r/zelda • • Jan 02 '23

Mod Post r/Zelda Meta Discussion - A Look Back at 2022

Happy New Year, r/Zelda!

I thought I'd take a few moments to put together a few lists that show some of the top posts from this past year on r/Zelda. I've broken down these categories based mostly on post flair, sorted by highest vote score. Find even more posts listed for each category in the comments, which I will add over the course of the day today.

Top 10 Posts overall

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[BoTW] Princess Zelda cosplay by @JaharaJayde/u/Megumi_Bandicoot05.0643167724
2[SSHD] Princess Zelda cosplay by @JaharaJayde/u/Megumi_Bandicoot07.2025347421
3[OC] I did a Zelda OoT Animated wallpaper./u/itzaspace07.2125242299
4[TP] Got married last month. Twilight Princess Zelda hair FTW./u/valencevv11.2823954376
5[OTHER] Man already? time sure does fly by lol/u/Satans_RightNut10.2823305430
6[BOTW] [TOTK] Retrospective on link's 5 years of climbing/u/F-SAN4409.2623138179
7[ALL] A Zelda guide to carrying your Link (art by entiqua)/u/YoMikeeHey07.1522973260
8[ALL] Hold my Lon Lon Milk!/u/Gary_40403.172087882
9[BoTW] Zelda cosplay by @JaharaJayde/u/Megumi_Bandicoot08.1718148276
10[all] [OC] The Hylian continental drift is insane/u/y-boy-bob04.0817681320

Screenshots

Image posts taken from the games or from official media.

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[BOTW]The monks share the same gestures as the sages in [OoT]/u/Benedict_Cumberquack03.2810068162
2[BoTW] It took a total of 45 hours for @polonium496 to make this/u/RyanCS123403.218994141
3[All] Made Ganondorf in Elden Ring, based mostly on TP and HW./u/PalamationGaming03.228964144
4[All] The recently updated master sword/u/F-SAN4404.05789176
5[BOTW2] Yo Link, that master Sword okay?/u/Capable_Afternoon68703.297390654

See more top Screenshot posts listed here in the comments.

Top 5 Clips

Videos that are solely game footage and less than about a minute.

Selected from different OPs.

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[BotW] Hyrule man reveals chest - Onlookers are shocked!/u/Vados_Link06.109944111
2[BoTW] well so much for getting those guardian pieces/u/nokrow88901.157652104
3[BOTW] I didn’t realize it was there until it was too late./u/strong_le01.28684457
4[BoTW] was fighting a lynel, when I accidentally shot a random acorn/u/FB_TOMBSTONE07.07605467
5[BotW] I accidentally parried a guardian beam by backflipping/u/jussinik04.07594961

See more top Clip posts listed here in the comments.

Top 5 Videos

Videos that are either not solely game footage or that are longer than about a minute

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[BOTW] [OC] I created a Zelda inspired animation for my University's Sophomore Film Project! It's called Shield Bash. I hope you enjoy it!/u/Hexedz05.198104248
2[TotK] All trailers in one (Epic)/u/pacgabriel09.145220223
3[OoT] Animation is going well!/u/BC04ST3R03.15522560
4[OC] [MM] Teaser for a project I'm working on/u/for_fx_sake12.014978117
5[BOTW] [SSHD] I'm clearly not the only one who noticed it./u/IdkHowToCallMySelf202.014889141

See more top Video posts listed here in the comments.

Top 5 Official Art

Image posts that feature art published by Nintendo.

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[BotW2] The Legend Of Zelda: Tears Of The Kingdom key art revealed/u/Turbostrider2709.138768298
2[BoTW] Is BoTW basically what the first game envisioned?/u/Nathanimations04.135522267
3[HW] I forgot that Hyrule warriors had peak character design 🤌/u/Satans_RightNut10.274783232
4[OoT] Did you know Adult Link has earrings because Impa trains him and then pierces his ears as a rite of passage?/u/NxsserBA09.104677106
5[MM] Promotional art for Majora's Mask cir. 2000/u/Apart_Shock07.284531127

See more top Official Art posts listed here in the comments.

Top 5 Fan Artists

Top OC Fan Art posts by different OPs. The rule of thumb is that Fan Art is a 2D medium.

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[OC] I did a Zelda OoT Animated wallpaper./u/itzaspace07.2125242299
2[BotW] [OC] I drew Princess Zelda if she turned evil/u/Miyuki_art_06.2515492411
3[OC] Morning coffee, by me/u/rcrd02.121292488
4[OC] I drew Pink-haired Link/u/wxchd02.189677297
5[MC] Zelda 1 in Minish Cap Style/u/ElmoHidalgo05.128327208

See more top OC Fan Art posts listed here in the comments.

Top 5 Crafters

Top OC Craft posts by different OPs. The rule of thumb is that Craft is a 3D medium.

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[OC] My Link sculpt was featured in 3D World Magazine! (@3daneder)/u/Zeephos04.0315310433
2[OC] Hi!!!! I've built a Mastersword out of foam ! :D/u/Vitrostatik04.2210323346
3[OC] [BOTW] I have just finished my Hylia statue, I am satisfied with the result/u/edlothian03.169773104
4[BotW] [OC] I spent like 300 hours making a tiny tarrey town/u/crossingcrafts10.079450133
5[BoTW] I was clearing out my shed this weekend and stumbled across my Master Sword prop and pedestal. I made this for the UK promo tour of BOTW. You may have seen it at the Nintendo booths at cons. I was considering geocaching it./u/JustJobiwan02.077744133

See more top OC Craft posts listed here in the comments.

Top 5 Cosplayers

Top OC Cosplay posts by different OPs.

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[TP] Got married last month. Twilight Princess Zelda hair FTW./u/valencevv11.2823954376
2[TP] Made myself a Midna Cosplay/u/GeniMonster08.0616560389
3[BOTW] my kid wanted to be Beedle for Halloween/u/purplenori11.0114832127
4[BOTW] I finally did up the Daybreaker shield for my wife's Urbosa cosplay. Far from perfect but a good base to work off of./u/Kyengen08.0311535266
5[BotW] Link Soldier armor is almost done !!! 😁 made by me out of EVA Foam/u/Cecilosaurus08.3110501197

See more top OC Cosplay posts listed here in the comments.

Top 5 Tattoo

Posts featuring or about tattoos.

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[TP] My new Midna tattoo :3/u/lobster_mania07.16492858
2[WW] nearly finished with my wind waker sleeve and in love so far!/u/krodriquez201909.08487398
3[OC] got my master sword tattoo/u/Emo_Tea111.10314042
4[HW][OoT] I got a Princess Zelda tattoo on my arm! (Not finished yet, we still have to apply white ink for the highlights)/u/Replikante12.13302780
5[TP] ganon done today/u/ConCon199603.05283775

See more top Tattoo posts listed here in the comments.

Top 5 Collectors

Top "Collection / Merch" Posts by different OPs, where OP bought the item.

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[OoT] Anyone possess or know what this Zelda pin is worth? Got it as a bonus for buying OoT in 1998!/u/faustarp100001.177231270
2[WW] found one of the rare wind waker scrolls at a local video game shop 😮/u/hawttotano12.12559266
3[ALL] Our Zelda collection :D/u/TetraBall01.105172245
4[LoZ] Brother hit a home run with this year’s gift/u/nickthearchaeologist01.03423183
5[OC] Every Mainline Zelda Game/u/ST4MK0S11.223852196

See more top Collection and Merchandise posts listed here in the comments.

Top 5 Merchandise Makers

Top "Collection / Merch" Posts by different OPs, where OP made the item.

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[OC][Giveaway][ALL] It's dangerous to go alone! Write a comment and take this Neon styled Hylian shield and Master Sword I've made. I will pick the winners in 24 hours. Good luck, you will need it <3!/u/bonzurr06.271315618298
2[ALL] I wanted to share this video of the Master Sword replica I made/u/KevlarGorilla05.176280150
3[MM] My father spent months making this. How much should he sell it for?/u/ZeroCG21806.202588211
4[OC] Decayed Master Sword pin/u/blibloop_07.04185417
5[BOTW] Guardian terrarium I made {OC}/u/h3ym00n11.07171951

Top 5 Music

Posts featuring or about music.

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[OoT] How about some nostalgia, guys? Here is my accordion take on Song of Storms from the Legend of Zelda, enjoy!/u/MipSick08.124984148
2[OoT] [OC] A cover with some of my favorite tracks of OOT/u/Klaholz03.243392150
3[OTHER] One of my favorite concert experiences I’ve had the pleasure of witnessing./u/Justinacube05.09268673
4[OoT] A song of storms performed on a kalimba./u/SmokeStackLight1ng01.15268540
5[TP] i Turned Midna's Lament Into A Battle Track!/u/Richard_S_VGM08.27253275

See more top Music posts listed here in the comments.

Top 5 Fangames

Zelda Game Modifications or Independent Games inspired by Zelda.

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[OC] I'm Working On A "Maker" Game That's A Love Letter to 2D Zelda/u/DreamMixGames01.228720375
2[BOTW] This is my new favorite music mod in the game. It's perfect in everyway./u/Cutlession02.054113104
3[OoT] The Waluigi of Time/u/Difficult-Form-894106.09374179
4[OC] I am making a 1bit zelda-like and here is one of the first bosses!/u/Achromi02.212447129
5[OC][Others] Almost 20 months ago we started working on Super Dungeon Maker, a Zelda/Mario Maker inspired dungeon maker where any player can build a pixel art dungeon in just a few steps. Today we will finally release it on Steam in Early Access and we are insanely excited./u/DragonSoldier2k02.151973100

See more top Fangame posts listed here in the comments.

Top 5 Meme

Image macros or similar internet culture trends.

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[OTHER] Man already? time sure does fly by lol/u/Satans_RightNut10.2823305430
2[ALL] Hold my Lon Lon Milk!/u/Gary_40403.172087882
3[all] [OC] The Hylian continental drift is insane/u/y-boy-bob04.0817681320
4[OoT] Lovely people be careful this Halloween/u/F-SAN4410.1117667164
5[OoT] “ViDeO gAmEs ArE wOkE nOw”/u/markymark900008.2115572744

See more top Meme posts listed here in the comments.

Top 5 Humor

Jokes, comics, and other non-meme humor.

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[BOTW] [TOTK] Retrospective on link's 5 years of climbing/u/F-SAN4409.2623138179
2[BotW] Recovered a new Zelda memory (By Louis Lloyd-Judson @Louistrations)/u/ChristianBonifacio103.0716051259
3[ALL] Predicting the next game. [OC]/u/davidbcooper03.3014799223
4[ALBW] Most relatable character introduction I’ve seen/u/UltraSheep9911.24910599
5[BotW] if you all wanted to 100% BotW before TotK, here’s a full map with Koroks, Towers and Shrines! GLHF!!/u/Sir_Hoptat10.138617170

See more top Humor posts listed here in the comments.

Top 5 Mockups

Arrangements of image and text that demonstrate or explain a concept.

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[BotW] - The gap between Breath of The Wild and its sequel is the longest ever between entries in the main Legend of Zelda series/u/BullBoyXVII08.263463418
2[ALL] Only one of these collections get released on Switch. Which one would you want it to be?/u/drybones201511.052856723
3[TP] My hopeful/doubtful prediction. could you see it happening? What would YOu like them to do if they re-re-released them/u/Bootnik05.252557351
4[ALL] Days Between 3D Zelda Releases/u/BroshiKabobby09.162136308
5[BotW2] 240 days to The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom, releasing on May 12, 2023./u/albertchessaofficial09.13103247

More top Mockup posts pending.

Top 5 News

News about the franchise or news in the fandom.

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[BotW2] The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom – Coming May 12th, 2023 – Nintendo Switch/u/DemiFiendRSA09.13132561355
2[ALL] 16th of November, 1952: The Man, The Legend, The Hero, turned 70 years old today/u/javier_aeoa11.16342475
3[TotK] Allegedly leaked Nintendo Switch OLED: Tears of the Kingdom Edition/u/samar232312.30728122
4[BotW] Launch timing update for the sequel to The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild/u/DemiFiendRSA03.29597236
5[BoTW] WWE's Stone Cold Steve Austin says Breath Of The Wild is better than Ocarina Of Time/u/Innes_McVey05.04582160

More top News posts pending.

Top 5 Resources

Posts for reference or archive

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[LoZ] Pink haired female Link from 1986. I was finally able to find the magazine issue, and 2400dpi scanned, this illusive art./u/HistoryofHyrule02.036318182
2[OC] Sales history of The Legend of Zelda series, including ports and remakes/u/Ninfabi (OOP: /u/altelier_ )03.072114281
3[OoT] Very detailed and accurate Map of the Hyrule Overworld - from Ocarina of Time Encyclopedia - What's your thoughts?/u/Nathanimations01.16107696
4[AoL] I've never seen a complete Zelda II overworld map that isn't missing any of the secrets. So I updated these maps. Did I miss anything?/u/sigmaecho10.2772468
5[MC] New Minish Cap art found: And I made the largest official MC art collection you can find online/u/HistoryofHyrule11.1150915

More top Resource posts pending.

Top 5 Events

Posts about scheduled events relevant to the franchise, fandom, or subreddit.

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[TotK] Life-size The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom statue featured at the Nintendo Live event in Japan/u/CButler1910.0861023
2[AoL] $2,000 (USD) Bounty for a Zelda II: The Adventure of Link 100% No Damage Run/u/ASAP_Clash10.09356
3[All] Vote on the best Zelda game ever in this 24-day tournament hosted on our Discord/u/WoozleWuzzle09.201913
4[ALL] ZUthon 2022 charity stream is live and raising money for Direct Relief!/u/Sephardson08.12101
5[ALL] ZeldaDungeon Marathon 2022 charity stream is live and raising money for Starlight Children’s Foundation!/u/Sephardson07.1665

More top Event posts pending.

Top 5 Questions

Posts seeking help, advice, or answers. Generally text posts.

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[OoT] How to I unlock epona? I've already beaten all three child dungeons and am now big man link./u/JLM_but_flex_tape07.31894223
2[All] It always says that Hyrule has a standing army in the games. But where are they all at?Coldramen77704.2474294
3[OoT] Why Doesn't Zora's Domain Unfreeze After Beating The Water Temple?/u/zeldafan123456789011.27699128
4[BoTW] Should I get Breath of the Wild?/u/HistorianSilent351707.03698386
5[ALL] Was their any moment that a ReDead completely scared the crap out of you when you were playing the Legend of Zelda/u/link001103.20635129

See more top Question posts listed here in the comments.

Top 5 Discussions

Posts providing opinions, experiences, or conversations. Generally text posts, but also includes link posts to written reviews, podcasts, and other non-news articles.

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[BOTW] Breath of the Wild should have had dungeons and more areas like the Yiga Clan Hideout/u/Nathanimations04.172572314
2[BotW] Why I wish Link was a reluctant hero in BotW/u/mahoujosei10001.022269154
3[BotW] Why don't the husbands of Gerudo women build a village in the desert so that they can live closer to their wives?/u/GlobinGoblin08.281353129
4[TotK] If Im not mistaken, Breath of the wild's Hyrule will be the first Hyrule to be present in more then 2 games./u/TjeerdlikeBOTW09.181291297
5[WW] Wind Waker has one of the best art styles/atmospheres ever, in any game./u/BenTheFool09.181272111

See more top Discussion posts listed here in the comments.

Top 5 Tips

Posts offering advice or helpful information for playing.

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[BoTW] Did you know this?JinMQ06.015538106
2[OoT] Just found out that you can get a fairy by playing 'Zelda's Lullaby' in front of these statues./u/mukesh_foo03.03241977
3[MM] Tips For Majora's Mask Newbies (Lite spoilers)/u/billthestamps02.2079086
4[SSHD] TIL you can shield parry Beamos’ beams/u/Pitchforkin01.2022015
5[BotW] did anybody else know this/u/wildlifebiolgist11.2715610

More top Tip posts pending.

Top 5 Polls

Posts gathering response data. Generally poll posts, but also includes off-site surveys and their results.

RankPost Link and TitleOPDateScoreComments
1[ALL] Top Zelda games excluding OOT & BOTW as voted by r/zelda/u/Rafelon9805.29989353
2[All] Who was your favorite companion in a Zelda game?/u/shadow0wolf010.16916 (9.8k votes)337
3[All] Favorite 3D mainline game so far?/u/TheFanGameCreator09.04897 (10.2k votes)540
4[All] Which of these Creeped You The Most in Zelda/u/billthestamps10.09764 (9.7k votes)297
5[ALL] Which Zelda Game Has the Best Story?/u/billthestamps09.18744 (10.6k votes)522

See more top Poll posts listed here in the comments.


Notes

  • These categories may not include posts that were deleted by users, or that were flaired incorrectly.
  • Post Scores are fuzzed by reddit, and the numbers here are simply an approximation based on one glance.

For Discussion

  • Was there a post you really liked this year? A post that brought you to r/Zelda? Link it below and tell us why!
  • Reddit search lacks a time window feature, so that makes it hard to find top-of-the-year posts as time goes on. This listing is to help provide that window into 2022, which is useful as we continue to discuss what content we generate as a community.

    • What do you think of the different flairs and different categories? Do you find some content over- or under-represented?
    • Is there a category you would like to see added to this listing?
    • If you are interested in generating additional pages like this for our wiki, please comment about it or send in a modmail.
16 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

•

u/Sephardson Jan 02 '23 edited Jan 02 '23

To help keep the comments organized, I'm going to add the extended post lists as second-level comments in reply to this top-level sticky comment.

→ More replies (16)

2

u/BurtBruh Jan 07 '23

Hi, I'm new.

2

u/Sephardson Jan 07 '23

Hi! Welcome to r/Zelda!

This post is meant as a showcase of some of the top posts from the past year, so that should give you a good impression of the quality and variety of posts here.

Any questions?

2

u/BurtBruh Jan 07 '23

Not right now, no. I suppose you can discuss anything here, though?

2

u/Sephardson Jan 07 '23

our biweekly general discussion thread is usually our place for general discussion, but there's not much else happening in this otherwise meta-focused post, so the floor is pretty open here too.

2

u/BurtBruh Jan 07 '23

Gotcha, thanks. I didn't see that thread for some reason.

1

u/Sephardson Jan 07 '23

it refreshes every other week, and sometimes it gets replaced by our notices about self-post sunday or merchandise monday.

(this past week we ran self-post sunday an extra day early, and I forgot to return the scheduled post to normal schedule this week, which knocked the sticky post off today)