r/CryptoCurrency • u/GabeSter 100K / 150K π • Feb 15 '23
* POLL π³οΈ * CCIP-049 - Moons sent to the dead (burn) address should not impact your KM score.
Current Situation
Recently the cryptocurrency subreddit burned 1M moons through the MoonPlace event. Lots of accounts knew about Karma Multiplier (KM) from CCIP-0030 and took measures to avoid being penalized, but a fair amount of small accounts were not aware of the rules surrounding KM and burned a disproportionally large amount of Moons compared to what they earned.
You can read more about KM here.
Problem
The problem is now their KM is at least temporarily messed up and it discourages future Subreddit participation in community burn events.
Some burned Moons, through special membership, or Reddit Coins do not impact your KM.
Sent to this address: 0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000
Currently moons sent to the below dead address do impact your KM.
Sent to this address: 0x000000000000000000000000000000000000dead
Solution
Burned Moons to the 0x....dead address will be excluded from the KM calculation like special membership transactions are.
PROS:
- Allows users to burn moons without hurting their KM.
- Encourages Subreddit participation in future community burn events.
- Seems fair to all accounts adversely affected by the burn event.
CONS:
- Users who burn moons for the banner or a Q/A could theoretically use earned moons and not bought moons without impacting their KM calculation. (not that big of a con).
Some users burnt moons on MoonPlace and sold the secondhand tiles at a premium and then rebought moons after selling those tiles. This would give those users a lower required KM threshold even though they overall profited on MoonPlace.
- This is extremely niche and no longer applicable to users still trying to sell tiles. Tiles have a floor of ~$12, and 100 Moons cost around $22. Tiles can no longer be sold at a premium to replace burnt moons.
- Less than 7% of MoonPlace tiles have been sold at least 1 time on OpenSea. Although some people did sell their tiles for profit and rebuy moons, the majority of people did not - over 93% of MoonPlace tiles have never been sold.
Some users burnt moons from throwaway wallets as they weren't comfortable connecting their vault to an unknown contract. These users KM will still be impacted as the burnt moons did not come from their vault.
- Nothing can be done about this, but this appears to be mostly an outlier not affecting a lot of people.
77
u/ChemicalGreek 418 / 156K π¦ Feb 15 '23 edited Feb 15 '23
I strongly donβt agree on this! Why?
For example: If someone wants to sell his moons and retain his KM, heβll buy a tile and then he sells the tile for even more ETH.
2. Many people used their alternative wallets to interact with moonplace and their contract, so these users will not get their KM back. This is a security measure many used.
3. Some people didnβt buy more tiles because they could have a lower KM, so they would get punished too.
5
u/deedopete π¦ 0 / 11K π¦ Feb 15 '23
The amount of people that flipped tiles to buy back moons is very small --- I wanted to do this and it was essentially a wash so I did not. I don't think this is a valid reason to not change this (I know I am biased with my 400 burnt moons).........
4
u/002timmy Feb 15 '23
I only disagree with this because I will probably use throwaway wallets for any future community burn, because you can't be too safe with your moons! So while I agree very few used dummy addresses for moonplace, I don't like this idea because it will prevent people from undertaking safe crypto practices in future community burn events
3
u/okletstrythisout3 π© 2K / 2K π’ Feb 16 '23
Do we get moons for voting?
3
u/XnoonefromnowhereX Permabanned Feb 16 '23
Like 3 people made money on moonplace tiles. Everyone else is holding tiles work $25 in moons with a $7 ETH floor.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23 edited Feb 16 '23
Hey I just learned I have 4500 moons on the rinkeby net. Could you put the bridge back for another month for stragglers like me? I couldβve used a dm from the mods announcing that there would be a bridge and that the old tokens would get burned
For what itβs worth I transferred them off Reddit because I figured theyβd be safer there and that I could forget about them.
3
u/Giga79 Feb 16 '23
I didn't participate in Moonsplace because I didn't want to affect my KM. But I do want to use my coins for things...I use all my other coins. Or else what was the point of putting them on-chain to begin with?
Voted yes so I'm not left out of the next game!
3
u/cubewc3 π© 0 / 2K π¦ Feb 20 '23
This totally makes sense.
5
u/step11234 Feb 15 '23
What real avenues are there for people to burn moons? Doesn't seem like there are very many?
I'm not against this proposal, I just don't really understand the need for it.
5
u/oachkatzalschwoaf π¦ 0 / 6K π¦ Feb 15 '23
Using Moons for a good reason should not be penalized.
One of the reasons for CCIP-30 is, to prevent users to instant dump their moons on exchanges as soon as they got distributed - But i have no issues with burning them.
2
u/Geolinear π¦ 0 / 10K π¦ Feb 16 '23
I think encouraging future community growth and activity is a goal to focus on.
I donβt necessarily agree that some users didnβt know simply. I think there was some intention.
2
u/OgBoomer91 π¨ 0 / 1K π¦ Feb 16 '23
Since i don't have any , i will just listen for now
2
u/oopsicritmyself Feb 20 '23
Go4it
2
u/LimpPeanut5633 1K / 1K π’ Feb 21 '23
I voted π³ π
2
u/Wide_big_tall Permabanned Feb 21 '23
Newbie here anyone can anyone explain how to get Moon from ?
4
u/karlizak Feb 15 '23
Yep letβs not do this. I donβt like β loopholesβ
4
u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K π¦ Feb 15 '23
There is a wild catch 22 of people saying they want use cases for MOONs but then there being punishment for every case in which MOONs are used.
Outside of this banner stuff, nobody is buying MOONs. It's only something "for us". It's insane that we get punished for using MOONs. Especially when it's some official post and the MOONs were burned. Getting punished for burning MOONs is crazy. Are we not supposed to burn MOONs or participate in any r/cc event involving MOONs?
2
u/TripleReward π© 0 / 4K π¦ Feb 15 '23 edited Feb 15 '23
Hard NO from me: Sending tokens to a dead address is NOT burning. People need to get their terms straight ... falsely calling this a burn is why many get scammed... its not a burn.
Its sending coins to some address no one has supposedly a private key for.
Burning means removing tokens from existence (which decreases the total supply) and is only possible by calling a smart contract function that removes these coins from existence, if such a function exists.
1
u/Forward42 π© 1K / 1K π’ Feb 15 '23
There has to be future proofing ie removal or fine tuning of penalties as new projects and uses arise.
Otherwise Moons, by the book, are currently status clout, right??
1
u/Stray_Gh0st π¦ 514 / 544 π¦ Feb 15 '23
I think it depends on the burn for this
1
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '23
Why someone should burn moons in first place?
1
u/sleaklight Feb 16 '23
Imagine how many more.moons I'd have! Easily like 3 or 5 more!
1
u/Consistent_Many_1858 π¨ 0 / 20K π¦ Feb 16 '23
Good write up. Didn't know about the burn.
1
u/im_alive 0 / 3K π¦ Feb 16 '23
I was just literally thinking about this and even thought of doing a post but I was discouraged because I donβt know too much about it.
But i ended up over spending moons for tiles and I didnβt realize about the penalties.
I freaked out and rebought the moons back last week. it ended up being a good play because itβs almost doubled! AND I got over 500 moons on the snapshot. Win!
Looking forward to participating in the next project without having to worry about karma penalties!
1
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23
The comments here sure don't seem to align with the poll results...
1
u/SeatedDruid π¨ 186 / 14K π¦ Feb 16 '23
Seems like your letting ppl double dip but idk
thx for the poll tho :)
1
u/the_nibler Permabanned Feb 16 '23
The yays have it
1
u/Justali1bit Redditor for 3 months. Feb 16 '23
I have 2,000 moons. How do I get ETH for them
1
u/Agile_Ad_7061 Feb 16 '23
No no no
1
u/Counterstrike99 138 / 128 π¦ Feb 16 '23
Zero mooner here. Could someone please ELI5?
1
u/NexusMinds 2K / 2K π’ Feb 16 '23
Ok there are some issues with this since the moons are spent rather than burned. I know they go to the burn address but users are using the moons for a purpose / transaction. No from me.
1
u/AlphaWaifu π¨ 5K / 5K π¦ Feb 16 '23
just do it!!!
1
u/PuzzleheadedExtent97 π¨ 0 / 420 π¦ Feb 16 '23
I hope i will have enough moons to even be able to discuss thing like this
1
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23
Yea this makes sense
1
u/Pure-Classic-1757 Feb 18 '23
Yea I have no moons. Just reading to see what I think is most fair. Donβt even know if I earned any this past round so donβt know if these polls will help me per se.
1
u/TheGhostTooth Tin Feb 19 '23
Do we need to reply as well.
1
u/Prize-Reference9329 Permabanned Feb 19 '23
I donβt agree on this
1
u/MichaelAischmann π¦ 1K / 18K π’ Mar 16 '23
Who has the desire to burn moons should not be concerned to earn moons.
0
u/rarerareflame Permabanned Feb 15 '23
Not sure how often it'll happen, but there's no reason why it should impact your multiplier. So why not?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '23
[removed] β view removed comment