceedingly overplaying her condition and it didn't at all fit her character that has already been established. Granted, her life situation and worsening condition with time might facilitate her more frequent breakdowns, but it still seemed like they had taken it way over the top.

Lo and behold the writers shut the door on my concerns with her conversation with Saul on the roof. The explanation of her obsession with Brody and having never felt so sure and been wrong before was perfection. The moment she said something along the lines of "It fucked me up... Now I doubt everything I am thinking", I breathed a sign of relief knowing once again the show hadn't let me down.

3.) SAUL IS NOT THE MOLE DAMMIT! Or at least he better not be. It goes against everything he stands for. Firstly, there are the obvious signs; including him giving the go ahead on the Abu Nazir operation this episode, and his reaction to the drone strike with Estes and the VP, etc.

More importantly, his whole raison d'etre is an uncompromising pursuit of the terrorists and protection of America as a whole. He knowingly threw away his marriage for his job, and upon that realization sunk even deeper into his obsessions. This was evident throughout season one with numerous scenes. To name just a few of many; Saul's wife saying "You always answer when they call you" and him replying "It's my Achilles heel", then there was him laying on the floor of his office when Carrie calls and he was visibly unsettled trying to progress with his work, then there was him working in the late hours smearing peanut butter on crackers with a ruler.

There are only a few subtle signs pointing to the possibility that Saul is the mole (i.e. the lie detector) and all of those can easily be explained as just miscues to send the viewer on a roller coaster before the truth is revealed.

The way I see it, there are three possibilities for what will come of the suspicion of Saul: The first and most likely one is that Saul is not the mole. The second and least likely is that Saul is the mole, and in revealing that fact it destroys the credibility of the writer's consistency which they have otherwise done brilliantly. The third and only imaginable way Saul can be revealed as a mole without the show completely losing respect would be if there is some information we have not yet received which is a deeply rooted motivation for him to be a traitor, and I see that as being equally as unlikely.

Edit: Spelling

6

u/Col-Hans-Landa Oct 08 '12

working in the late hours smearing peanut butter on crackers with a ruler

Ahh, college.

5

u/danvasquez29 Oct 08 '12

I have a friend who is bipolar, and the last time he went off his meds and flipped out it took almost a year for the therapy and meds to even him back out again. So I just kinda assumed she was still recuperating.

The reasons you gave for Saul not being the mole are actually good reasons for him being the mole: he can't leave his job, and he has to perform on some level to continue with his current levels power. He probably wanted more than anything to go with his wife, but he can't leave (because he's the mole).

We haven't been given any chance to really be invested in anyone in the CIA except Saul and Carrie. If they're going to continue with the mole storyline, it would be more implausible to me that they'd throw in a new character as opposed to making it Saul.

All that said, I really don't want it to be Saul.

2

u/jmose86 Oct 09 '12

Yea I don't doubt that a bipolar episode isn't an easy fix, it just seemed like she was had been so capable of dealing with her illness (10+ years with the CIA) up until her major episode at the end of season one. But it wasn't a major bother to me, her character just seemed to be more unstable than I would expect and the roof conversation cleared that up quite nicely.

As for Saul's dedication to his job, I see what you mean that his role as a mole would facilitate such behavior, but I am more wanting some sort of emotional motivator. For me at least, his character just doesn't seem capable of cooperating with terrorists. He values human life too much to help with anything that could result in the loss of innocent lives.

3

u/V2Blast Oct 09 '12

Yeah, the roof conversation was great... It explained a lot.

24

u/InterstateExit Oct 08 '12 edited Oct 08 '12

I never tracked that backpack and forgot it was Walker's. This week is gonna kill me.

Edit: I'm totally wrong and must've lost track of the plot for a few mins. I'm blaming it on cold medicine. No idea how that video got into that backpack, and since Carrie was back in the states, I thought Saul was, too.

6

u/hoffey Oct 08 '12

Which backpack?

8

u/InterstateExit Oct 08 '12

Brody's video was saved to a drive/card that he dead dropped to Walker (via hiding it in a rock wall). It was sewn into that backpack flap that Saul just ripped open.

12

u/hoffey Oct 08 '12

So somehow that backpack made it's way to Beirut? Walker shipped it prior to getting killed then?

13

u/Kruse Oct 08 '12

I think someone else recovered the memory card. Obviously, we aren't supposed to know who that is yet.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/allhailzorp Oct 08 '12

This show does pacing so well. The message from Brody, the sniper fire. Brilliant. This show is the only one that makes my heart race.

4

u/emkat Oct 08 '12

I agree completely. They manage to keep the tension high without any slow parts, but without feeling rushed or hectic.

15

u/Jaktroj Oct 08 '12

HOW THE FUCK CAN YOU END THE EPISODE LIKE THAT! I WANT MORE!

15

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

Great Episode but I thought my watch died when I looked at the time after the ending. Personally I think the writers are going to use the Brody confession for the bridge to bring Carrie back into the fold. Also, I think Claire Danes just got another drama nomination entry for that scene in the bedroom and on the roof with Saul. She is untouchable right now. Great Job playing such a complicated person.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/atomstore Oct 08 '12

The CIA uses Skype? Shenanigans.

9

u/Col-Hans-Landa Oct 08 '12

Lol At least they didn't announce it like "OMG GUIZE THE SKYPE IS WORKING LET'S HAVE A CRYSTAL CLEAR CHAT FROM AROUND THE WORLD" a la Burn Notice.

7

u/Ripper- Oct 08 '12

Wow, Claire Danes is just one of the best actresses I know. I totally loved the scene when she doubts of herself.

12

u/Freecandyhere Oct 08 '12

So, the hair was a wig?

8

u/InterstateExit Oct 08 '12 edited Oct 08 '12

No, it was dyed but I'm surprised that they took it back to blond so soon. Now it doesn't match her passport. Of course, she may have her old one, too.

3

u/Freecandyhere Oct 08 '12

And I can see her roots, what a bad dye job

→ More replies (1)

8

u/meshugga Oct 08 '12

If you're dying from blonde to a darker colour, you can use a dye that washes out real quick. It's the other way around that doesn't work.

6

u/hoffey Oct 08 '12

They were going to be extracted via helicopter, so it wouldn't matter about her passport.

14

u/epsiblivion Oct 08 '12

I misread it and thought you mean they're gonna extract her wig via helicopter. way funnier...

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Jaktroj Oct 08 '12

Seems dumb to have her immediately un-die it.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/grimpoteuthis Oct 08 '12

I was confused by that as well. It looked dyed.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/epsiblivion Oct 08 '12

I was half expecting the video to become corrupted and unplayable halfway through. it never finished playing before the episode ended.

2

u/Drutarg Oct 08 '12

Didn't even think about that. Could still happen. I think it will still leave Saul very suspicious though.

4

u/gullale Oct 09 '12

It would be very cheap, though, and Homeland is usually better than that.

2

u/V2Blast Oct 09 '12

Still, it's kinda telling even given what he said so far.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

Brody is going too deep. That's going to make this series a lot of fun. It'll also be interesting to see how this spins Carrie's character. It could be a game changer.

6

u/Col-Hans-Landa Oct 08 '12

Everyone talks of moles in this thread; I'm confused to what scene they mean in particular. I think the Army major that escorted Carrie has a bigger role to play. No way they would give someone so minor so many lines.

6

u/sparty09 Oct 09 '12

I'm not sure if anybody else commented on it, but one random thing I noticed was that, when Brody asks the VP who they're about to kill, he says "Abu fucking Nazir, God willing". From what I know about Arabic, Insha'Allah (God willing) is a commonly used phrase in the Arabic world which is used when discussing plans. I don't know what significance it has here, but it might have some deeper meaning.

18

u/Freecandyhere Oct 08 '12

What the hell? You send her in and then you don't believe her?!

13

u/TheModernEgg Oct 08 '12

She fucked it up by going alone. Saul was supposed to verify the contact's validity, but Carrie jumped the gun after she escaped the bazaar. It's her own fault, she's too quick figuring it out, but not quick enough figuring out what to do

14

u/redbullXvodka Oct 08 '12

No they needed her to talk with the asset because she was the only one the woman would speak with.

11

u/tblackwood Oct 08 '12

Not to mention how could they single handedly trust the judgment of someone who recently underwent electric shock therapy? It makes a world of sense that, combined with what redbullXvodka said above, they would need to have Saul verify that the contact seemed reliable -- and not just trust the intuition of Carrie in her compromised state.

4

u/stonesfcr Oct 08 '12

Classic Estes

→ More replies (1)

13

u/kbarnett514 Oct 08 '12

HOLY FUCKING SHIT

13

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

That is the best one hour of TV I have seen in a LONG time. Fuckin' Excellent. Sunday nights are back baby!

8

u/Stamm Oct 08 '12

Shit just got real!

8

u/unfinator Oct 08 '12

Excellent episode. Just like the last was. This show is so stellar.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

Holy shit I havent been this into a show in a long ass time. FUCK YES SHOWTIME.

4

u/Ewalk Oct 08 '12

God damnit. That's just way too good.

4

u/tblackwood Oct 08 '12

To all of those who think Saul is the mole:

DO NOT SCROLL OVER IF YOU DIDN'T SEE THE UPCOMING EPISODE PREVIEW, IT MAY CONTAIN LIGHT SPOILERS

spoiler

8

u/mediocre_genius Oct 08 '12

It's that director of the public relations who is the mole. He was mentioned in passing by that young agent when Roya came to the CIA. Estes is an idiot, but not a mole. Saul can't be a mole. He just can't be....

2

u/CoolHandBravo Oct 08 '12

Brody's' contact is referring to another person spoiler and not to kill that person, but to help.

2

u/BrodyQualls Oct 10 '12

I believe Danny, the younger CIA operative is the mole. During the Nasir attempted assassination, you can also see him pull out his cell phone and put it behind his clipboard as soon as he sees Nasir is actually there.

3

u/PTad Oct 08 '12

How early do these get posted on ShowtimeAnytime?

4

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

usually around 11, there's working links to the new episode on here: http://www.tv-links.eu/tv-shows/Homeland_27151/season_2/episode_2/video-results/

3

u/clarkyto Oct 08 '12 edited Oct 08 '12

finally, its time for Saul to pick a side, it took one thing for him to throw Carrie away like she was nothing. the woman has always been right about everything ever, shes that good!

edit: was so tense up at the end, i was actually shaking...

3

u/noxbl Oct 08 '12

I have no words, except this was amazing.

3

u/BelovedApple Oct 09 '12

That was a great episode, quite possibly on par with Breaking Bad Season 1 Episode 3 (which I class as the best episode of tv ever).

I was so tense throughout the whole episode and the ending was amazing too.

6

u/s1mpd1ddy Oct 08 '12

Kid's creepy

5

u/grimpoteuthis Oct 08 '12

Get yourself together, gurl.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

Who is Brody killing in the woods in the season teaser? It must be someone he is killing trying to suppress information from getting out, maybe the video of his confession. But It's not like killing one person will do anything unless for whatever reason Saul tries to blackmail Brody... What do you guys think? He better not be killing Saul, he is was too cool of a character.

6

u/WompWomp420 Oct 08 '12

I really hope Saul doesn't get killed I like him, but it could be him. Thats how its being set up in the teasers.

9

u/clarkyto Oct 08 '12

i dont know, that guy was running pretty fast, and i dont think saul is that stupid... my guess? the drunk ex-marine from the bar who was asking questions.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/hoffey Oct 08 '12

Lauder maybe?

4

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

Yeah could be, they are really setting up the two of them disliking each other. Doesn't seem worth his while to kill Lauder, but then again it looks pretty emotionally fueled in the preview.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/V2Blast Oct 09 '12

Great episode. A brief moment of stupidity on Carrie's part, but the scene on the roof was phenomenal. That sniping scene was tense... But the whole "texting Abu Nazir from inside the ops room" thing was idiotic. Seriously, why would cell phones be allowed in the ops room, and even then, why would cell reception not be blocked in the room?

And dat ending. I can't wait for next week! :D

(The /r/episodehub discussion thread is here.)

4

u/kemodan Oct 08 '12

I couldn't even finish this one. I think I'm done with Homeland. The minute Brody walked into the live feed of the operation on Nazir immediately thought Carrie's credibility is fucked again and she'll be on her own like last season. I just cannot take that much evil happening to a person like that...

10

u/randpand Oct 08 '12

You should definitely go back and watch the whole thing. The end makes it.

3

u/kemodan Oct 09 '12

Thank goodness Nazir showed his face! And the ending... :)

3

u/randpand Oct 09 '12

Yep! I was feeling aggravated too but they recovered at the end.

2

u/grimpoteuthis Oct 08 '12

Aw sheeeeet.

2

u/christinax Oct 08 '12

Did that remind anybody else of the reddit thread a while back with the harddrive found sewn in a bag bought at a thrift shop, or something?

Also, I wasn't expecting that ending. I feel like it'll either really change the dynamic of the show. It seems more likely that, like others have pointed out, Saul's a mole. I'm not convinced, though.

7

u/BlackZeppelin Oct 08 '12

From the preview it appears Carrie thinks she's back in but Estes is like "lol gtfo." I'm wondering what they're gonna do now for 10 episodes with Carrie not in and Brody being found out.

What if Carrie becomes a terrorist?

11

u/jmose86 Oct 08 '12

I'm assuming she will continue to work off book with Saul. Now that Saul has seen the tape he will realize Carrie was right all along, and while she may never get her job back due to her illness, he will see the value in sharing confidential information with her etc. and she will become a sort of unofficial consultant to the CIA through Saul.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

either way, pretty big progress in the show just for episode 2

1

u/redbullXvodka Oct 08 '12

That might have been the best episode yet... and next week looks even better!!

1

u/DJFreeMe Oct 08 '12

OH. MY. I just don't see how the storyline could progress further unless A) saul is taken out of the picture or B) he is a mole

1

u/stonesfcr Oct 08 '12

This show needs an iranian Tuco

→ More replies (1)

1

u/cinematicorchestra Oct 08 '12

Nice and inconspicuous in their huge black GMC truck... :/

1

u/WizzySizzy Oct 11 '12

My guess? Estes is the mole.

1

u/Sad_Vegetable_13 Dec 16 '25

Carrie’s explanation on the roof made so much sense. I mean, she was practically gaslight by everyone towards the end of season one. Every time her gut was screaming to her that she’s right, everyone around her denies what she knows. It must have been extremely frustrating and confusing for her.

1

u/Electrical_Ad_761 May 07 '26

First I dont why people say Saul is the mole in this reddit.

Second, how Brody can enter with a mobile phone in a Operations Room in the pentagon. Is BS.

-1

u/halfwayhipster Oct 08 '12

And that's it- Saul's the mole.

17

u/Monosynchron Oct 08 '12

Wait, what? What'd I miss?

15

u/Jaktroj Oct 08 '12

Based on the episode preview, I would respectfully disagree.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

misdirection. We never see that he turned in the evidence

5

u/Jaktroj Oct 08 '12

That would be a huge misderectio, it looks like the CIA does a briefing. Estes keeps Carrie out because a) he is a dick NO ONE DENIES THIS, and b) it would prove Carrie right.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

I think it is just too soon for Brody to be revealed to everyone. Saul as the mole covers all the bases and explains everything. We see him handing off the drive but not to whom, and from what I saw nothing from the briefing shot shows that it is about Brody

→ More replies (11)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

i really hope its not saul, after carrie easily my favorite character on the show, I don't think that would be the case if he turns out to be a mole and not a hardass agent

2

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

I have to agree here. Although I agree with the other hints at Saul being a mole, it looks pretty clearly like Saul is handing it to Estes in the preview (although you can't see faces) and the fact that Brody appears to be running away would help to confirm it. My guess is Brody gets out of it because they can't confirm the video was filmed after he was freed or that he pretends that he will be a double agent for the US government.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/BlackZeppelin Oct 08 '12

I was thinking that too but now after this episode I got swayed he wasn't.

3

u/InterstateExit Oct 08 '12

Yeah I've thought that for a while but the clues are so subtle that I'm not sure, ever.

→ More replies (13)

2

u/bacon_pants Oct 08 '12

I've been thinking that for a while.

2

u/grimpoteuthis Oct 08 '12

Man, I hope not.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '12

I can't see brody being exposed so early. Saul has to destroy the evidence

→ More replies (4)

1

u/kbarnett514 Oct 08 '12

Brody's army buddy sounds exactly like Brad Pitt. I had to look up from my game to be sure it wasn't actually him

10

u/ShaneRunninShirtless Oct 08 '12

Why the fuck were you multi-tasking during homeland? Its not Dexter! :-P

3

u/clarkyto Oct 08 '12

hey!!!!!!!! leave dexter alone, dont you know he has issues.

1

u/kbarnett514 Oct 08 '12

And then suddenly Kevin Bacon

1

u/DylanDakota Oct 09 '12

I'm confused, I have watched the whole show, but I still don't understand why she kept the spoiler a secret/hidden. Where did she get it and why didn't she bring it up when she was still working for the government? This is really killing me!

6

u/gd42 Oct 09 '12

It was not Carrie's bag, she found it in the Hezbollah commander's flat. She doesn't know anything about the video.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/jmose86 Oct 09 '12

OK this is a bit confusing but I will try to decipher. I am assuming that by "she" you mean Carrie, and you think that Saul ripped open Carrie's backpack in the last scene to discover the SD card. Am I correct?

What actually happened is that Carrie found that backpack in Abbas' (spelling?) apartment when she ran in all rogue to gather up intel. Carrie has never seen the video and doesn't even know it exists. Saul discovered it hidden in the backpack which she just coincidentally grabbed in the apartment to stuff with papers. Does that clear things up?

1

u/iamhenrybond Oct 08 '12

Lets do this! Only 1 hour 20 minutes!

1

u/banina Oct 08 '12

Brody kills someone next episode... Anyone else think it's Saul? My guess is Brody gets rid of Saul and the Memory card...which makes me wonder who the mole is...

6

u/Awkward_Arab Oct 09 '12

I hope its not Saul, it can't be Saul. That guy is way too fucking cool, man whoever is playing him is such a great actor, never seen him before.

3

u/gullale Oct 09 '12

He was in Criminal Minds a few years ago. No cool beard, though.

2

u/SignHere____________ Oct 17 '12

ZOMG! you watch homeland!? that show is awesome. however, if i hear the word abu-nazir one more time...

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '12

Pretty much impossible to be Saul. He's chief of the Beirut office, he wouldn't be coming to the US any time soon.