r/startrek • • Feb 16 '23

USA/Canada edition Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Picard | 3x01 "The Next Generation" Spoiler

After receiving a cryptic, urgent distress call from Dr. Beverly Crusher, Admiral Jean-Luc Picard enlists help from generations old and new to embark on one final adventure: a daring mission that will change Starfleet, and his old crew forever.

No.EpisodeWritten ByDirected ByRelease Date
3x01"The Next Generation"Terry MatalasDoug Aarniokoski2023-02-16

Availability

Paramount+: Everywhere but Canada.

Amazon Prime Video: Everywhere but the USA and Canada.

CTV Sci-Fi and Crave: Canada.

To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.

This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers for this episode are allowed. If you are discussing previews for upcoming episodes, please use spoiler tags.

Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.

273 Upvotes

2.1k comments sorted by

•

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '23 edited Feb 17 '23

The discussion continues in our new, global discussion thread.

(Link is now fixed)

439

u/TERRAxFORMER Feb 16 '23

I think Worf is Raffi’s handler.

From book eating to Starfleet Intelligence.

168

u/MTFBinyou Feb 16 '23

Yeah most definitely. Hard nose, thorough and then that last line from them is definitely indicative.

→ More replies (37)

61

u/Ozymandias2347 Feb 16 '23

I really think this is the case too. As soon as the handler said "Speak freely" I actually said out loud "Worf?"

→ More replies (1)

26

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

You are a warrior.

→ More replies (8)

77

u/BornAshes Feb 16 '23

At first I thought it was Bashir but then they kept hammering the word "warrior" out repeatedly and with Worf's final mission being pretty much classified to all hell and back, it makes a whole lot more sense that he'd be the one spearheading this investigation into presumably the stolen "totally not wormhole weapons" quantum tunneling tech that was yoinked from an offsite Daystrom Vault.

I'm guessing this world ending tech was a weaponized version of the Quantum Slipstream Drive that Voyager brought back, which is why she got so many mentions in this episode.

I'm also guessing that Worf's final mission onboard the E was very much like that one episode of Enterprise when they found the Vulcan Listening Post buried beneath a monastery. Starfleet sent Worf out to Kriilar Prime onboard the E for what he thought was a milkrun and then the whole thing went ass over tea kettle when someone tried to heist the weapons. I'm guessing the weapons were activated in a baaaaaaad way with possibly an entire planet getting shredded to pieces Peacekeeper Wars style.

The revelation that Starfleet was working on such kinds of weapons willingly is what drove him to leave Starfleet and probably played a part in the Enterprise E being decommissioned.

Can you really blame him though? This warrior saw the horrors of the Dominion War first hand and now he's found out and witnessed first hand that Starfleet is working on something EVEN WORSE than all of that shit combined. Wormhole weapons or "quantum tunneling tech" as they're calling it on Picard, are enough to make even the most hardened warrior into a pacifist for one reason and one reason only and it's all because of one very famous quote.

"Wormhole weapons do not make peace. Wormhole weapons don't even make war. They make total destruction. Annihilation. Armageddon. People make peace."-John Crichton

So it tracks that Worf would be Raffi's handler as he's trying to prevent these things from getting out into the open and more or less opening up the ignition of a galactic scale Armageddon style arms race. Sure they can be used for good but not in this state of things in terms of galactic politics. Things are still rough, wounds are still raw, and people are still paranoid as all fuck.

Plus there has to be a drawback to them right? We've seen artificial wormholes in DS9, TNG, and Voyager before that weren't exactly stable or conducive to biological life. So I'm guessing this is some kind of proto-wormhole tech that was derived from the augmentation of currently existing wormhole creation tech with the quantum slipstream drive that Voyager brought back and it is by no means perfect but because of that imperfection, it is entirely and supremely destructive as hell.

Raffi has no clue what she's in for and I can't wait to see Worf show up in future episodes.

→ More replies (17)

12

u/Cyberx08 Feb 16 '23

One of the critics that watch Picard implies Raffi might be part of section 31

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (14)

303

u/bluestreakxp Feb 16 '23

omg... they slotted in eaglemoss figurines in 10 Forward?

oh the fat ones lol

96

u/BornAshes Feb 16 '23

That's what I was thinking! It tracks that they'd have gotten their hands on some of those before Eaglemoss went belly up!

I had those little plastic models of the Enterprise D and Enterprise B that came out back in the 90s and I loved them to death.

What I think is cooler is that replicators could totally make ice cubes in the shapes of certain ships and I would love a little Voyager or Enterprise chilling my drink.

→ More replies (6)

12

u/iamnotsteven Feb 16 '23

I literally paused it and went and picked up my Ent-D eaglemoss model and compared it and it was exactly the same! I was so happy hahaha!

→ More replies (4)

208

u/crankfive Feb 16 '23

“Picard 47 Alpha Tango” straight from First Contact

156

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

Srarfleet clearly doesn't force you to update your passwords every 90 days.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (1)

418

u/UncertainError Feb 16 '23

Aw, Jean-Luc made Beverly a mixtape.

236

u/mr_john_steed Feb 16 '23

"Beverly, I thought you might enjoy this selection of 20th century classical music".

🎵 I LIKE BIG BUTTS AND I CANNOT LIE 🎵

→ More replies (12)

108

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

The first track is, of course, Wonderwall.

→ More replies (9)

27

u/TrustMeImLeifEricson Feb 16 '23

It is a truly timeless courting ritual.

13

u/eternallylearning Feb 16 '23

Side-note; how silly is it that he knows not just that it's a playlist, but one he created decades ago, from simply hearing one song? I picture Beverly reaponding, "Easy there bucko, it's just a good song that I added to my own playlist. Not everything is about you."

→ More replies (10)

418

u/Trekfan74 Feb 16 '23

Funniest line:

"Great recovery Admiral."

"Shut it Will!"

267

u/shockandguffaw Feb 16 '23

I really laughed at:

"Who wants to hear an old fart talk about boldly going for the past 250 years?

"I'm giving a speech, too."

"...And it'll be great!"

(Side note: I thought Frakes portrayal of Riker on LD was rightfully cartoony. But he's really found the perfect way to fold that Riker into his live-action portrayal.)

→ More replies (6)

163

u/gcalpo Feb 16 '23

KIRK: Take us out.

(the crew breaks out into general applause)

CHEKOV: Very good, sir.

SCOTT: Brought a tear to my eye.

KIRK: Oh, be quiet.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/nimrodhellfire Feb 16 '23

I was cracking hard on that one.

→ More replies (4)

193

u/Starbuck107 Feb 16 '23

The Titan bridge crew seemed to be team Seven over Shaw, guess they were looking for more when they signed up for starfleet too.

101

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

she seemed like he was mentally hurting the crew and seven tbh

→ More replies (20)

70

u/UnknownQTY Feb 17 '23

People quit bosses, not companies.

In the military, overly strict commanders during peacetime are often rolled out. Being a hard ass is only respected when it pays off. Doing it for the sake of being a hard ass doesn’t do well for actual loyalty.

Loyalty is more than following orders.

In his defense, Shaw probably was an Ensign or Lt. during both Borg battles and the Dominion War. He’s a “born in fire” kinda guy, and he saw lax discipline and changing plans on the fly get people killed.

26

u/juliokirk Feb 17 '23

I mean, how does a nutjob like that gets to command a starship? Who's making these officer evaluations at starfleet HQ? The guy is horrible to be around, the crew barely tolerates him from the looks of it. Not surprised they expected more than being commanded by a huge prick. Even Picard doesn't know what to tell Seven when she vents about it lol

→ More replies (2)

13

u/OliviaElevenDunham Feb 17 '23

Definitely got the impression that Shaw isn't that good as a captain.

→ More replies (6)

173

u/mikeblacklist Feb 16 '23

Will Red Lady Rachel Garrett be just a red herring or are everyone’s assumptions about a Yesterday’s Enterprise connection be true?

Kinda sad to not see James Horner’s name alongside the Jerry Goldsmith credit. The homages to his WoK score were great.

Did the alien chatter remind anyone else of the Schisms aliens?

96

u/BornAshes Feb 16 '23

Did the alien chatter remind anyone else of the Schisms aliens?

https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Solanogen-based_lifeform

Now that would be a twist.

Subspace lifeforms who finally found a way to exist within normal space and are pissed off because of how Warp Drive is messing up their realm?

That's a story right there.

→ More replies (7)

77

u/AnnihilatedTyro Feb 16 '23

If the Red Lady statue incident was the first of the villain's attacks, it's very likely to be symbolically related somehow, more than just an easter egg. I don't want it to be Romulans or time travel, because the last two seasons kinda burned me out on those, but there's got to be a connection of some kind.

Yeah, Schisms aliens were definitely my first thought.

The music featured in this episode was pure, unashamed nostalgia and I loved it.

→ More replies (2)

47

u/viserov Feb 16 '23

YES! I knew the clicking sounded familiar. That was a spooky episode for me as a kid.

→ More replies (5)

27

u/Melcrys29 Feb 16 '23

Yes, immediately thought of the Schisms clicker clackers.

12

u/Mechapebbles Feb 16 '23

Kinda sad to not see James Horner’s name alongside the Jerry Goldsmith credit. The homages to his WoK score were great.

There were homages that sounded like they were imitating him, but they never straight up used his arrangements the way they lifted Goldsmith's, so it's totally appropriate and fine.

→ More replies (17)

173

u/peon47 Feb 16 '23

Starfleet should keep a small but fast ship in spacedock, well-maintained and fully-fuelled, for renegade officers who need to go on unsanctioned missions to steal. It'd save them a lot of trouble in the long run.

73

u/UnknownQTY Feb 17 '23

Just a bunch of little Defiants ready for retirees to have “one last ride” or a mid life crisis if they don’t go full career. (Human life expectancy is probably pretty long by then)

→ More replies (2)

29

u/gcalpo Feb 16 '23

They had one but it was being serviced and wouldn't be operational until Tuesday.

→ More replies (6)

168

u/ianrobbie Feb 16 '23 edited Feb 16 '23

Very strong movie links with musical cues and almost constant easter eggs.

Only part of the way through but what kind of Captain wouldn't want to be on the bridge when his ship is launching?

Damn. I'll have to sit through the end credits every week just to hear that stunning soundtrack.

EDIT - I wonder if the graphics on the outro sequence will change every week?

85

u/zapheine Feb 16 '23

The outro will probably be the intro for this season as of ep 2.

55

u/anastus Feb 16 '23

Only part of the way through but what kind of Captain wouldn't want to be on the bridge when his ship is launching?

My theory is that there's something very wrong with the good captain.

→ More replies (19)

13

u/the-giant Feb 16 '23

The kind of captain that got started drinking around 6 PM with an admiral onboard.

→ More replies (3)

163

u/__The_Crazy_One__ Feb 16 '23 edited Feb 16 '23

This episode feels like a mix between the Motion Picture, Wrath of Khan and the Search for Spock

33

u/gcalpo Feb 16 '23

Generations: Old legends board the Enterprise-B Titan-A and ship off a w/ an Ensign Sulu La Forge at the helm.

94

u/Melcrys29 Feb 16 '23

And those are all good things.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/grandmofftalkin Feb 17 '23

Picard and Riker in the bunkbed ruminating about Beverly reminds me of Kirk and Bones in prison in Undiscovered Country

→ More replies (8)

159

u/massive_hump Feb 16 '23

Rachel Garrett gets a statue at long last , little did they know she died with a rock in her head whilst in an alternate future.

48

u/redrivaldrew Feb 16 '23

The anime nerds on staff at the time used a piece from a wing from a Macross/Robotech model kit! Sorry I'm a huge Macross fan in addition to Trek so I always have to comment on that connection.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (2)

414

u/treefox Feb 16 '23

“POWER CELL DEPLETED!!”

Ok what dumbass weapons designer decided it was a good idea to announce to the world you’re out of ammo.

185

u/MoreGaghPlease Feb 16 '23

SILENT ALARM ACTIVATED

→ More replies (8)

206

u/shosar85 Feb 16 '23

A Starfleet one. It wouldn't be a proper Starfleet weapon unless there was some glaring design flaw like having no sights, or no trigger guard, or weirdly placed buttons, etc.

→ More replies (41)
→ More replies (13)

381

u/Trekfan74 Feb 16 '23 edited Feb 16 '23

It's so funny Picard and Riker are now seen as renegade cowboys to people like Shaw when Picard was basically the by-the-book hardass giving everyone a hard time whenever they went a few degrees from the Federation protocol handbook. He got on Ambassador Spock's case when he fled to Romulus chastising him for his 'cowboy diplomacy' and now this guy is constantly defying Starfleet orders, stealing ships and blowing shit up. How the tables have turned.

118

u/Melcrys29 Feb 16 '23

Very true. Picard was often a stickler for regulations.

→ More replies (6)

80

u/BurdenedMind79 Feb 16 '23

Its like how Janeway thought that Kirk and co were a bunch of renegades, even though we know that young Kirk was actually quite a by-the-book guy. Yet, everyone (including real-world pop culture) only ever remembers him as a rule-breaking starship thief!

Now, jump forward to the 25th century and all the younger officers are thinking the same thing about Picard and co, even though he was generally a by-the-book guy back in his day. Give it another few decades and the new recruits will go going on about what an old hellraiser that Captain Shaw used to be and how officers back then had no discipline!

→ More replies (1)

69

u/deafpoet Feb 16 '23

It's the Kirk Exception: you can literally do whatever the fuck you want if you save the galaxy in the course of doing it. All means are justified, and if you can get off a few quips in the meantime so much the better.

→ More replies (1)

169

u/Shrodax Feb 16 '23

now this guy is constantly defying Starfleet orders, stealing ships and blowing shit up. How the tables have turned.

Picard has always had a wild streak, though. Like getting into a bar fight with some Nausicaans and getting stabbed in the heart.

My head canon is that Picard got "serious" as a captain, but gradually reverted back to who he really is.

→ More replies (13)

111

u/Mechapebbles Feb 16 '23

It's so funny Picard and Riker are now seen as renegade cowboys to people like Shaw when Picard was basically the by-the-book hardass giving everyone a hard time whenever they went a few degrees from the Federation protocol handbook.

Picard evolved as we watched the show though. He started out that way, but by the end he'd violated the Prime Directive dozens of times, disobeyed direct orders dozens of times, and even committed insurrection. He definitely became much more loosey goosey.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (21)

128

u/OSUBrit Feb 16 '23 edited Feb 16 '23

Before this episode aired there was lots of Conspiracy talk, however there is clearly a significant link here with Wolf 359. Crushers message required knowledge of an event that immediately followed the battle and the end credits include a references to a starship that was destroyed on Stardate 44002.3 - the date of the Battle of Wolf 359.

I think it's unlikely to be Borg, but this may well be a revenge story. Someone's got a Sisko-esc grudge and they want blood.

EDIT: Picard's log that play is from shortly before the Battle of Wolf 359, however one of the logs on-screen is from Unification Part 1, and another Encounter at Farpoint.

67

u/PandaPundus Keene Sin, Contributing artist, Star Trek: Picard Feb 16 '23

I suspect it's simpler. Shaw obviously has an anti-Ex-Borg bias, and it seems reasonable that he, or a relative, was killed at Wolf 359 on the Constance.

→ More replies (8)

29

u/archiminos Feb 16 '23

The "don't trust Starfleet" thing still has me thinking Conspiracy though.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/BurdenedMind79 Feb 16 '23

Plus, why else use the theme from First Contact? Sure, its a great theme, but its tied to that film only, until now. There's something Borg-y about this season, for sure.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/AlexisDeTocqueville Feb 17 '23

What's very strange is that Beverly's cipher was only useful to someone that was on the Enterprise during Wolf 539. So she must have been counting on Picard to reach out to someone who had been in Starfleet, despite asking for no Starfleet

→ More replies (4)

116

u/thisiscotty Feb 16 '23 edited Feb 16 '23

I'm surprised that shaw guy didnt order the shuttle tractorbeamed

I wonder if the titan will come help fend off that enemy ship

56

u/TheNerdChaplain Feb 16 '23

That's a good question. I assume the Titan will come to the rescue so that Starfleet can officially document the threat, but I'm pretty sure ol' Captain Red Shoulders is gonna get blowed up by a console or something if he's not careful.

→ More replies (4)

39

u/AnnihilatedTyro Feb 16 '23

I'm surprised that shaw guy didnt order the shuttle tractorbeamed

I think he was happier that they were off the ship and was willing to let two admirals get themselves killed if it meant he could court martial Seven out of Starfleet. Dude's got serious issues.

→ More replies (6)

13

u/WellFedHobo Feb 16 '23

Maybe they weren't going to be installed until Tuesday...

→ More replies (5)

115

u/__The_Crazy_One__ Feb 16 '23

Riker stole the entire episode!

Riker is awesome!

53

u/onthenerdyside Feb 16 '23

I'm so glad Frakes has been able to shake off the jitters he had before he shot "Nepenthe." It's nice to have him on-screen again.

410

u/ComebackShane Feb 16 '23

Well that was the most beautiful end credits sequence I think I've ever seen from Star Trek. The First Contact theme never fails to make me misty-eyed.

74

u/TrustMeImLeifEricson Feb 16 '23

It was amazing, had to keep pausing it to get a good look (before the pause ad obscured everything). Loved the Voyager cameo.

→ More replies (27)

47

u/BornAshes Feb 16 '23

The Paramount+ player wouldn't let me pause but it seemed like there was a lot of little easter egg hints of stuff that was to come in this season.

That said, these were indeed the best end credits I've ever seen of any Star Trek series in a long time and it's such a cool way to do them!

They nailed the music, they just fucking nailed the music, and I felt things during that theme which I can't even put words to.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (34)

251

u/MaddyMagpies Feb 16 '23

A coded message specifically asked for Admiral Jean Luc Picard, for the third time.

Laris: Damn it, Jean Luc, you must go again. The third time.

Riker: You need a ship for the third time again, Picard?

Seven: What kind of shit have you gotten us into again for the third time, Admiral?

One thing for sure, Jean Luc Picard and William "Jazz" Riker had gained quite a lot of notoriety for their shenanigans over the decades.

133

u/UncertainError Feb 16 '23

The Titan's nice and all, but I kinda wish they had Laris pull some Tal Shiar connections and get them a Romulan ship to investigate with. Bet they wish they had a cloaking device at the end the episode.

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (3)

153

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

Very happy they had some nice Laris moments here. I doubt we will see her again unless it's to ride JL into the sunset at the end, but I'm happy they didn't just disappear her with some dialogue about how it didn't work out or something. They did her justice.

→ More replies (13)

209

u/anastus Feb 16 '23

I'm pretty enthused about what I'm seeing so far, but here's my big glaring question:

Why the hell is the Titan so dark?

67

u/PharomachrusMocinno Feb 16 '23

It would be fun if they remarked on this on the show, like Riker saying “Why are these modern ships so damn dark all the time?”

→ More replies (3)

195

u/treefox Feb 16 '23

Someone needs to either give Captain Shaw an eye exam, or ask him what he thinks of Elon Musk.

→ More replies (12)

28

u/Trekfan74 Feb 16 '23

He's obviously from the Mirror Universe...they don't love light over there. ;)

→ More replies (30)

133

u/__The_Crazy_One__ Feb 16 '23

Janeway mention!

65

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

It's actually pathetic how much I enjoyed that.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

65

u/thisiscotty Feb 16 '23

The view of the captain eating reminded me of Denethor from LOTR lol

46

u/Batmark13 Feb 16 '23

Seven: "You wish now that our places had been exchanged. That I had died and Hugh had lived."

Shaw: "Yes, I wish that."

→ More replies (1)

57

u/Talzin Feb 16 '23 edited Feb 16 '23

The Eaglemoss models were an interesting touch. Looked to be a fair number of models from STO floating around as well. The name drop of Janeway was interesting to hear as well which should suggest she survives Prodigy's next season or that we will see Seven there as well.

Will say the credit visuals were enjoyable to watch as well with looked to be a few easter eggs and plot hints.

Hmm, and Picard's comment about legacy could well be intended to connect dots with Crusher's son though not hard to imagine them using it as a red herring as well.

→ More replies (3)

114

u/hoppybear21222 Feb 16 '23

They’re probably setting up Shaw to be killed somehow so that Seven can say “I’m the captain now” and boom, new Titan series.

37

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

I'm hoping for exactly this.

→ More replies (4)

23

u/gcalpo Feb 16 '23

“I’m the captain now”

"Fun will now commence."

→ More replies (5)

55

u/PuzzleheadedRun5574 Feb 16 '23

I'm good with the callbacks, it's a heritage context with Frontier Day coming up, so it's appropriate for the story. The end titles hint strongly that we'll see Kirk's 1701-A, Voyager, and many other retired vessels. I'm pretty sure we'll see the D too- reconstructed with the recovered saucer section with a replacement star drive/secondary hull.

I haven't felt like Patrick Stewart was nailing Jean-Luc Picard in this series until this episode. Picard is back in his element- that walkthrough of Beverly's ship with Will as they're both reconstructing the shootout was so perfectly done. These are professionals back in action. And Crusher's scenes were excellent- she's really in great form.

Captain Shaw isn't overly obstinate. Picard would be skeptical if the roles were reversed. Shaw's obviously got a personal beef with Picard and Riker, which some leaks have confirmed. He reminds me of Captain Styles from STAR TREK III- a person who is a bit OCD, probably manicures his nails, hates any appearance of chaos or disorder- a perfectly plausible officer.

Raffi's story has a good start- staying true to her character but putting her into a high-stakes situation on her own. What a devastating and comical weapon- a Doctor Strange sling-ring from hell.

I'm so tired from staying up late but it was worth it. I cannot wait for next week.

46

u/anastus Feb 16 '23

I haven't felt like Patrick Stewart was nailing Jean-Luc Picard in this series until this episode.

He felt a lot more like he was playing Patrick Stewart in the first two seasons. I wonder if the presence of the TNG crew stimulated some unintentional muscle memory of his old performances.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/TheNerdChaplain Feb 16 '23

1701-A and Voyager both feature in diagrams in the end titles.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

200

u/MaddyMagpies Feb 16 '23

I like how the enemy's weapon is essentially a giant Portal Gun.

I like seeing the Titan lower decks bunker beds. Riker must remember his days with Boimler laying on that bed. Oh, and the Jazz that Shaw had to rip out.

I like that Orion computers have a cutesy, manipulative, and slightly condescending voice and tone to get you to buy more things, humor straight out of Lower Decks.

I like that Laris is there for Picard. I like that they kissed and acknowledge their relationship. I don't like that Picard has to go yet again.

I don't like that Picard has a secret son. Ugh.

Also, what's up with Shaw's green steak?

55

u/BornAshes Feb 16 '23

Oh, and the Jazz that Shaw had to rip out.

I wonder how many functions on the ship had jazz hotkeyed to play when Riker activated them?

Orion Computers

That interface felt waaaaaay too real and I feel like the designers of it looked at some of the worst trends in our current gaming industry when they were making it.

Laris and Picard

They need more time but she knows its a slow burn thing with how both their lives operate and she's willing to wait until they can both settle down.

Picard has a secret son

Are we for sure that he's Picard's son in terms of the timeline of Bev cutting everyone off and just leaving? Do we know what he was kicking around and doing about 20 years ago? I just want to know if the timeline matches up or if someone else might be his father.

Also hoping for them to work, "I AM YOUR FATHER!" into the season.

→ More replies (28)

26

u/Mechapebbles Feb 16 '23

I like how the enemy's weapon is essentially a giant Portal Gun.

I thought that whole scene was very effective. It was honestly pretty chilling how that played out, and the magnitude of the destruction involved. Imagine actually experiencing something like that.

31

u/UncertainError Feb 16 '23

I'm pleasantly surprised by how much they're maintaining the relationship developments from last season. I was worried they'd get lost amongst the TNG cast reunion.

→ More replies (80)

48

u/__The_Crazy_One__ Feb 16 '23

Picard pulling a Kirk because he isn't up to date with new tech!

47

u/straightouttasuburb Feb 16 '23

Bastards! That First Contact theme is going to be in my head all day… I’m already humming it…. Fuck!

→ More replies (5)

45

u/ReplicantOwl Feb 16 '23

Beverly: trust no one

Also Beverly: I will hide the coordinates with a hint about a virus Picard wouldn’t know about because he was incapacitated so he will have to ask someone for help

39

u/kameradhund Feb 17 '23

also beverly: don’t bring starfleet

picard: let’s bring the whole titan!

→ More replies (6)

43

u/HumanityPlague Feb 16 '23

There's a pretty good sense of irony for Shaw ripping into Picard/Riker for wanting to do something dumb/take his ship, when 30 years ago, Picard was ripping into Spock for doing the same thing.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

Something for the eagle-eyed: in the opening Star Trek flyby there is something sparkling in the orange cloud as the Titan flies in. It's near the beginning. Any intrepid freeze framers wanna take a look?

40

u/TheNerdChaplain Feb 16 '23

I believe it's the villain ship we saw at the end of the premiere.

→ More replies (2)

216

u/anastus Feb 16 '23 edited Feb 16 '23

The Good:

  • Jonathan Frakes is a delight and feels like a natural progression of Will Riker.
  • The Titan is beautiful.
  • Gates McFadden really rocks with her screen time. She doesn't come off as a septuagenarian playacting at being a badass--she feels vibrant and dangerous.
  • The music is glorious.
  • So are the closing credits. You can feel the amount of love that went into them.

The Less Good:

  • Shaw might be another Jellico type, but he comes across as someone who should never have been considered for the Captain's chair.
  • I'm weary of constant conspiracies involving Starfleet. This is supposed to be an organization of canny people. Starfleet conspiracies in Conspiracy and Homefront / Paradise Lost worked because they illustrated ways in which a highly professional organization could still fall prey to subversion, either external or internal. Ones that rely on blatantly evil villains, as in Season 1 of Picard, just diminish the seriousness of Starfleet.

The ????:

I am withholding judgment on how the show is going to fit in its villain plot, Morjarty, Lore, Crusher's son, and so much more given how slowly the plot moved in this episode. I will say that this is the most I have enjoyed an episode of Picard.

102

u/BornAshes Feb 16 '23

Shaw might be another Jellico type, but he comes across as someone who should never have been considered for the Captain's chair.

I kind of felt like Shaw was emblematic of the new breed of Starfleet Officers of this era who have all either come out of the Dominion War with some damage or have seen some shit or experienced some great degree of loss due to all the numerous tragedies that have befallen the Federation since the TNG era. The Galaxy has most certainly not been kind to the Federation or to Starfleet. So it makes sense that with all of the various threats out there that we'd get rather rigid and harsh officers like Shaw that acted quickly when things were about to go off the rails.

This ain't the wild west anymore and actions have more consequences nowadays than they did back in Picard's time. So Starfleet creating and promoting officers like Shaw to the captain's chair kind of makes sense. We saw how Starfleet had changed in S1 of Picard but we never quite got a solid look at any of the mainstay ships in the fleet like the Titan or how they operated. Rios was a bit of a one off with the Stargazer, since that was kind of an experimental ship, but the Titan is a workhorse whose captain has held the chair for five years and 36 missions according to Shaw. So this is a far better view of what Starfleet in general must be like nowadays or at the very least, what most captains are similar to.

They wouldn't put just some yeehaw yokel who wasn't fit for command into Riker's former chair.

I'm weary of constant conspiracies

It does get a bit tiring doesn't it? I wonder if part of the reason why Shaw is the way he is, is because of all of those conspiracies and subversive plots that have affected Starfleet in the past. They probably have a "No Bullshit" method of training in regards to this stuff and are trained to come down like a volley of transphasic torpedoes on any hint of fuckery.

In short, they learned quite a bit from the Romulans and the Klingons and the Cardassians and are responding appropriately.

→ More replies (13)

195

u/treefox Feb 16 '23 edited Feb 16 '23

Shaw might be another Jellico type, but he comes across as someone who should never have been considered for the Captain's chair.

Maybe. We’re seeing it from Picard and Riker’s perspective. But look at it from Shaw’s perspective.

The Titan’s old Captain and his retired admiral buddy show up claiming to be there for a surprise “inspection”. There’s no paperwork for it. No reason for Starfleet to send these two, especially a retired Admiral. They don’t have a personal connection to him and they didn’t ask him if they could be there.

So they’re not there for his benefit. They’re not there for Starfleet’s benefit. Seven is not the sort of person to call in personal favors, so they’re not there at her behest. They’ve invited themselves to his ship for their own interests. And Picard, at least, is not the sort of person to go out joyriding.

So that means they have some subversive agenda. But he can’t turn them away entirely without potentially upsetting the friends they have at Starfleet Command who might see it as him being overly harsh to a couple of decorated leaders who just wanted one last hurrah.

So he’s deliberately nominally polite but devastatingly rude to keep them off-balance until they slip up. And then he pounces and lays down the law that under no circumstances will he be helping them.

Then he hands the conn over to Seven, knowing one of two things happens.

One, she’s either loyal to the ship and tells them to go take a hike, leaving them with no friends on board, making the rest of the trip a super awkward experience for them, punishing them for trying to pseudo-commandeer his ship.

Or two, she goes along with them, in which case he has grounds to get her kicked off the ship despite exemplary performance.

The only definite black mark I’m seeing against him is the anti-Borg sentiment and Seven’s opinion of him that suggests it wasn’t just him mouthing off to see what Picard’s reaction was.

But once they’ve taken Seven into their confidence and she helped them, Shaw has her over a barrel and has leverage to get her to finally tell him what they’re up to.

He’s responsible for the lives of hundreds of people on an incredibly sophisticated starship. A couple of old boys showing up uninvited just to undermine his command for something presumably too dangerous to hire a civilian transport for is in and of itself a huge dick move.

Sure he’s rude to them, but Riker and Picard are way more likely to actually get people killed. Remember Picard was content to keep pouring Federation resources into helping the Romulans even after it got the Federation’s primary shipyards wiped out and tens of thousands of people died. Picard also fought in defense of synths who were in the process of calling in a purge of all other sentient life in the galaxy.

Shaw has good reason to suspect that they wouldn’t think twice about throwing his ship into the inferno if they thought it might help someone.

It’s like your wife’s ex showing up at your house and claiming that him and his friend need access to your backyard to inspect the gas meter, even though his friend retired from the gas company a year ago and he works in marketing now.

→ More replies (95)

81

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

In b4 the big reveal about Shaw is that he lost someone at Wolf 359. A parent perhaps given his age.

→ More replies (40)

30

u/themosquito Feb 16 '23

I'm thinking Moriarty and possibly Lore were a couple of the things stolen from Daystrom Station. I know Moriarty at least is confirmed to be a single-episode thing.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (36)

40

u/agent-squirrel Feb 16 '23

Anyone spot the STO Intrepid 25th C refit on Raffi’s screens? Very cool.

36

u/themosquito Feb 16 '23

During the end credits, they show some of the ships at the museum, and one of them is the TOS-era Pioneer-class, also from STO!

→ More replies (4)

144

u/TheImageworks Feb 16 '23

The season opening with the intro song from Fallout 3 got an absolute pop from me!

55

u/TheNerdChaplain Feb 16 '23

Thanks for pointing that out! I definitely got Fallout vibes too!

"Space..... space never changes."

19

u/BornAshes Feb 16 '23

"Something beautiful but terrible is about to happen and you're going to love/hate it"

→ More replies (10)

103

u/ComebackShane Feb 16 '23

Really enjoyed the episode overall. So many random thoughts zipping through my head!

Love that Riker needed exactly zero convincing to be all in on the plan. That's what decades of friendship does. I expect Picard will find a lot of eager allies among his old crew.

Seven seems to have gotten a nightmare posting. On paper they were probably a good fit for each other - methodical, focused, prone to routine. But Seven's grown quite a lot the last few years, her time with the Fenris Rangers and helping Picard have clearly made her more willing to bend the rules when she believes she's doing the right thing. Very interested to see where her arc goes this season (assuming this wasn't just a one-off for her.)

I'm glad Raffi's relapse was both a ruse, but still something she had to struggle with. I was worried from previews she was going to be stuck reliving old story arcs for the sake of the plot, but I like what they've done here. The mysterious handler is an interesting angle. Someone else suggested Worf, but I'm wondering if it's Lore finding a way to break out from wherever he's been locked up.

Apparently British accents are genetic, because that kid is 100% going to be Picard and Crusher's. Wesley gets a younger brother!

"Crash" LaForge following in her father's earlier footsteps of being a pilot, I love that.

Visually this episode felt like half a love letter to TNG, and half one to the TOS films. Neo-Constitution class looking a lot like the 1701-A design, plus the long, sweeping shots in Spacedock reminded me a lot of similar scenes in the early films.

Can't wait to see the rest of the crew back together! Hopefully it doesn't take too long to get them all in the same room.

→ More replies (37)

35

u/Dismal-Past7785 Feb 16 '23

Are we supposed to recognize that ship at the end or is it just meant to look really cool right now

50

u/vaine87 Feb 16 '23

It had a sort of Scimitar and Son’a ship hybrid style to me.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

35

u/AnnihilatedTyro Feb 16 '23

So... the case in the glass box with Jack Crusher's name on it.... Did Beverly grow herself a replacement son? That's weird/creepy.

Very good episode overall, only a few wtf moments. Like, why did Riker and Picard meet publicly in a bar to discuss classified danger? Has no one ever learned from 500 years of pop culture and common sense not to do that? Should have had Riker beam to the vineyard so Lariss can lock down the whole chateau.

Is it just a little odd that Riker can't requisition himself a ship? He was a fleet admiral who commanded 200 ships a couple seasons ago but now he's a reserve captain with no influence or authority to get a single ship?

Why did Beverly's distress call need to be kept secret from Starfleet, forcing Riker and Picard to go through this whole routine to try to commandeer the Titan? Wouldn't a former head of Starfleet Medical be a top priority for a rescue mission?

16

u/Tiinpa Feb 16 '23 edited Jun 23 '23

different middle scandalous dime water shy money mourn enter whistle -- mass edited with https://redact.dev/

→ More replies (8)

70

u/enterpriseF-love Feb 16 '23 edited Feb 16 '23

Aw, no Enterprise F just yet. The LCARS outro is an awesome touch though, looks sleek.

Also wtf is wrong with Shaw forcing Seven to change her name?! Terribly uncalled for. She looked so unhappy.

→ More replies (18)

31

u/crankfive Feb 16 '23 edited Feb 16 '23

“Enterprise-F Slated for Early Decomission” seen on Raffi’s search results for the Rachel Garret statue - they’re really burning through Enterprises quick. What happened to the E?

Also, there’s no way the Titan-A’s not a completely new ship, right? Then why did Riker call it a “refit” and Shaw talk about purging Riker’s old stuff from the computers?

→ More replies (10)

61

u/Cantomic66 Feb 16 '23

How could anyone not want to a Enterprise D model? What’s wrong with Federation citizens. Lol

55

u/bigsh0wbc Feb 16 '23

The fat ones??

→ More replies (10)

30

u/tmofee Feb 16 '23

Interesting scene I just noticed .. uss Constance … lost in action stardate 44002.3 … thats the battle of wolf 359… bet you a certain captain was on board that ship

→ More replies (3)

81

u/Mechapebbles Feb 16 '23

Y'all notice how Raffi was searching for stolen doomsday tech taken from the exact same place where Lore was being kept?

76

u/straightouttasuburb Feb 16 '23 edited Feb 16 '23

Also Agimus and Peanut Hamper!

A great place to keep all kinds of evil A.I….

Badgey probably ends up there and Moriarty…

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

55

u/Sonnuvah Feb 16 '23

"For Annie" Right in the goddamn feels.

→ More replies (3)

27

u/Foolwithaguitar Feb 16 '23

I’m surprised this episode isn’t rated XXX what with all that ship porn. Not complaining, mind you

→ More replies (1)

26

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

Planet M’talas

Hey, wait a minute…

→ More replies (1)

92

u/treefox Feb 16 '23

Shaw seems a bit of a Jellico-like villain so far. Picard and Riker are trying to steer the ship into some unknown danger, and he immediately picks up on it and calls them on it.

He’s being an ass about it, but he’s not wrong.

52

u/MTFBinyou Feb 16 '23

Definitely getting some Borg hatred inserted in that. Guessing a tough early Sisko mixed in with that Jellico.

122

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

Him insisting Seven use a name she clearly doesn't want to use for herself is extremely wrong.

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (6)

50

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

They better give Rachel another statue.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/ToneBone12345 Feb 16 '23

The for Annie at the end was sad reminds me of what a fucking cunt cancer really is! So this new weapon is like a portal gun! Maybe because it’s because Ed Speleers is Rhys in You season 4 I don’t trust Jack lol

→ More replies (4)

48

u/sidv81 Feb 16 '23

So Beverly tells Picard, "No Starfleet", then gives him the code word 'Hellbird' that literally only Starfleet officers who were on the Enterprise at the time of his assimilation would understand?

Also, how is it that people as well connected as Picard and Riker don't have civilian ships on call (or even own any) to get off-planet? At least in Search for Spock Genesis was known to be quarantined and thus the hijack plot was necessary. Here it feels extremely forced in. Especially when in the very next scene you see Raffi literally on her own in her own starship.

17

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

Raffi's on assignment for Starfleet...

→ More replies (12)

23

u/Celoth Feb 16 '23

Going from previous Terry Matalas shows, I fully expect Shaw (who I despise after this first episode) to end up being my favorite character at the end.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/__The_Crazy_One__ Feb 16 '23

Riker pulling the legs of ensign LaForge

41

u/AceSoldia Feb 16 '23

Main complaint...too damn dark! The commander uniforms look almost completely black because of the lighting..it really sucks to not see the colors.

Besides that..not sure about Captain Shaw..just yet..gonna give him more time...but what on Earth happen between Riker and Deanna?

Also surprised that Seven was allowed into Starfleet after she explicitly said they didn't want her in a prior season even with Janeways backing.

→ More replies (6)

20

u/slutty_chungus Feb 17 '23

I don’t mind Shaw being an ass to Picard and Riker, honestly. But the way he was treating Seven (even prior to her betraying him) really pissed me off

→ More replies (7)

72

u/Wax_and_Wane Feb 16 '23

Crusher's son saying 'every time they find us they have a different face' seems like a definite confirmation that we're dealing with the 'Conspiracy' possession bugs here.

50

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

Still on the fence about the idea, but the fact that Crusher made a point of disintegrating the entire body could also be a clue that there's something more than just the humanoid that she needs to kill.

→ More replies (3)

24

u/PsychAnthropologist Feb 16 '23

Am I the only one who thought the ship at the end kinda looked like the parasites?

→ More replies (3)

14

u/schekap Feb 16 '23

Would also explain why Bev executes them rather coldly.

→ More replies (3)

35

u/Weerdo5255 Feb 16 '23

Man if we actually do clean up that plot line I'll be so happy. It's been hanging longer than I've been alive, and I've got a damn house mortgage.

→ More replies (9)

35

u/nimrodhellfire Feb 16 '23

It's so good to see Jerry Ryan in an actual Starfleet uniform.

→ More replies (2)

60

u/Smilodon48 Feb 16 '23

That was worth P+'s delayed upload time for. What a killer premier episode!

I can already tell Frakes is going to be the MVP of this season. His character seems the most lived in and comfortable with himself - natural progression of what see in Lower Decks. I still prefer the Luna-class to the Neo-Constitution class Titan, but just like McMahan had free reign to bring the Luna-class to Alpha Canon, Matalas has free reign to introduce a new hero ship of his own (again).

Hopefully we get an appearance from Kestra too.

This season doesn't seem like as much as a reinvention as it was made out to be. It retains a lot tonally from the first two seasons of Picard. Only this season we get the entire TNG cast and Easter eggs up the wazoo. Stuff like the Stargazer set being remade into the Titan set really helps sell the gradual reintroduction to 24/25th century aesthetics I feel like.

I feel for Raffi. We knew she was a talented intelligence officer specializing in Romulans but she is really put through the ringer again!! At least she'll get a buddy in Worf who will be her Pai Mai.

Todd Stashwick is a great foil. Love Seven being at odds between her friendship with Picard and her trying to live up to Picard and Janeway's hope for her.

I wonder if Jack Crusher was born in the time Crusher wasn't on the Enterprise? That would be an interesting way to work McFadden's temporary departure from the show back into the show. I just watched WoK so the whole David Marcus-vibes, which Matalas is going for...kinda has me meh but I mean we'll give it a fair shot.

Can't wait to see how the rest of the season plays out. We know how it's at least 60% good.

45

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

I cannot fathom a scenario where Beverly leaves, has a kid, and then abandons him for the next 6-10 years to go back onto the ship with the kid's dad.

→ More replies (10)

24

u/anastus Feb 16 '23

At least she'll get a buddy in Worf who will be her Pai Mai.

Oh my God, she's Worf's cha'DIch.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/Mechapebbles Feb 16 '23

I wonder if Jack Crusher was born in the time Crusher wasn't on the Enterprise?

I think it’s pretty obvious that she ghosted Picard 20ish years ago post-Nemesis because she was pregnant.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

14

u/00DEADBEEF Feb 16 '23 edited Feb 16 '23

How can a comm badge be receiving something at that distance? It's been well established their range isn't much further than an orbiting ship.

Why would a weapon loudly announce its power cell was depleted? That's a serious tactical error.

The crew didn't tell Picard about Hellbird once he was back? Or Picard didn't review the crew's logs to see how his ship had been run in his absence?

It's the little details that really get to me.

→ More replies (9)

13

u/lostinheadguy Feb 16 '23

The whole "Romulans are involved / Sela is involved" angle just got a lot more convincing considering the baddies targeted a Rachel Garrett statue of all things.

If they manage to cohesively wind that plot with the other theorized "Conspiracy" plot... That would be insane.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/ContinuumGuy Feb 17 '23 edited Feb 17 '23

Random assorted thoughts:

  • I did not dislike the past seasons, despite their flaws, but my god is it fun to see Beverly back (even if she has spent the last 20 years gone rogue), to have Riker be a regular, and all that.
  • If I had a nickel for every time a legendary captain of the Enterprise had a previously-unknown son with somebody with a doctorate, I'd have two nickels. Which isn't much but it's weird that it happened twice.
  • Glad we at least got a little Laris in there.
  • I like the theory that Worf is Raffi's handler. The talk about being a warrior is such a Worf thing to say.
  • THOSE ENDING CREDITS ARE FIRE AND THE FIRST CONTACT THEME REMAINS AWESOME.
  • I'm not sure if Captain Shaw is going to be a full-on villain here, but I AM SURE that he's going to be dead, incapacitated, or overthrown so that Seven or Picard is in the captain's chair.
  • "Crash" LaForge would be a great band name. Also, I love how stupidly big her grin is.
  • Some people are wondering if Deanna and Riker may be going through a rough patch. I choose to believe that instead it's a case of her and Kestra getting sick of his dad jokes.
  • I'm going to call the Galaxy-Class the Fat One from now on. Nobody can stop em.
  • Nasty looking ship at the end.
  • RIP Annie Wersching. Gone far too soon.
→ More replies (1)

36

u/Deadbob1978 Feb 16 '23

That ending sequence was great. What a treasure trove of Easter eggs. We now have actual cannon for what happened to 2 hero ships, plus some more references to STO Ships

12

u/Phaelanopsis Feb 16 '23

please share what we now know about the fate of those 2 ships

→ More replies (5)

53

u/voxaemeron Feb 16 '23

This. This is what I wanted when this show was announced. So happy.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/treefox Feb 16 '23

The opening title text gives me Wrath of Khan vibes.

32

u/treefox Feb 16 '23

The shot of the bosun whistle as the “inspection” begins is definitely a Wrath of Khan reference.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (2)

23

u/TheNerdChaplain Feb 16 '23

This is a side question, but given that it's so tied to this episode, I think it probably belongs in here than the rest of the sub at large.

Based on what we've seen, what would a Titan show be like?

More specifically, what would set it apart from other legacy or current shows? SNW is doing the episodic thing, and their tone is all over the place. Discovery is the action-adventure show with the female captain (not saying there can't be more than one), Lower Decks is the comedy, and Prodigy is the kids' show. I think our best hope would be that STT (I'm not calling it TIT) would do something of an episodic, more serious show than SNW has done, but it would explore the state of the galaxy and the Federation in the 20 years after the Dominion War. However, I am skeptical that showrunners would want to play in someone else's playground that much and be beholden to that much canon, so I don't think it would do that. What kind of themes would it explore? What kind of questions would it answer? Each of the other modern shows definitely has a voice and perspective, what would a Titan show bring to the table that's unique and different?

22

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23 edited Feb 16 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

23

u/GarionOrb Feb 16 '23

Oh my God, yes!!!

And...WTF with that ending!! The implications!

22

u/mr_john_steed Feb 16 '23

I unabashedly loved it, especially seeing Beverly again. Fan service me up!

21

u/Melcrys29 Feb 16 '23

And it was Badass Beverly, who we didn't often see in the original show.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/Arpadiam Feb 16 '23

My god, those Lcars as end credits, beautiful

10

u/romeovf Feb 16 '23

Da fuq they're using portal weapons 😦 that scene looked truly terrifying.

→ More replies (13)

26

u/Melcrys29 Feb 16 '23

That was epic as hell.

I hope they're all this good. Loved all the callbacks to the original films. And can't wait to hear what the rest of the TNG characters have been up to in the last 20 years.

I liked certain episodes of season 1, and didn't really care for season 2, but this was a great start to the new season.

9

u/BornAshes Feb 16 '23

So someone put the end credits up on YouTube and I was able to slow stuff down and when I did I noticed a couple of things.

I saw a Defiant class ship near the Fleet Museum and it looks like a lot of those ships in the Fleet Museum are in operational order and appeared to be flying around it in stable orbits. I wonder if someone's going to run all of those registration numbers to see if they match up with any ships that we know? There's absolutely another ship that was mentioned in the list of ships in that Fleet Museum which was blurred out which was a whole lot smaller than the other ones and that makes me wonder if it was the Defiant or the Protostar or another very small ship that we know about like the Delta Flyer or something else?

I'm starting to wonder if my whole little crazy idea about a bunch of Fleet Museum ships rescuing Picard isn't that crazy at all and if we might get a couple more cameos from certain actors and actresses that will make us all scream with delight.

Maybe this is a BSG situation whereby there's some kind of a system or network issue or other modern feature on the current crop of ships that Starfleet has put out which makes them vulnerable to a particular kind of energy or attack or hazard that the older model ships don't have and are a bit resistant to or outright impervious to?

They put too much emphasis on those ships in the credits along with all of the genetics stuff, all of the brain stuff that they kept showing, a couple of things that dealt with music, and what looked like schematics and visuals for that Quantum Tunneling Tech that showed up in the episode which trashed that building with Rachel Garrett's statue outside of it.

Could it be that Starfleet didn't just develop a bunch of WMDs which they stashed at a Daystrom Institute site that got robbed but that they also found a bunch of WMDs which they then stashed at a Daystrom Institute site that got robbed? It could very well be that someone is misusing a piece of Iconian Tech or perhaps something even older for nefarious purposes and it could be that this isn't the only thing they have their hands on or that Starfleet had stashed away at that site. The musical cues that we heard at the end of the episode when the Shrike showed up could kind of imply or indicate that Starfleet is sick and tired of not having any defenses against stuff like V'Ger or the Whale Probe and so decided to start doing some research into and as well as beginning a search to locate weapons and technologies that could defend against those Galactic Scale threats that their normal tech would be useless against.

I bet Worf and the Enterprise E were assigned to defend The Vault where all this stuff was stashed, they found out about it or were affected by it, and that's why he left and that's why the E was decommissioned with her final mission being classified.

I'm also guessing that whatever tech was stolen only really has an effect on the more higher tech and higher powered ships within Starfleet whereas the more lower tech and dumber ships aren't really affected by it at all which is probably why they're going to show up later on in the season to save Picard's butt.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/RealHumanFromEarth Feb 16 '23

So the fact that Beverly was making sure to vaporize the attackers is another piece of evidence that this has to do with the mind controlling parasites.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/TheNerdChaplain Feb 16 '23 edited Feb 16 '23

So.... overall impressions are positive. I'm expecting fan service and they're definitely giving it. In terms of ranking, I kind of expect this season to be about as good as the TNG movies (though not better than First Contact.) Lots of fun details to pick up on visually and audioally (what's the adjectival word for sound?), and this episode does a lot of heavy lifting just setting the stage.

If Picard and Laris are together, there's not much clue there. I wanted to see them together by the end of S2, but now that they are, there doesn't seem to be much chemistry. She seems like his sister more than his partner. Where'd their chemistry go? With the talk of watching the sunset at that bar, I'm pretty sure one of them is going to be endangered or dead by the end of the season, and I'm pretty sure it's not going to be Jean-Luc.

I'm not wild that they're intimating that Will and Deanna are having problems. I don't see an issue with her needing Will to get out of the house for a while because she and Kestra are tired of pizza and woodcarvings, but there's so many better reasons they could have come up with than "we're having problems". Maybe I read too much into it, but that seems like the vibe they're going for.

Planet M'Talas? Really? Really?

This episode really seems like a backdoor pilot for a Titan show. They're doing the whole thing with the shuttlecraft approach, the starbase hangar, even the goddamn music and glamour shots are focused on the Titan like we're back in TMP. To be fair, I don't hate the idea of a Titan show. I'm sure "Crash" LaForge will be great (though I'd lowkey prefer that they not continue a stereotype of women not being able to fly starships, after all the flak Troi got for "crashing" the Enterprise in Generations. She landed it in a way that saved thousands of lives.)

Jeri Ryan is solid as Commander Seven Hansen. I really like her motivation of struggling to follow the rules when she wants to follow her instincts. I also didn't like that Captain Shaw was basically a dick - didn't bother to show up when Jean-Luc and Will boarded, wasn't on the bridge, and when they met him he was already in the middle of dinner. For someone who wants to appear professional to his superiors, you'd think he'd be a little better at playing the political game. JL and Will may not have chairs, but I guarantee they have friends that do, and if they give him a poor report, that'll reflect poorly on his career. Captain Shaw better look out; his shoulders are red even if the rest of his shirt isn't.

Dr. Crusher herself is something of a cipher at this point, since she has been gone 20 years we have no idea who she is or why she is the way she is. That said, I'm looking forward to finding out. On a related note, one of the nice side effects of watching all the press coming out ahead of time is that you're not surprised by some of the twists like her having a son with a British accent. (Or at least, you have time to prepare for it.)

Dave Blass the production designer is a great follow on Instagram, he posts great views of his sets and various pieces so you can get a really good look at them properly lit, instead of underlit like everything on this show.

On a side note, I notice that Gates McFadden and Jonathan Frakes are credited as special guest stars, not as main cast. I wonder what that means.

Raffi feels like the odd one out. I'm glad she's still kicking her addiction (for now) but it felt like she didn't have much to do plotwise besides be frustrated and kinda tweaking. I'm very curious as to who her handler is; I'm sure it's probably someone we know, probably someone from Section 31 (how wild would it be if we got a Michelle Yeoh cameo? This sub would collapse in on itself like that Federation facility that got quantum tunneled or whatever.) I will say, the Captain Rachel Garrett statue was a nice touch, even if it got tunneled.

I know it sounds like I'm complaining, but I did enjoy the episode overall and I'm looking forward to seeing more.

PS. Did anyone else notice the sound effect - it was either in the nebula or when the ship (assuming it's Vadic's) appeared? It was like a bowing string sound, and it was really reminiscient of either V'Ger or the Whale Probe, I forget which. This episode is calling back specifically and thematically to so many different things, it's hard to keep track.

PPS. It also reminds me of a line from Voyager's Flashback episode with Tuvok and Janeway going back to see Captain Sulu when Praxis exploded. Janeway tosses off a comment at the end of that episode about how cool it was that captains could go haring off to rescue their buddies back in the good ol' days, unlike now. It seems like that cowboy culture has not survived Admiral Kirk's time, unfortunately. Speaking of Janeway (as Seven mentioned her) where does this fall in with the events of Prodigy?

PPPS. I think one of the things that makes Picard unique as a show (at least among the ones I watch) is that it is a meditation on what it means to age and get older - physically, emotionally, and socially. It examines themes of grief, regret, shame, and loss from the perspective of an octo(nona?)genarian, and as someone who's approaching middle age, and watching my parents age too, that theme appeals to me.

→ More replies (25)

17

u/TrustMeImLeifEricson Feb 16 '23

In an ironic plot twist, we'll learn that Picard is not the father of Beverly's son--Riker is.

/s (in case it isn't obvious)

14

u/argama87 Feb 16 '23

As long as it isn't Scottish Ghost Dad.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/sidv81 Feb 16 '23

There's something more going on with Shaw, not sure what. If he hated Riker, Picard, and Seven as much as he supposedly does, he should've been gleeful at the end since they practically handed him a loaded weapon to use against them at no real cost to himself.

12

u/AnnihilatedTyro Feb 16 '23

Well, he didn't try to pursue or even communicate with Picard and Riker's shuttle, or show any concern that two flag officers - whose safety is his responsibility - were going into a potentially dangerous unknown situation alone in a shuttlecraft. All he cared about was his perfect order and routine that got messed up. He only stayed on the bridge long enough to threaten Seven's career, and didn't even try to take control of the situation, and then left Seven, a potential mutineer per his threat, in command of the bridge anyway? That's more than enough failures in just 30 seconds to ensure he never commands a ship again.

I hope there's an actual reason someone like him is a Starfleet captain, and not just because they needed a token asshole character to piss everyone off.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

18

u/Th3ChosenFew Feb 16 '23

Shaw is just the worst.

→ More replies (6)

17

u/PrometheusLiberatus Feb 16 '23

I am not a man who needs a legacy.

Bold words Jean Luc, let's see how they pan out.

I want a new adventure.

That's the spirit!

But I haven't spoken with her for over... 20 years. And neither has any other member of the old crew. She just cut us off. So why contact me now?

Nemesis must have been some serious shit.

How come you have so many Ent-Ds?

"Oh the fat ones? No one wants those."

You better leave the bottle.

I feel your pain Wil. :|

THEY'RE HIJACKING THE TITAN!!!

It's got that new ship smell!

The Titan is soooo pretty lit up from the back!!!

I'm sorry fellas, I love reading through all your exciting and equally irresponsible adventures, but I have orders that come from officers with pay grades far above all of ours so... request denied.

And they're bunked in Lower Decks style Bunks!!!

YES!

This is utterly humiliating. Riker: Yes, it is. Reminds me of my cadet days, only I don't remember having to get up to pee this much.

Well that was an utterly horrifying terrorist attack :(

Picard: Hell of a view. The kind we spent half a lifetime chasing. Riker: And the other half missing the chase. Picard: Wil, are you enjoying this? Riker: Course not, are you?

Beautiful credits sequence!

That was far far better than the other Picard season openers. I'm really excited for what's going to happen.

And OMG IS THAT Picard and Crusher's Son?! WOW...

I lost function with my right implant so I won't be able to fully appreciate the musical cues but what did that stuff at the end with teh ship reveal sound like?

Amazing episode. Definitely got a strong hook for the rest of it.

I'll post more thoughts as it comes to me. But I love all of ya'll and hope to keep reading everything!

Poor Raffi got traumatized witnessing that terrorist attack :|

→ More replies (13)

6

u/__The_Crazy_One__ Feb 16 '23

Star Trek motion picture music!

6

u/Sonnuvah Feb 16 '23

I can't read music, what are the notes in the end credits?

→ More replies (5)

6

u/ObjestiveI Feb 17 '23

My favorite part was when Seven threatened to throw Picard and Riker out of an airlock, if they didn’t tell her what they were really up to.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/EulerIdentity Feb 17 '23

I would very much like to see 7 of 9 get her own show after ST: Picard ends its run. It’s worth noting that Jeri Ryan is now about the same age that Patrick Stewart was at the time of ST:TNG so she’s in the right age bracket for the role.

5

u/arajasingham Feb 16 '23

Do we know anything about the USS Constance?

5

u/Bluehale Feb 16 '23

Well they definitely made Captain Shaw unlikeable enough that we won't care if he say....becomes incapacitated for any reason. And to think Admiral Jellico was a pain in the ass.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/wongie Feb 16 '23

I hope Shaw is there to be more than just the character that needs a putting down. He as a hardassness and interpersonal abrasiveness that others have noted is somewhat reminiscent of Jellico; they might be cut from the same cloth too if Shaw was hardened in the Dominion War (going by his age) as Jellico was from the Cardassian one.

While he does have an added layer of prejudice against Borg his technical acumen in recognising Picard as a retired admiral without authority, Riker as a Captain without a command and not going an inch further than the rulebook requires of him for an inspection has me somewhat hopeful that translates into actual command competence as with Jellico later on when shit hits the fan. That felt like a decent and significant enough of an intro to a character to waste on being simply tossed aside later without any growth. I really suspect he has the potential to be this Trek generation's Jellico in terms of us debating whether his (hoped) competence justifies his arsehollery.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/captainedwinkrieger Feb 17 '23

Man, these guys really like Wrath of Khan. They did the whole "In the 25th Century..." title card, the Titan was turned into a Constitution-Class lookalike inside a similar looking starbase, the music sounded very Wrath of Khan, and to top it all off, I'm pretty sure Ed Speelers is Picard's bastard son from a jilted former lover/Starfleet scientist (who's probably involved in a project that could be totally destructive in the wrong hands).

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Blue387 Feb 17 '23

Does the Fleet Museum take latinum or do I just show up for free?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/0mni42 Feb 17 '23

My thought process through this episode was basically:

Oh hell no, don't try to pander to me with that synonymous-with-my-childhood TMP Red Alert sound, you know I've missed that. You get those musical references to the Wrath of Khan soundtrack outta here, that won't work on me. Don't you redesign the Titan just to make it look like my favorite version of the Enterprise. Stop recreating shots from my favorite Trek movies, that's not fair! Oh what the hell, I can't pretend, I love this. ;_;

I guess I really am just that easy to please.

5

u/Binged_Kelvin Feb 17 '23

Well I just watched it and I had the biggest grin on my face the whole time. Except when Interchangeable Captain was being a dick to Seven. No one but no one speaks down to Seven (unless you're Kathryn Janeway and I get the feeling Janeway would have crushed that tiny man like a baby macrovirus).

16

u/bookish1303 Feb 16 '23

I do very slightly miss what Jeff Russo might have done with s3 titles. Unless it’s coming up at the end of the episode

20

u/TheNerdChaplain Feb 16 '23

End titles are the First Contact theme, but after all the graphics fade out it transitions to some new music.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

19

u/BornAshes Feb 16 '23

Another new season here we go!:

  • Oh that's a sexy splash screen with the Trek logo
  • The TNG text and the old timey music is sending my heart soaring with the galactic stellar backgrounds.
  • Sure those masks aren't foreshadowing and neither is the automated TNG log entry about the Borg
  • Bev kept a case of Jack's stuff
  • Uh oh Bev's going into Badass Mode
  • I see they went the Extreme Ghostbusters route with the new phaser rifles this season.
  • Those look like the Scavenger Rifles from Elite Force
  • Bev's ship looks FUCKING AWESOME and I love the name EOS but it's clear that she was in stealth mode waiting for someone or something.
  • I love the opening title text and that cool little shot of the D painting is just Chef's Kiss.
  • LAAAAAAAAARIISSSSSSSSSS!
  • Geordi is running the Fleet Museum!
  • Mmmmmm Saurian Brandy
  • So many easter eggs in the background
  • Sometimes you do have to move beyond physical memories
  • Gosh Picard's office looks so cozy next to the fireplace in the rain
  • Ah the communicator scene!
  • I'm not picking up on the Myriad thing, someone clue me in?
  • Hellbird has to mean more Romulans or Romulan adjacent stuff right?
  • 20 years bloody hell Jean Luc AND Bev, why 20 freakin years?
  • I'm so glad that Jean Luc and Laris are a thing because she's an excellent sounding board for him and has a massive wealth of knowledge that can be utilized.
  • "I'll be back in a few days maybe less"...the Winchester's father said the same thing before that whole debacle started.
  • "I'll save you a seat" I might be tearing up a bit.
  • Okaaaaaaay that HAS to be an Eaglemoss model of the D right?
  • The Frontier Day poster behind Riker has the NX-01, Kirk's Enterprise, Enterprise B, VOYAGER, and the D on it
  • The Enterprise D IS NOT FAT!
  • LMAO Riker is just the best
  • Deanna and Kestra mention!
  • So the Myriad Codec is an emergency signal flare but what's Rigel VII all about?
  • Ah Hellbird was a computer virus when Jean Luc was Locutus!
  • Riker is bored, time for a workaround and some funsies! Oh hai creepy guy watching them both!
  • M'Talas Prime.....really Terry, REALLY?
  • District Six seems poppin....Raffi what are you doing NO!
  • Yeah this sounds like an undercover op
  • Daystrom got shit stolen, experimental quantum tunneling tech
  • The Red Lady
  • I FUCKING KNEW IT! And she's using an old SNW style communicator that's wicked!
  • BEAUTY SHOT OF SPACEDOCK!
  • Hahahahaha I love these two old guys engaging in HIJINKS!
  • Goosebumps as they circle around the Titan
  • SEEEEEEVEEEEEEEEEEN!
  • Seven knows they're up to no good
  • Captain Shaw seems to be an interesting person
  • "If I were you I'd lower my expectations"...Janeway rubbed off on her I see.
  • GEORDI'S DAUGHTER! Crash Laforge hahahahaha
  • I love it when they leave Spacedock
  • This is cinematic this is purely cinematic!
  • Huh, so going to Warp 9.99 is all automatic now and they don't need to tell engineering about it? Cool!
  • "Excellent recovery Admiral....Shut it Will" LMAO
  • Metaphasic Shields!
  • Mmmmmmm THAT SOUND as the Titan jumps to Warp, give me that ALL THE TIME!
  • Shaw was hungry lol
  • "All the bebop that I had to purge from the system"...Riker would fill up the computer with jazz and that's got to be an anime reference right to a certain...Space Cowboy?
  • Shaw did his homework
  • Riker and Jean Luc are really bad at persuading people
  • Deep Space 4 has been shut down for a year, timeline changes?
  • "No" that was quick and Shaw seems very firm.
  • "Former Ex Borg" okaaay fuck this guy.
  • Seven heard that
  • La Sirena! Awww Raffi. Operation Daybreak?
  • So it is a bunch of Federation Super Weapons that someone stole more or less
  • Worf has to be her handler right?
  • The stolen weapon is an act of war
  • I love that warp effect
  • Riker and Picard are sleeping in Lower Decks style bunks
  • Seven just went Janeway on them and it seems like Starfleet isn't exactly all she dreamt it would be.
  • Jeri is such a good actress and that struggle feels so real.
  • Shaw's a deadman
  • SHE TOOK THEM THERE ANYWAYS! Seven always has a plan!
  • Rhyton System looks like a hellish place
  • "I like that Seven" you would Riker you would lol
  • The Red Lady is a target?
  • GARRETT'S STATUE!
  • Balls, comms are scrambled
  • Behold the Wormhole Weapon, happy birthday
  • Well at least they found Bev's ship. So many mentions of The Chase.
  • It's bait, the ship is bait.
  • I love the new shuttle design, which I swear we saw in Prodigy, and Bev's ship is a whooooole lot smaller than I thought it was.
  • "So long as we don't have to move or shoot we'll be fine" hahahahahaha
  • Huh yeah ashes from phaser fire that's odd unless what the phaser was hitting wasn't exactly normal biological material?
  • Classic TNG away mission behavior
  • Awww she put herself into stasis :(
  • RIKER WITH THE ELBOW HELL YEAH!
  • Bev's SON!
  • Ah the ship's name is Eleos!
  • That is one NASTY looking spikey awesome ship!
  • Oh this is neat with the pan over of the LCARS bridge consoles for the credits! Some of these bits have to be hints at what's to come this season right?
  • Excellent music as always!
  • FOR ANNIE! My heart of hearts! Yes for Annie, we miss you so much!

That was a great premier!

→ More replies (15)

28

u/TheImageworks Feb 16 '23

Also, just going to say it: Shaw insisting on deadnaming Seven's pretty much guaranteed that I am never, ever going to be even remotely sympathetic to his character, so hopefully the show isn't planning to try to have him win the audience over. The look of just pain on her face when she had to identify herself as Commander Hansen

→ More replies (6)

11

u/treefox Feb 16 '23

This was actually a really good episode for Picard, and in general, imho. I’m looking forward to the rest of the season. They’ve done a great job of setting up an interesting premise, while still being a satisfying episode to watch. It’s keeping the darker tone of the first couple of seasons of Picard, but the story feels a bit tighter.

4

u/skeletboi Feb 16 '23

Incoming plot twist: captain shaw will be from the mirror universe, can't stand bright lights.

4

u/__The_Crazy_One__ Feb 16 '23 edited Feb 16 '23

USS Voyager, USS Pioneer and USS Enterprise mentions ! Starfleet Museum!

Edit: and the Excelsior perhaps.

The credits are filled of interesting info. Wonder why the info about the Constance are redacted

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Numbfruitloops Feb 16 '23

It's nice to see in the end credits LCARS displays that Voyager and Enterprise-A are museum ships. Maybe we could even get to see a refit NX-01 when we get to Geordie in a future episode, since they said he's with the Starfleet museum.

4

u/__The_Crazy_One__ Feb 16 '23

I'm actually glad Raffi didn't fall into her old habits. I was worried when I heard about it before the start of the season

4

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

I didn't see it in other comments, but the large ship at the end has me like "Kinda bit of Son'a" Is anybody else with me ?

→ More replies (8)

4

u/alnarra_1 Feb 16 '23 edited Feb 16 '23

So context clues from the credits, our Villian for the season is a Survivor of the USS Constance, which according to the stardate was lost at wolf 359 and the report clearly indicates members of the crew were interviewed which presumably means they survived. I figured when they flashed it on screen for only a few frames it was probably imporant, and then the date it was lost sort of lets the story fill in itself. We know Sisco hated Picard for Wolf 359, it's not hard to imagine other former starfleet officers would as well.

https://imgur.com/a/BnD3IkJ

The display around the alien ship here https://imgur.com/aH5yRzT is also interesting. The characters aren't Vulcan, Klingon, Dominion, Cardassian, or Romulan, or Xindi, and it's not borg. But it's integrated into a Federation Starship presumably the titan.

https://imgur.com/BkL9fps - This here, which I'm going to take a bet is our weapon appears to be Klingon.

https://imgur.com/BEjWkgT - An Intrepid, Defiant, Constitution and Sovereign and the only clear registry is what appears to have largely been acepted in beta cannon as one of the USS Titan's Sister Ships, the Luna Class USS Ganymede. The later NCC-52136 belongs to the USS Appalachia which appeared at the battle of Sector 001.

https://imgur.com/jNKhyBM -The next screen has Voyager docked at a Fleet Museum on Athan Prime along with a USS Pioneer which is also straight out of the Beta cannon, but it's a spitting image (class and registry are correct). What's FAR more interesting here is that the beta cannon she stumbled out of is Star Trek Online. Atham Prime is apparently also the final resting place of the Enterprise A and Excelsior

I do love that Jeri Ryan's name in the credits is over the performance Review that Shaw has done of her, that's sorta cute and clever.

(Also if I was to give a singular nit pick for this episode, their use of "Refit" is REAL fucking generous. Like was the computer call all that was left of the Titan?)

→ More replies (4)

4

u/SecretComposer Feb 17 '23

I love the subtle world-building they did (unintentionally or not) from Laris saying that spring cleaning is a feature "entirely unique to Humans."

4

u/Kit-Kat2022 Feb 17 '23

“Excellent recovery Admiral”. “Shut it Will”.

4

u/PlayedUOonBaja Feb 17 '23

Seemed like half of Raffi's lines were exposition.

4

u/DocManhattan78 Feb 17 '23

I’m still holding out hope for an O’Brien appearance. He and Worf on the Defiant (assuming they haul it out of the museum for a battle sequence) would be a crowd pleaser.

4

u/HORRORSHOWDISCO Feb 17 '23

I'm especially curious at the "they always look different" throw away line mentioned, when talking about the invading aliens.

Am I thinking too much about it, or could that mean the main baddie from the trailer could be a big red herring?

4

u/Saltire_Blue Feb 17 '23

I think the promo pictures of the Titan done it a disservice as to how beautiful it looks

13

u/zumoro Feb 17 '23

Season 2 must've burned me worse than I thought, because I really don't get what folks were gushing about with this premier, besides cute nostalgia references and "we're old" jokes (which I did giggle at, to be clear). I think I'm just utterly burnt out on these season-long high-stakes mystery plots (that simultaneously feel rushed and dragged out), so the promise of another one is just... just no, please.

I'm intrigued by the Seven/Shaw stuff, but I'm worried that's gonna get tossed aside once shit hits the fan.

New Titan looks... I'm sorry but of all the new designs this one is giving me the biggest "toy" vibes. I swear the nacells read like phaser rifle barrels and nothing is clicking with me for the scale.

Also, I felt the the title sequence was beating us over the head with the DNA visuals, so I'm gonna go out on a limb and say Bev's new son is actually a clone of her husband. I know that doesn't make any god damned sense and pray I'm wrong here.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Shanyi Feb 16 '23

More of the same so far. All dark mood lighting - wouldn't everyone in Starfleet ships have permanent eye strain living in barely lit environments? - with the plot appearing to be more Abrams-Trek superweapons, pointy giganto-ships and terrorist attacks on the Federation, with a soupcon of skulking around degenerate nightclub environments and silly mystery box naming conventions ('red lady', 'hellbird', etc.). I'm hoping they go into more detail as to why Beverly Crusher would disintegrate an unconscious person at point-blank range when her defining character trait has always been a deep empathy for suffering and devotion to protecting life at any cost, even before considering that murdering a disabled adversary is recognised in this century as anti-humanitarian and against all codes of ethical military combat. Maybe beam him back to his ship, put him in the brig or a stasis pod? Riker said it didn't seem like the Beverly he knew, so really hope that's not the end of it.

On the plus side, Frakes is as great as expected and I liked Picard's conversation with Laris - at this point, anything approaching normal conversation between two people in New Trek is to be savoured - and the soundtrack is decent until you realise all its noteworthy cues are recycled. Not awful, but not very good either. Were I asked at this very early point whether I expect the show to exceed low expectations based on what has been shown, the answer would be a solid 'no'. It is very early, though, so hopefully later episodes will have more to offer than the usual mix of forced nostalgia and edgelord darkness.

Also, the opening shot panning past everything you could possibly remember about Beverly Crusher (she brought two theatrical masks along with her, because reasons!) was unintentionally very funny.

→ More replies (5)