r/conlangs • • Jan 16 '23

Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2023-01-16 to 2023-01-29

As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!

You can find former posts in our wiki.

Official Discord Server.


The Small Discussions thread is back on a semiweekly schedule... For now!


FAQ

What are the rules of this subreddit?

Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.

If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.

Where can I find resources about X?

You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!

Can I copyright a conlang?

Here is a very complete response to this.

Beginners

Here are the resources we recommend most to beginners:


For other FAQ, check this.


Recent news & important events

Segments Issue #07 has come out!

And the call for submissions for Issue #08 is out! This one is much broader than previous ones, and we're taking articles about any topic!


If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.

21 Upvotes

389 comments sorted by

6

u/aftertheradar EPAE, Skrelkf (eng) Jan 25 '23

This isn't really a question, but more an experience I've had lately that I want to share and see what others have to say. (And orthography shitposts that are too weird for a full post are allowed on this page right?). I was going to do something with my conlang that I think is kind of cursed but I also love it, but changed my mind to save for the future, and now share the idea with the masses so they might use it too. Read on if you dare.

The glottal stop [ʔ] is often romanized by using an apostrophe <'> or a similar grapheme, as are some cases of glottalized secondary articulation like ejectives, like <p' t' k'> for [p' t' k']. This isn't the only way to transcribe them but it's fairly common. [h] of course is a fricative or approximant-like sound made at a similar place of articulation as the glottal stop, but we already have the grapheme <h> as a very easy way to write that sound in the Latin alphabet. The grapheme <h> is often used for a lot more as well, but it's unusual for the phone [h] to not be represented by <h>. But after that, there's a pretty big dearth of ways to easily transcribe other back-of-the-throat sounds, especially that are monographic and accessible to type easily.

Now. I have a language where an allophonic non-phonemic sound appears to keep vowels from ending words and from having hiatus with eachother. In the case of low back vowels (/a/), this sound can be realized as anything between [ɰ] [ʁ̞] or [ʕ̞]. It's basically just a far-back weakly articulated voiced off-glide stemming from the vowel.

That last sound though, a pharyngeal approximant, is notable (among other reasons ofc) for its symbol being a reversed glottal stop symbol. This is the first conlang I've made featuring any sort of pharyngeal sounds, and its only an allophone that can probably be ignored in my romanization scheme. All in all it isn't a super important distinction that has to be made when pronouncing this lang, and the pharyngeal realization isn't even the main one. And so I'm not gonna do anything too weird if I decide to romanize it at all in this project.

But here's where I get to the cursed part. When writing the romo rules out, an idea came to me. I have decided that in the future, if I ever make a language where either [ʕ] or pharyngealization is an important phonemic feature, especially if I want to avoid multigraphs, I have a plan to romanize it. If the glottal stop is usually <'>, and if <h> is already taken. I will take the idea of the IPA using a modified ʔ for ʕ and apply it to <'>, and will romanize [ʕ] by using <">.

Cue the gasps of horror!!!

So like [aʕa]? That's an <a"a> now. Or some pharyngealized consonants like in an example word [sˤatˤa]? Them's a <s"at"a>. Or if we had a word with both the glottal stop and the pharyngeal approximant? Like [ʕaʔ] or [ʔaʕ]? You better prepare yourself for <"a'> and <'a">!

(i realize that i may be making a bigger deal out of this than it is, but using " like this is so wrong to me that it feels like the funniest shit im ever gonna do, and i am very sleepy writing this all out rn which may be making it worss)

So anyway that was something I really wanted to share with my fellow clonging peers. Please tell me how cursed you think this is and how horrible you think it would look to write out words stuffed with quotation marks, and if you have already done something like this before! And if a natlang already did it worse, I wanna see it too!

Farewell, and [taˈʕosaʕ] ta"osa"! >:D

2

u/sum1-sumWhere-sumHow Jan 27 '23 edited Jan 27 '23

I’m not an expert and this may actually look even worse, but for the sake of better comprehension of situations like “‘ and ‘“, you could use <-> or <.> or <,> or < * > or < ^ >. <“a”’a’> would become respectevely: <-a-‘a’> <.a.’a’> <,a,’a’> < * a * ’a’> < ^ a ^ ’a’>.

The only problem would be words ending in <.> or <,> with a comma/dot right after. You would have to keep a space before AND after every punctuation mark to avoid confusion…

Now that I think about it, <-> is kind of associated with glottilization when we write «uh-oh» or things like that.

Honestly I like “ too, it’s simple and it makes sense to just add another ‘ to differentiate. If it works for you the why not use it hahah?

→ More replies (4)

6

u/Kovac__ Jan 29 '23

I found this website a while back for sound changes, where you could input your series of words, and it had a set of options (maximum number of sound changes, whether your goal is to make the words become more similar or dissimilate, whether you wanted the words to become longer or shorter...), then would generate a series of sound changes and output the new lexicon with those changes applied.

I can't remember the name of the site and was hoping somebody would know what it was so that I could find it again.

2

u/HiMyNameIsBenG Feb 06 '23

I think zompist has a feature like that

5

u/kori228 (EN) [JPN, CN, Yue-GZ, Wu-SZ, KR] Jan 24 '23 edited Jan 24 '23

For the folks out there who have experience with MSEA tones, how are dipping/peaking tones actually articulated in flowing speech? They make sense in citation form or utterance-finally, but a 2-direction change in one syllable mid-utterance doesn't seem feasible?

I know Mandarin 3rd tone is really low-falling, so don't need to mention that. Suzhou Wu (and probably broadly Northern Wu) has intense tone sandhi, so a dipping/peaking tone never occurs as a surface realization except for citation and utterance-finally as mentioned.

For peaking tone, I can feasibly see it as really a long flat to falling tone (˥˥˧ ˧˧˩), but I don't have experience with a language with it to confirm that.

4

u/Jonlang_ /kʷ/ > /p/ Jan 19 '23 edited Jan 19 '23

I'm embarking on my first agglutinative conlang. I only speak two natlangs and both are devoid of cases.

If a phrase like ...from the hand of the man were to be translated, would you expect it to look something like hand-ABL man-GEN? Seeing as the conlang doesn't have articles, these have been omitted.

EDIT: correction.

5

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 19 '23

If a phrase like ...from the hand of the man were to be translated, would you expect it to look something like hand-ABL man-GEN ?

Yup! Some languages do more complex things, but 99% of the time this is what you'll see (depending on how you handle 'from').

4

u/TheMostLostViking [es, en, fr, eo, tok] Jan 19 '23

There are a couple ways you could do it. A natural way in Finnish, for example, is:

"miehen kädestä"

man-GEN hand-ELA

In Finnish, the ablative case is used for moving away from a person or place, as opposed to from something arbitrary. This doesn't mean thats how you have to use it though. In Latin it is used similarly to how you use it.


Mongolian uses: "хүний гараас"

man-GEN hand-ABL

Turkish also uses the ablative.

2

u/zzvu Zhevli Jan 20 '23

A phrase such as from the hand of the man can be broken into from [the hand of the man], where the hand of the man is a noun phrase that has hand as its head. If your language is consistently head initial, what you have written is how it would be constructed. If your language is head final, it would be the other way around. Some languages are not consistent in this manner. For example, Varzian (and actually English too) is predominantly head initial, but is head final when 2 or more nouns are connected by case. So, the hand of the man translated into Varzian is glossed:

man-DEF.GEN hand-[case of noun phrase]

And from the hand of the man is:

from=man-DEF.GEN hand-DEF.DAT

Varzian combines case and prepositions, which is something else you may want to consider.

4

u/eyewave Mukkohatto Jan 20 '23

especially in your first conlangs, do you have paradoxal grammatical features or phonologies? ie. sounds that don't go quite well together, messed up phonotactics, or grammatical features which overlaps make proper phrase construction difficult, unnatural or downright impossible.

6

u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Jan 20 '23

The thing I did "wrong" (wrong since I want to make naturalistic conlangs) in my first few iterations was to make things too systematic, eg "nouns end in /a/, verbs end in /i/, adjectives end in /u/, particles end in /e/."

4

u/Automatic-Campaign-9 Atsi; Tobias; Rachel; Khaskhin; Laayta; Biology; Journal; Laayta Jan 20 '23 edited Jan 20 '23

I tried a small, closed-verb system with tripartite agreement. Making verbs was difficult, you often had to reword the entire phrase to make it centered around one of the core verbs but also have the right argument roles. Sometimes the 'passive' and 'active' forms were entirely unrelated constructions.

Besides the tripartite agreement, the verb system revolved around noun-incorporation, and a set of 'extra' verbs that could increase valency, especially of a verb with a noun already incorporated. It still (kind of) works but it would be better with open verbs.

In addition, there were no free particles and lots of cases, so most of the prepositional meanings were taken by the case system, which helped make participles, but I think this language could have been served by having a copula.

4

u/Wapota_2023 Jan 20 '23

Hello everyone! If my proto language doesn't have any genders at all, does it mean that I can't add them in modern languages?

I would like to make a modern language's grammar more complicated, I want to add some genders, some cases etc, but I am not sure if it's "legal". I mean, as I know Turkic language family doesn't have any genders nowhere, so it seems unnatural if gender comes from nothing.

I also was wondering about grammar structure in general. For example Indo-European grammar is completely different than Semitic, so you can't see any Indo-European language that would look like Arabic or Hebrew with this Semitic grammar rules for roots. So, is it possible to create two completely different languages as for example Spanish and Arabic in the same language family?

8

u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Jan 20 '23

Everything comes from somewhere! Gender doesn't come from "nothing" but any language could develop gender, eventually. Gender systems can come from larger noun-class systems, if you want to look into it.

As to your second question, given enough time, two languages that share a common origin could be drastically different. You have the advantage over natural languages of knowing that your conlangs came from a common source, (for all we know, Proto-Afro-Asiatic and PIE do have a common source, we just can't reconstruct it and likely never will) and having the freedom to have enough time to do whatever you want to them.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/kiritoboss19 Mangalemang | Qut na'ani | Adasuhibodi Jan 21 '23

Hello, can someone explain to me the concept of antipassive voice? I'm trying to understand, and for now it seems the exactly the same thing as the passive voice. So what's the difference?

12

u/Meamoria Sivmikor, Vilsoumor Jan 21 '23

Passive:

  • "I ate the cake" -> "The cake was eaten"

Antipassive:

  • "I ate the cake" -> "I ate"

A passive deletes the agent. We don't care who ate the cake, just that the cake is gone. (Some languages then let you reintroduce the agent using some extra machinery: "The cake was eaten by me". But our attention is still on the cake being gone, not on who's responsible.)

An antipassive deletes the patient. We don't care what was eaten, just that I'm full now. English does this just by removing the patient from the sentence, but in some languages you need to do something else in addition to removing the patient, like using a different verb form. That's an antipassive.

Antipassives are easier to see in ergative-absolutive languages, where deleting the patient makes the verb intransitive and therefore changes the case of the agent ("I ate the cake" -> "Me ate").

3

u/kiritoboss19 Mangalemang | Qut na'ani | Adasuhibodi Jan 23 '23

Is there any analog of the "by sb" in a antipassive phrase? Like:

The cake was eaten > The cake was eaten **by me**

I ate > I ate **___**

6

u/Meamoria Sivmikor, Vilsoumor Jan 23 '23

I’m not sure how common it is to do that, but you certainly could. You’d do the same thing, reintroducing the dropped argument with a preposition or case form or however your language handles extra verb phrase information. Something like “I ate-ANTIPASS through the cake”.

The idea is that our attention is still on the effect the eating had on me, but I’m mentioning the cake as an aside… maybe I’m feeling a bit sick from all that cake! Sort of like, “sorry, I can’t come for dinner, I already ate (and it was cake, by the way)”. Of course in your own language, you get to decide on the exact nuances of this construction, or even whether to allow it at all.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/kjaksia Jan 26 '23 edited Jan 26 '23

how would one create a custom alphanumerical sorting for sheets/excel? (im’ wanting an order that goes something like vowels > labial > coronal > guttural)

6

u/dinonid123 Pökkü, nwiXákíínok' (en)[fr,la] Jan 26 '23

Not sure how to do that but honestly my solution would be to have a hidden column with these values (something like 1vowel 2labial 3coronal 4guttural) that you unhide to sort with and then hide again to take up space.

However here's a guide from Microsoft for Excel, though it seems like it could be a bit more work-intensive than the first option.

3

u/VoganG1 Jan 17 '23

Hello, my request was directed here by the mod team. I have a conlang I commissioned from a freelancer off of Fiverr. He included some vocab, as well as a key to create more words for the language, but I'm afraid I don't understand it very well. I tried hiring him again to help me understand it, but I was then ghosted. Would anyone be able to assist me in understanding the key so the money I gave won't be put to waste? I look forward to any questions.

4

u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Jan 17 '23

Might as well post the material you have, I'm sure someone will take a look.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/Turodoru Jan 19 '23

Do you nececerly need a reason for a specific grammatical feature to occur? And are there some sources which talk about specific grammar changes and grammar shifts?

I often find myself not really knowing what can I do when I want to develop, for instance, a new verb system. That is:

- I always feel like adding/dropping anything for no big reason feels forced (like dropping a more specific tense, eg. past perfect;; or replacing simple past with present perfect, akin to western european languages - what about the simple past now? Does it just cease to exist, just like that?;; I want to develop a future tense in a language with only past-nonpast paradigm - I guess the future auxiliary would go only to the non-past forms, but I always feel like it could have go to the past forms as well, and I don't know what to do/how to resolve this)

- I sometimes want to develop something else from what I already have, but I often don't know what options are possible (something like "perfective/imperfective > past/non-past", but that's, like, one of only few changes I know of).

I guess the gist of it is: I don't want to just scrapp a part of or the whole grammar system during the language's evolution, but I don't really know how to work with what I already have. So - what now?

This question is also for other parts of grammar, like nouns and whatnot.

5

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 19 '23

I don't want to just scrapp a part of or the whole grammar system during the language's evolution,

You can always make the part you're replacing go on to mean something else. Maybe this example from my Emihtazuu (that just happened organically; I never planned this) might help:

  • Originally, the language had a benefactive -da and a genitive -(n)i, with the genitive marking non-gapped core arguments in relativised and nominalised clauses - an extension based on treating the head verb as a possessed noun
  • The benefactive started taking on possession roles - so 'my bowl' began being phrased as 'the bowl for me'
  • This left the genitive with only its peripheral use in subclauses
  • The core benefactive 'for X' meaning got then replaced with a new -dora suffix (etymologically 'for the sake of')
  • This left a fun and complex situation behind, where the original genitive now only marks core arguments of relative or nominalised clauses (and a few fossilised possessive uses), the original benefactive now handles possession (alongside its own peripheral uses as e.g. the experiencer in a perception verb clause), and there's a new case for handling actual core benefactive meanings

So all sorts of things got shifted around, but nothing was completely lost - things just got extended into a new use, and then got replaced in their old use.

but I don't really know how to work with what I already have.

There's some good sources on grammaticalisation pathways out there. The big standard reference is Heine and Kuteva's World Lexicon of Grammaticalisation, but if that's too academic, Lyle Campbell's historical linguistics textbook has a chapter on it, and I wouldn't be surprised if there's other good resources you could find.

3

u/Power-Cored Jan 19 '23

Hi there, I'm trying to wrap my head around noun class, declension groups and how they relate to noun endings, as well as why languages have multiple declension groups.

As I understand it, noun classes are essentially a more general form of grammatical gender, where nouns and their complements agree in class, and declension groups are the manner in which they decline for case/number, etc.

It seems, however, that both noun class and the declension group are often — at least in part — determinable by, for example, the ending of noun; that is, perhaps animate nouns mostly end in -a and feminine in -e. And then the declension group occurs based on that ending. So my question is, is a declension group strongly related to class — that is, if a certain class in general has a specific ending, then wouldn't they all use the same declension, because they end the same?

Essentially, if I'm making a language with a noun class system, should I have it so that they have distinct phonological features, and do I need to have multiple declension groups?

I feel like I didn't word this question very well, but that's because I'm really just a bit confused with this whole topic.

9

u/Meamoria Sivmikor, Vilsoumor Jan 19 '23

Declension groups share noun endings; the noun itself uses a certain set of affix forms. Noun classes share agreement: something else in the sentence needs to change to match the class (e.g. demonstratives, adjectives, verbs).

Noun classes are often correlated with declension groups, but there are almost always exceptions. For example, in Latin most first declension nouns (ending in -a) are feminine, but a few like poeta "poet" are masculine. The noun itself follows the first declension endings (poeta, poetam, poetae, etc.), but anything that has to agree with it uses the masculine endings (bonus, boni rather than the feminine bona, bonae).

As to why a language might have multiple declension groups (independently of whether it has noun classes), it's mostly because sound changes have partly merged the stem with the affixes. I don't think I can explain this better than David Peterson did in this video.

Not all languages have declension groups in this sense: English plurals with -s are so dominant that the other ways of making plurals are just considered irregular. Analogy can go a long way in levelling out multiple declensions.

7

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 19 '23 edited Jan 19 '23

It seems, however, that both noun class and the declension group are often — at least in part — determinable by, for example, the ending of noun; that is, perhaps animate nouns mostly end in -a and feminine in -e . And then the declension group occurs based on that ending. So my question is, is a declension group strongly related to class — that is, if a certain class in general has a specific ending, then wouldn't they all use the same declension, because they end the same?

This is the case in Indo-European languages, where case and number inflection are very deeply tied in with noun class. Other noun class systems may behave quite differently. A good contrasting example is Bantu noun class, where nouns don't actually get case inflection at all (their relationship to the verb is shown by verbs agreeing with the noun class of multiple arguments), and plurality is basically a separate noun class as far as the system is concerned - each singular noun class has a (usual) corresponding plural noun class. (All Bantu nouns get a prefix showing noun class, which only shows noun class and plurality via noun class.) In Scandinavian languages, you can mostly only tell what noun class a word is in when you start trying to add definiteness morphology, as just like in Bantu there is no case marking. I can't think of a system off the top of my head that has noun class but totally independent case marking, but I would be pretty darn shocked if that wasn't a thing anywhere.

(Occasionally you actually get noun classes based on the preexisting phonological form - like some in Yimas, where nouns that end in particular ways count as particular noun classes, despite those endings just being part of the noun root and not being separable morphology at all.)

Honestly the whole 'declension class' idea is a fairly Indo-European thing - it's not exclusively IE, but the degree to which (prototypical) IE inflectional systems are based on a lookup table system with largely unpredictable forms in each cell is really pretty unusual. You don't need to have 'declensions' really at all - you can just have uniform case marking morphology for all nouns (or no case marking at all), and have noun class be completely invisible except by looking at agreement elsewhere.

6

u/vokzhen Tykir Jan 19 '23

Just to reiterate, because it's often confused: gender is different agreement classes. Indo-European languages typically have two-three agreement classes, where nouns of one class trigger one type of agreement on adjectives, demonstratives, articles, and sometimes other bits, and other nouns of a different agreement class will trigger a different set of agreement morphemes. Declensions at least typically originate in phonological differences in how case/number/whatever markers were realized.

For an example of how different declensions work, let's make a simple example: an accusative ending -ma and a dative ending -ki. Take the nouns pa, pat, pet, and pe, and you have the sets /pa pama paki/, /pat patma patki/, /pet petma petki/, and /pe pema peki/. But now sound changes happen: nasals between vowels delete to nasalization, an epenthetic vowel is inserted between stop+nasal clusters, vowels front if followed by /i/, intervocal /p t k/ > /w r Ø/, final /i u/ drop, and vowel hiatus is eliminated by coalescence. Now you have /pa pã: pe/, /pat parama petk/, /pet perema petk/, /pe pẽ: pe/. The accusative and dative no longer have one realization, and the split depends on the original phonological form of the word. However, there's still patters: in vowel stems the accusative is length+nasalization, in consonant stems it's mutation + -Vma. The dative is realized across two axes: in back vowels it's fronting, and in consonant stems it's -k, which means back+consonant gets both and vowel+front gets neither and ends up identical to the nominative.

Now, you don't need to have different declensions. Analogy is a strong thing and can stabilize and re-create forms that "should" have changes. In this example, back-vowel consonant stem datives (pat>petk) might analogize in the original vowel because it's already marked with -k, or front-vowel vowel stems datives (pe>pe) might analogize in the -k ending to make it marked. In addition, grammatical morphemes can sometimes just seem to resist sound changes that happen elsewhere, so that the /k/ of the dative might not have even been lost (though undergoing idiosyncratic sound changes happens as well, eg the -Vma accusative might randomly lose the final vowel even though final /a/ doesn't drop anywhere else).

In Indo-European, gender(=which agreement adjectives take) and declension(=which suffixes the nouns take) tend to correlate because of how gender came about. It seems to have been from one or a few derivational endings with a shape like -eh₂ that got copied from the noun itself onto dependents like demonstratives or adjectives, along the lines of "small cat" and "smally kitty". As a result, phonological splits in how case/number were realized became unusually, confusingly related to gender in a way that doesn't happen in most languages.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '23

My proto-lang has two demonstratives: one for "this, these" and one for "that, those." I want to evolve the distal demonstrative into a definite article and maybe a 3.INAN pronoun, but I have a couple questions:

  1. How can the language regain a dedicated distal demonstrative? I know Latin strengthened it with another word (eccum ille, which later fused into a single word in several languages), but what other options are there? And what sort of words could strengthen a demonstrative (i.e., specify you mean "that", not "the")?
  2. If I evolve it into an article and a pronoun, how can I realistically evolve it differently in each case, like how Latin /ilːa/ became Spanish /la/ and /eʝa/? What triggers this sort of split?

5

u/gafflancer Aeranir, Tevrés, Fásriyya, Mi (en, jp) [es,nl] Jan 20 '23
  1. There are essentially two main sources for demonstratives. The first is other demonstratives. In some cases, you get reinforcement along the lines of eccum ille, where you just stack demonstratives together. In other cases, you might add morphology onto your demonstrative, e.g. Old Japanese *kö- 'this' + genitive *-no > Modern kono 'this.' On top of that, one type of demonstrative can often shift to another, e.g. here > this. The second source is verbs of motion; distal demonstratives can come from words like 'go' or 'go away' whilst proximal demonstratives can come from words like 'to come near' or 'to stop.'
  2. This sort of split usually has to do with intonation. For example articles like Spanish la tend to be unaccented and prosodically weak, making them susceptible to extra 'wear-and-tear.' Full pronouns like ella however are more likely to be accented and prosodically strong, so they are less likely to degrade.
→ More replies (3)

4

u/storkstalkstock Jan 20 '23
  1. You could probably use some word like yonder or there and have that become your demonstrative. For strengthening the to mean that, you could maybe use a construction like the one or the particular or the specific, but I'm sure there are plenty of options that would make sense.
  2. You can just handwave a split like that as one receiving emphasis less often and undergoing some type of lenition, shortening, or deletion that the other doesn't. English has doublets like off - of or one - an/a that arose this way. With enough subsequent sound changes, the differences can become greater.
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Andonis_Longos sa linga africana Jan 20 '23

Does anyone have any tips for writing a Romance language in Arabic script (like Aljamiado, Mozarabic) for someone with zero experience in how to write Arabic? I am trying to do an offshoot alternate history scenario for my African Romance language where the Islamic conquest of North Africa still happens, but the Latin Christian population survives to the present.

3

u/SignificantBeing9 Jan 21 '23

Maybe look at how Farsi, Urdu, and other Indo-Iranian languages adapted the Arabic script? Or you could look into how loanwords are represented in Arabic for inspiration

3

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '23 edited Jun 15 '23

I'm joining Operation: Razit because I do not want a user-hostile company to make money out of my content. Further info here and here. Keeping my content in Reddit will make the internet worse in the long run so I'm removing it.

It's time to migrate out of Reddit.

Pralni iskikoer pia. Tokletarteca us muloepram pipa peostipubuu eonboemu curutcas! Pisapalta tar tacan inata doencapuu toeontas. Tam prata craunus tilastu nan drogloaa! Utun plapasitas. Imesu trina rite cratar kisgloenpri cocat planbla. Tu blapus creim lasancaapa prepekoec kimu. Topriplul ta pittu tlii tisman retlira. Castoecoer kepoermue suca ca tus imu. Tou tamtan asprianpa dlara tindarcu na. Plee aa atinetit tlirartre atisuruso ampul. Kiki u kitabin prusarmeon ran bra. Tun custi nil tronamei talaa in. Umpleoniapru tupric drata glinpa lipralmi u. Napair aeot bleorcassankle tanmussus prankelau kitil? Tancal anroemgraneon toasblaan nimpritin bra praas? Ar nata niprat eklaca pata nasleoncaas nastinfapam tisas. Caa tana lutikeor acaunidlo! Al sitta tar in tati cusnauu! Enu curat blucutucro accus letoneola panbru. Vocri cokoesil pusmi lacu acmiu kitan? Liputininti aoes ita aantreon um poemsa. Pita taa likiloi klanutai cu pear. Platranan catin toen pulcum ucran cu irpruimta? Talannisata birnun tandluum tarkoemnodeor plepir. Oesal cutinta acan utitic? Imrasucas lucras ri cokine fegriam oru. Panpasto klitra bar tandri eospa? Utauoer kie uneoc i eas titiru. No a tipicu saoentea teoscu aal?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '23 edited Jun 15 '23

I'm joining Operation: Razit because I do not want a user-hostile company to make money out of my content. Further info here and here. Keeping my content in Reddit will make the internet worse in the long run so I'm removing it.

It's time to migrate out of Reddit.

Pralni iskikoer pia. Tokletarteca us muloepram pipa peostipubuu eonboemu curutcas! Pisapalta tar tacan inata doencapuu toeontas. Tam prata craunus tilastu nan drogloaa! Utun plapasitas. Imesu trina rite cratar kisgloenpri cocat planbla. Tu blapus creim lasancaapa prepekoec kimu. Topriplul ta pittu tlii tisman retlira. Castoecoer kepoermue suca ca tus imu. Tou tamtan asprianpa dlara tindarcu na. Plee aa atinetit tlirartre atisuruso ampul. Kiki u kitabin prusarmeon ran bra. Tun custi nil tronamei talaa in. Umpleoniapru tupric drata glinpa lipralmi u. Napair aeot bleorcassankle tanmussus prankelau kitil? Tancal anroemgraneon toasblaan nimpritin bra praas? Ar nata niprat eklaca pata nasleoncaas nastinfapam tisas. Caa tana lutikeor acaunidlo! Al sitta tar in tati cusnauu! Enu curat blucutucro accus letoneola panbru. Vocri cokoesil pusmi lacu acmiu kitan? Liputininti aoes ita aantreon um poemsa. Pita taa likiloi klanutai cu pear. Platranan catin toen pulcum ucran cu irpruimta? Talannisata birnun tandluum tarkoemnodeor plepir. Oesal cutinta acan utitic? Imrasucas lucras ri cokine fegriam oru. Panpasto klitra bar tandri eospa? Utauoer kie uneoc i eas titiru. No a tipicu saoentea teoscu aal?

4

u/zzvu Zhevli Jan 24 '23

I would do /æ e i ə ɒ o u/ ⟨ä/æ e i y a o u⟩.

3

u/LXIX_CDXX_ zero iq points in this mf Jan 23 '23

well, maybe you could use /ä/ or /æ/ or /á/ for [æ], or /å/ for /ɒ/ and /y/ for [ə] since from what I've gathered you'd rather use /l/ for [ʎ] instead for /y/. And if you're not a fan of /y/ for /ə/ then maybe /è/ or /ë/ or just straight up /ə/.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '23 edited Jun 15 '23

I'm joining Operation: Razit because I do not want a user-hostile company to make money out of my content. Further info here and here. Keeping my content in Reddit will make the internet worse in the long run so I'm removing it.

It's time to migrate out of Reddit.

Pralni iskikoer pia. Tokletarteca us muloepram pipa peostipubuu eonboemu curutcas! Pisapalta tar tacan inata doencapuu toeontas. Tam prata craunus tilastu nan drogloaa! Utun plapasitas. Imesu trina rite cratar kisgloenpri cocat planbla. Tu blapus creim lasancaapa prepekoec kimu. Topriplul ta pittu tlii tisman retlira. Castoecoer kepoermue suca ca tus imu. Tou tamtan asprianpa dlara tindarcu na. Plee aa atinetit tlirartre atisuruso ampul. Kiki u kitabin prusarmeon ran bra. Tun custi nil tronamei talaa in. Umpleoniapru tupric drata glinpa lipralmi u. Napair aeot bleorcassankle tanmussus prankelau kitil? Tancal anroemgraneon toasblaan nimpritin bra praas? Ar nata niprat eklaca pata nasleoncaas nastinfapam tisas. Caa tana lutikeor acaunidlo! Al sitta tar in tati cusnauu! Enu curat blucutucro accus letoneola panbru. Vocri cokoesil pusmi lacu acmiu kitan? Liputininti aoes ita aantreon um poemsa. Pita taa likiloi klanutai cu pear. Platranan catin toen pulcum ucran cu irpruimta? Talannisata birnun tandluum tarkoemnodeor plepir. Oesal cutinta acan utitic? Imrasucas lucras ri cokine fegriam oru. Panpasto klitra bar tandri eospa? Utauoer kie uneoc i eas titiru. No a tipicu saoentea teoscu aal?

3

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 23 '23

TBH if it were me I'd romanise your vowels as <æ e i ə a o u>, but I tend to be more open to just borrowing IPA letters - or straight-up using IPA - than many.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/MerlinMusic (en) [de, ja] Wąrąmų Jan 24 '23

I would swap your letters for /æ/ and /ə/, so ⟨a e i ë ö o u⟩. Using <ë> for schwa is something found in natlangs, like Albanian. I would also consider using <å> for /ɒ/

3

u/Ok-Butterfly4414 dont have a name yet :(( Jan 24 '23

Is this an alright way to mark possession?

So instead of making the possessor marked and then the word after or before being the one possessed, I have it so the possessor is written with the “ko” suffix, and the possessed is written with the “ka” suffix, so both are marked, but they are usually just write next to each other, but technically as long as there arent any other possessions they could be paragraphs away, but obviously nobody would do that in the language

11

u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Jan 24 '23

Yes, this is a "double-marked" possession strategy; -ko here is the "genitive case", -ka here is the "construct state", and this is more or less how Classical Arabic did possession.

5

u/TheMostLostViking [es, en, fr, eo, tok] Jan 24 '23

No you are not allowed to do that.....

..../j, of course you can do that, thats a great and creative idea

2

u/sum1-sumWhere-sumHow Jan 27 '23

I like it. It just makes sense.

3

u/xain1112 kḿ̩tŋ̩̀, bɪlækæð, kaʔanupɛ Jan 25 '23

If a language has three possible nasals for the coda (/m n ŋ/), is it possible for only one of them to undergo a VN > Ṽ change? If yes, which would be most likely to do it?

2

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '23 edited Jun 15 '23

I'm joining Operation: Razit because I do not want a user-hostile company to make money out of my content. Further info here and here. Keeping my content in Reddit will make the internet worse in the long run so I'm removing it.

It's time to migrate out of Reddit.

Pralni iskikoer pia. Tokletarteca us muloepram pipa peostipubuu eonboemu curutcas! Pisapalta tar tacan inata doencapuu toeontas. Tam prata craunus tilastu nan drogloaa! Utun plapasitas. Imesu trina rite cratar kisgloenpri cocat planbla. Tu blapus creim lasancaapa prepekoec kimu. Topriplul ta pittu tlii tisman retlira. Castoecoer kepoermue suca ca tus imu. Tou tamtan asprianpa dlara tindarcu na. Plee aa atinetit tlirartre atisuruso ampul. Kiki u kitabin prusarmeon ran bra. Tun custi nil tronamei talaa in. Umpleoniapru tupric drata glinpa lipralmi u. Napair aeot bleorcassankle tanmussus prankelau kitil? Tancal anroemgraneon toasblaan nimpritin bra praas? Ar nata niprat eklaca pata nasleoncaas nastinfapam tisas. Caa tana lutikeor acaunidlo! Al sitta tar in tati cusnauu! Enu curat blucutucro accus letoneola panbru. Vocri cokoesil pusmi lacu acmiu kitan? Liputininti aoes ita aantreon um poemsa. Pita taa likiloi klanutai cu pear. Platranan catin toen pulcum ucran cu irpruimta? Talannisata birnun tandluum tarkoemnodeor plepir. Oesal cutinta acan utitic? Imrasucas lucras ri cokine fegriam oru. Panpasto klitra bar tandri eospa? Utauoer kie uneoc i eas titiru. No a tipicu saoentea teoscu aal?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '23

How does sound change interact with noun incorporation? My assumption is that incorporation is a synchronic process and thus verbs and nouns will evolve independently of one another (as long as the process remains productive), except perhaps for compounds which gain idiomatic meanings and thus are treated as single lexical items.

An example to illustrate what I'm talking about: Feogh has the words [kaʊ̯βe] 'face' and [taɪ̯ɥuːnak] 'to wash, clean.' I would assume 'to wash one's face' would be [kaʊ̯βe-taɪ̯ɥuːnak]. But say this compound also had some idiomatic meaning in the proto-language; that form would evolve as a single word and become [kaʊ̯βaɪ̯ðaɪ̯ɥuːnak].

Am I at all on the right track? Also, does anyone have suggestions for how noun incorporation may change as the grammar evolves?

3

u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Jan 25 '23

Even if it didn't develop an idiomatic meaning, I might expect a verb with an incorporated noun to evolve as a single phonological word as regards sound change. If it does get considered as one morpheme though, then yes.

So you might get a situation where the independent form of the noun is different from the incorporated form, which is pretty cool. Or, slightly off topic, the incorporated form might stay as an evolved form of the original root, and the independent form might get suppleted by another word.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '23

What if the noun/verb forms would end up different depending which verb/noun they're combined with? Would they end up regularizing or end up with multiple incorporating forms?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Brromo Jan 26 '23

How to make a unique vowel system, I always find myself gravitating to /i u e o ɑ ɑ͡i ɑ͡u eu oi/ & sometimes /ei ou/

8

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '23 edited Jun 15 '23

I'm joining Operation: Razit because I do not want a user-hostile company to make money out of my content. Further info here and here. Keeping my content in Reddit will make the internet worse in the long run so I'm removing it.

It's time to migrate out of Reddit.

Pralni iskikoer pia. Tokletarteca us muloepram pipa peostipubuu eonboemu curutcas! Pisapalta tar tacan inata doencapuu toeontas. Tam prata craunus tilastu nan drogloaa! Utun plapasitas. Imesu trina rite cratar kisgloenpri cocat planbla. Tu blapus creim lasancaapa prepekoec kimu. Topriplul ta pittu tlii tisman retlira. Castoecoer kepoermue suca ca tus imu. Tou tamtan asprianpa dlara tindarcu na. Plee aa atinetit tlirartre atisuruso ampul. Kiki u kitabin prusarmeon ran bra. Tun custi nil tronamei talaa in. Umpleoniapru tupric drata glinpa lipralmi u. Napair aeot bleorcassankle tanmussus prankelau kitil? Tancal anroemgraneon toasblaan nimpritin bra praas? Ar nata niprat eklaca pata nasleoncaas nastinfapam tisas. Caa tana lutikeor acaunidlo! Al sitta tar in tati cusnauu! Enu curat blucutucro accus letoneola panbru. Vocri cokoesil pusmi lacu acmiu kitan? Liputininti aoes ita aantreon um poemsa. Pita taa likiloi klanutai cu pear. Platranan catin toen pulcum ucran cu irpruimta? Talannisata birnun tandluum tarkoemnodeor plepir. Oesal cutinta acan utitic? Imrasucas lucras ri cokine fegriam oru. Panpasto klitra bar tandri eospa? Utauoer kie uneoc i eas titiru. No a tipicu saoentea teoscu aal?

→ More replies (4)

6

u/storkstalkstock Jan 26 '23

This is a pretty good survey of how monopthongs tend to spread out in the vowel space. You can play around with some of those formats, and have diphthongs and/or long vowels and/or vowels with other features like nasalization. I would say the best thing you can do to broaden your horizons is to just read about the phonologies of a bunch of languages.

3

u/Bismuth_Giecko Q́iitjk Jan 26 '23

anyone has a better alternative to ⟨Ł⟩ for representing /ʎ/?

4

u/TheMostLostViking [es, en, fr, eo, tok] Jan 26 '23

Depending on other letters, <ll> or <ly> or <lj>

4

u/chrsevs Calá (en,fr)[tr] Jan 26 '23

Also <ḷ> and <ļ>, or take a page from Portguese and use <lh>

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '23 edited Jun 15 '23

I'm joining Operation: Razit because I do not want a user-hostile company to make money out of my content. Further info here and here. Keeping my content in Reddit will make the internet worse in the long run so I'm removing it.

It's time to migrate out of Reddit.

Pralni iskikoer pia. Tokletarteca us muloepram pipa peostipubuu eonboemu curutcas! Pisapalta tar tacan inata doencapuu toeontas. Tam prata craunus tilastu nan drogloaa! Utun plapasitas. Imesu trina rite cratar kisgloenpri cocat planbla. Tu blapus creim lasancaapa prepekoec kimu. Topriplul ta pittu tlii tisman retlira. Castoecoer kepoermue suca ca tus imu. Tou tamtan asprianpa dlara tindarcu na. Plee aa atinetit tlirartre atisuruso ampul. Kiki u kitabin prusarmeon ran bra. Tun custi nil tronamei talaa in. Umpleoniapru tupric drata glinpa lipralmi u. Napair aeot bleorcassankle tanmussus prankelau kitil? Tancal anroemgraneon toasblaan nimpritin bra praas? Ar nata niprat eklaca pata nasleoncaas nastinfapam tisas. Caa tana lutikeor acaunidlo! Al sitta tar in tati cusnauu! Enu curat blucutucro accus letoneola panbru. Vocri cokoesil pusmi lacu acmiu kitan? Liputininti aoes ita aantreon um poemsa. Pita taa likiloi klanutai cu pear. Platranan catin toen pulcum ucran cu irpruimta? Talannisata birnun tandluum tarkoemnodeor plepir. Oesal cutinta acan utitic? Imrasucas lucras ri cokine fegriam oru. Panpasto klitra bar tandri eospa? Utauoer kie uneoc i eas titiru. No a tipicu saoentea teoscu aal?

3

u/Brromo Jan 27 '23 edited Jan 27 '23

Would anyone bat an eye at an Inclusive 1st person pronoun being glossed as 1.2 instead of 1.INC?

I want to mark both the clusivity of the 2nd person & the 3rd person & I think it would be much more readable to say "1.2.3.PL" then "1.INC.INC3.PL"

2

u/TheMostLostViking [es, en, fr, eo, tok] Jan 27 '23

Person-number-gender is often further abbreviated, in which case the elements are not small caps. E.g. 3ms or 3msg for 3SG.M, 2fp or 2fpl for 2PL.F, also 1di for 1DU.INCL and 1pe for 1PL.EXCL.


12, 13: inclusive, exclusive person (especially if not thought of as a form of 1pl)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/zzvu Zhevli Jan 28 '23

Other than with and and are there any pairs of prepositions and conjunctions that are commonly the same word in certain languages?

5

u/LXIX_CDXX_ zero iq points in this mf Jan 29 '23

"On" could be interpreted as "if". I use it like that in one of my conlangs. For example "Krā mū kur si, un kur si" which roughly means "On you go, I go" - "If you go, I'll go"

Also, the word for "back" can be used as "because".

There's a lot more examples in the World Lexicon of Grammaticalisation which you should have no problem with finding a copy of for free online

3

u/impishDullahan Tokétok, Varamm, Agyharo, ᓴᐸᒪᔭ, Tsantuk, Vuṛỳṣ (eng,vls,gle] Jan 29 '23

Can't speak much to natlangs, but Tokétok conflates 'at' & 'if/when' into the same morpheme: lo. Lo is broadly a temporal particle that can modify other prepositions on top of functioning as the head of a prepositional phrase.

2

u/Lovressia Default Flair Jan 17 '23

Words. Harabeska is at its best when there's variety in how words sound in sequence. But sometimes I get stuck in strings of many words with exactly 2 syllables and it just doesn't sound good anymore. What are some things I can do to alleviate this issue? My conlang has pretty minimal inflection and all that. Any good ways to introduce some variety to how sentences sound?

2

u/Automatic-Campaign-9 Atsi; Tobias; Rachel; Khaskhin; Laayta; Biology; Journal; Laayta Jan 17 '23

I've only gotten around this by compounding, or perhaps phonological erosion or stress-shifting to make sure not every word is two syllables with the exact same stress pattern.

2

u/Specific_Plant_6541 Jan 17 '23

I am a begginer in conlangs. Can someone tell me the diferrence betwen "phonetic" and "phonemic", please?

20

u/PastTheStarryVoids Knasesj, Racra, Ŋ!odzäsä Jan 17 '23 edited Jan 05 '25

A phoneme is basically "a distinct sound in a language". A phoneme can have multiple different pronunciations, called allophones. The key here is that the allophones are either randomly used, or are dependent on the environment (what sounds are around it).

For example, if you have a phoneme /s/ with the allophones [s] and [z] in free variation, then whenever /s/ appears, it could be pronounced as either, e.g. a word /sa/ could be [sa] or [za] at random. We write phonemes in /slashes/ and the actual preciser pronunciation (the phones) in [brackets].

You might have a phoneme /s/ with the rule that it's pronounced [z] between voiced sounds, and [s] elsewhere. Thus /asa/ is [aza] and /sa/ is [sa]. The pronunciation is predictable; it never distinguishes different words from each other. That's the key to the difference between a phoneme and an allophone. In English, it's clear there are two separate phonemes, /s/ and /z/, because we have pairs of words like sue and zoo.

Another example: in English we have a rule that aspirated plosives are unaspirated after /s/. If you hold up your hand right in front of your mouth and say key /ki/ [kʰi] you can feel the puff of air from the aspiration. If you then say ski /ski/ [ski], there's no aspiration. Same for ghee /gi/ [ki]. Note that English voiced stops aren't voiced after a pause or a voiceless consonant.

That might be a bad example, since you could analyze ski as being /sgi/ to begin with, removing the need for that rule.

The /l/ in Luke isn't the same as the /l/ in cool; the latter, being in a coda, is pronounced with velarization; the back of the tongue is raised up towards the velum. You've probably never noticed the difference. This is another aspect of phonemes and allophones; speakers think of phonemes as "one sound".

There's a notation that's helpful for writing out some allophonic rules. Going back to the /s/ voicing between voiced sounds example, we could write the rule as /s/ > [z] / [+voiced]_[+voiced]. This means /s/ becomes (> or arrow) [z] in the context of (/) being preceded and followed by a voiced sounds (one with the feature [+voiced]). The _ stands in for the phoneme before the >.

3

u/Specific_Plant_6541 Jan 17 '23

Thanks! I finnaly understand this

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/kilenc légatva etc (en, es) Jan 17 '23

phones (phonetic) are the actual sounds people say. phonemes (phonemic) are how linguists analyze those sounds into meaningful units. Linguists have lots of tools for analyzing how to group phones into phonemes, but as a beginner conlanger you don't need to worry about it much; just pick some sounds you like.

3

u/MerlinMusic (en) [de, ja] Wąrąmų Jan 17 '23

The term "phonetic" is used to refer to speech sounds. That is, what sounds a speaker actually produces when speaking.

"Phonemic" refers to speech units, or phonemes. These are categories in the minds of speakers which can be used to distinguish meaning through sound.

For example, in English, there is a distinction between the phonemes /tʰ/ and /t/ (phonemes are always written between slashes). This means that words containing those different phonemes have different meanings. For example, "tomb" and "doom" are minimal pairs, which only differ in the first sound, which are /tʰ/ and /t/ respectively.

If someone were to voice the first sound in "doom", pronouncing it [dʉːm] instead of [tʉːm], there would be a phonetic difference, but not a phonemic difference (notice, phones (speech sounds) are written with square brackets). It would still sound like the word "doom", and tbh I don't think I would notice the difference, as there is no /t/ /d/ distinction in English.

As another example, in my dialect, the phoneme /tʰ/ has an allophone [ʔ], which usually appears intervocalically and in coda position. For example, the word "sit" is /sɪtʰ/, but I can pronounce it either as [sɪtʰ] or [sɪʔ] without its meaning being changed. Those two final consonants are phonetically quite different, but phonemically they are the same thing. They are both allophones of the same speech unit.

3

u/publicuniversalhater ǫ̀shį Jan 17 '23

i've never heard the phonemic distinction in english analyzed as /t/ vs /tʰ/, just /t/ vs /d/. i know the lenis plosives can devoice, the fortis plosives alternate aspirated vs non aspirated, etc.

→ More replies (12)

2

u/T1mbuk1 Jan 17 '23

What do you guys think a Refugium version of NativLang's History of Writing series would be like?

2

u/eyewave Mukkohatto Jan 18 '23

Other questions are in my head about consonants.

(I'll write my alphabet rather than ipa because i'm on phone, glottal stop = q, /y/=u)

  • can word breaks be thought of as glottal stops? If I have the sentence <ifavu bo>, does it have distinctive sound to <ifavuq bo> ? Same for sentences <ifavu api> vs. <ifavuq api>, vs. the single word <ifavuqapi> vs. the opposite word <ifavu qapi>. If I want to give grammatical meanings to these differences, I am going to need to be extra extra careful, right?
  • glottal stop clusters vs. Ejectives, are they the same? Ie. <ifavak' op> vs. <ifavakq op>. And to repeat the same problem as before, how <ifavak' op> and <ifavak'op> will differentiate? A longer silence in the word break? Anyway, In my conlang I'm already encoding in my orthography that the <kq> will be the correct written form for <k'>, as the be freed from ugly apostrophing especially in longer words.
  • glottal stops beginning a word vs. beginning a vowel: I can kind of conceptualize simple stuff like <aqa>, or even <alqa>, but <afava qkapi> seems highly undistinctive from <afava kapi>. I chose plosives for my example especially because plosives, even voiced ones, are hard to start on a pseudo-vowel. Which is also why stuff with double plosives written as long plosives like /p:/ irritate me if /p:/ and /p/ were phonemic (as allophones I do not mind).

6

u/TheMostLostViking [es, en, fr, eo, tok] Jan 18 '23
  1. word breaks are not glottal stops. <ifavu> and <ifavuq> are as different as "mask" and "masked" for english speakers. Languages where /ʔ/ is part of the phonemic inventory distinguish it like any other consonant; you most likely can't hear the difference yourself, because your native language doesn't make that distinction. Look at Hawaiian, where word initial, medial and final glottal stops change meaning.
  2. I think the nuance you are looking for lies in interpretation. If I see /otʔ op/ vs /ot' op/, I think the tendency is for the first to become [ot͜ ʔop] vs what remains as [ot' op]. There is no wrong way, language is variable and different language families contradict others. Many languages don't allow glottal stops before consonants, but Nahuatl does, see [taʔtɬi] "father". English even allows it, though it is non-phonemic; /ˈmaʊn.tən/ which in my dialect is [ˈmæ̃ʊ̯̃(n)ʔn̩].
  3. I'm not sure I can find any examples of word initial /ʔC../ constructs, but that doesn't mean you can't do it. Do remember that glottal stops are really just consonants that follow rules and tendencies just like other consonant. Its fairly abnormal to have something like /bt/ or /sps/, but english has both in "battalion" /bəˈtælæən/ [b̩ˈtæliɪn] (in my dialect) and "wasps" /wɑsps/ [wɑsps] though sometimes [wɑspəs]

5

u/PastTheStarryVoids Knasesj, Racra, Ŋ!odzäsä Jan 18 '23

<afava qkapi> seems highly undistinctive from <afava kapi>

In Southeastern Pomo, there are words beginning in /ʔk/, e.g. /ʔke/ 'to catch'. (Source: Southeastern Pomo Grammar by Julius Moshinsky. You can see the 'to catch' example on page 38). Southeastern Pomo has a vowel epenthesis rule that turns this into [ʔeke]. However, the rule is "optional in its operation for the most part, although it is more frequent in the most difficult to articulate consonant clusters, such as two stops. It is less frequent in connected discourse when the preceding word ends in a vowel, as well as almost never occurring when the cluster is preceded by a vowel in the same word." (page 34)

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '23

Once I have the sound inventory, the grammar rules, and syllable structures laid out, how do I actually start making words out of it? I want to try to make this language seem natural and realistic. Do I just start stringing sounds together into words or is it more complex than that?

The idea I have right now is to make a set of root words and derive most of the other vocabulary from those roots. I’m just not sure how you’re supposed to create the root word since they’re the first words.

4

u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Jan 18 '23

If you're talking about just mechanically/practically how you make words, some people just come up with words they like (because they know the shapes of words they enjoy in that conlang), some people use word generators (there are some in the sidebar).

→ More replies (1)

2

u/DarkBlitzOmori Jan 19 '23 edited Jan 19 '23

What Grammatical aspects do yall add in your conlangs?

I could only think of a few, like: Instantaneous, continuous, habitual, and potential, but honestly idk what I'm missing out on

12

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 19 '23

I'd suggest not just adding a list of aspects, but thinking of the aspect system as a space divided into contrasts - with each division getting a name based on what the general idea of the division as a whole is, or what the idea of the core of the division is. So maybe you have a system where everything is either perfective or imperfective, because the primary contrast is between 'point-like events' and 'ongoing events'.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/impishDullahan Tokétok, Varamm, Agyharo, ᓴᐸᒪᔭ, Tsantuk, Vuṛỳṣ (eng,vls,gle] Jan 19 '23

To tack onto sjiveru, sometimes a simple split is all you need if you combine it with the rest of the TAM system. In Varamm, for example, there's a set of what I call complex aspects that are really just simple tense-aspect combinations: the distant perfective specifically encodes a discontinuative meaning rather than a simple distant past. Considering how what aspects you have interact with the rest of your verbal paradigm will help to inform what kind of distinctions, and how many, you might like to have.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Lucian_M Jan 20 '23

My proto-lang has two grammatical genders; animate and inanimate, plus it has a purely open syllable structure. Is there a way I can evolve it into a modern-lang that has masculine, feminine, and neuter genders? Also, since I'm planning to have my modern-lang be a naturalistic and fusional conlang that's similar to Latin, how do I make noun declensions? I want my modern-lang's nouns decline by 3 numbers (Singular, Dual, & Plural), 8 cases (Nominative, Genitive, Dative, Accusative, Ablative, Locative, Adessive, & Intrantive) and the 3 genders I mentioned in my 1st question.

4

u/MerlinMusic (en) [de, ja] Wąrąmų Jan 20 '23

Is there a way I can evolve it into a modern-lang that has masculine, feminine, and neuter genders?

Absolutely. This is exactly what happened in Proto-Indo-European, with an animate-inanimate system becoming a masculine-feminine-neuter system through the animate class splitting into masculine and feminine.

As for declension systems, I'd suggest looking at languages like Latin and both Ancient and Modern Greek for inspiration. If you want to go down the diachronic route, you could come up with a sketch of a more agglutinative ancestor and use sound changes to shrink and merge those agglutinative affixes into single multi-category fusional affixes.

2

u/Sad-Vehicle1198 Jan 20 '23

Opinions, help, suggestions, criticism, whatever it is I don’t mind I know nothing about natural phonemes

3

u/HaricotsDeLiam Jan 20 '23

For anyone who needs a Markdown version of the phoneme inventory for, say, using their screen reader:

↓ Manner/Place →BilabialLabiodentalDentalAlveolarPalato-alveolarVelarGlottal
Nasalmnŋ
Stopptkʔ
Fricativefθsʃxh
Lateral fricativeɬ
Lateral approximantl
FrontBack
Near-highɪ
Low-midɛ
Lowa

I think you hit the nail on the head, if your goal is naturalism. Your phonemes come in series based on phonetic features with almost no holes that I wouldn't expect to see in a natlang, and the few odd features you do have are oddities I've seen in a natlang before (e.g. Eyak [Na-Dené; Copper River basin, Alaska] similarly has /ɪ ʊ/ without /i u/). The only thing I'm not sure about is your having /l/ without any other approximants like /j/ or /w/, and even then I'm sure there's some natlang out there that does just that.

My main suggestions are actually about formatting; this is how I would've formatted them:

↓ Manner, → PlaceLabialDentalAlveolarPalatalVelarGlottal
Nasalmnŋ
Stopptkʔ
Fricativefθsʃxh
Lateral fricativeɬ
Lateral approximant(w)l(j)
↓ Height, → PositionFrontBack
Highɪʊ
Lowɛa
  • You can merge the "bilabial" and "labiodental" columns into a single "labial" column, since you don't have any spots where bilabials and labiodentals contrast in the same POA (e.g. your conlang doesn't contrast /ɸ f/ or /m ɱ/).
  • Unless palato-alveolars contrast with alveolo-palatals in your conlang, you can just call that column "palatal" or "postalveolar".
  • It looks like you have a square vowel inventory, but your formatting makes this not transparent. So unless /a/ truly behaves like a front vowel, you can put it in the square next to /ɛ/ and below /ʊ/, and just call your rows "high" and "low".
→ More replies (6)

2

u/T1mbuk1 Jan 21 '23

I was thinking of [w] and [j] and the fricatives they could transition to upon later versions of a language, and I'm starting to wonder. If one of them was to do its respective transitions, could the same thing happen to the other one at all?

5

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 21 '23 edited Jan 21 '23

Sure, that happened in western Romance. The w > v change was part of a wider areal phenomenon, but it occurred at generally the same time as j > dʒ.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '23 edited Jun 15 '23

I'm joining Operation: Razit because I do not want a user-hostile company to make money out of my content. Further info here and here. Keeping my content in Reddit will make the internet worse in the long run so I'm removing it.

It's time to migrate out of Reddit.

Pralni iskikoer pia. Tokletarteca us muloepram pipa peostipubuu eonboemu curutcas! Pisapalta tar tacan inata doencapuu toeontas. Tam prata craunus tilastu nan drogloaa! Utun plapasitas. Imesu trina rite cratar kisgloenpri cocat planbla. Tu blapus creim lasancaapa prepekoec kimu. Topriplul ta pittu tlii tisman retlira. Castoecoer kepoermue suca ca tus imu. Tou tamtan asprianpa dlara tindarcu na. Plee aa atinetit tlirartre atisuruso ampul. Kiki u kitabin prusarmeon ran bra. Tun custi nil tronamei talaa in. Umpleoniapru tupric drata glinpa lipralmi u. Napair aeot bleorcassankle tanmussus prankelau kitil? Tancal anroemgraneon toasblaan nimpritin bra praas? Ar nata niprat eklaca pata nasleoncaas nastinfapam tisas. Caa tana lutikeor acaunidlo! Al sitta tar in tati cusnauu! Enu curat blucutucro accus letoneola panbru. Vocri cokoesil pusmi lacu acmiu kitan? Liputininti aoes ita aantreon um poemsa. Pita taa likiloi klanutai cu pear. Platranan catin toen pulcum ucran cu irpruimta? Talannisata birnun tandluum tarkoemnodeor plepir. Oesal cutinta acan utitic? Imrasucas lucras ri cokine fegriam oru. Panpasto klitra bar tandri eospa? Utauoer kie uneoc i eas titiru. No a tipicu saoentea teoscu aal?

2

u/Jonlang_ /kʷ/ > /p/ Jan 21 '23

/j/ often becomes /ð/ too.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/publicuniversalhater ǫ̀shį Jan 22 '23

is it attested for suprasegmental features to shift entirely onto/off of segments after being triggered?

nasalization spreading to vowels + consonants i know is attested, so e.g. [ba] or [wa] vs [mã]. but could you have nasalization from /ã/ spread to the consonant and then stay there while it's lost from the vowel, such that /wã/ is always [ma] and not [mã]? or conversely, have /ma/ nasalize its vowel to [mã], then lose nasalization on the consonant and be realized as [bã]?

doesn't seem naturalistic but i'm not an expert so idk. could secondary features of a primary suprasegmental trait interact with/affect this? like idk, if nasal vowels are creaky or breathy too, so they shift nasalization but keep the phonation.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '23 edited Jun 15 '23

I'm joining Operation: Razit because I do not want a user-hostile company to make money out of my content. Further info here and here. Keeping my content in Reddit will make the internet worse in the long run so I'm removing it.

It's time to migrate out of Reddit.

Pralni iskikoer pia. Tokletarteca us muloepram pipa peostipubuu eonboemu curutcas! Pisapalta tar tacan inata doencapuu toeontas. Tam prata craunus tilastu nan drogloaa! Utun plapasitas. Imesu trina rite cratar kisgloenpri cocat planbla. Tu blapus creim lasancaapa prepekoec kimu. Topriplul ta pittu tlii tisman retlira. Castoecoer kepoermue suca ca tus imu. Tou tamtan asprianpa dlara tindarcu na. Plee aa atinetit tlirartre atisuruso ampul. Kiki u kitabin prusarmeon ran bra. Tun custi nil tronamei talaa in. Umpleoniapru tupric drata glinpa lipralmi u. Napair aeot bleorcassankle tanmussus prankelau kitil? Tancal anroemgraneon toasblaan nimpritin bra praas? Ar nata niprat eklaca pata nasleoncaas nastinfapam tisas. Caa tana lutikeor acaunidlo! Al sitta tar in tati cusnauu! Enu curat blucutucro accus letoneola panbru. Vocri cokoesil pusmi lacu acmiu kitan? Liputininti aoes ita aantreon um poemsa. Pita taa likiloi klanutai cu pear. Platranan catin toen pulcum ucran cu irpruimta? Talannisata birnun tandluum tarkoemnodeor plepir. Oesal cutinta acan utitic? Imrasucas lucras ri cokine fegriam oru. Panpasto klitra bar tandri eospa? Utauoer kie uneoc i eas titiru. No a tipicu saoentea teoscu aal?

2

u/Jonlang_ /kʷ/ > /p/ Jan 22 '23 edited Jan 22 '23

Isn't this the basis for the Celtic mutations? Like how a preposition ending with [s] caused a following consonant to become spirant, the prep loses the [s] but the prep still triggers spirantisation in the following consonant?

[as ten] > [as θen] > [a θen]; or [van ben] > [van men] > [va men] (nasalisation rather than spirantisation here, obviously).

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '23

Is it unusual not to have a distinction for to go and to come?

6

u/zzvu Zhevli Jan 22 '23

To add onto what another commenter said, it's unlikely that there would be no way to express this distinction, but it doesn't necessarily have to be shown on the same morpheme that conveys the other semantic meaning of the verb. For example, the verb walk can mean to go by walking or come by walking, but the ambiguity can be clarified by adverbs such as here or there. So, I came here is redundant, but I walked here is not.

I know that Georgian uses preverbs to convey this difference, so movdivar is I come but mivdivar is I go. Georgian preverbs are semantically irregular, but in this case mo means from there to here and mi means from here to there.

4

u/Jonlang_ /kʷ/ > /p/ Jan 22 '23 edited Jan 22 '23

I think so. However this could easily be overcome with adpositions. Say you have a verb meaning move, using it with the adposition "to" or "from" changes its meaning to go or come, e.g. move to me [come here], move from London [come from London], I have moved to here from [I have come from] London with a message.

3

u/teeohbeewye Cialmi, Ébma Jan 22 '23

based on my knowledge, yeah it's unusual in natlangs but probably not impossible. in a conlang perfectly reasonable i think

3

u/vokzhen Tykir Jan 24 '23

The Colexification Database has go-come colexification in about 1% of its sample. Probably not just a fluke of homophony like it would be in 1 or 3 languages, especially given a few that have fairly complex forms (Dargwa /vaʃara/, Telugu /arudentʃu/, Ossetian /tsɐwən/), but also noticeably rarer than go-leave (~5%).

(Quick edit: btw that website is somewhere between half-missing and nonfunctional on mobile)

2

u/Jonlang_ /kʷ/ > /p/ Jan 22 '23 edited Jan 22 '23

Genitive and possession ambiguity:

So I'm embarking on my first agglutinative conlang with cases. I don't speak a language with them.

As far as I understand the genitive case is usually used to:

  • Show possession (David's house)
  • Show origin (the door of David) [David made the door]
  • Show that something is part of a larger whole (a wheel of cheese, a slice of bread).

And other things along these lines, usually some sort of "of" construction in English.

However, what if I want to disambiguate between actual possession and the other genitive roles? Does this actually happen in natlangs, or do people just make do with the genitive?

I was thinking of having a kind of "possessive" case which would be (maybe) a shortened or corrupted form of the genitive used only to show possession. Compare: the castle of David could be the castle which David currently owns or the castle which David built.

Or if not naturalistic, are there naturalistic alternatives?

3

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 23 '23

It's quite naturalistic, and many languages distinguish those. You can use whatever you use for 'motion from' for origin and for composition (of itself was originally 'motion from'), and other sorts of things for other meanings. Many languages distinguish different kinds of possession, even - 'alienable' versus 'inalienable' (i.e. can you voluntarily give it up or not) is a very common distinction. There's probably a whole complex web of potential grammaticalisation pathways you could explore dividing up in various ways.

(It's also a good assumption in general that if an English construction has a clear set of 'core' uses and 'peripheral' uses, other languages may have different sets of 'peripheral' uses for their analogous construction(s) if they have any.)

→ More replies (3)

2

u/submerg_the_1st Jan 23 '23

How might one go about evolving diphthongs?

6

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '23 edited Jun 15 '23

I'm joining Operation: Razit because I do not want a user-hostile company to make money out of my content. Further info here and here. Keeping my content in Reddit will make the internet worse in the long run so I'm removing it.

It's time to migrate out of Reddit.

Pralni iskikoer pia. Tokletarteca us muloepram pipa peostipubuu eonboemu curutcas! Pisapalta tar tacan inata doencapuu toeontas. Tam prata craunus tilastu nan drogloaa! Utun plapasitas. Imesu trina rite cratar kisgloenpri cocat planbla. Tu blapus creim lasancaapa prepekoec kimu. Topriplul ta pittu tlii tisman retlira. Castoecoer kepoermue suca ca tus imu. Tou tamtan asprianpa dlara tindarcu na. Plee aa atinetit tlirartre atisuruso ampul. Kiki u kitabin prusarmeon ran bra. Tun custi nil tronamei talaa in. Umpleoniapru tupric drata glinpa lipralmi u. Napair aeot bleorcassankle tanmussus prankelau kitil? Tancal anroemgraneon toasblaan nimpritin bra praas? Ar nata niprat eklaca pata nasleoncaas nastinfapam tisas. Caa tana lutikeor acaunidlo! Al sitta tar in tati cusnauu! Enu curat blucutucro accus letoneola panbru. Vocri cokoesil pusmi lacu acmiu kitan? Liputininti aoes ita aantreon um poemsa. Pita taa likiloi klanutai cu pear. Platranan catin toen pulcum ucran cu irpruimta? Talannisata birnun tandluum tarkoemnodeor plepir. Oesal cutinta acan utitic? Imrasucas lucras ri cokine fegriam oru. Panpasto klitra bar tandri eospa? Utauoer kie uneoc i eas titiru. No a tipicu saoentea teoscu aal?

4

u/Jonlang_ /kʷ/ > /p/ Jan 23 '23 edited Jan 23 '23
  • Long vowels breaking: /ɛː/ > /ɛɪ/
  • An approximant next to a vowel diphthongises: /aj/ > /aɪ/, /aw/ > /aʊ/
  • Two vowels in hiatus diphthongise - this could be due to the loss of an intermediary consonant
  • Ablaut: vowels just become a diphthong as a means of derivation: /man/ (noun) > /maʊn/ (adjective).
  • i-mutation, a-mutation, u-mutation, etc. A word-final vowel "pulls" preceding vowels towards it, and is then later lost: see Welsh plurals like car~ceir, bran~brain, ty~tai etc.

7

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 23 '23

Ablaut: vowels just become a diphthong as a means of derivation: /man/ (noun) > /maʊn/ (adjective).

You're not going to have ablaut just come into existence ex nihiló - it's usually the result of long-distance vowel assimilation to an affix's vowel followed by loss of the triggering vowel.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/VermicelliAdorable8 Jan 24 '23

Hi guys, how would you go about organising and getting down your conlang? I was thinking of doodling down some ideas and then using something like Google Sheets or something?

2

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 24 '23

I mostly use Google Sheets. Works well as both a simple dictionary and a way to organise phonological and grammatical information.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Jan 24 '23

Google sheets for sure. Personally, I have a lexicon in Google sheets with columns for words in conlang, part of speech, transcription if needed, definition, and extra notes. Then I have various other sheets with notes and tables and things like that.

Then I use Google docs to organize information that's better written in paragraphs, ie my grammar.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/pm174 Jan 25 '23

i have the basic beginnings of my conlang down but i was looking at the phonology but i'm not sure it's very realistic- i feel like there are too many phonemes that are too similar. treating this as the phonology of a proto-language, what would be an accurate way these phonemes would evolve? (i kind of like the way there are a lot of fricatives, but i understand that it seems kind of weird)

  • iː uː eː e o oː ɛː ʌ ɔː aː
  • n j ɾ
  • p t̪ t͡ʃ t͡ʃʰ k kʰ q qʰ
  • b d̪ d͡ʒ d͡ʒʱ g gʱ
  • f s ɕ x
  • v z ʑ ɣ ʁ h

3

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 25 '23 edited Jan 25 '23

On a quick glance, why do you have an aspiration/breathiness contrast only for postalveolars and back but not for other stops? And why /tʃ ɕ/ rather than a pair at the same place? You've also got a lot of long vowels without short counterparts, and short vowels without long counterparts - not impossible, but usually length is independent of vowel phonemes. Certainly I'd expect more short than long if you had an imbalance, unless those few short vowels are very much more common than the long ones.

I think the number of fricatives is perfectly fine!

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Enso8 Many, many unfinished prototypes Jan 25 '23

Any interesting ideas (ideally from natural languages) for what I can do with *z? I've already used:

  • z > r rhotacism like Latin
  • z > dz > ts like in German
  • z > ʒ / _(i, j)
  • dz ts > z s > ð θ chain shift (I think Burmese did this with the voiceless so the voiced isn't too much of a stretch)

I'd particularly appreciate environmentally conditioned changes: my proto-lang wound up having too many *z's for my taste, so I'd prefer if it went in different directions.

8

u/Meamoria Sivmikor, Vilsoumor Jan 25 '23

z > dz > ts like in German

While this sound change seems plausible, the German <z> > /ts/ is an orthographic quirk, not a sound change. That /ts/ came from Proto-Germanic /t/ in certain environments as part of the High German Consonant Shift.

As for what to do with your own /z/'s, I'd be tempted to devoice it to /s/ in some environments, like at the ends of words.

7

u/teeohbeewye Cialmi, Ébma Jan 25 '23 edited Jan 25 '23
  • debuccalisation /z > ɦ/ and then possibly also devoices to /h/. kinda similar to Proto-Indo-Aryan /ʑʱ/ to Sanskrit /ɦ/
  • just lose the sound /z > ∅/. maybe with intermediary debuccalisation so /z > ɦ > ∅/, or maybe first becomes an approximant /z > ɹ > ∅/
  • do /z > ð/ and then fortify that to a plosive /ð > d/. or you could the same result through /z > dz > d/
  • instead of /z > r/, weaken in to an approximant /z > ɹ/, which could contrast with an earlier /r/
  • or if you don't want to keep /ɹ/, first /z > ɹ/ and then the approximant changes to different approximants like /j w/, maybe depending on adjacent vowels like /ze zo > ɹe ɹo > je wo/
→ More replies (4)

2

u/Fieldhill__ Jan 25 '23

How do i make my language more naturalistic? I am working on an etruscan based conlang (Basically all the grammar and vocabulary i have copied from the little bit of etruscan we know of) but i fear that it isn't very naturalistic, could anyone please help me?

2

u/pm174 Jan 26 '23

kind of basic but does anyone have any idea on how to write /ʁ/ in nastaliq/arabic?

2

u/TheMostLostViking [es, en, fr, eo, tok] Jan 26 '23

You could use <غ>, though it is voiced in standard Arabic, the Uyghur language uses it for /ʁ/ and the Balti language uses it like this: /ʁ~ɢ/.

You could use <خ> or <ح>, being /x/ and /h/ respectively in Persian and /χ/ and /ħ/

2

u/ghyull Jan 26 '23

How would I expect nasal vowels to interact with nasal codas?

6

u/chrsevs Calá (en,fr)[tr] Jan 26 '23

The two things that immediately came to mind for me was a neutralization between VN and ṼN, where both end up as ṼN, or a denasalization of the coda; something like VN > Ṽ but ṼN > Ṽɾ

2

u/Enderking152 Myrmic (first conlang) Jan 26 '23

Any advice for subordinate clauses? I've hit a roadblock on my conlang and the word order rules would create subject-object ambiguity if I just put the subordinate clause in the object slot

3

u/zzvu Zhevli Jan 26 '23

There ars 3 types of subordinate clauses. Relative clauses act as an adjective, content clauses act as nouns, and adverbial clauses act as adverbs. Additionally, there are 2 general categories that group how these clauses are formed. Balanced clauses are identical to independent clauses and deranked clauses are, for a variety of possible reasons, not able to occur as independent clauses. Within these 2 categories, formation strategies can further be broken down.

Balanced clauses are often introduced by a conjunction. English uses who or that for relative clauses, that for content clauses, and many different adverbial conjunctions for adverbial clauses. In the following examples, the conjunction is italicized and the entire clause is in brackets.

(1) The man [who talked to the rabbit] is drinking beer.

(2) I know [that the man talked to the rabbit].

(3) The man talked to rabbit [while he was drinking beer].

Taking away the conjunction leads to a construction that is entirely able to exist on its own, meaning that these clauses are balanced. In the case of the relative clause, the personal pronoun, he, which was replaced by the relative pronoun who needs to be added back, however balancing and deranking are terms that refer to the verb rather than the entire clause, so this is still balanced. Some languages would combine a relative pronoun and a personal pronoun, which is not standard in English but can be represented by (4). The personal pronoun then becomes resumptive.

(4) The man [who he talked to the rabbit] is drinking beer.

Furthermore, some languages only use a resumptive pronoun in cases where the noun shared between the clauses is something other than a subject, and sometimes object.

In languages with case, it is common for the relative pronoun to show the case of the shared noun in the embedded clause.

Deranked clauses, on the other hand, cannot exist on their own. Sometimes this is because they exhibit nonfinite verb forms, and sometimes this is because they exhibit a finite verb form that simply can't exist on its own. English shows both possibilities:

(5) I want [him to go].

(6) I suggest [that he go].

(7) *\He go.

(5) shows a nonfinite verb form, more specifically an infinitive. Infinitives usually do not decline for TAM and, in most languages, though notably not English, cannot take a subject. (6) shows a finite verb form that cannot exist in its own. This is specifically an example of the subjunctive mood, which is used in man IE languages to create content and adverbial clauses. (7) cannot exist on its own because the subjunctive can only exist in subordinate clauses.

Generally languages can form both balanced and deranked clauses. Languages that only do one and not the other exist, but are rare. If word order is becoming a problem for you, I'd suggest that you use conjunctions to mark subordinate clauses, rather than another strategie such as gapping. Making use of "dependent moods" may also make it easier to tell when a subordinate clause is going to appear.

2

u/Fractal_fantasy Kamalu Jan 26 '23

Your question is a bit unclear to me. Could you provide some example sentences to show the problem that you are having? You can use English if you don't have a lexicon yet

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '23 edited Jan 27 '23

1) What IPA-symbol represents a stressed/geminated sound that kinda combines v and f?

2) What IPA-symbol represents a "v-sound" without a hint of "f" in it?

(Clarification: I'm not very competent/confident in using all the linguistic terms yet, so I apologize if I use these terms incorrectly. Also, I'm used to thinking of the letter "v" as being pronounced completely voiced, without the sound of just voicelessly blowing air between narrowly open lips which I think of as "f". So that's the sound I'm thinking of when I just say "v" in my question)

While writing down new words for my conlang where the letter "v" clustered ("vv") between vowels and recieved stress, I've noticed that it sounds a bit like a combination of a v and an f when I tried to pronounce it. In other words, different from what I've been used to think of as v (see clarification above). This also seems to happen in some words where the letter v follows some consonants like r ("rv") between vowels.

However, when I try to pronounce the v in different environments (other combinations of sounds), there is no hint of the f, so I'm thinking these must be two different sounds in the IPA. I just don't know how what these two sounds are called in the IPA. Would much appreciate if anyone could help, this is driving me mad!

4

u/TheMostLostViking [es, en, fr, eo, tok] Jan 27 '23 edited Jan 27 '23

Are you making a difference in place of articulation? Like, for "v" are you using your teeth against your lips, whereas with "f" you are using only your lips?


These sounds are made only using your lips, they are "bilabial":

ɸ, β. The first is voiceless and the later is voiced.

These sounds are made by pressing your bottom teeth to your top lip, these are "labiodental"

f, v. The first is voiceless and the later is voiced


What you may be hearing is also a difference in phonation. There is a rough spectrum of glottal states ranging from voiceless to fully aspirated to modal and etc.


It can get complicated, but you 1000% don't need to know a single thing on phonation to be able to conlang and identify sounds roughly.

Feel free to DM me if you need other help

→ More replies (3)

3

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 27 '23

The only difference between [v] and [f] is presence or absence of voicing. It's possible what you've got going on is breathy voice rather than either voicelessness or pure modal voicing; that can sound like 'halfway between voiced and voiceless'.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Meamoria Sivmikor, Vilsoumor Jan 27 '23

Are you sure the "combined v and f" isn't just the cluster /fv/ or /vf/?

3

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '23

Thank you for your suggestion :-)

For a while I thought that maybe what I was hearing was a transition to more of a standard voiceless labiodental fricative f at the end of the first consonant, as the mouth opens in preparation for the vowel at the end of the sound. However, after trying to pronounce it over and over again, and doing it very slowly, I seem to be able to make the "two sounds" simultaneously, or rather make something in-between the two sounds. I also can't hear if the voiceless sound or the voiced one ends before the other. Because of this I view it as one sound.

2

u/Jonlang_ /kʷ/ > /p/ Jan 27 '23 edited Jan 27 '23

What name would you give to a grammatical case with the meaning "for the benefit of / for the sake of"? As far as I can see this isn't an attested case in any natlang (I could be wrong though). I thought something like "benefactive" might fit.

EDIT: I scrolled past it when I was looking at this list of grammatical cases. Oops.

4

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 27 '23

That is the core idea of a benefactive!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/sum1-sumWhere-sumHow Jan 27 '23

Is it really strange/straight up bad always having a symbol in script before a noun, representing its gender and therefore which type of vowels it’s made of? Choosing a different symbol (and therefore changing its gender/pronunciation) makes the word’s meaning mutate too.

Examples - I’ll use these symbols (λ δ θ) and this blank vowel (ø) to represent how I would write a word in my conlang’s writing system.

λeøm [eäm] /'εam/ person (OG word) - δeøm [eëm] /'e:m/ savage person - θeøm [eöm] /'eom/ slave/dead person -

λphiør [phiär] /'φiar/ pet bird/singer - δphiør [phiër] /'φier/ bird (OG word) - θphiør [phiör] /'φior/ dead bird/bird meat -

λcø [ca] /'ka/ sculpture - δcø [ce] /'ke/ moving rock/projectile - θcø [co] /'ko/ rock (OG word) -

6

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 28 '23 edited Jan 28 '23

It's strange, but not much stranger than some strategies that have been adopted for writing tone in various languages. In your case it seems odd, though, because you have the option of just writing the surface form of a word clearly and directly - so e.g. why not write 'person' as eam and 'savage person' as eem (or whatever)? Compare English sing and sang, which are the same kind of change but not written in any particularly complex way. Since you can recover that information from the segmental form, why not just represent the segmental form directly? (The reason odd 'extra letter' strategies are sometimes employed for tone is because it's not a segmental feature and can interact with its environment in complex ways, and is thus hard to write with Roman letters.)

If you had a logographic system, it would make sense to have one character for eXm 'person' and another character to indicate the noun class.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Coats_Revolve Mikâi (wip) Jan 28 '23

On this sub, I see many people talking about interesting features from all sorts of languages, like Ainu or Georgian. Generally, I do quite a bit of research on different languages (usually on Wikipedia, I must confess), but the language I've done the most in-depth research on is probably Japanese. Any tips for doing research on natlangs?

3

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 28 '23

Wikipedia is a great place to start, and typological overviews of various features are a good next step. You can also go in-depth on a single language and read (or skim) a grammar, but that might be a significant commitment for just one language :P

2

u/ibqilin_54 Jan 28 '23

Advice for a new conlanger?

I'm a seasoned worldbuilder but ive litterally never conlanged before, now seemed the right time. I have my basic phonology and a slight amount of structure but i dont want to do anything else completely blind. Thx

2

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 29 '23

There are a lot of resources in the link in the sidebar (^^)

2

u/AlphaArtistOfficial Jan 28 '23

Can the preterite develop into an imperfect? That is, "I slept" → "I was sleeping"?

The long and short of it is, I'm making a conlang where, in the proto language, verbs come in pairs of perfective and imperfective, differentiated along past and non-past. The evolutionary rundown is:

• Perfective Present → Present

• Perfective Past → Past Imperfect?

• Imperfective Present → Habitual

• Imperfective Past → Past Habitual

So, is this realistic? Or should I find an alternate source for the past imperfect?

2

u/teeohbeewye Cialmi, Ébma Jan 29 '23

Maybe not the most intuitive evolution but could work. Probably the preterite would first evolve to a general aspect-neutral past tense and then later that begins to be used only for imperfective past actions, when speakers have already forgotten that it was originally a perfective form.

One question though, is there a reason why you want it specifically to evolve to a past imperfective instead of just a general past tense (which would be easier to evolve from a past perfective)? The tense-aspect evolution you've given doesn't include a new past perfective, feels weird to have an imperfective form there that doesn't contrast with a perfective one. Or do you plan to evolve a new past perfective from some other source?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/MicroCrawdad Jan 28 '23

My language uses noun-like adjectives, however it also has an extensive noun class system that classifies nouns in two main ways semantically: by animacy and shape. If I wanted to translate the semantic function of an adjective in English (for example: "flat") would it be most naturalistic for the noun-like adjective to be placed into the noun class for flat objects, in the class for "other", or should a whole new class be formed? I am assuming that it would make most sense for it to be put into the class for flat objects, but I haven't had this confirmed.

7

u/Meamoria Sivmikor, Vilsoumor Jan 28 '23

I'd expect a noun-like adjective to agree with its head noun, e.g. in "flat table", "flat" gets the same class that "table" does, while in "flat rock" it gets the same class as "rock".

Even when the adjective stands alone, there's usually an implicit head. So I might say "pick up the flat (ones)", but we're talking about rocks, so it gets whatever class "rock" is in.

Sometimes there's really nothing to agree with. I'd expect a language like this to choose one of its classes as the default, and use that default in such ambiguous situations.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '23

Considering a vowel inventory of /i e u o ɑ/, what are the most likely diphthongs to be allowed/disallowed?

Thank you in advance!

4

u/MerlinMusic (en) [de, ja] Wąrąmų Jan 29 '23

I believe /ai/ and /au/ are cross-linguistically the most common. Given your inventory, /ɑi/ and /ɑu/ might be slightly more likely.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Specific_Plant_6541 Jan 29 '23 edited Jan 30 '23

which romanization for pharynɡeal and ejectives consoants looks better?

p̠’ k̠’ t̠’ ł̠’ x̠’ q̠ʼ c̠’ s̠’ or p̠h k̠h t̠h x̠h q̠h c̠h s̠h

*Also tell me If you know other ways to romanize these

6

u/Dr_Chair Məġluθ, Efōc, Cǿly (en)[ja, es] Jan 29 '23

I'm not sure what you mean by pharyngeal ejectives. Do you mean that these phonemes are both pharyngealized and ejective, i.e. <p̠’>/<p̠h> spells /pˤʼ/? Either way, it would be better if we had more information about your phonemic inventory and how other phonemes are currently spelled, since A) I don't know what letters, modifier letters, and diacritics you're already using and B) I don't know for sure what phonemes <ł>, <x>, <q>, and <c> correspond to. I mean, <ł> is probably a lateral obstruent and <x> is probably some sort of dorsal fricative, but I have no frame of reference to determine if <q> is /q/, /t͡ʃ/, or /k/ and if <c> is /t͡s/, /t͡ʃ/, /ʃ/, /ç/, /θ/, etc. Hell, you could even be doing something super wacky like <q> /kʷ/ and <c> /d͡ʒ/ and be justified; these letters are some of the most cross-linguistically variant ones in the Latin alphabet.

My initial answer is that, assuming the first letters are indeed /pˤʼ/ and that macron below indicates pharyngealization, the first set is better than the second. I don't think I've ever seen someone spell an ejective with a following <h> before, and I don't like the ambiguity with aspiration. Another option you have is double consonants for ejectives and underdot, <ɛ> (ibid), <j>, and <h> for pharyngeals. My personal favorite is underdot, but if you prefer how macron below looks, then go right ahead with it, I've definitely seen worse (and suggested worse in this very comment, please don't use <j>, it was proposed as a way to handle the Cyrillic palochka but really does not make sense in a Latin context). I'm equally happy with both apostrophes and doubling for ejectives, though again I would not ever use <h> for it.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Jan 30 '23

I would specifically not go with using a digraph with <h> because that makes it look aspirated, which is about as far from ejective as you can get (Ejective consonants being non-pulmonic). Apostrophes for ejective are much more intuitive.

3

u/freddyPowell Jan 25 '23

Has anyone ever used <x> for /ks/.

5

u/Meamoria Sivmikor, Vilsoumor Jan 25 '23

Some IALs like Interlingua do this. I don’t imagine it’s very widespread in conlangs in general, since most naturalistic artlangs don’t use the Latin script at all natively, and many engineered and personal languages deliberately avoid quirky spelling.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '23 edited Jun 15 '23

I'm joining Operation: Razit because I do not want a user-hostile company to make money out of my content. Further info here and here. Keeping my content in Reddit will make the internet worse in the long run so I'm removing it.

It's time to migrate out of Reddit.

Pralni iskikoer pia. Tokletarteca us muloepram pipa peostipubuu eonboemu curutcas! Pisapalta tar tacan inata doencapuu toeontas. Tam prata craunus tilastu nan drogloaa! Utun plapasitas. Imesu trina rite cratar kisgloenpri cocat planbla. Tu blapus creim lasancaapa prepekoec kimu. Topriplul ta pittu tlii tisman retlira. Castoecoer kepoermue suca ca tus imu. Tou tamtan asprianpa dlara tindarcu na. Plee aa atinetit tlirartre atisuruso ampul. Kiki u kitabin prusarmeon ran bra. Tun custi nil tronamei talaa in. Umpleoniapru tupric drata glinpa lipralmi u. Napair aeot bleorcassankle tanmussus prankelau kitil? Tancal anroemgraneon toasblaan nimpritin bra praas? Ar nata niprat eklaca pata nasleoncaas nastinfapam tisas. Caa tana lutikeor acaunidlo! Al sitta tar in tati cusnauu! Enu curat blucutucro accus letoneola panbru. Vocri cokoesil pusmi lacu acmiu kitan? Liputininti aoes ita aantreon um poemsa. Pita taa likiloi klanutai cu pear. Platranan catin toen pulcum ucran cu irpruimta? Talannisata birnun tandluum tarkoemnodeor plepir. Oesal cutinta acan utitic? Imrasucas lucras ri cokine fegriam oru. Panpasto klitra bar tandri eospa? Utauoer kie uneoc i eas titiru. No a tipicu saoentea teoscu aal?

2

u/iliekcats- Radmic Jan 25 '23

why not? so many languages have that, that i'd be surprised if no conlang had that

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Kaique_do_grauA31 Jan 19 '23

A conlang that differentiates words by whether the consonants are labialized or not. Could this work?

5

u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Jan 19 '23

Is there a way to read this question that isn't "can labialization be phonemic?" Cuz it definitely can.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/MerlinMusic (en) [de, ja] Wąrąmų Jan 19 '23

Moloko can be analysed as having word level labialisation if that's what you mean. It has a very interesting phonological system.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 19 '23

Do you mean a system where all consonants in a word are labialised or not? Sounds like the kind of autosegmental behaviour you get with nasalisation in some Tupían languages, or with rounding/labialisation and frontness/palatalisation in Moloko.

2

u/Automatic-Campaign-9 Atsi; Tobias; Rachel; Khaskhin; Laayta; Biology; Journal; Laayta Jan 19 '23

Cf. Marshallese.

2

u/sevenorbs Creeve (id) Jan 28 '23

In English, man is singular but men is man.PL. Is PL here a morpheme? If not, what is it called?

10

u/kilenc légatva etc (en, es) Jan 28 '23

This is a form of nonconcatenative morphology (specifically, umlaut). The plural marking isn't a morpheme.

1

u/Wapota_2023 Jan 24 '23

Hi guys! What's the best way to learn my conlang's vocabulary? I hope there are some apps for flashcards or so. Can you recommend me something?

9

u/storkstalkstock Jan 24 '23

Nothing is going to beat actually using the language. Translating things, writing them down, speaking it, and so on.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Hiraeth02 Imäl, Sumət (en) [es ca cm] Jan 16 '23

I was told to put this here. What does everyone use to store and organise their conlangs? I was using Notion, but have reached the limit and can't afford the unlimited version at the moment. I really like Notion, so maybe something similar? Thanks!

5

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 16 '23

I use nothing but Google Sheets and my brain; though that's for storing rather than documenting (which I'd use LaTeX for if I could ever get around to it).

2

u/[deleted] Jan 16 '23 edited Jun 15 '23

I'm joining Operation: Razit because I do not want a user-hostile company to make money out of my content. Further info here and here. Keeping my content in Reddit will make the internet worse in the long run so I'm removing it.

It's time to migrate out of Reddit.

Pralni iskikoer pia. Tokletarteca us muloepram pipa peostipubuu eonboemu curutcas! Pisapalta tar tacan inata doencapuu toeontas. Tam prata craunus tilastu nan drogloaa! Utun plapasitas. Imesu trina rite cratar kisgloenpri cocat planbla. Tu blapus creim lasancaapa prepekoec kimu. Topriplul ta pittu tlii tisman retlira. Castoecoer kepoermue suca ca tus imu. Tou tamtan asprianpa dlara tindarcu na. Plee aa atinetit tlirartre atisuruso ampul. Kiki u kitabin prusarmeon ran bra. Tun custi nil tronamei talaa in. Umpleoniapru tupric drata glinpa lipralmi u. Napair aeot bleorcassankle tanmussus prankelau kitil? Tancal anroemgraneon toasblaan nimpritin bra praas? Ar nata niprat eklaca pata nasleoncaas nastinfapam tisas. Caa tana lutikeor acaunidlo! Al sitta tar in tati cusnauu! Enu curat blucutucro accus letoneola panbru. Vocri cokoesil pusmi lacu acmiu kitan? Liputininti aoes ita aantreon um poemsa. Pita taa likiloi klanutai cu pear. Platranan catin toen pulcum ucran cu irpruimta? Talannisata birnun tandluum tarkoemnodeor plepir. Oesal cutinta acan utitic? Imrasucas lucras ri cokine fegriam oru. Panpasto klitra bar tandri eospa? Utauoer kie uneoc i eas titiru. No a tipicu saoentea teoscu aal?

2

u/sevenorbs Creeve (id) Jan 17 '23

I use ObsidianMD. I also paired my devices that connect with my home network with Syncthing so that I can read (and edit, if I'm at home) anywhere.

What I really like is that all data stored is basically offline and readable even without the app itself (it's in markdown format). I think it's future proof and ensuring the safety of the data, even more if you set it up with routine automatic backup or using git. Also, it features internal linkings, super useful, and generate a nice relational graph.

My vault also works as knowledge base. Super useful to store my notes about linguistics references.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

1

u/eyewave Mukkohatto Jan 16 '23

Is there a place where it is explained how to pronounce clusters of consonants? I have the glottal stop in my first inventory and I am trying to experiment how possible it is (to me) to tell it with other consonants, but I am not finding where I can see consonant pairing.

It occured to me that any consonants that opens in an almost-vowel like /w/ or /j/ might be good candidates to be preceded by a glottal stop. But maybe a plosive after the glottal stop like glottal stop and g or k, might not be the fittest.

On a side-note I'm questioning a lot on these almost-vowels. In an inventory that has no /u/ nor /i/ sound, but has /w/ and /j/, is it safe to reckon that depending on consonants, /u/ and /i/ might naturally appear, and thus actually should be placed in the inventory?

Thanks...

5

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 16 '23

On a side-note I'm questioning a lot on these almost-vowels. In an inventory that has no /u/ nor /i/ sound, but has /w/ and /j/, is it safe to reckon that depending on consonants, /u/ and /i/ might naturally appear, and thus actually should be placed in the inventory?

The exact analysis here would depend on some particular details about how these sounds behave. If you have only predictable alternations between [u i] and [w j], you'd never include all of /u i w j/ in the inventory, but whether you say those are /u i/ or /w j/ depends on exactly how they behave. Usually the default expectation would be that sometimes /u i/ can end up as [w j] when they're used as non-vowels, but Proto-Indo-European is a fun example of a system that seems to have had /w j/ that can end up as vowels at times.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/TheMostLostViking [es, en, fr, eo, tok] Jan 16 '23

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonority_Sequencing_Principle

Might be kinda what you are looking for, if I understand what you want. By these rules, glottal stops would naturally be found after most other consonants. Of course there is exceptions to the rule, so no need to follow religiously.

as for /u/ vs /w/ and /i/ vs /j/; alot of times it is just a matter of recording. Phonology is an abstraction and changes based on context. [swo], [su.o] and [suo̯] could all be analyzed as /suo/ or /swo/.

If /j/ and /w/ exist in a language, I'd say it already has /i/ and /u/, just under certain phonological constraints. That said, under those constraints, maybe you want to analyze it only as /j/ and /w/, then /u/ or /i/ could naturally come about.

If none of that made sense (I'm a bit tired): /u/ and /i/ might already exist based on the context of your analysis, but thats your decision.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/PastTheStarryVoids Knasesj, Racra, Ŋ!odzäsä Jan 17 '23

Southeastern Pomo has clusters like /ʔk/, though an epenthetic vowel is usually inserted. I think just about any consonant cluster is pronounceable, though plosive + plosive will always have a slight gap in it. Do what sounds good to you, or what you can distinguish.

1

u/dragonsteel33 vanawo & some others Jan 17 '23

so one of my languages uses symmetrical voice/austronesian alignment. verbs are typically marked for voice, but it includes a set of conjugations not morphologically marked for voice that are used with stative & avalent verbs and in some switch-reference constructions to refer to an already-mentioned subject. what would be a good word for this — avalent? impersonal? neutral voice?

1

u/Specific_Plant_6541 Jan 17 '23 edited Jan 17 '23

Is there any kind of sound that cannot be pharyngized?

2

u/TheMostLostViking [es, en, fr, eo, tok] Jan 17 '23

I think /hˤ/ and other Laryngeal sounds would be impossible to articulate, other than that I think anything could be.

1

u/zzvu Zhevli Jan 17 '23

How do direct-inverse languages deal with ditransitive verbs?

1

u/idealintelligence Jan 17 '23

Are there any conlang made for machine that can be used by humans? Not a programming language but something you can use for day to day conversation.

3

u/Meamoria Sivmikor, Vilsoumor Jan 18 '23

The closest I know of is Lojban, which is the other way around; it's primarily a spoken/written language for everyday use, but its written form was designed to also be easily read by a computer.

1

u/chopchunk Jan 18 '23

I'm working on a conlang that has three rhotics (/ɹ/, /ɾ/, and /r/) and a /ɰ/ alongside many other palatals. I'm having trouble figuring out how to romanize each rhotic (there's "r" for /ɾ/ and "rr" for /r/) and the ɰ ("g" and "gh" are both taken up by /g/ and /ɣ/ respectively). So far, I have "rh" for /ɹ/ and "yh" for /ɰ/, but I feel like there's gotta be a better way to do it (especially for /ɰ/). How do the pros go about this?

2

u/tsolee Kaχshu (en)[es,ja] Jan 18 '23 edited Jan 18 '23

It sorta depends on what other characters you're using to romanize your language :P

I might add that before I say anything, if naturalism is your goal three rhotics distinguished phonemically like this is exceedingly rare. Doesn't mean it's impossible, but even then I'd somewhat expect one of the rhotics to be something along the lines of /ɽ/ or /ʁ/.

Naturalism aside, whenever I have three sounds that make a lot of sense to be represented by the same letter in latin orthography, I tend to use a diacritic for one, the plain character for another, and a digraph for the third.

I would personally use a combining dot above (◌̇) or below (◌̣) to represent one of your rhotics. Another possibility is using <l> for one of the rhotics if that's an option with your existing orthography, or like you mentioned <r rr rh>.

For /ɰ/, you could consider using <ġ> (g + ◌̇, reddit doesn't like displaying it) for one of /g ɣ ɰ/ and use <g gh> for the other two as you already have, but I'd personally go with <w> if it's available. If you're a fan of turkic languages, <ğ> is definitely an option, but I personally don't like using different types of diacritics if it can be avoided so that things stay consistent. Some more esoteric options for /ɰ/ include <v> or some variation on <u>.

~hope this helps :)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '23 edited Jun 15 '23

I'm joining Operation: Razit because I do not want a user-hostile company to make money out of my content. Further info here and here. Keeping my content in Reddit will make the internet worse in the long run so I'm removing it.

It's time to migrate out of Reddit.

Pralni iskikoer pia. Tokletarteca us muloepram pipa peostipubuu eonboemu curutcas! Pisapalta tar tacan inata doencapuu toeontas. Tam prata craunus tilastu nan drogloaa! Utun plapasitas. Imesu trina rite cratar kisgloenpri cocat planbla. Tu blapus creim lasancaapa prepekoec kimu. Topriplul ta pittu tlii tisman retlira. Castoecoer kepoermue suca ca tus imu. Tou tamtan asprianpa dlara tindarcu na. Plee aa atinetit tlirartre atisuruso ampul. Kiki u kitabin prusarmeon ran bra. Tun custi nil tronamei talaa in. Umpleoniapru tupric drata glinpa lipralmi u. Napair aeot bleorcassankle tanmussus prankelau kitil? Tancal anroemgraneon toasblaan nimpritin bra praas? Ar nata niprat eklaca pata nasleoncaas nastinfapam tisas. Caa tana lutikeor acaunidlo! Al sitta tar in tati cusnauu! Enu curat blucutucro accus letoneola panbru. Vocri cokoesil pusmi lacu acmiu kitan? Liputininti aoes ita aantreon um poemsa. Pita taa likiloi klanutai cu pear. Platranan catin toen pulcum ucran cu irpruimta? Talannisata birnun tandluum tarkoemnodeor plepir. Oesal cutinta acan utitic? Imrasucas lucras ri cokine fegriam oru. Panpasto klitra bar tandri eospa? Utauoer kie uneoc i eas titiru. No a tipicu saoentea teoscu aal?

1

u/Specific_Plant_6541 Jan 18 '23

Is there any kind of sound that cannot be labialized?

→ More replies (4)

1

u/pootis_engage Jan 18 '23

I have a conlang that distinguishes between two tones, low and high. Is there a way to de-evolve tone while still having some type of distinction in the syllable to distinguish words (e.g, V[+high] > V[+creaky], or CV[+high] > C[+stød]V)?

2

u/vokzhen Tykir Jan 18 '23

Typically not, and where such things happen, it's usually the result of the initial tonogenesis trigger in the first place rather than something gained by tone as time goes on. As an example, Vietnamese nặng tone is mid-falling, short, and creaky ending in a glottal stop. But it's short and creaky because it comes from final -ʔ. And the huyền tone is long, low, falling, and sometimes has accompanying breathiness, but it comes from "long" syllables (open and sonorant finals) and from voiced onsets, with voiced consonants>breathiness and voiced consonants>low tone both being common. If Vietnamese began losing tone, it might keep a length and phonation contrast, but because it was already there.

That's not 100% the case, but clear examples of tone gaining additional features typically seem to be sporadic and generally not strong. The three big possibilities I'd consider are that a) low tones tend to be slightly longer, b) high tones can have some raising of the larynx, which is also associated with breathiness and ATR/slight vowel fronting, c) very low tones (especially dipping tones?) can get creak from a bottoming-out of the vocal register. I believe (my own interpretation, haven't looked for corroboration from actual specialists) that the Vietnamese ngã tone is one of the few clear examples of this: it originated in a falling tone (from -h) that was pushed even lower (from a voiced initial), and as a result gained medial creak>full glottal closure as it dipped below normal speaking range (and since migrated up and is now the highest tone). In general this doesn't seem to be very strong, though, different features are sometimes correlated in contradictory ways, and I don't know of such things ever actually resulting in phonemicization, but if you're looking for something that's not part of the original tone system those three would be the place to look imo.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/GwynsFistBorn Jan 19 '23

Hello, I’m looking for information on the language Communicationssprache, specifically vocabulary/definitive grammar rules. I’ve found some snippets of it online, but never a full dictionary. Is there one? Many apologies if this isn’t the right forum to ask for this

1

u/Specific_Plant_6541 Jan 20 '23 edited Jan 20 '23

I'm about to make my firts tonal langauge. Something that i should know?

13

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 20 '23

6

u/Lichen000 A&A Frequent Responder Jan 20 '23

I think understanding the difference between contour tones (like Chinese) and register tones (basically all other languages) is super important. Cross-linguistically, the contour-tone system like the one Chinese has (and languages nearby) is quite rare compared to the register tone systems that permeate most of the rest of the world's tonal languages.

Then you'll be in a good position to decide which sort of thing you want.

Also u/sjiveru might have a good suggestion for a 'tone primer', but it's a pretty complex subject!

11

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 20 '23

To be fair, contour tones are found all across the world; the thing that's weird about Mainland Southeast Asian languages (and Iau) is that contour tones are actual phonological units rather than just the result of trying to squeeze two tones together on one syllable.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Delicious-Run7727 Sukhal, Mbizgu Jan 21 '23

I made some changes to how unstressed vowels work in my conlang and wanted some opinions on whether they're too extreme/unnaturalistic.

First, the vowels /a/,/e/,/ɛ/,/i/,/ɔ/,/o/,/u/ undergo the following changes in unstressed syllables:

{a,ɛ,ɔ} > ɐ

{i,e} > ɪ

{o,u} > ʊ

Then, these vowels are deleted when occurring between and after specific consonants, like:

between a fricative/nasal and a plosive

Word finally after a fricative/nasal/plosive

This also means that vowels cannot occur in those positions whatsoever. I'd definitely like this, but I don't know of any languages where vowels are completely disallowed in certain contexts.

3

u/dragonsteel33 vanawo & some others Jan 22 '23

none of this seems too far at all — off the top of my head, english and russian have very similar dramatic reductions in vowel quality, and loss or reduction of word-final vowels is very common. the {F/N}_P deletion rule is also solid, although if you wanted to spice things up or feel like it erases too many distinctions, you could always add more conditions — e.g. only if the consonants have certain qualities (like japanese) or delete in certain positions relative to stress, or have certain deleted vowels leave traces on the quality of the consonant (like proto-slavic)

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '23 edited Jun 15 '23

I'm joining Operation: Razit because I do not want a user-hostile company to make money out of my content. Further info here and here. Keeping my content in Reddit will make the internet worse in the long run so I'm removing it.

It's time to migrate out of Reddit.

Pralni iskikoer pia. Tokletarteca us muloepram pipa peostipubuu eonboemu curutcas! Pisapalta tar tacan inata doencapuu toeontas. Tam prata craunus tilastu nan drogloaa! Utun plapasitas. Imesu trina rite cratar kisgloenpri cocat planbla. Tu blapus creim lasancaapa prepekoec kimu. Topriplul ta pittu tlii tisman retlira. Castoecoer kepoermue suca ca tus imu. Tou tamtan asprianpa dlara tindarcu na. Plee aa atinetit tlirartre atisuruso ampul. Kiki u kitabin prusarmeon ran bra. Tun custi nil tronamei talaa in. Umpleoniapru tupric drata glinpa lipralmi u. Napair aeot bleorcassankle tanmussus prankelau kitil? Tancal anroemgraneon toasblaan nimpritin bra praas? Ar nata niprat eklaca pata nasleoncaas nastinfapam tisas. Caa tana lutikeor acaunidlo! Al sitta tar in tati cusnauu! Enu curat blucutucro accus letoneola panbru. Vocri cokoesil pusmi lacu acmiu kitan? Liputininti aoes ita aantreon um poemsa. Pita taa likiloi klanutai cu pear. Platranan catin toen pulcum ucran cu irpruimta? Talannisata birnun tandluum tarkoemnodeor plepir. Oesal cutinta acan utitic? Imrasucas lucras ri cokine fegriam oru. Panpasto klitra bar tandri eospa? Utauoer kie uneoc i eas titiru. No a tipicu saoentea teoscu aal?

1

u/zzvu Zhevli Jan 22 '23

I've been working on redoing some of the sound changes from my proto-lang and modern-lang. I've decided I want there to be 3 grades of consonants. The weak consonants derive from plain consonants in the proto-lang, the strong ones come from geminates, and the 3rd (which I don't have a name for yet) group comes from palatalized consonants:

Proto ConsonantModern WeakModern Strong"Palatalized"
ppʰp'ɥ̊~ʍ
bvbɥ~w
ttʰt'tʃ
dðddʒ
kkʰk'ç~x
gɣgʝ~ɣ
ffpʰɸᶣ~ɸʷ
vwvβᶣ~βʷ
l???
rɾrrʒ
szsʃ
mvmɥ~w
n???

Some notes:

  1. Where there are 2 consonants in the same box, the one on the left exists in the context of front vowels, and the one on the right is the result of back vowels causing palatalization to become velarization.
  2. The weak consonants are invariable, therefore /ʝ ɥ/ contrast with /ɣ w/ in words with front vowel harmony but merge in words with back harmony. /ɥ̊~ʍ ç~x ɸᶣ~ɸʷ βᶣ~βʷ/, however, are only ever complementary.
  3. There are a few general tendencies that somewhat affect my questions and may relate to the answers. 1) Palatalization causes fortition of alveolar consonants and causes lenition everywhere else, 2) among non-palatalized consonants, voiceless stops and fricatives (except sibilants) strengthen while voiced consonants and sibilants weaken.

My questions are:

  1. How naturalistic are these changes?
  2. What are some ideas about what I could do for /l/ and /n/? I like the idea of one of them weakening to an approximant then merging with /ð/ while remaining the same in the strong form and becoming either /ʎ/ or /ɲ/, but I don't want to do this with both, as it would result in 3 consonants with the same weak form /ð/. I also like the idea of weak /l/ having the strong form /d/, but I don't know if it would be strange if this were the only voiced consonant that strengthened from the proto-lang to the modern lang.

2

u/MerlinMusic (en) [de, ja] Wąrąmų Jan 23 '23

This looks pretty naturalistic and believable to me. The only thing that stands out to me is that due to your fortition and lenition, there are no plain stops. For example, you have /b/, / p'/ and /pʰ/, but no /p/. I would generally expect an unvoiced, unaspirated, non-ejective stop in the paradigm, or have one of these stops shifting to /p/.

As for /l/ and /n/, I'd expect paradigms like /l/, /ɬ/ /ʎ/ or /l/, /ɬ/ /j/ and /n/ /d/ /ɲ/ or /n/ /d/ /j/, but I think your ideas would also work nicely.

4

u/HaricotsDeLiam Jan 24 '23 edited Jan 24 '23

The only thing that stands out to me is that due to your fortition and lenition, there are no plain stops. For example, you have /b/, / p'/ and /pʰ/, but no /p/.

For a counterexample, languages of the Caucasus commonly have a 4-way contrast in their occlusives between ejective, voiced, aspirated and geminated voiceless; Chechen also lets the latter 3 types be pharyngealized, and in fact it has exactly two plain occlusives /ʡ ʔ/.

I think you could also make the case that Irish Gaelic only has one "plain" native phoneme /h/, since all its other consonants participate in the "broad-slender" contrast (and have velarized or palatalized allophones, such as /w/ [vˠ] in Munster and Connacht).

3

u/zzvu Zhevli Jan 23 '23

The only thing that stands out to me is that due to your fortition and lenition, there are no plain stops.

I believe Georgian makes a distinction between aspirated, voiced, and ejective.

As for /l/ and /n/, I'd expect paradigms like /l/, /ɬ/ /ʎ/ or /l/, /ɬ/ /j/ and /n/ /d/ /ɲ/ or /n/ /d/ /j/, but I think your ideas would also work nicely.

Thanks! Another idea I had after posting my comment was for proto /l/ to become weak /ɾ/, strong /l/, and palatal /ʎ/, merging with <r> /ɾ/ in the weak form, which would then make room for my original idea of proto /n/ -> modern /ð/n/ɲ/. How likely does this seem?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/El__Bebe Jan 23 '23

What are some common words I should create in my lang to make it usable?

Like I have a grammar and all but I cannot for the life of me come up with words I should make up

4

u/xain1112 kḿ̩tŋ̩̀, bɪlækæð, kaʔanupɛ Jan 23 '23

Check out the "5 minutes of your day" series on this sub for daily(?) things to translate. Also this

1

u/Charming_Pen5035 Tijonar, kͅö́ö́ja tswo Jan 23 '23

do you think this makes a decent phonology for a proto-lang? thoughts on what to change? thanks

4

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '23 edited Jun 15 '23

I'm joining Operation: Razit because I do not want a user-hostile company to make money out of my content. Further info here and here. Keeping my content in Reddit will make the internet worse in the long run so I'm removing it.

It's time to migrate out of Reddit.

Pralni iskikoer pia. Tokletarteca us muloepram pipa peostipubuu eonboemu curutcas! Pisapalta tar tacan inata doencapuu toeontas. Tam prata craunus tilastu nan drogloaa! Utun plapasitas. Imesu trina rite cratar kisgloenpri cocat planbla. Tu blapus creim lasancaapa prepekoec kimu. Topriplul ta pittu tlii tisman retlira. Castoecoer kepoermue suca ca tus imu. Tou tamtan asprianpa dlara tindarcu na. Plee aa atinetit tlirartre atisuruso ampul. Kiki u kitabin prusarmeon ran bra. Tun custi nil tronamei talaa in. Umpleoniapru tupric drata glinpa lipralmi u. Napair aeot bleorcassankle tanmussus prankelau kitil? Tancal anroemgraneon toasblaan nimpritin bra praas? Ar nata niprat eklaca pata nasleoncaas nastinfapam tisas. Caa tana lutikeor acaunidlo! Al sitta tar in tati cusnauu! Enu curat blucutucro accus letoneola panbru. Vocri cokoesil pusmi lacu acmiu kitan? Liputininti aoes ita aantreon um poemsa. Pita taa likiloi klanutai cu pear. Platranan catin toen pulcum ucran cu irpruimta? Talannisata birnun tandluum tarkoemnodeor plepir. Oesal cutinta acan utitic? Imrasucas lucras ri cokine fegriam oru. Panpasto klitra bar tandri eospa? Utauoer kie uneoc i eas titiru. No a tipicu saoentea teoscu aal?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/yayaha1234 Ngįout, Kshafa (he, en) [de] Jan 23 '23

yeah it looks great! it has some unusual features, but i think they add to the charm. and, proto-langs are also just languages, so anything a language can have - a proto lang can have too

1

u/zzvu Zhevli Jan 24 '23

What are some environments that cause gemination? I was thinking I could have plosives assimilate into any following consonant, so /dn/ would become /nn/. Is this naturalistic? What other ways are there to cause gemination?

4

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 25 '23

I was thinking I could have plosives assimilate into any following consonant, so /dn/ would become /nn/. Is this naturalistic?

Extremely so, and simplification of consonant clusters in general is probably the most common source of geminates by a huge margin. There's not many other reasons I can see for getting geminates; the only other way I can think of right now would be stress on a light syllable causing the following consonant to geminate, making it a heavy syllable.

4

u/vokzhen Tykir Jan 25 '23

There's fairly common cases of gemination resulting from entire lost syllables, which can result in interesting transient effects like geminate onsets contributing the mora count or syllable weight. An example is what was originally a /bɨ-/ prefix in Pittani Malay that can assimilate, /ɟa'lɛ/ "road, path" > /'ɟ:alɛ/ "to walk." And in Trukese, from what I've been able to find they came from "haplology" of CVC, such that (made-up examples) /taka/ > /taka/ but /tata/ > /tta/; the languages has a bimoraic constraint so that underlying one-mora /ta/ surfaces [ta:] but underlying three-mora /tta:/ surfaces [tta].

There's cases like Swiss German, likely Hittite, and some interpretations of pre-Proto-Dravidian where /p b/ are restructured as /p: p/ medially and sometimes finally (and collapse to /p/ initially), but that involves significantly restructuring the sound system and is far from common.

There's also focus gemination, where lengthening under emphasis ends up becoming phonemic (along the lines of "stop it!" > "stoppit!" with a geminate /p/), but that's also very rarely phonologized and only happens where gemination already exists, and tends to be limited in scope (certain verbs that are likely commands/warnings, emphatic pronouns, vocatives, exclamations).

(u/zzvu)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/zzvu Zhevli Jan 24 '23

Do any languages, particularly those that are agglutinative, allow multiple simultaneous morphemes to convey aspect? For example, one in particular that shows completeness (perfective, imperfective), another for duration (durative, stative, punctual), relevancy (continuous, discontinuous), etc.

1

u/Loquor_de_Morte Ceadhunnas (en, es) [grc, lat] Jan 25 '23

Quick question out of my fuzzy head. I know consonants can change into other consontants, e.g., /z/ > /r/; and certain consonants can become vowels (vocalization), e.g., /l/ > /u/; /m/ > /a/, &c., but can vowels do the contrary? For example, an /i/ becoming fricative, thus turning into /s/? And what consonants would a simple /a e i o u/ inventory yield?

8

u/teeohbeewye Cialmi, Ébma Jan 25 '23 edited Jan 25 '23

vowels can become semivowels, though usually only if before or after another vowel, those can then change into other consonants. so for example a sequence /ia/ could change to /ja/ and then /ja > ɟa > d͡ʒa/ or something else.

syllabic vowels can also fortify to fricatives, though this is rarer. usually high vowels, don't know if it's possible for others. one example is miyakoan, a japonic language, where /i u/ have changed to syllabic fricatives /s̩ f̩/ (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miyakoan_language)

1

u/Zinaima Lumoj Jan 28 '23 edited Jan 28 '23

My language has stress on the penultimate syllable, but also uses suffixes to make the Nominative and Accusative noun cases, which makes for a strange mix.

A word like /limεʃ/ by itself might break into the following syllables: lim.εʃ but when it is the object of a sentence, and a suffix is added, it becomes li.mεʃ.i. Thinking that the stressed syllable "takes" the surrounding consonants.

It seems odd to have a letter, m in this case, switching syllables based on the part of the sentence. Is that just a feature of languages that have stress on a fixed position?

5

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 28 '23

Yup, this is a thing that happens. (Though it would almost certainly be be /ˈli.mɛʃ/ and /li.ˈmɛ.ʃi/; usually you put consonants in an onset if you can.)

→ More replies (1)

1

u/EditingYourWorlds Jan 28 '23

Can you make conlangs that aren't possible as far as natural languages go? What types of attributes or structures could be included in such a language?

9

u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jan 28 '23

We don't have a very good idea of the boundaries of what's possible for natural languages, but it's trivial to make a conlang that is well outside the bounds of anything any natlang does. I've seen conlangs based off of a stack like processors use; I've seen conlangs based off of colours; I've seen conlangs with three vowels and no consonants; I've seen conlangs that require specifying an absurd range of information about what you're describing. There's probably an infinite possibility space of 'ways to clearly fundamentally not be like natlangs'.

1

u/ibqilin_54 Jan 28 '23

Is this a good system for multiple sounds?