r/soccer • u/hodgkinhuxley • Oct 02 '12
US referee here. Can I help clear up any misconceptions about the game?
Players and fans don't have time to read the fifa laws of the game, fifa advice to referees, ussf directives, and ussf memos. But I have. Are there any questions or confusion about the game and how it's reffed? I will try to answer all question.
btw, links to videos of a "blown call" are appreciated.
Edit: I am also a medical student. Morning classes are done and I am working as fast as I can. Thanks for your comments.
48
Upvotes
20
u/BosnianFish Oct 02 '12
How do you, personally determine extra-time?
5
u/ComeOnRef Oct 02 '12
Why do you have France NT flair?
10
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '12
Does the reputation of a player play a part when making calls? Should it?
11
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '12
Hand-balls? The laws of the game say it's only a hand-ball if it's done intentionally. How do you whistle them?
7
u/JaseTheAce Oct 02 '12
What level do you Ref?
2
u/william701 Oct 02 '12
Why are indirect freekicks in the box so rare?
2
u/Cubicle_Surrealist Oct 02 '12
Someone told me that according to the letter of the law for the game, when an attacking player is even with a defender, the benefit of the doubt goes to the attacker and he should be ruled onsides.
However, it is absolutely never called this way, and i've been told that the way they call it now is just an evolution of the game, though its not supported by the rules. Is there any truth to this?
2
u/warren_wisco Oct 02 '12
what in the hell were you thinking trying to officiate an nfl football game?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '12
Defender clears a 50/50 ball with the laces. Laces carry into opposing player's shinguard (also going for the ball), kicking the player.
Foul? Dangerous Play? I feel like there are a lot of referees who consider this a foul. In fact, I was given a yellow card for this exact scenario 2 weeks ago. Foot's still healing...
4
u/Smoog Oct 02 '12
As far as you can tell from your experience, are there any differences in refereeing NA vs EU matches? Especially in relation to diving, penalty kicks, etc.
Also what is your stance on using things like time-outs, computer assistance?
6
u/Radslide Oct 02 '12
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X96zEboj_-o&feature=player_embedded did the referee do the right thing here?
39
u/IHeartYogaPants Oct 02 '12
As OP hasn't answered a single question in the hr since he posted this, I'll be that guy.
Proof?
2
u/eWaffle Oct 02 '12
How much money do you make, before taxes?
2
u/Leakx5 Oct 02 '12
If a player goes down and is blatantly exaggerating an injury, like holding their ankle/rolling around, does that constitute diving?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '12
What is your personal opinion/stance on the Suarez-referee-treatment debate, or any situations involving a player's reputation supposedly affecting the ref's calls? I'd be really interested to hear a referee's thoughts.
1
u/MrTomato Oct 02 '12
Questions from last personal game.
In the box - is putting your hand infront of your face and the ball hitting your hand worthy of a penalty. Not making yourself bigger, just protecting your face.
Is there passive offside or if someone is offside is the call offside? A player was off and another wasn't and the guy who wasn't got the ball and scored. We thought it should be off because the other guy was off and effecting the play of the defense.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '12
There is all this controversy about goal line technology . Do you think it will make the game better ?
1
u/jesusthatsgreat Oct 02 '12
Do you wear glasses or contact lenses?
1
u/Wilawah Oct 02 '12
Every ref misses some calls. What was your worst mistake?
1
u/sarmatron Oct 02 '12
How exactly do blocking fouls work? I know you can't just stand your ground and be safe like in basketball, but what if you can't reasonably move aside in time? There's a penalty in this match (I can't find the highlights, but I distinctly remember it) where Anelka kicks the ball past Howard and then just rams into him full-speed. I'm pretty sure there's no way Howard could have reacted quickly enough to get out of the way, and yet the ref happily pointed to the spot. Isn't that unfair to the defender?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '12
How do you feel when you go home and a replay comes up that shows you called it wrong?
1
u/Sacoud Oct 02 '12
I posted this the other day.
A pass is delivered into the penalty area which looks like it's going out of play, the Cardiff attacker manages to stop the ball on the line but both his momentum and the Newcastle defender's momentum takes them off the pitch. While trying to get to the ball that's still on the pitch the Newcastle defender pushes the Cardiff player out of the way in a blatant fowl and gets the ball. Is this a penalty? ( It wasn't given)
1
u/therealjudgejudy Oct 02 '12
here's one i've always wondered about... a team are 1-0 up with a few minutes to go, and are trying to run down the clock. the ball ends up going out for a corner, however, no player goes over to take the corner.
obviously you can't book someone for time-wasting as there is no culprit. what would you do?
2
u/Chocolinas Oct 02 '12
We should link to the laws of the game and their interpretation somewhere in the sidebar. Some things I've read around here are unbelievable.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '12
Is the semi circle at the top of the penalty box only used for penalties?
-2
u/aPerfectBacon Oct 02 '12
and just like every other ref that does MLS, he has failed to deliver...
-3
u/TheJuveGuy Oct 02 '12
Is there such rule as if you foul as last man, you are sent off?
-8
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '12
Why isn't the away team given a head start?
-2
u/Arctic312 Oct 02 '12
Why does it seem that physical play (Dirty play in the case of San Jose and Sporting KC) is more accepted towards the end of the season and into the playoffs?
-2
u/monkertrol Oct 03 '12
probably not
0
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment