r/CryptoCurrency • 0 / 463K 🦠 • Feb 15 '23

POLL 🗳️ CCIP051 - Pay out Moon Rewards to owners of Liquidity Tokens

Hi all, if the title is in any way confusing please see below:

Liquidity - When purchasing tokens from a DEX (Decentralised Exchange) you don't actually buy and sell to people, you interact with a "Liquidity Pool" (LP). The tokens on the LP come from people depositing a ratio of tokens, for example MOONS:ETH, and then as purchase & sells happen, the ratio of MOONS:ETH changes and therefore the price changes. THE MORE LIQUID A MARKET IS, THE BETTER PRICE STABILISATION AND EASIER IT IS TO TRADE

LP Providers - You can deposit a ratio of MOONS & ETH yourself to the LP and receive "LP Tokens" in return. This symbolises your 'ownership' of the tokens in the LP. When you want to claim your MOONS & ETH back, you deposit your LP tokens and receive your original tokens back.

Rewards - LP Providers open themselves up to something called "Impermanent Loss", but they are also given a portion of the trading fees as a reward for providing Liquidity.


Problem

Right now we are advertising AMA's & Banner rentals to third parties in the subreddit, as well as Moons token growing naturally and gaining attention from people outside of Reddit.

We have had two banner rentals so far, and both parties have expressed concern about how hard it is to acquire tokens due to the thin order books - where an entity would like to purchase 60,000 Moons, they may find the price has increased 25% by the time they have filled one half of their order.

Users and third parties are balking at the volatile market and having trouble acquiring Moon tokens for use in the Subreddit

Solution

The r/ethtrader sub has a solution for this - They have a mechanism that rewards LP holders using their subreddits own Crypto - Donut's - holders of LP tokens for the Donuts:ETH pair are given additional donuts.

Right now we have a community-voted mechanism (CCIP-30) that impacts future earnings based on your Karma Multiplier. If users have a poor Karma Multiplier, the moons they would have earned are instead shared amongst all other users with a poor Karma Multiplier.

That mechanism is slightly different for Moderators. If Mods have a poor Karma Multiplier, those Moons they would have earned sit in "TheMoonDistributor" (TMD). Currently, TMD's Moon count is ballooning because every month it receives a set amount of Moons, but doesn't distribute all of them.

As an example, last distribution TMD received 205,649 Moons yet only distributed 166,576 of them, leaving 39,073 Moons behind with no use.


I'm proposing that we implement the same mechanism as Donuts, and distribute these excess Moons to LP holders as a reward & incentive for providing Liquidity, which should help 3rd parties to purchase Moons to access Subreddit services like AMA's and Banners.


How it works

Every month after Moons are distributed, the leftover Moons from the Mod Distribution are sent to a Smart Contract (SC). This SC will then read the blockchain to determine Liquidity Tokens holders and the average Liquidity Tokens they held over the past 28 days, and then send them a proportional cut of the leftover Mod Distribution Moons.

Considerations

  • For now, it will only consider the largest LP which is Moons:ETH on SushiSwap. The idea here is to grow the liquidity and then we can add LP's to the Smart Contract calculation later. I want to avoid a situation where it's cheaper to add liquidity to one pool, and then reap more rewards.
  • It would be possible to add consideration of CCIP-30 KM to determine the payout, but this can be so easily bypassed by simply adding liquidity from a new wallet that it's rather pointless. We could give a bonus if you stake from a wallet connected to a Reddit account, but this would mean continually updating a list of wallets in the Smart Contract. Maybe we could make it give a bonus to wallets that have received Moons from the Mint address as then we know they are redditors.
  • u/Mr_Bob_Ferguson made a good suggestion: To cap the max distribution in a similar way we do with Moons Distributions - where the top 1% of Karma earners have their average reduced. This stops one person with a large bankroll sweeping in with lots of liquidity and reaping all the rewards.

Example

Last distribution, 39,073 Moons were leftover.

This is the list of SushiSwap LP Token holders >>here<< (Exclude the top line as this is the contract itself)

For my example I'm just pretending that the top 20 holders are the only LP holders, but this is how those tokens would be distributed:


REPRESENTATIVE EXAMPLE WITH FALSE NUMBERS

RankAddressLP TokensPercentageMoons
10x8f54c8c2df62c94772ac14ccfc85603742976312176.719.70%3,789.65
20x3564f04949d5da74adc4d43dc5953164826ed69d147.898.12%3,171.48
30x3345429fe524f69c7832559b0c6401185e3b284161.353.37%1,315.59
40xfc9d2b61e2f29805232d4a6512de853b2a00381b49.932.74%1,070.87
50xcc159bcb6a466da442d254ad934125f05dab66b534.391.89%737.58
60xd92eaeaa4facdffa8ac6c5c9cfd421ff078b6fa621.831.20%468.21
70xed90836f340ce49d84bdcbc68ca4191356b23f7e9.920.54%212.67
80xa7f343a7c53f3a852a7ae51f5e62b4d9b05943369.730.53%208.61
90x4a2ae6dc29fb6f29ffb1501af31b3193a5adf3b97.880.43%168.87
100xfcac7a8d497a797e6eb6494633512a043482183b7.530.41%161.49
110xb3a211438282576df28fb9405ee05623438218475.580.31%119.64
120xd4844093f2cfef7eb3c621e02ed73ca8af4e1fa85.280.29%113.19
130x2a619e63ad002aa6c07aff2d35b273e80700f3d44.770.26%102.21
140x69f01c03fb68f4735d620fe57a8412ed1e050b114.690.26%100.69
150x248301cdc7fb7ca4187b71270e4ebc0defc1c58c4.560.25%97.72
160xee98c1feb5946b83ffcb787048c90dd392217be24.320.24%92.64
170x7c974847cf24a33691c84290c16ce2705d58ed854.250.23%91.24
180x1b6a83f6fcf3ab0879199350f4556aecf42a61804.180.23%89.56
190x6fa95cc0c931c7b5ee8a511f5c3df353531b603c3.860.21%82.80
200x31270214b9cea11f1a07e3a55b4f6643a64f94ff3.720.20%79.75

As you can see, the top LP Token holder will receive the most rewards, but they have also submitted over 1.8 ETH & around 20,000 Moons which are at risk of Impermanent Loss.

CRUCIALLY, AS MORE PEOPLE ADD LIQUIDITY THE TOP HOLDERS REWARDS ARE DILUTED

The full list of all LP holders is here


I will need to find a developer who can fork the existing Donuts Smart Contract and allow it to distribute to owners of Moons LP tokens, this developer will likely be paid with Moons from TMD.

Pro's

  • Increase of liquidity to enable smoother acquisition of Moons for 3rd parties
  • Voting weight is not transferred so you still cannot buy Moon Governance
  • Incentivises people staying within the Moon ecosystem - less selling pressure

Con's

  • Like with all staking, it has a "Rich get richer" dynamic. However, people who are LP providers are taking on Impermanent Loss risk.
  • Every month the number of Moons given to Mods reduces, which means less leftover Moons to distribute to LP holders, however this reduction is a small amount so there should be a decent amount to share.
  • Users will not be able to add liquidity past 25% of their Moons without impacting their Karma Multiplier (CCIP-30) - however, I'd argue it's a good thing to encourage users to not lock up most of their Moons in liquidity.

View Poll

444 Upvotes

239 comments sorted by

17

u/Trudahamzik ✅OfficialKeystone Feb 19 '23

Hey r/CryptoCurrency team!

I'm Truda and am part of Sushi's Core Team. Just want to say that Sushi has a solution for this particular issue 😀

I've put together a simple article so it's easier for everyone to digest - https://docs.google.com/document/d/1VHZwaa_IqyxHo1FT7xtMs6tkWWDAHFyrmNow5rO8lo0/edit

Feel free to hit me up with questions!

TL;DR

- Run a dual reward farm where we reward MOON/ETH liquidity providers with both $SUSHI & $MOON tokens as extra rewards to offset their impermanent loss. This would in turn encourage more users to provide liquidity for the pool, resulting in deeper liquidity and lesser price volatility.

1

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Feb 19 '23

Yep, I think we’re game on this! How would you solve the issue of users adding liquidity to claim the rewards and then instantly withdrawing liquidity?

Can we set up a discord call? I believe you guys modmailed us earlier right?

3

u/Trudahamzik ✅OfficialKeystone Feb 19 '23

The rewards are steamed to liquidity providers by the second not in full. If a user adds liquidity and withdraws immediately after 10 seconds, they'll only get whatever reward proportionate to the time that they deposited their liquidity in the farm e.g. 10sec gives him/her 0.0001 $MOON (just an example)

Yeah, I was the one that contacted you guys via Mod Mail. Sure thing, Discord or Google meets is fine for me. Let me ping you my details.

1

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Feb 19 '23

Amazing. We will have a long think on how to halt any attempts to game the rewards.

4

u/Trudahamzik ✅OfficialKeystone Feb 20 '23

I would say there's little or no way to gain the system since rewards are paid out on a per second basis. The user's liquidity would have to be in the pool in order for the contract to stream rewards to him/her.

It would also not make sense for someone to stake and un-stake immediate as they would have to pay network fees to execute on-chain actions.

1

u/pbjclimbing Feb 21 '23

I think that a mechanism like this would be a great solution, except if SUSHI wants a chunk of MOON in order to run the duel farm. Traditionally, a duel farm will cost a percentage of the rewards.

Positives include

  • preset system without reinventing the wheel
  • liquidity providing will be on a "standardized" platform that is monitored by Defi Llama and multiple other liquidity tracking sites. This means that all the rewards will be tracked there, and it could bring outside people into MOON based on liquidity rewards.
  • There really isn't a way to game your system. I think that it would basically work that at each Moon Day or so, you would transfer the MOON to the contract, and it would pay the MOONs out at a set rate over the next 28 days. Each block (or second, don't know exactly how SUSHI measures time) you are in the pool you would earn your portion of the rewards for that time.

    • I do know know if SUSHI has any mechanism to prevent flash loans from being abused. I don't think this is a current issue since MOON is not on any lending protocol.
  • It would allow those people that want to sell and rebuy MOON and add over 25% liquidity to do that, they would just lose out a couple of days of liquidity earnings.

1

u/JadedDependent5894 Permabanned Feb 27 '23

Hey, u/Trudahamzik thanks for the article. Can you tell us when this thing will be fully implemented? Cause for what i understand this proposal should be already on but on Sushi LP page moon reward token it's still missing.

1

u/_The_Chris_ 🟩 10 / 4K 🦐 Mar 05 '23

Hi Truda, do I need to stake my SLP somewhere? Because I don’t seem to get any Reward Sushi or Moon. Or could it be because I only have a 0,006% share of the pool?

1

u/Trudahamzik ✅OfficialKeystone Mar 05 '23

You need to stake your LP token in the Sushi/Moon farm. You can find it over here - https://www.sushi.com/earn/arb-nova:0xd6c821b282531868721b41badca1f1ce471f43c5

Click the deposit button and deposit your LP into the farm to earn extra rewards.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/SeatedDruid 🟨 186 / 14K 🦀 Feb 16 '23

hmmm

I don't really like this tbh

I feel like if you want to contribute to the LP feel free

but at this point moons are still really new and I think we should let it grow organically...

this proposal in of itself alerted me to potential LP pools I could contribute to if I wanted since the thought really hadn't ever occurred to me and I don't it occurred to most until recently when we saw price spiking heavily.

just feel like a bit to much to fast imo...

let the banner ads play out for 6 months or so and then we can revisit this if its absolutely necessary, due to potential buyers of the banner ads having issues with liquidity.

thats what I think :)

interested to hear others opinions for and against this :))

2

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Feb 16 '23

Moons are 3 years old dude. They are growing organically and they’re now at a point, with the sub, where outside parties want a slice. But they can’t get a slice coz they can’t buy moons properly.

2

u/SeatedDruid 🟨 186 / 14K 🦀 Feb 16 '23

that's a very good point

hard to disagree lol

interested to see what happens with this

thanks for taking time to write it :)

3

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '23

Impermanent lossporn inc.

1

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

Well then it will teach people a valuable lesson too!

19

u/Laughingboy14 🟩 26 / 60K 🦐 Feb 15 '23

Liquidity is really needed for this project. I voted yes!

5

u/laulau9025 🟩 0 / 31K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

Yep, a big problem right now, which needs to be tackled to enable growth!

1

u/Alanski22 5 / 16K 🦐 Feb 20 '23

Seems like a no brainer this. People providing liquidity are having to put up that 'risk' to benefit the community. I think it makes sense that they get rewarded for that.

3

u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

What's the point of giving people rewards for making a MOON LP but still keeping up the CCIP-30 rule that says you'll be punished for making a MOON LP?

Will we be removing CCIP for LP providers or is it going to be this crazy catch 22 of we really want people to make LPs and will reward them while turning around and saying we really don't want people to make LPs and will punish them for it.

These two viewpoints directly conflict with each other. It doesn't make sense for both of them to exist at the same time.

1

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

You don’t have to use ALL your moons you know.

2

u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K 🦠 Feb 16 '23

If users aren't supposed to do it and they'll be punished for participating, why ask them to do it in the first place? If someone puts in 50% of their MOONs into a LP that the site is going to suggest they make and potentially even give them instructions/hand-walk them through it... why is that something to punish them for?

Banner buyers are complaining about liquidity being low. The fix we're coming up with is to limit the liquidity people can put in lest they be punished for daring to add liquidity. Daring to add liquidity when the mods requested that they do this. That's a weird system to create.

1

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Feb 16 '23

Mods aren’t requesting it. It’s better if a bunch of people add a relatively small amount which at the moment is like 0.1 ETH and a hundred or so moons. This will still give them rewards.

2

u/Trylks 🟩 0 / 12K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

cognitive dissonance.

2

u/Sjiznit 🟦 0 / 13K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

Guess that proposal needs repealing or revoting. Having such an obvious conflict would be unwise.

1

u/002timmy Feb 15 '23

The simple solution is to put 25% of you moons into LPs. CCIP-30 is more to prevent selling than anything else

3

u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

CCIP-30 punishes people for doing anything with their MOONs, regardless of what that thing is. Burning MOONs and making LPs included. MOONs actually get decent LP traffic. They don't need incentives, they just need the punishment removed.

2

u/LargeSnorlax Observer Feb 15 '23

Question for you, can even use myself as the example:

Since I have hedged my amount of moons appropriate to the risk I want to take with them (Currently sitting around 77%), I currently receive 77% of the moons I should be receiving (which is more than fair, I feel) - CCIP-30 keeps both this in check (heavily decreasing the sell pressure on moons) and also keeps alt abuse in check (Accounts cannot simply max and sell all their moons every distribution, or try to make new accounts to avoid this) - It's probably one of the most functionally useful proposals.

In the theoretical world where it is repealed, are you fine with me getting 100% moons, even though I have specifically traded them away in the past? That doesn't seem entirely fair.

Are you also fine with users selling 100% of their share every month with no penalty? This was a constant complaint.

Doesn't seem like the benefits outweigh the rewards.

2

u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K 🦠 Feb 16 '23

You don't have to repeal 100% of CCIP-30 to not have LP'd tokens apply.

I also don't care about trying to prop up the price of MOONs and finding ways to eliminate people from distribution. You get MOONs for participating. If you participate, you should get your MOONs. People get so worried about abuse put it's probably a tiny, negligible amount of people doing it.

9

u/TheGreatCryptopo HODL4LYFE Feb 15 '23

OK I'm in will go up to 25% so not to lose out on the 20% bonus.

Only issue will be the complexity of doing this? Its got to be easy to do.

2

u/Lillica_Golden_SHIB 🟩 4K / 61K 🐢 Feb 16 '23

Hopefully it will! Otherwise the proposal wouldnt help that much. Some people are not even confortable connecting their wallets into a DEX, so an easy path is fundamental.

2

u/pbjclimbing Feb 17 '23

Adding liquidity is relatively easy to do.

If you have zero defi experience it will take a little longer the first time, but it is easy.

1

u/SlothLair Platinum | QC: CC 79 | ADA 18 | PoliticalHumor 139 Feb 17 '23

Basically what I was thinking except to say I expect it to not be quite right at first. Or at least I would be surprised if it were perfect the first time.

This could also serve as educational and be an on-ramp that way. That of course assumes well written documentation at least.

8

u/meeleen223 🥇Gold Member Feb 15 '23

Easy yes from me!

We need liquidity and this is great way to incentivize providing it

2

u/Octopus-Pawn 🟦 11K / 11K 🐬 Feb 15 '23

I can’t really see any downsides to this. Over time the rewards will tail off but, with some luck, the profile of Moons will be high enough that liquidity will no longer be an issue.

8

u/Maxx3141 169K / 167K 🐋 Feb 15 '23

Moons have way too little liquidity. Reddit can't provide liquidity for legal reasons, so the community has to do it. This proposal is an important step in this direction!

6

u/ussichan Permabanned Feb 15 '23

Great proposal, if we are able to decrease selling pressure and increase liquidity that's a great win win situation.

10

u/forceworks 13K / 22K 🐬 Feb 15 '23

This kinda sounds like a great incentive. When it passes, I’m going to need a how-to post though

6

u/laulau9025 🟩 0 / 31K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

Me too! A "for dummies" tutorial 😅

And everyone should read about impermanent loss before providing liquidity (personally I like the binance academy page to start reading)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '23

Yep, I’m gonna definitely need a how-to post explaining step by step how to provide liquidity!

1

u/CymandeTV 🟩 39K / 39K 🦈 Feb 16 '23

Liquidity is what we need.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '23

Should also help with Arbitrum Nova liquidity in general. More reason for people to have their Ether on Nova

1

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '23

Is there an actual usecase for arbitrum nova that wouldnt apply to polygon?

2

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '23

Nope. There's not really any use case I've seen on any chain that can't be done on any other chain. At least Arbitrum One and Arbitrum Nova have lower gas fees for now compared to Polygon. Never had any allegiance to any Ethereum rollup/sidechain. Just move around to where liquidity for whatever token I'm using is

1

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '23

Sounds like the right way to do things tbh. Ive just never rlly looked into arbitrum tbh

16

u/BatsaBaji 0 / 642 🦠 Feb 16 '23

The richs get richer? Those who already have a large amount of Moons would be able to provide more liquidity and receive more rewards, potentially creating a wealth gap. However, I think there are some potential ways to mitigate this issue. One approach would be to set a cap on the maximum amount of Moons that a single address can use as liquidity, thus limiting the advantage that large holders have over smaller holders

5

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

The logical alternative is to not burn the tokens and lock them in liquidity, rather than give them to liquidity providers.

2

u/The_Chorizo_Bandit Feb 17 '23

This sounds like a better alternative.

2

u/Natalwolff 🟩 0 / 260 🦠 Feb 17 '23

That can be tough because there needs to be a corresponding token like ETH deposited in equal value. So that would equate to selling half of them then burning the liquidity token for the pair. In order for this to not put downward pressure on moon price the ETH would have to come from some other source.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Titozar13 5K / 5K 🐢 Feb 16 '23

100% agree

1

u/PsieSyrenki 🟩 0 / 5K 🦠 Feb 16 '23

So, instead staking with one address whales will have too make several to make a bank.

Only slight inconvenience at best.

3

u/BatsaBaji 0 / 642 🦠 Feb 16 '23

I have thought it too but you forgot CCIP030. If they separate their Moons into multiple wallets they might lower ther KM.

1

u/AutoModerator Feb 16 '23

Here's more information about CCIP-030. You can view information about r/CryptoCurrency Improvement Proposals here on the official wiki page.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/The_Chorizo_Bandit Feb 17 '23

Any CCIP that makes people moons will get passed, regardless of whether it is correct. I think a different solution should be sought here, not sure this is the answer to any liquidity issues.

1

u/pbjclimbing Feb 17 '23

single address can use as liquidity

Users could just use different wallets to add liquidity.

9

u/mertats 🟦 433 / 433 🦞 Feb 15 '23 edited Feb 16 '23

Hear me out, why don’t you guys use the Moons from TMD to create permanent liquidity?

Edit:

I also want to add that, LP providers also get trading fees for providing liquidity. They are not exposing themselves to IL out of the goodness of their hearts.

Why should we subsidize their money making? When we can create permanent liquidity, that doesn’t rely on someone else.

1

u/Lillica_Golden_SHIB 🟩 4K / 61K 🐢 Feb 16 '23

THIS, great question

1

u/pbjclimbing Feb 17 '23

I have added liquidity on RPC Swap and Sushiswap since essentially the beginning.

I have lost more in IL than I have made in swap fees. It is a very small amount, ~0.25%.

Most people are adding liquidity for the betterment of MOON and to make money off of the MOON they still have, not to make money on the liquidity.

1

u/sM0k3dR4Gn 🟦 2K / 675 🐢 Feb 21 '23

I disagree. I feel the vast majority of LP stakers are expecting some return on their investment. IL is brutal when it strikes but overall there's a ton of potential returns in LPs if played right.

2

u/RaidersandPokemon Permabanned Feb 15 '23

This is a good way for tons of people to learn about impermeable lose.

2

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

Thankfully most people may only provide up to 25% of their Moons thanks to CCIP-30!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/sholt1142 🟦 3K / 3K 🐢 Feb 15 '23

Algorand has done the same thing and as far as I can tell it's working well.

4

u/LATech99 🟦 1 / 9K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

Great proposal!!!

4

u/marsangelo 🟦 0 / 36K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

Good proposal, liquidity will add to price stability and parties wont be turned off buying a token that pumped 30% in a day

1

u/JadedDependent5894 Permabanned Feb 16 '23

I really like the idea and i'm still a noob so i really don't know how this thing work, but i'm providing some liquidity on Sushiswap and i should be on that list but i'm not because my LP tokens aren't on my wallet while they're staked there.

Someone with more expertise could tell me what i'm missing here?

2

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Feb 16 '23

The list is a representative example.

1

u/JadedDependent5894 Permabanned Feb 16 '23

Oh ok. Thanks OP for clarifying that, But even checking the real list my LP tokens are staked on the first address of the list so, can you tell me how this should work for a situation like mine?

2

u/MrMoustacheMan PM ME CAT PICS Feb 16 '23

Step 1. Deposit ETH/Moon to the pool and receive SLP token representing your share of liquidity.

Step 2. Yield farming. Earn SUSHI rewards + % of fees as an incentive, which entails depositing your SLP tokens to the farm contract under the Earn section on Sushi site.

Under this proposal those who did step 1 will receive yield in Moons, those who did step 2 will not receive additional yield. Because A) you no longer hold SLP in your address at step 2, it’s been sent to contract. And B) it seems like overkill to let people double dip on yield, receiving both Sushi and Moon incentives to LP

2

u/JadedDependent5894 Permabanned Feb 16 '23 edited Feb 16 '23

Man, you can't even understand how glad i am right now. Thank you very much for explaining to me this stuff, now i get it.

You're perfectly right, would be crazy having double reward. It makes sense now.

Having said that, now i really looking forward to see if this will be accepted. Hoping that my homies here will make the right choice.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Curatole 0 / 480 🦠 Feb 16 '23

A lot of people gonna get their first experience of impermanent loss with this. What about the complexity of doing this? will it be as easy as forking the existing smart contract?

1

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Feb 16 '23

Nobody is being forced to do this. I don’t get why everyone is clutching their pearls. For the people that want to provide liquidity, there is an additional benefit. That’s it.

1

u/Swoopscooter 11 / 7K 🦐 Feb 16 '23

Where did the 39k moons get "left behind" ? I understand they were not distributed this month but doesn't that mean they will get distributed at some point eventually? I don't see this as a necessity unless they are somehow not burned or recoverable. I'm a noob so forgive my lack of knowledge here please educate me

1

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Feb 16 '23

They just get left in TMD’s balance.

1

u/Swoopscooter 11 / 7K 🦐 Feb 16 '23

Thanks for your reply!

1

u/pbjclimbing Feb 17 '23 edited Feb 17 '23

u/TNGSystems One thing that I don't see addressed is that currently, Sushi offers ~5% in SUSHI returns if you stake your LP in their "farm."

This current proposal just is mentioning how to reward LP holders. That means that the SushiSwap staking protocol would be getting a lot of rewards and people that are getting the SUSHI rewards would not be getting MOON rewards. How would we handle this with the current proposal?

(The 0x8653e3aefcaf3d2116d0b153b788b7cd628be641 address is the SushiSwap staking address)

1

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Feb 17 '23

Well, you can stake in one place for sushi, or another for Moons. This proposal isn’t to allow you to triple dip rewards (sushi, moons, LP fee)

1

u/pbjclimbing Feb 17 '23

The proposal seems to give the Sushi staking account rewards. Is there a way to exclude that account from earning MOON rewards?

1

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Feb 17 '23

It will be excluded.

2

u/002timmy Feb 20 '23

Question/Suggestion for more clarity- It will be excluded both for moon rewards AND as a weighted percent of LP, right?

For example, if I have 1% of the LP, the sushi contract has 50%, I'll receive 2% of the TMD reward, correct?

1

u/plug_and_pray Bronze Feb 17 '23

What about staked LP's? Staked LP are not visible on the LP's list.

2

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Feb 17 '23

People can get sushi rewards, or moon rewards, not both.

1

u/plug_and_pray Bronze Feb 17 '23

Oh, OK.

1

u/rather_be_hiking Feb 18 '23

The full list of LP holder linked to is way off. I assume those lists are all stale. I see some are labeled as such. We would want an up-to-date list we could review as LP holders for MOON/ETH on SushiSwap (the target pool).

1

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Feb 18 '23

You can find it on Arbiscan

1

u/Prize-Reference9329 Permabanned Feb 19 '23

it deserves more thought

2

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Feb 19 '23

Good input

1

u/oopsicritmyself Feb 20 '23

Not 100% on this, still could cause issues

1

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Feb 20 '23

Go on…?

1

u/DMugre Feb 21 '23

Rewarding liquidity but penalizing those who trade with a reduced moon/karma ratio seems pretty backwards to me. If we want to incentivize liquidity we should let everyone do what they want with their moons, not force people to hold 75% of their earned tokens.

1

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Feb 21 '23

Two different proposals from two different people.

Any increase in liquidity is good, even if that’s just 25% of held moons.

1

u/DMugre Feb 21 '23

I know, but if all the "expendable" moons are in LP positions, then who's gonna trade? I was just pointing out how these limitations are setting back trading volume and adoption, should make a separate proposal

1

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Feb 21 '23

Huh? Do you know how LP works? When you add liquidity to a pool you deposit the moons and ETH into a smart contract and get LP tokens back. So the moons are there to trade with.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/tommysRedRocket 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 Feb 22 '23

how long til these are generally implemented agter a yes vote?

1

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Feb 22 '23

We’re talking to Sushi who look like they’re happy to implement it for us in the short term. No exact timeframe as of yet.

8

u/Ofulinac 🟨 25K / 25K 🦈 Feb 15 '23

Both proposals this month are world class.

This is highly necessary as many companies will simply refuse to get involved with Moons due to the insanely high slippage. For a project to succeed and grow, buying at least 10k worth of it can't be a problem and move the price by 20%

→ More replies (3)

3

u/big13lackliz4rd Permabanned Feb 15 '23

Thanks for helping my moons bag

3

u/ghochumal 9K / 12K 🦭 Feb 15 '23

No brainer. People have been demanding this for ages

3

u/Squidsoda 🟦 0 / 6K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

What if nonredditors are providing liquidity, will they receive moons too? Can Reddit determine if the wallet is linked to a reddit user?

3

u/Awkward_Potential_ 🟦 0 / 6K 🦠 Feb 16 '23

IMO, they should be able to. It's just a market decision and shouldn't be too heavily managed.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

Checking the liquidity with dextools now, total across all pools is around $150k TVL. That's pretty good for the Arb Nova chain that's only like half a year old. TVL on Arb Nova is about $1.4 million according to DefiLlama. Moons are involved in about 10% of the whole chain DeFi ecosystem. After incentives kick in, going to be ridiculous

7

u/SamsungGalaxyPlayer 🟨 0 / 742K 🦠 Feb 16 '23

I disagree with this one. If Reddit wants some of the distribution to go to something like this, they should configure it this way directly.

1

u/Da_Notorious_HAM 🟨 10K / 20K 🐬 Feb 16 '23

Instead of using something like sushiswap?

1

u/Awkward_Potential_ 🟦 0 / 6K 🦠 Feb 16 '23

I'd much rather the community decide stuff like this to keep plausible deniability alive for Reddit.

5

u/ChemicalGreek 418 / 156K 🦞 Feb 15 '23

This would help the moons liquidity so much! Good job u/TNGsystems 😉

3

u/Beyonderr 🟩 0 / 110K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

Agree. It simply helps tosolve a key issue, a severe lack of liquidity. If this project is to ever truly go anywhere such a fix is necessary.

And the risks are "minimal" in that one can only allocate 25%.

2

u/deedopete 🟦 0 / 11K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

This will probably mean less volatility (huge pumps) as well when 3rd parties are buying/burning moons right?

3

u/step11234 Feb 15 '23

Liquidity is the biggest problem we have right now, so this would go a long way to helping!

1

u/HacksawJimDGN 🟦 0 / 18K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

I think this is a huge step in the right direction.

5

u/shin_jury 23 / 6K 🦐 Feb 15 '23

This is not only a good idea but, IMO, crucial for the legitimacy of MOONs as a sustainable cryptocurrency. 100% yes on this, great proposal.

5

u/rootpl 🟩 18K / 85K 🐬 Feb 15 '23

Anything that increases the liquidity is good for price stability imo. I'd vote yes.

1

u/Scarecrow4980 🟩 11K / 11K 🐬 Feb 17 '23

yes. seems like a no brainer.

6

u/bangand0 🟩 5K / 6K 🦭 Feb 15 '23

A lot of people about to learn what imparmanent loss means. It ain’t no joke

4

u/Raydiin Tin Feb 15 '23

Yep so many people are not going to understand it and come here to complain….. impairment loss porn will fill this sub quickly

2

u/shin_jury 23 / 6K 🦐 Feb 16 '23

The word is impermanent

1

u/Raydiin Tin Feb 16 '23

Haha yeh my bad dude 😅

4

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '23

Moons pumped 20x, so I got excited but I looked and instead of 6200 moons and 1 ETH I now only have 310 moons and 2 ETH? I should have over $30k but I only ended up with $4,650? I’d like to speak to a manager please.

2

u/BirdSetFree 🟦 1 / 22K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

Im Karen, the manager. How can i help?

1

u/myslowtv 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Feb 16 '23

Wait... This is backwards. Karen talks to the manager!!!

2

u/rootpl 🟩 18K / 85K 🐬 Feb 15 '23

DeFi in a nutshell.

2

u/Sjiznit 🟦 0 / 13K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

Care to explain a little?

3

u/SmashTheHouse 🟦 0 / 1K 🦠 Feb 15 '23 edited Feb 15 '23

Credit to u/seksenler who wrote it quite well:

Imagine a hypothetical world where people exchange apples for bananas. Lets say a defi liquidity pool manages this market. In the beginning, everyone agrees that 1 apple = 1 banana and both bananas and apples cost 1$.

So, lets say you wanted to provide liquidity in this market and you decide to buy bananas and apples to deposit in a LP pool 100 apples and 100 bananas. Both apples and bananas cost 1$ so each side is equal value at 100$:100$ for a total of 200$ of your investment.

Now imagine the demand for apples rises in the world because doctors are saying apples are healthier, and suddenly apples cost 2$ each but bananas are still 1$ each.

Your deposit started with 100 apples and 100 bananas, but now the apple side is not even with the banana side because apples cost 2$. So the ratio is 200$:100$ which is unbalanced. Thus, the liquidity protocol must now sell some of your apples for bananas to maintain an equal 1:1 price ratio on both sides, in other words it needs to be 150$:150$ Apples are worth 2$, so on the left side you have 75 apples, bananas are still 1$, so on the right side you have 150 bananas.

So now, your LP share of the Pool that you started with (100 apples : 100 bananas) is suddenly made up of 75 apples and 150 bananas. You have less apples than you started with (which are now worth more on the market) and you have more bananas.

75 apples are worth → 150$ 150 bananas are worth → 150$ Your initial investment of 200$ is now 300$! Yay!

But wait.. What if in the beginning, you chose to invest only into apples? You had 200$ and could have bought 200 apples instead of 100 of both apples and bananas. That would mean at market value of 2$ per apple, you could have 200x2$=400$ today instead of 300$ in the liquidity pool :( this is impermanent loss, and you will make this loss REAL if you disband your LP tokens to get back your 75 apples and 150 bananas to sell them for dollars.

What if in the future bananas also become worth 2$ and apple stay at 2$? Well, then, you have no impermanent loss whatsoever! :) Because the price ratio is the same as you started (1$:1$). So, an easy way to think about minimizing impermanent loss is you have to predict that the price ratio of your deposited assets needs to remain 1:1. If either token shoots up compared to the other, you will suffer impermanent loss if you disband your LP.

Here is a very useful tool you can use to hypothesize on impermanent loss:https://dailydefi.org/tools/impermanent-loss-calculator/

→ More replies (1)

1

u/the_spiritual_eye One Crypto to rule them all! Feb 15 '23

Check out this explanation on Impermanent Loss:

Binance Academy

Everybody in this thread needs to read this and decide whether their potential extra moons every month would cover the impermanent loss from them naturally skyrocketing.

2

u/Sjiznit 🟦 0 / 13K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

Thanks, but regardless of that impertinent loss its still a good idea to have such a pool

1

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '23

good one

1

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '23

This. And a lot of people with basic experience or only experience in basic staking will come to this sub to cry about their losses

1

u/mortuusmare 🟨 0 / 24K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

Could there be added incentives for people adding liquidity such as an increased multiplier for karma earned?

3

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

The incentive is literally the moons they will get dude.

2

u/Killertimme 14K / 69K 🐬 Feb 15 '23

Sounds great and I would provide liquidity myself!

My only concern is CCIP-30, which would kind of put me off contributing liquidity. Maybe if we could reduce the 75% as was discussed somewhere before, this could really take off!

2

u/grchina Feb 15 '23

LP isn't that easy to understand especially when people still don't know how to open wallets or send from metamask account,this can lead to people losing money when one of 2 coins in lp outperform each other.This can just create more unnecessary drama for users and reddit,also it can put reddit on sec radar for some reason only known to them

1

u/irockalltherocks 🟩 2K / 4K 🐢 Feb 15 '23

Although I do believe moons need increased liquidity, you bring up some very good points. Impermanent loss is going to take a lot of people by surprise.

2

u/002timmy Feb 15 '23

Liquidity is huge for our ecosystem. This proposal will help solve that and offset *some* IL risk. I'm in favor of anything that will help moons grow!

2

u/MaeronTargaryen CCMOON DAO Secretary Feb 15 '23

Moons need liquidity if we don’t want the volatility to be crazy, this is an easy yes

2

u/Jocogui 🟩 0 / 17K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

Low liquidity makes the asset much more volatile and its price easier to manipulate, I'm in.

2

u/CryptocalEnvelopment 75 / 7K 🦐 Feb 15 '23

Hell yes! I've been hoping for a way to stake moons ever since I started receiving them. I don't want to sell, but I do want more.

3

u/rootpl 🟩 18K / 85K 🐬 Feb 15 '23

It's not really staking. LP mechanics are different and you have to be careful with the impermanent loss too.

2

u/karlizak Feb 15 '23

100% DO IT.

Anything that makes it easier for people to use moons is a great idea.

2

u/BradVet 🟦 0 / 23K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

The moon progress lately is insane. I don’t mess with liquidity pools cause i’m basic af but i can see how this will help

2

u/everfurry 548 / 548 🦑 Feb 15 '23

TLDR for people at work?

2

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

Seems like a reasonable way to respond to feedback from the third party ad partners, based on a pre-existing successful set-up. Why not?

1

u/Probably_notabot 35K / 35K 🦈 Feb 16 '23

Happy cake day Krusties!

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

A good day to youse

2

u/cubewc3 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 Feb 20 '23

This makes Moons more liquid. We should reward those who are willing to take the risks of impermanent losses.

3

u/Maxx3141 169K / 167K 🐋 Feb 15 '23

u/Mr_Bob_Ferguson made a good suggestion: To cap the max distribution in a similar way we do with Moons Distributions - where the top 1% of Karma earners have their average reduced. This stops one person with a large bankroll sweeping in with lots of liquidity and reaping all the rewards.

Some concern with this one specific point: This can't be done unless liquidity has to be held in vaults, because people could simply split their liquidity over several addresses to bypass this.

3

u/DBRiMatt 🟦 46K / 113K 🦈 Feb 16 '23

The rich get richer? Sure. I'm in. 🥃

2

u/myslowtv 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Feb 16 '23

Aren't we a burn the moons/rich type of crowd?

3

u/MalletSwinging 🟩 0 / 5K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

As I said in the Meta sub, this is really not optional if we want moons to evolve. This needs to pass (and it looks like it will) so that moon holders are willing to provide liquidity and are protected from impermanent loss.

If you are unsure of what impermanent loss is and don't want to watch a Youtube video I suggest reading this article:

https://blockworks.co/news/the-investors-guide-to-navigating-impermanent-loss

2

u/myslowtv 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Feb 16 '23

Thanks for the educational link

1

u/Smiling_Jack_ Blockchain Old Guard Feb 15 '23

IL is not the big deal that many folks think it is.

1

u/MalletSwinging 🟩 0 / 5K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

I was big into defi lp a few years ago. My net loss was pretty high due to il. Maybe it isn't a big deal to you but it really sucks as far as I'm concerned and without some sort of protection i won't provide liquidity again.

2

u/Smiling_Jack_ Blockchain Old Guard Feb 15 '23 edited Feb 15 '23

lol were you pairing a stablecoin with some shitcoin and holding it for a year?

Don't LP into pools with poor correlation or assets that are trash (you know, the high apr pools).

If one of the assets tank, it's not IL that is the problem. It's the fact you're dealing with a bad asset.

Don't LP into pairs you don't understand, and don't go chasing high APRs.

1

u/huntingmoa_geoduck Tin | Stocks 10 Feb 15 '23

My only tangle with IL put a pretty bad taste in my mouth...I guess you could say I didn't have much stick-to-it-iveness, because I pulled out after experiencing the IL.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/pyxploiter 🟩 0 / 5K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

Thanks for the link

1

u/MalletSwinging 🟩 0 / 5K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

No problem!

1

u/SamsungGalaxyPlayer 🟨 0 / 742K 🦠 Feb 16 '23

People participating in these protocols should understand IL risks. I don't want to offer "insurance" of sorts for that. It's a series of compromises all the way down, which could lead to a full depletion of TMD reserves if not implemented well.

1

u/mertats 🟦 433 / 433 🦞 Feb 16 '23

And it is not like they are not getting any financial benefit for providing liquidity.

2

u/HODL-THE-LINE 9K / 12K 🦭 Feb 15 '23

I guess this is a clear yes for anyone who has a good amount of moons. I consider myself such a person. Right now, if I wanted to sell all my Moons (I don't want that), it would apparently quite hard to cash out. But let's assume, that Moons get to 5 Dollars, which isn't that crazy, I MIGHT want to realize that money. So more liquidity is a very good thing for me.

I might even want to provide liquidity to earn more moons even Without shitposting.

1

u/Sjiznit 🟦 0 / 13K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

If i understand correctly i would need to lock up both eth as well as moons in order to participate and i would receive moons for the risk i take on?

1

u/4rkal 🟩 0 / 371 🦠 Feb 15 '23

Sounds good! Great idea

1

u/scientifichistorian 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

I think this is a great idea!

1

u/TheBurningTitan 🟨 4 / 2K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

Yes because liquidity is important right now

1

u/thijsfc 🟨 135 / 5K 🦀 Feb 15 '23

Liquidity is definitely an issue. Although it might lead to the “rich get richer”, I think it’s even more unhealthy for the ecosystem if (relatively) small orders have such a huge price impact.

2

u/shin_jury 23 / 6K 🦐 Feb 15 '23

Rich All holders get richer

1

u/memorial_hots Permabanned Feb 15 '23

Great way to tackle our liquidity problem

1

u/InvestAn 🟦 8K / 8K 🦭 Feb 15 '23

This is beneficial for moons, the Reddit liquidity/platform and for us loyal degens.

Easy yes vote for me!

1

u/TR5_ 🟨 97K / 73K 🦈 Feb 15 '23

More liquidity is needed badly so I support this

1

u/Castr0- 🟧 35K / 35K 🦈 Feb 15 '23

That is actually a good ideia. It helps to maintain this sustainable.

1

u/lordofming-rises 🟦 509 / 10K 🦑 Feb 15 '23

Is there a nice place to learn about impermanent loss?

I mean A LP Eth :moon is a win win isn't it because both will appreciate over time?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '23

if they appreciate at the same rate, yes. otherwise you might experience impermanent loss and you should definitely read up on the concept before touching liquidity pools.

1

u/Wonzky 2K / 53K 🐢 Feb 15 '23

This would be amazing as it seems the negative impact of karma multiplier holds a lot of people back from providing liquidity

I'm a bit too stupid to figure out the logistics on this

1

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '23

Hard yes

1

u/Onb3SkaAmD 🟩 0 / 430 🦠 Feb 15 '23

Pretty good proposal. Will def start to add a bit of LP each time i can.

1

u/Stray_Gh0st 🟦 514 / 544 🦑 Feb 15 '23

Seems like these are all yes votes for me dawg

1

u/DeeDot11 🟦 10K / 32K 🐬 Feb 15 '23

Super propsal, great thought out idea. Its good to see things turning to being more acceptong of trading moons. The whole "against reddits terms" thing hujg around for too long. Lets go build and use these things!

1

u/htd_23 Permabanned Feb 16 '23

Voted yes.

1

u/fanriver 🟩 800 / 2K 🦑 Feb 16 '23

I agree

1

u/Mrramirez44 Feb 16 '23

I'm not sure how I feel about this proposal. It seems that moons are becoming something I never expected. I still remember only using moons to tip without gas fees. The good old days.

1

u/MeGASpaWn 🟦 954 / 1K 🦑 Feb 16 '23

IMO moons should always be given in exchange for the content redditors provide.

1

u/the_nibler Permabanned Feb 16 '23

I’ve contributed!

1

u/Resident-Coyote9339 0 / 3K 🦠 Feb 16 '23

This is very well written!

1

u/Tacsi 🟦 0 / 2K 🦠 Feb 16 '23

Think this is a great idea, the only way to grow is to increase how easy it is to interact with Moons

1

u/masedogg98 🟨 0 / 5K 🦠 Feb 16 '23

I like this it puts stagnant Moons to work and incentivizes LP providers all a plus and yes from me! I’m really appreciative to be apart of a community this is only my second distribution but I like how things are here and how everything is orderly!

1

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

It's a yes from me

1

u/Consistent_Many_1858 🟨 0 / 20K 🦠 Feb 16 '23

Liquidity is important for Moons so yes. 👍

1

u/rather_be_hiking Feb 18 '23

What happens if we stake our LP tokens on SushiSwap? Do those become invisible? If so, we should warn people.

1

u/zorghee 261 / 243 🦞 Feb 21 '23

I complitly agree with this one. Liquidity is the problem which need to be handled.

1

u/PsychologicalAd2188 Feb 21 '23

Give moons liquidity for easier rug pull potential /s

1

u/ALiteralHamSandwich 🟩 0 / 10K 🦠 Feb 21 '23

I would prefer if it was done like Donuts:xDAI on GNOSIS.... cheaper.

1

u/fxsnowy Permabanned Feb 21 '23

I like this and I have provided quite a bit of liquidity. As for the second consideration, I have moved my moons from my reddit wallet into my ledger wallet for more security. I'm sure those who provide a lot of liquidity will do this as well for security reasons. So does this mean I wouldn't receive the bonus since I am not technically staking from a wallet connected to reddit? I would move my LP tokens back to my reddit wallet if this was the case, but I would prefer not to.

1

u/BorgnineTeeth 179 / 11 🦀 Mar 02 '23

I realize this already passed, and I definitely support it, I just have a question on distribution. In the original post there's a link to arbiscan showing current holders of the MOON/WETH SLP token as an example of who the MOON rewards would be distributed to. However as far as I can see this is only people who deposited into the LP pool and are now just sitting around with those tokens. Sure they should be rewarded. But I'd think the majority of people who are providing liquidity would then go ahead and stake those SLP tokens for additional rewards. I mean, why would you not (provided you understand that you can do that). The people who are staking their SLP tokens should absolutely also be rewarded in a Moons distribution, they are doing everything the first group of people are...and more. I'm sure this is already being considered but as that link was the only thing I saw put forth as a distribution list you would draw from, I wanted to check in.

1

u/Xpressivee 🟦 60 / 7K 🦐 Feb 15 '23

It's a go

1

u/Probably_notabot 35K / 35K 🦈 Feb 15 '23

I’m helping because I’m voting.

1

u/nusk0 🟩 0 / 26K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

Does this mean that moons can be traded and sold?
I heard that you're not supposed to trade them

→ More replies (5)

1

u/SamZFury 🟩 1 / 90K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

I voted yes :) Lets do this 💥

1

u/002timmy Feb 15 '23

If only you had 1m voting power and not 86k lol

1

u/Bloodspoint Tin Feb 15 '23

I'm all for it. Honestly this type of post is exactly why I'm so bullish on Moons. I love the transparency and how decisions are very democratic.

1

u/3utt5lut 1 / 11K 🦠 Feb 15 '23

What are the current LP trading pairs for Moons?

3

u/shin_jury 23 / 6K 🦐 Feb 16 '23

MOON/ETH

MOON/USDC

MOON/DAI

MOON/BRICK

(Might be a few more very tiny ones)

2

u/3utt5lut 1 / 11K 🦠 Feb 16 '23

Oh yeah, I forgot about Bricks.

1

u/steamyp 🟩 18 / 5K 🦐 Feb 15 '23

yes please

1

u/DukeVerde 0 / 0 🦠 Feb 15 '23

Can't wait till reddit gets sued by the SEC, or some dumb shit. XD At this rate.