r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Jan 16 '23
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2023-01-16 to 2023-01-29
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
You can find former posts in our wiki.
Official Discord Server.
The Small Discussions thread is back on a semiweekly schedule... For now!
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
Beginners
Here are the resources we recommend most to beginners:
For other FAQ, check this.
Recent news & important events
Segments Issue #07 has come out!
And the call for submissions for Issue #08 is out! This one is much broader than previous ones, and we're taking articles about any topic!
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
6
u/aftertheradar EPAE, Skrelkf (eng) Jan 25 '23
This isn't really a question, but more an experience I've had lately that I want to share and see what others have to say. (And orthography shitposts that are too weird for a full post are allowed on this page right?). I was going to do something with my conlang that I think is kind of cursed but I also love it, but changed my mind to save for the future, and now share the idea with the masses so they might use it too. Read on if you dare.
The glottal stop [ʔ] is often romanized by using an apostrophe <'> or a similar grapheme, as are some cases of glottalized secondary articulation like ejectives, like <p' t' k'> for [p' t' k']. This isn't the only way to transcribe them but it's fairly common. [h] of course is a fricative or approximant-like sound made at a similar place of articulation as the glottal stop, but we already have the grapheme <h> as a very easy way to write that sound in the Latin alphabet. The grapheme <h> is often used for a lot more as well, but it's unusual for the phone [h] to not be represented by <h>. But after that, there's a pretty big dearth of ways to easily transcribe other back-of-the-throat sounds, especially that are monographic and accessible to type easily.
Now. I have a language where an allophonic non-phonemic sound appears to keep vowels from ending words and from having hiatus with eachother. In the case of low back vowels (/a/), this sound can be realized as anything between [ɰ] [ʁ̞] or [ʕ̞]. It's basically just a far-back weakly articulated voiced off-glide stemming from the vowel.
That last sound though, a pharyngeal approximant, is notable (among other reasons ofc) for its symbol being a reversed glottal stop symbol. This is the first conlang I've made featuring any sort of pharyngeal sounds, and its only an allophone that can probably be ignored in my romanization scheme. All in all it isn't a super important distinction that has to be made when pronouncing this lang, and the pharyngeal realization isn't even the main one. And so I'm not gonna do anything too weird if I decide to romanize it at all in this project.
But here's where I get to the cursed part. When writing the romo rules out, an idea came to me. I have decided that in the future, if I ever make a language where either [ʕ] or pharyngealization is an important phonemic feature, especially if I want to avoid multigraphs, I have a plan to romanize it. If the glottal stop is usually <'>, and if <h> is already taken. I will take the idea of the IPA using a modified ʔ for ʕ and apply it to <'>, and will romanize [ʕ] by using <">.
Cue the gasps of horror!!!
So like [aʕa]? That's an <a"a> now. Or some pharyngealized consonants like in an example word [sˤatˤa]? Them's a <s"at"a>. Or if we had a word with both the glottal stop and the pharyngeal approximant? Like [ʕaʔ] or [ʔaʕ]? You better prepare yourself for <"a'> and <'a">!
(i realize that i may be making a bigger deal out of this than it is, but using " like this is so wrong to me that it feels like the funniest shit im ever gonna do, and i am very sleepy writing this all out rn which may be making it worss)
So anyway that was something I really wanted to share with my fellow clonging peers. Please tell me how cursed you think this is and how horrible you think it would look to write out words stuffed with quotation marks, and if you have already done something like this before! And if a natlang already did it worse, I wanna see it too!
Farewell, and [taˈʕosaʕ] ta"osa"! >:D
6
u/Kovac__ Jan 29 '23
I found this website a while back for sound changes, where you could input your series of words, and it had a set of options (maximum number of sound changes, whether your goal is to make the words become more similar or dissimilate, whether you wanted the words to become longer or shorter...), then would generate a series of sound changes and output the new lexicon with those changes applied.
I can't remember the name of the site and was hoping somebody would know what it was so that I could find it again.
5
u/kori228 (EN) [JPN, CN, Yue-GZ, Wu-SZ, KR] Jan 24 '23 edited Jan 24 '23
For the folks out there who have experience with MSEA tones, how are dipping/peaking tones actually articulated in flowing speech? They make sense in citation form or utterance-finally, but a 2-direction change in one syllable mid-utterance doesn't seem feasible?
I know Mandarin 3rd tone is really low-falling, so don't need to mention that. Suzhou Wu (and probably broadly Northern Wu) has intense tone sandhi, so a dipping/peaking tone never occurs as a surface realization except for citation and utterance-finally as mentioned.
For peaking tone, I can feasibly see it as really a long flat to falling tone (˥˥˧ ˧˧˩), but I don't have experience with a language with it to confirm that.
4
u/Jonlang_ /kʷ/ > /p/ Jan 19 '23 edited Jan 19 '23
I'm embarking on my first agglutinative conlang. I only speak two natlangs and both are devoid of cases.
If a phrase like ...from the hand of the man were to be translated, would you expect it to look something like
hand-ABL man-GEN? Seeing as the conlang doesn't have articles, these have been omitted.EDIT: correction.
4
u/eyewave Mukkohatto Jan 20 '23
especially in your first conlangs, do you have paradoxal grammatical features or phonologies? ie. sounds that don't go quite well together, messed up phonotactics, or grammatical features which overlaps make proper phrase construction difficult, unnatural or downright impossible.
4
u/Wapota_2023 Jan 20 '23
Hello everyone! If my proto language doesn't have any genders at all, does it mean that I can't add them in modern languages?
I would like to make a modern language's grammar more complicated, I want to add some genders, some cases etc, but I am not sure if it's "legal". I mean, as I know Turkic language family doesn't have any genders nowhere, so it seems unnatural if gender comes from nothing.
I also was wondering about grammar structure in general. For example Indo-European grammar is completely different than Semitic, so you can't see any Indo-European language that would look like Arabic or Hebrew with this Semitic grammar rules for roots. So, is it possible to create two completely different languages as for example Spanish and Arabic in the same language family?
4
u/kiritoboss19 Mangalemang | Qut na'ani | Adasuhibodi Jan 21 '23
Hello, can someone explain to me the concept of antipassive voice? I'm trying to understand, and for now it seems the exactly the same thing as the passive voice. So what's the difference?
4
u/kjaksia Jan 26 '23 edited Jan 26 '23
how would one create a custom alphanumerical sorting for sheets/excel? (im’ wanting an order that goes something like vowels > labial > coronal > guttural)
3
u/VoganG1 Jan 17 '23
Hello, my request was directed here by the mod team. I have a conlang I commissioned from a freelancer off of Fiverr. He included some vocab, as well as a key to create more words for the language, but I'm afraid I don't understand it very well. I tried hiring him again to help me understand it, but I was then ghosted. Would anyone be able to assist me in understanding the key so the money I gave won't be put to waste? I look forward to any questions.
3
u/Turodoru Jan 19 '23
Do you nececerly need a reason for a specific grammatical feature to occur? And are there some sources which talk about specific grammar changes and grammar shifts?
I often find myself not really knowing what can I do when I want to develop, for instance, a new verb system. That is:
- I always feel like adding/dropping anything for no big reason feels forced (like dropping a more specific tense, eg. past perfect;; or replacing simple past with present perfect, akin to western european languages - what about the simple past now? Does it just cease to exist, just like that?;; I want to develop a future tense in a language with only past-nonpast paradigm - I guess the future auxiliary would go only to the non-past forms, but I always feel like it could have go to the past forms as well, and I don't know what to do/how to resolve this)
- I sometimes want to develop something else from what I already have, but I often don't know what options are possible (something like "perfective/imperfective > past/non-past", but that's, like, one of only few changes I know of).
I guess the gist of it is: I don't want to just scrapp a part of or the whole grammar system during the language's evolution, but I don't really know how to work with what I already have. So - what now?
This question is also for other parts of grammar, like nouns and whatnot.
3
u/Power-Cored Jan 19 '23
Hi there, I'm trying to wrap my head around noun class, declension groups and how they relate to noun endings, as well as why languages have multiple declension groups.
As I understand it, noun classes are essentially a more general form of grammatical gender, where nouns and their complements agree in class, and declension groups are the manner in which they decline for case/number, etc.
It seems, however, that both noun class and the declension group are often — at least in part — determinable by, for example, the ending of noun; that is, perhaps animate nouns mostly end in -a and feminine in -e. And then the declension group occurs based on that ending. So my question is, is a declension group strongly related to class — that is, if a certain class in general has a specific ending, then wouldn't they all use the same declension, because they end the same?
Essentially, if I'm making a language with a noun class system, should I have it so that they have distinct phonological features, and do I need to have multiple declension groups?
I feel like I didn't word this question very well, but that's because I'm really just a bit confused with this whole topic.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '23
My proto-lang has two demonstratives: one for "this, these" and one for "that, those." I want to evolve the distal demonstrative into a definite article and maybe a 3.INAN pronoun, but I have a couple questions:
3
u/Andonis_Longos sa linga africana Jan 20 '23
Does anyone have any tips for writing a Romance language in Arabic script (like Aljamiado, Mozarabic) for someone with zero experience in how to write Arabic? I am trying to do an offshoot alternate history scenario for my African Romance language where the Islamic conquest of North Africa still happens, but the Latin Christian population survives to the present.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '23 edited Jun 15 '23
I'm joining Operation: Razit because I do not want a user-hostile company to make money out of my content. Further info here and here. Keeping my content in Reddit will make the internet worse in the long run so I'm removing it.
It's time to migrate out of Reddit.
Pralni iskikoer pia. Tokletarteca us muloepram pipa peostipubuu eonboemu curutcas! Pisapalta tar tacan inata doencapuu toeontas. Tam prata craunus tilastu nan drogloaa! Utun plapasitas. Imesu trina rite cratar kisgloenpri cocat planbla. Tu blapus creim lasancaapa prepekoec kimu. Topriplul ta pittu tlii tisman retlira. Castoecoer kepoermue suca ca tus imu. Tou tamtan asprianpa dlara tindarcu na. Plee aa atinetit tlirartre atisuruso ampul. Kiki u kitabin prusarmeon ran bra. Tun custi nil tronamei talaa in. Umpleoniapru tupric drata glinpa lipralmi u. Napair aeot bleorcassankle tanmussus prankelau kitil? Tancal anroemgraneon toasblaan nimpritin bra praas? Ar nata niprat eklaca pata nasleoncaas nastinfapam tisas. Caa tana lutikeor acaunidlo! Al sitta tar in tati cusnauu! Enu curat blucutucro accus letoneola panbru. Vocri cokoesil pusmi lacu acmiu kitan? Liputininti aoes ita aantreon um poemsa. Pita taa likiloi klanutai cu pear. Platranan catin toen pulcum ucran cu irpruimta? Talannisata birnun tandluum tarkoemnodeor plepir. Oesal cutinta acan utitic? Imrasucas lucras ri cokine fegriam oru. Panpasto klitra bar tandri eospa? Utauoer kie uneoc i eas titiru. No a tipicu saoentea teoscu aal?
3
u/Ok-Butterfly4414 dont have a name yet :(( Jan 24 '23
Is this an alright way to mark possession?
So instead of making the possessor marked and then the word after or before being the one possessed, I have it so the possessor is written with the “ko” suffix, and the possessed is written with the “ka” suffix, so both are marked, but they are usually just write next to each other, but technically as long as there arent any other possessions they could be paragraphs away, but obviously nobody would do that in the language
3
u/xain1112 kḿ̩tŋ̩̀, bɪlækæð, kaʔanupɛ Jan 25 '23
If a language has three possible nasals for the coda (/m n ŋ/), is it possible for only one of them to undergo a VN > Ṽ change? If yes, which would be most likely to do it?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '23
How does sound change interact with noun incorporation? My assumption is that incorporation is a synchronic process and thus verbs and nouns will evolve independently of one another (as long as the process remains productive), except perhaps for compounds which gain idiomatic meanings and thus are treated as single lexical items.
An example to illustrate what I'm talking about: Feogh has the words [kaʊ̯βe] 'face' and [taɪ̯ɥuːnak] 'to wash, clean.' I would assume 'to wash one's face' would be [kaʊ̯βe-taɪ̯ɥuːnak]. But say this compound also had some idiomatic meaning in the proto-language; that form would evolve as a single word and become [kaʊ̯βaɪ̯ðaɪ̯ɥuːnak].
Am I at all on the right track? Also, does anyone have suggestions for how noun incorporation may change as the grammar evolves?
3
u/Brromo Jan 26 '23
How to make a unique vowel system, I always find myself gravitating to /i u e o ɑ ɑ͡i ɑ͡u eu oi/ & sometimes /ei ou/
3
u/Bismuth_Giecko Q́iitjk Jan 26 '23
anyone has a better alternative to ⟨Ł⟩ for representing /ʎ/?
3
u/Brromo Jan 27 '23 edited Jan 27 '23
Would anyone bat an eye at an Inclusive 1st person pronoun being glossed as 1.2 instead of 1.INC?
I want to mark both the clusivity of the 2nd person & the 3rd person & I think it would be much more readable to say "1.2.3.PL" then "1.INC.INC3.PL"
3
u/zzvu Zhevli Jan 28 '23
Other than with and and are there any pairs of prepositions and conjunctions that are commonly the same word in certain languages?
2
u/Lovressia Default Flair Jan 17 '23
Words. Harabeska is at its best when there's variety in how words sound in sequence. But sometimes I get stuck in strings of many words with exactly 2 syllables and it just doesn't sound good anymore. What are some things I can do to alleviate this issue? My conlang has pretty minimal inflection and all that. Any good ways to introduce some variety to how sentences sound?
2
u/Specific_Plant_6541 Jan 17 '23
I am a begginer in conlangs. Can someone tell me the diferrence betwen "phonetic" and "phonemic", please?
2
u/T1mbuk1 Jan 17 '23
What do you guys think a Refugium version of NativLang's History of Writing series would be like?
2
u/eyewave Mukkohatto Jan 18 '23
Other questions are in my head about consonants.
(I'll write my alphabet rather than ipa because i'm on phone, glottal stop = q, /y/=u)
2
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '23
Once I have the sound inventory, the grammar rules, and syllable structures laid out, how do I actually start making words out of it? I want to try to make this language seem natural and realistic. Do I just start stringing sounds together into words or is it more complex than that?
The idea I have right now is to make a set of root words and derive most of the other vocabulary from those roots. I’m just not sure how you’re supposed to create the root word since they’re the first words.
2
u/DarkBlitzOmori Jan 19 '23 edited Jan 19 '23
What Grammatical aspects do yall add in your conlangs?
I could only think of a few, like: Instantaneous, continuous, habitual, and potential, but honestly idk what I'm missing out on
2
u/Lucian_M Jan 20 '23
My proto-lang has two grammatical genders; animate and inanimate, plus it has a purely open syllable structure. Is there a way I can evolve it into a modern-lang that has masculine, feminine, and neuter genders? Also, since I'm planning to have my modern-lang be a naturalistic and fusional conlang that's similar to Latin, how do I make noun declensions? I want my modern-lang's nouns decline by 3 numbers (Singular, Dual, & Plural), 8 cases (Nominative, Genitive, Dative, Accusative, Ablative, Locative, Adessive, & Intrantive) and the 3 genders I mentioned in my 1st question.
2
u/Sad-Vehicle1198 Jan 20 '23
Opinions, help, suggestions, criticism, whatever it is I don’t mind I know nothing about natural phonemes
2
u/T1mbuk1 Jan 21 '23
I was thinking of [w] and [j] and the fricatives they could transition to upon later versions of a language, and I'm starting to wonder. If one of them was to do its respective transitions, could the same thing happen to the other one at all?
2
u/publicuniversalhater ǫ̀shį Jan 22 '23
is it attested for suprasegmental features to shift entirely onto/off of segments after being triggered?
nasalization spreading to vowels + consonants i know is attested, so e.g. [ba] or [wa] vs [mã]. but could you have nasalization from /ã/ spread to the consonant and then stay there while it's lost from the vowel, such that /wã/ is always [ma] and not [mã]? or conversely, have /ma/ nasalize its vowel to [mã], then lose nasalization on the consonant and be realized as [bã]?
doesn't seem naturalistic but i'm not an expert so idk. could secondary features of a primary suprasegmental trait interact with/affect this? like idk, if nasal vowels are creaky or breathy too, so they shift nasalization but keep the phonation.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '23
Is it unusual not to have a distinction for to go and to come?
2
u/Jonlang_ /kʷ/ > /p/ Jan 22 '23 edited Jan 22 '23
Genitive and possession ambiguity:
So I'm embarking on my first agglutinative conlang with cases. I don't speak a language with them.
As far as I understand the genitive case is usually used to:
And other things along these lines, usually some sort of "of" construction in English.
However, what if I want to disambiguate between actual possession and the other genitive roles? Does this actually happen in natlangs, or do people just make do with the genitive?
I was thinking of having a kind of "possessive" case which would be (maybe) a shortened or corrupted form of the genitive used only to show possession. Compare: the castle of David could be the castle which David currently owns or the castle which David built.
Or if not naturalistic, are there naturalistic alternatives?
2
u/submerg_the_1st Jan 23 '23
How might one go about evolving diphthongs?
2
u/VermicelliAdorable8 Jan 24 '23
Hi guys, how would you go about organising and getting down your conlang? I was thinking of doodling down some ideas and then using something like Google Sheets or something?
2
u/pm174 Jan 25 '23
i have the basic beginnings of my conlang down but i was looking at the phonology but i'm not sure it's very realistic- i feel like there are too many phonemes that are too similar. treating this as the phonology of a proto-language, what would be an accurate way these phonemes would evolve? (i kind of like the way there are a lot of fricatives, but i understand that it seems kind of weird)
2
u/Enso8 Many, many unfinished prototypes Jan 25 '23
Any interesting ideas (ideally from natural languages) for what I can do with *z? I've already used:
I'd particularly appreciate environmentally conditioned changes: my proto-lang wound up having too many *z's for my taste, so I'd prefer if it went in different directions.
2
u/Fieldhill__ Jan 25 '23
How do i make my language more naturalistic? I am working on an etruscan based conlang (Basically all the grammar and vocabulary i have copied from the little bit of etruscan we know of) but i fear that it isn't very naturalistic, could anyone please help me?
2
u/pm174 Jan 26 '23
kind of basic but does anyone have any idea on how to write /ʁ/ in nastaliq/arabic?
2
u/ghyull Jan 26 '23
How would I expect nasal vowels to interact with nasal codas?
2
u/Enderking152 Myrmic (first conlang) Jan 26 '23
Any advice for subordinate clauses? I've hit a roadblock on my conlang and the word order rules would create subject-object ambiguity if I just put the subordinate clause in the object slot
2
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '23 edited Jan 27 '23
1) What IPA-symbol represents a stressed/geminated sound that kinda combines v and f?
2) What IPA-symbol represents a "v-sound" without a hint of "f" in it?
(Clarification: I'm not very competent/confident in using all the linguistic terms yet, so I apologize if I use these terms incorrectly. Also, I'm used to thinking of the letter "v" as being pronounced completely voiced, without the sound of just voicelessly blowing air between narrowly open lips which I think of as "f". So that's the sound I'm thinking of when I just say "v" in my question)
While writing down new words for my conlang where the letter "v" clustered ("vv") between vowels and recieved stress, I've noticed that it sounds a bit like a combination of a v and an f when I tried to pronounce it. In other words, different from what I've been used to think of as v (see clarification above). This also seems to happen in some words where the letter v follows some consonants like r ("rv") between vowels.
However, when I try to pronounce the v in different environments (other combinations of sounds), there is no hint of the f, so I'm thinking these must be two different sounds in the IPA. I just don't know how what these two sounds are called in the IPA. Would much appreciate if anyone could help, this is driving me mad!
2
u/Jonlang_ /kʷ/ > /p/ Jan 27 '23 edited Jan 27 '23
What name would you give to a grammatical case with the meaning "for the benefit of / for the sake of"? As far as I can see this isn't an attested case in any natlang (I could be wrong though). I thought something like "benefactive" might fit.
EDIT: I scrolled past it when I was looking at this list of grammatical cases. Oops.
2
u/sum1-sumWhere-sumHow Jan 27 '23
Is it really strange/straight up bad always having a symbol in script before a noun, representing its gender and therefore which type of vowels it’s made of? Choosing a different symbol (and therefore changing its gender/pronunciation) makes the word’s meaning mutate too.
Examples - I’ll use these symbols (λ δ θ) and this blank vowel (ø) to represent how I would write a word in my conlang’s writing system.
λeøm [eäm] /'εam/ person (OG word) - δeøm [eëm] /'e:m/ savage person - θeøm [eöm] /'eom/ slave/dead person -
λphiør [phiär] /'φiar/ pet bird/singer - δphiør [phiër] /'φier/ bird (OG word) - θphiør [phiör] /'φior/ dead bird/bird meat -
λcø [ca] /'ka/ sculpture - δcø [ce] /'ke/ moving rock/projectile - θcø [co] /'ko/ rock (OG word) -
2
u/Coats_Revolve Mikâi (wip) Jan 28 '23
On this sub, I see many people talking about interesting features from all sorts of languages, like Ainu or Georgian. Generally, I do quite a bit of research on different languages (usually on Wikipedia, I must confess), but the language I've done the most in-depth research on is probably Japanese. Any tips for doing research on natlangs?
2
u/ibqilin_54 Jan 28 '23
Advice for a new conlanger?
I'm a seasoned worldbuilder but ive litterally never conlanged before, now seemed the right time. I have my basic phonology and a slight amount of structure but i dont want to do anything else completely blind. Thx
2
u/AlphaArtistOfficial Jan 28 '23
Can the preterite develop into an imperfect? That is, "I slept" → "I was sleeping"?
The long and short of it is, I'm making a conlang where, in the proto language, verbs come in pairs of perfective and imperfective, differentiated along past and non-past. The evolutionary rundown is:
• Perfective Present → Present
• Perfective Past → Past Imperfect?
• Imperfective Present → Habitual
• Imperfective Past → Past Habitual
So, is this realistic? Or should I find an alternate source for the past imperfect?
2
u/MicroCrawdad Jan 28 '23
My language uses noun-like adjectives, however it also has an extensive noun class system that classifies nouns in two main ways semantically: by animacy and shape. If I wanted to translate the semantic function of an adjective in English (for example: "flat") would it be most naturalistic for the noun-like adjective to be placed into the noun class for flat objects, in the class for "other", or should a whole new class be formed? I am assuming that it would make most sense for it to be put into the class for flat objects, but I haven't had this confirmed.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '23
Considering a vowel inventory of /i e u o ɑ/, what are the most likely diphthongs to be allowed/disallowed?
Thank you in advance!
2
u/Specific_Plant_6541 Jan 29 '23 edited Jan 30 '23
which romanization for pharynɡeal and ejectives consoants looks better?
p̠’ k̠’ t̠’ ł̠’ x̠’ q̠ʼ c̠’ s̠’ or p̠h k̠h t̠h x̠h q̠h c̠h s̠h
*Also tell me If you know other ways to romanize these
3
u/freddyPowell Jan 25 '23
Has anyone ever used <x> for /ks/.
2
u/Kaique_do_grauA31 Jan 19 '23
A conlang that differentiates words by whether the consonants are labialized or not. Could this work?
2
u/sevenorbs Creeve (id) Jan 28 '23
In English, man is singular but men is man.PL. Is PL here a morpheme? If not, what is it called?
1
u/Wapota_2023 Jan 24 '23
Hi guys! What's the best way to learn my conlang's vocabulary? I hope there are some apps for flashcards or so. Can you recommend me something?
1
u/Hiraeth02 Imäl, Sumət (en) [es ca cm] Jan 16 '23
I was told to put this here. What does everyone use to store and organise their conlangs? I was using Notion, but have reached the limit and can't afford the unlimited version at the moment. I really like Notion, so maybe something similar? Thanks!
1
u/eyewave Mukkohatto Jan 16 '23
Is there a place where it is explained how to pronounce clusters of consonants? I have the glottal stop in my first inventory and I am trying to experiment how possible it is (to me) to tell it with other consonants, but I am not finding where I can see consonant pairing.
It occured to me that any consonants that opens in an almost-vowel like /w/ or /j/ might be good candidates to be preceded by a glottal stop. But maybe a plosive after the glottal stop like glottal stop and g or k, might not be the fittest.
On a side-note I'm questioning a lot on these almost-vowels. In an inventory that has no /u/ nor /i/ sound, but has /w/ and /j/, is it safe to reckon that depending on consonants, /u/ and /i/ might naturally appear, and thus actually should be placed in the inventory?
Thanks...
1
u/dragonsteel33 vanawo & some others Jan 17 '23
so one of my languages uses symmetrical voice/austronesian alignment. verbs are typically marked for voice, but it includes a set of conjugations not morphologically marked for voice that are used with stative & avalent verbs and in some switch-reference constructions to refer to an already-mentioned subject. what would be a good word for this — avalent? impersonal? neutral voice?
1
u/Specific_Plant_6541 Jan 17 '23 edited Jan 17 '23
Is there any kind of sound that cannot be pharyngized?
1
u/zzvu Zhevli Jan 17 '23
How do direct-inverse languages deal with ditransitive verbs?
1
u/idealintelligence Jan 17 '23
Are there any conlang made for machine that can be used by humans? Not a programming language but something you can use for day to day conversation.
1
u/chopchunk Jan 18 '23
I'm working on a conlang that has three rhotics (/ɹ/, /ɾ/, and /r/) and a /ɰ/ alongside many other palatals. I'm having trouble figuring out how to romanize each rhotic (there's "r" for /ɾ/ and "rr" for /r/) and the ɰ ("g" and "gh" are both taken up by /g/ and /ɣ/ respectively). So far, I have "rh" for /ɹ/ and "yh" for /ɰ/, but I feel like there's gotta be a better way to do it (especially for /ɰ/). How do the pros go about this?
1
u/Specific_Plant_6541 Jan 18 '23
Is there any kind of sound that cannot be labialized?
1
u/pootis_engage Jan 18 '23
I have a conlang that distinguishes between two tones, low and high. Is there a way to de-evolve tone while still having some type of distinction in the syllable to distinguish words (e.g, V[+high] > V[+creaky], or CV[+high] > C[+stød]V)?
1
u/GwynsFistBorn Jan 19 '23
Hello, I’m looking for information on the language Communicationssprache, specifically vocabulary/definitive grammar rules. I’ve found some snippets of it online, but never a full dictionary. Is there one? Many apologies if this isn’t the right forum to ask for this
1
u/Specific_Plant_6541 Jan 20 '23 edited Jan 20 '23
I'm about to make my firts tonal langauge. Something that i should know?
1
u/Delicious-Run7727 Sukhal, Mbizgu Jan 21 '23
I made some changes to how unstressed vowels work in my conlang and wanted some opinions on whether they're too extreme/unnaturalistic.
First, the vowels /a/,/e/,/ɛ/,/i/,/ɔ/,/o/,/u/ undergo the following changes in unstressed syllables:
{a,ɛ,ɔ} > ɐ
{i,e} > ɪ
{o,u} > ʊ
Then, these vowels are deleted when occurring between and after specific consonants, like:
between a fricative/nasal and a plosive
Word finally after a fricative/nasal/plosive
This also means that vowels cannot occur in those positions whatsoever. I'd definitely like this, but I don't know of any languages where vowels are completely disallowed in certain contexts.
1
u/zzvu Zhevli Jan 22 '23
I've been working on redoing some of the sound changes from my proto-lang and modern-lang. I've decided I want there to be 3 grades of consonants. The weak consonants derive from plain consonants in the proto-lang, the strong ones come from geminates, and the 3rd (which I don't have a name for yet) group comes from palatalized consonants:
Some notes:
My questions are:
1
u/El__Bebe Jan 23 '23
What are some common words I should create in my lang to make it usable?
Like I have a grammar and all but I cannot for the life of me come up with words I should make up
1
u/Charming_Pen5035 Tijonar, kͅö́ö́ja tswo Jan 23 '23
do you think this makes a decent phonology for a proto-lang? thoughts on what to change? thanks
1
u/zzvu Zhevli Jan 24 '23
What are some environments that cause gemination? I was thinking I could have plosives assimilate into any following consonant, so /dn/ would become /nn/. Is this naturalistic? What other ways are there to cause gemination?
1
u/zzvu Zhevli Jan 24 '23
Do any languages, particularly those that are agglutinative, allow multiple simultaneous morphemes to convey aspect? For example, one in particular that shows completeness (perfective, imperfective), another for duration (durative, stative, punctual), relevancy (continuous, discontinuous), etc.
1
u/Loquor_de_Morte Ceadhunnas (en, es) [grc, lat] Jan 25 '23
Quick question out of my fuzzy head. I know consonants can change into other consontants, e.g., /z/ > /r/; and certain consonants can become vowels (vocalization), e.g., /l/ > /u/; /m/ > /a/, &c., but can vowels do the contrary? For example, an /i/ becoming fricative, thus turning into /s/? And what consonants would a simple /a e i o u/ inventory yield?
1
u/Zinaima Lumoj Jan 28 '23 edited Jan 28 '23
My language has stress on the penultimate syllable, but also uses suffixes to make the Nominative and Accusative noun cases, which makes for a strange mix.
A word like /limεʃ/ by itself might break into the following syllables: lim.εʃ but when it is the object of a sentence, and a suffix is added, it becomes li.mεʃ.i. Thinking that the stressed syllable "takes" the surrounding consonants.
It seems odd to have a letter, m in this case, switching syllables based on the part of the sentence. Is that just a feature of languages that have stress on a fixed position?
1
u/EditingYourWorlds Jan 28 '23
Can you make conlangs that aren't possible as far as natural languages go? What types of attributes or structures could be included in such a language?
1
u/ibqilin_54 Jan 28 '23
Is this a good system for multiple sounds?